Charles Gannsen Research/Read the book/The Search for His Origin/Conclusion

What We Still Do Not Know

This chapter is printed here in full, as it stands in the public edition of the book (build of 19 November 2026). Corrections made since printing are listed under errata.

Who was Charles Gannsen before he came to St. Louis? He named Trendelburg as his birthplace in 1862, and his marriage entry of 1866 gives Deisel as his home. No German record has yet been tied to him. These are the open questions whose answers would change his story or name his family.

In this chapter
  1. His origin: who he was by birth
  2. What would settle it
  3. Leaving Germany and the years before the war
  4. The St. Louis years
  5. DNA and family papers
  6. A note for the next researcher
  7. Notes
  8. Supplements

His origin: who he was by birth

Karl Ludwig Hofedietz, born at Deisel on 13 November 1837, was possibly Charles.1 He is the author’s leading candidate among the open boys of his home villages (see “The Boy from the Goose Corner”). No record proves it. DNA tests of his relatives, read with the records, or the court files at Karlshafen could answer the question that remains.2

If he was Karl Ludwig, he was born at Deisel and named Trendelburg, the town next door, in 1862.3 The chapter “The Candidates and How They Were Ruled Out” describes the search of the registers, boy by boy. Twenty-seven boys of Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld are still open, with three more from the confirmation classes.4 The author has now searched the baptism registers of fifty-seven places.5

If he was not Karl Ludwig, the names Gans and Konze, weighed in Part Four, are still the best leads. Either could be hidden under a new name, as a Gans of Oedelsheim lived as Willy Johnson (see “The Candidates and How They Were Ruled Out”).6

His birth date rests on two records that disagree. The 1900 census, taken in his lifetime, gives November 1836; the burial register, from his family after his death, gives 26 January 1835 (see “Where and When He Was Born”).7

The archive at Marburg has answered, and its answers show which records a researcher can use now. The court records of Karlshafen, which would hold any surviving file on Karl Ludwig’s 1843–60 guardianship or his absence in 1900, are uncataloged and closed to readers. The Helmarshausen list of soldiers on leave has not been ordered. The author has asked the archive whether it covers men of Deisel and Trendelburg, and will order it only if it does.8 In November 2026 a researcher engaged by the author is to photograph the 1829–30 court file “Konze against the widow Hoffeditz,” Deisel’s release file to 1858, its poor-relief file and the district’s pass registers.9

Other records could still name him. One group is the parish files at the Landeskirchliches Archiv (the regional Protestant church archive) in Kassel.10 The others are the second copies of the registers sent to the government and the town and court papers of Trendelburg and Karlshafen, if they survive.11 Two more open sources are local to Deisel: what its oldest people remember of the old house names, and the papers of the village historical society’s genealogist.12

What would settle it

The list below runs in order of value. Each item would move the case for Karl Ludwig one way or the other.

