★ At a Glance
ELIMINATED Investigation: 19 November – 23 December 2025Henry Bonhagen / Bodenhausen line — pursued briefly Nov 2025. Eliminated when Henry Bonhagen surfaced in Virginia (1858 marriage), then Baltimore — never St. Louis. A related Phillip Koester moved to South Carolina; another Koester namesake went to Richmond.
Why this matters for finding Charles: Eliminated 19-20 November 2025. Geographic mismatch — none of the Bonhagen / Koester branches passed through St. Louis. One of the early Trendelburg-area candidate eliminations.
Documented US destinationsVirginia · Baltimore · South Carolina · Richmond
VerdictEliminated · geographic mismatch
📂 Full research log
The Trendelburg researcher's chart — received via email
20. Henry Bonhagen / Bodenhausen line — Deisel · pastor's-shorthand surname theory (Bodenhausen → Bonsen)
The Trendelburg researcher's genealogical content
- The Trendelburg researcher found in an old book of his hometown the family name Bodenhausen — long Hessian surname routinely shortened by pastors to Bonsen. Surname-resemblance theory: Bonsen → Gonsen / Gonnson.
- Detailed look at the Bonhage(n) family in Deisel attached 23 Dec 2025.
- Henry Bonhagen — emigrated; identified via 1858 Norfolk marriage record. The bride's hometown on that record reads as Karlshafen (consistent with the Hessian Karlshafen → Bremen emigration route the Trendelburg researcher described).
- Friedrich Bonhagen — Henry's brother, lived in Baltimore as a tailor.
- Earlier (19 Nov 2025) the Trendelburg researcher had short-listed Phillip Koester from his Karl-firstname Deisel emigrant filter; eliminated as emigrating too late.
Why this line was rejected
Eliminated 19–20 Nov 2025: Henry Bonhagen surfaced in Virginia (1858 marriage), then Baltimore — never St. Louis. Phillip Koester moved to South Carolina; Phillip Koester's namesake went to Richmond. The Bonsen→Gonsen surname-resemblance theory is intellectually coherent but produced no Charles-shaped match.