Charles Gannsen Research/How sure are we?

How Sure Are We?

The book states how certain each fact is with one of four words: proven, very probably, probably, possibly. Here is what each word means, how sure the answers to the main questions are, and where the grades stand in the tables and notes of the book.

Filled at every update of the website from the glossary, the notes and the tables of the book.

The key

The four words

The book states how certain each fact is with one of four words.

Proven (in the tables of the website, confirmed): an original record, or an official copy made from it, states the fact, the record has been read in its image, and no record found contradicts it. A written argument from several records that meets the Genealogical Proof Standard also proves a fact.

Very probably: the evidence is strong, several independent facts agree, and nothing points the other way.

Probably: the evidence is good but rests on inference, or on some other copy rather than the original.

Possibly: only an index entry, a search result, a weak link, a reading not yet tested or a statement made long after the event suggests it.

The entry goes on: The tables use two further marks: records differ, where the sources disagree, and his recollection only, for an address that rests on his own statement of 1890 alone. In the appendices and tables the marks (v. prob.), (prob.) and (poss.) stand for very probable, probable and possible. In the Notes the same grades follow the citation they grade: Proven; Very probable; Probable; Possible; and Conflicting, where the records disagree.

records differ, Conflictinghis recollection only

From the entry “Certainty” in the glossary of the book, printed as it stands.

His origin

The main questions

Four questions about his origin, each with the answer as it stands and a way to the records behind it.

His own sworn statement

Where he was born

On 2 December 1862 he swore that he was born at Trendelburg, written “Trennelburg,” in Kurhessen. Deisel, about a mile and a half (2.3 km) away, was probably his last home and possibly his birthplace.

The enlistment paper

Not proven

When he was born

Born about 1835; the records give years from 1833 to 1841. The burial register gives 26 January and the 1900 census gives November. Neither date is proven. He died on 16 December 1903 at St. Louis.

Where and When He Was Born

Not proven

His German surname

The name he used fits two German surnames, Gans and Konze. Konze has more of the evidence, and neither is proven. The leading candidate was born a Hofedietz, and a Konze family possibly took him in.

The Name He Used

Possibly

The leading candidate

Charles was possibly Karl Ludwig Hofedietz, born at Deisel on 13 November 1837, who was orphaned at six and whom the court at Karlshafen summoned in 1900 as missing in America. He is the author’s leading candidate among the open boys, not the only one, and no record yet proves that he was Charles.

The Boy from the Goose Corner

The whole case is laid out in The case in one page and in The Key Evidence.

Counted from the book

Where the grades stand

The book states a grade in set places: in the grade column of a table, and after a citation in the notes. The marks below are counted from those pages at every update, one mark for each grade word.

ProvenVery probableProbablePossibleConflictingHis recollection only

Charles’s Addresses and Occupations, Year by Year: Addresses, 1859–1903

In the forty-five rows of the column “Certainty” the grade words stand fifty-three times: twenty-two proven, fifteen very probable, eleven probable, two possible, three with his recollection only.

One group of marks for each row, in the order of the table. A dash is a row without a grade word.

Open the table

Charles in the City Directories

In the thirty rows of the column “Grade” the grade words stand thirty times: eleven proven, nine very probable, seven probable, three possible.

One group of marks for each row, in the order of the table. A dash is a row without a grade word.

Open the table

The notes to the book

In the notes 190 citations are followed by a grade: 129 proven, nineteen very probable, twenty-one probable, sixteen possible, five conflicting. They are in fourteen chapters and appendices.

One mark for each graded citation, in the order of the notes.

Chapter by chapter

  • Chapter 1. Kurhessen: Deisel and Trendelburg, c. 1835–1858 two proven, one possible Notes to this chapter
  • Chapter 2. Leaving Hesse, c. 1858–1859 one probable Notes to this chapter
  • Chapter 4. Enlistment: Battery B at St. Louis, 1862–1863 eleven proven, two very probable, one possible, one conflicting Notes to this chapter
  • Chapter 5. Sergeant on the Missouri Posts, 1863–1865 nine proven, one very probable, one probable, two possible, two conflicting Notes to this chapter
  • Chapter 6. Reduced to the Ranks and Mustered Out, 1865 ten proven, one very probable, three possible, one conflicting Notes to this chapter
  • Chapter 7. Marriage, 1866 five proven, one probable, two possible Notes to this chapter
  • Chapter 8. The Saloon Years, 1866–1870 twenty proven, six very probable, five probable, one possible Notes to this chapter
  • Chapter 9. The Horse-Car Years, 1870–1876 nine proven, three very probable, two probable, four possible Notes to this chapter
  • Chapter 10. Jackson Street and the Cotton Press, 1877–1884 six proven, five probable, one possible Notes to this chapter
  • Chapter 11. The Watchman and the Pension, 1885–1895 twenty-four proven, three very probable, one probable Notes to this chapter
  • Chapter 12. Widowhood and Last Years, 1896–1903 thirty-one proven, two very probable, three probable, one possible, one conflicting Notes to this chapter
  • Chapter 13. What His Life Tells Us one probable Notes to this chapter
  • Chapter 20. Bertha and the Rothschilds, 1880–1959 one very probable Notes to this chapter
  • Lot 7 two proven, one probable Notes to this chapter
On the pages of the book

How the marks work

On the seventeen pages listed here, a grade word in a grade column or after a citation is shown with its mark. Choose the word to read its meaning in place.

Grade words in running text are shown without a mark. There the same words also stand in sentences such as “neither is proven,” where a mark would be wrong.

Pages with marks

Read with care

What the counts do not show

The counts are counts of grade words in set places. They are not a count of the facts in the book. In the chapters a grade word stands in the sentence itself, and those words are not counted here.

In one row of a table there can be more than one grade word, one for each address or entry in it.

A grade belongs to the evidence found so far. When a new record is found, a grade can change, and this page follows at the next update of the website.

About this page

How this page is made

The meanings are the entry “Certainty” of the book’s glossary, word for word. The answers to the main questions are the website’s standing statements, which follow the book. The counts are taken from the pages of the book online each time the website is updated.

The standard of proof that the grades rest on is set out in the chapter How the Research Was Done.