  1. A DNA test of a descendant of Karl Ludwig’s sisters, or of a man of the Hofedietz male line. “What DNA Can and Cannot Say” sets out how each result would be weighed; no single result would be proof on its own.13
  2. The Karlshafen court files, if the archive opens them. They could show why a curator was named for him and possibly where in America he went.14
  3. The outcome of the 1900 summons: a judgment declaring him dead, and any notice to his heirs, showing whether anyone claimed property of his.15
  4. Who raised the Hofedietz orphans. The Deisel property registers name their guardian in 1852–60: very probably the farmer Christoph Moritz, grandfather of the curator of 1900 (see “The Boy from the Goose Corner”). They do not name the household the children lived in. The Deisel church council’s minutes of 1844–52 could possibly record who cared for the orphaned Karl Ludwig. They can be read only in the church archive’s reading room at Kassel, and the author has not yet read them.16 Martina Lüdicke’s 2003 study of church discipline at Deisel, which rests on those minutes, was read in November 2026. It shows that the minutes survive for the years of his childhood and record cases by name, among them cases in the Hofedietz family.17 The answer would test whether Karl Ludwig possibly grew up in a Konze household.18
  5. His brothers Friedrich Wilhelm (1833) and Heinrich (1843), who must be traced to show that neither was Charles.19
  6. The American life of Carl Ludwig Martini of Trendelburg (1834), who left for America in 1854. He is the only open Carl Ludwig born at Trendelburg, the birthplace Charles swore to, and a record of his later life would show whether he was Charles or rule him out (see “The Boy from the Goose Corner”).20
  7. Later notices about him as an absent conscript in the Wochenblatt für die Provinz Niederhessen, 1855–62, probably in its supplement, the Polizeiliche Nachrichten. From July 1858 to 1861 the paper was titled the Tageblatt für die Provinz Niederhessen. The judgment that followed his summons of February 1858 has been found in the Oberhessen weekly (see “The Boy from the Goose Corner”). An order to serve the sentence, or a notice placing his property under a curator, would show what came of it.21 The Niederhessen paper is not digitized and survives on microfilm at the university library in Kassel. In October and November 2026 the author asked the library to look through its notices for 1855–62, narrowed to 1858–60. On 17 November 2026 it sent its first result, his summons of February 1858 as the Niederhessen weekly printed it on 16 February. The rest of the search is still pending.22
  8. A fresh reading of the initial in his 1862 signature, read as C by a German paleographer and as L by a fellow researcher.23
  9. If the case fails, a Big Y test of a man in a documented Konze or Gans male line, and the open boys of “The Candidates and How They Were Ruled Out.”24

Leaving Germany and the years before the war

The 1900 census gives 1859 as his year of immigration, but no passenger list, permit or port record found so far names him.25

If he left without permission, a summons for him should have appeared in the provincial gazettes. For Karl Ludwig Hofedietz one did: the Niederhessen and Fulda weeklies of February 1858 printed it, and the Kassel court’s judgment followed that summer (see “The Boy from the Goose Corner”).26 They show that Karl Ludwig was gone from home by early 1858, not where he went. His guardian had already said where: on 5 December 1857 he told the court at Karlshafen that Karl Ludwig was in America.27 No court notice read in the Reichsanzeiger of 1866–1925, or in the other papers searched, summons a Gannsen or a Konze as a missing person. The Karlshafen court’s summons of Karl Ludwig Hofedietz in 1900 appears above.28

A single German record could settle his birthplace, his name and his birth date at once. The most promising records are at the Hessisches Staatsarchiv in Marburg: the district’s release files and the 1855–59 Kurhessian army books, which list the men called up by name.29 They exist only as originals, and the archive copies them only to order.

Deisel’s release files survive for the years to 1858 and from 1861, so the gap covers 1859, the year of immigration that the 1900 census gives, and 1860.30 Martina Lüdicke, in her 1994 study, counted about two Deisel emigrants in 1859 and about four in 1860, and she names none of them. No release volume covering 1859 has been found for Deisel or Trendelburg. One of her listed sources is Nr. 115, the district’s census and statistical file for 1859–60. The author has not seen that file; he has asked the archive whether it, or the district’s emigration file, names those emigrants. For those two files he has ordered nothing.31 An 1859 release, if he had one, could still be found among the district’s loose or late-filed papers.

The government’s counts show few people leaving without a release, but they include only the departures the officials knew about (see “Leaving Hesse, c. 1858–1859”).32 One estimate puts those who left Kurhessen without a release in the 1850s at about as many as those with one.33

Kennedy’s 1859 directory is the one pre-war St. Louis directory not yet read for him.34

The St. Louis years

Why was he reduced to the ranks in March 1865? His cards give only the battery’s order, “Co. O. No. 1” (Company Order No. 1), and no court-martial. That spring Battery B also demoted at least four corporals.35 The battery’s own order book, if one survives, would give the reason. The National Archives shows the battery’s books only in its reading room in Washington, and the author has asked record agents there to look for it.

What was the charge at his 1896 Grand Army court-martial? The order of 2 January 1896 from the Grand Army’s Department of Missouri approves the post court’s findings without stating them. The Westliche Post, read page by page for June 1895 to January 1896, has no report of the case.36 The books of his post, Col. Meumann Post No. 496, if they survive, would give his birthplace, and its minutes would name the charge.37

In 1900 Charles asked the Probate Court to name a guardian for the orphaned sons of Theodore Gottlob. Gottlob’s pension file is the first file to order. It should hold his own declarations; it could name Charles, and it would show who looked after the boys’ claim after their father died.38

DNA and family papers

Two DNA leads are still open. One is a small group of MyHeritage matches rooted in the Deisel area, not yet placed on Charles’s own line. The other is a 49-centimorgan match on the side of his grandson Frederick Charles Johnson, not yet placed in any family. “What DNA Can and Cannot Say” describes both.39

Two of his possessions have come down in the line of his grandson Henry C. Johnson: his portrait and his 1867 deed to the family lot.40 Anyone descended from Charles who has old papers, photographs or a Bible could hold the one record that names his village or his parents.

A note for the next researcher

Read the image, not the index. Do not rule a boy out on his birth year or his surname alone. Treat a database’s silence as a pointer, not a negative, until you have measured its coverage. And write down what you searched as carefully as what you found.

So much is settled: the two records that name Trendelburg and Deisel, and the life he lived in St. Louis. What is still open is the boy he had been, with his German name, his parents and his parish. Karl Ludwig Hofedietz is possibly that boy, and the records listed above could show it.

Notes

40 notes
  1. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [LEDGER]
  2. Autosomal tests of a descendant of Charles at FamilyTreeDNA, AncestryDNA and MyHeritage; Deutscher Reichsanzeiger und Preußischer Staatsanzeiger, Nr. 54, 1 Mar 1900, images 14–15; Hessisches Staatsarchiv Marburg, Arcinsys catalog: Best. 180 Hofgeismar Nr. 128. The Karlshafen court files are HStAM Best. 275 Karlshafen (Amtsgericht Karlshafen, 1815–1937), much of it, especially of the nineteenth century, unlisted. [AUTO] [RA1900] [HSTAM]
  3. Declaration of Recruit, Volunteer Enlistment and surgeon’s form for examining a recruit, 2 Dec 1862, St. Louis; St. Marcus Evangelical Church (St. Louis, Missouri), marriage register 1866, p. 135, entry 676/4, image 381. [ENL62] [MAR66]
  4. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [LEDGER]
  5. Parish search coverage, 57 places of Kreis Hofgeismar. [COVER]
  6. The surname record: twenty-eight attestations of Charles’s surname in fourteen spellings; Working positions of the research, October 2026. [SURN] [DEC]
  7. St. Marcus Evangelical Church (St. Louis, Missouri), burial register, pp. 240–241, no. 3393, image 943. [BUR03]
  8. Hessisches Staatsarchiv Marburg, replies to Jed Johnson, 26–28 Oct 2026, Nr. 1546. [HSTAM28]
  9. Professional researcher engaged by the author to work at the Hessisches Staatsarchiv Marburg, emails to Jed Johnson, 13 Nov 2026, Nr. 1546, 180, Nr. 128, Nr. 1998. The call numbers are HStAM Best. 275 (the Karlshafen court records), HStAM 261 Nr. 1546 (Konze against the widow Hoffeditz) and 330 Helmarshausen A 134 (the soldiers on leave). [MRES1113]
  10. Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck, Kassel, Pfarrarchive Trendelburg and Deisel; database search of 10 Jul 2026 (no Konze entries); files not read. Inquiries of 10 Oct 2026 to the archive (E 1 Trendelburg Tr. 169, 174, 175) and to the Pfarramt Trendelburg (Deisel church-council minutes 1828–1866, parish chronicle), unanswered as of 17 Oct 2026. [LKA]
  11. Hessisches Staatsarchiv Marburg, catalog in Arcinsys, consulted Oct 2026: Best. 315 k (Kirchenbuchduplikate) Nr. 176, 178, 179 (Trendelburg) and Nr. 48–50 (Friedrichsfeld); Best. 10 c (Maß- und Rangierbücher), Nr. 1238–1242 (artillery, 1855–1859) and the parallel books of other arms; Best. 330 Helmarshausen A 134, “Beurlaubte Militärs,” 1791–1863. Originals; not read; Hessisches Staatsarchiv Marburg, Arcinsys catalog: Best. 180 Hofgeismar Nr. 128. [HSTAMX] [HSTAM]
  12. Dorfleben. Ein Blick in die Geschichte von Deisel [Village life: a look into the history of Deisel], p. 98. [NICK]
  13. Autosomal tests of a descendant of Charles at FamilyTreeDNA, AncestryDNA and MyHeritage; FamilyTreeDNA Big Y-700 test of a direct male-line descendant of Charles. [AUTO] [BIGY]
  14. Hessisches Staatsarchiv Marburg, replies to Jed Johnson, 26–28 Oct 2026, Nr. 1546. [HSTAM28]
  15. Deutscher Reichsanzeiger und Preußischer Staatsanzeiger, Nr. 54, 1 Mar 1900, images 14–15. [RA1900]
  16. Landeskirchliches Archiv Kassel (Az. 43.1) to Jed Johnson, email, 30 Oct 2026. [LKAK1030]
  17. Martina Lüdicke, Kirchenzucht und Alltagsleben. Page 19, note 25 (the minutes survive), and pages 119, 122 and 262 (the Hofedietz cases). [LUED03]
  18. A researcher in Germany, email to the author, 5 Apr 2026 (“Andreas Konze”), with further emails of 6–8 Apr 2026, letters in the author’s files, American Fork, Utah. Suggests of Charles that “perhaps he belongs to this unusual family,” that of Andreas Konze of Trendelburg, who had “left his family secretly”; A researcher in Germany, email to the author, 12 Apr 2026. [RLET260405] [RLET260412]
  19. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [LEDGER]
  20. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [LEDGER]
  21. Wochenblatt für die Provinz Fulda (Fulda), 1858, Nr. 8, p. 82, image 96; Wochenblatt für die Provinz Oberhessen (Marburg), 1858, Nr. 39, p. 723, image 730; Wochenblatt für die Provinz Niederhessen, 1855–1862, titled Tageblatt für die Provinz Niederhessen from 1 Jul 1858 to 1861 (ZDB IDN 015319938), with its uncounted supplement Polizeiliche Nachrichten, microfilm 37 ZA 2353, and Kasseler Zeitung, 1851–1867, microfilm 37 ZA 2367, Universitätsbibliothek Kassel (a search of the Wochenblatt, 1855–62, requested 17 October 2026, narrowed to 1858–60 on 6 November 2026 and still under way at the library; its first result, sent 17 November 2026, is cited as WB1858); printed holdings of the Wochenblatt (1822–1866) per Zeitschriftendatenbank, ZDB 015319970 (https://zdb-katalog.de/title.xhtml?idn=015319970 : accessed 4 November 2026). Eberhardt’s Allgemeiner Polizei-Anzeiger, 1853–1866, all Hofgeismar notices read (negative). [WBFULDA58] [WBOBERH58] [NIEDWB]
  22. Wochenblatt für die Provinz Niederhessen, 1855–1862; Wochenblatt für die Provinz Niederhessen (Kassel), Nr. 20, 16 Feb 1858. [NIEDWB] [WB1858]
  23. A German paleographer and compiler of village family books, letters to the author by email; A fellow researcher, reading of the 1862 signature. [Paleographer's letters, 2026] [Fellow researcher's reading, 2026]
  24. FamilyTreeDNA Big Y-700 test of a direct male-line descendant of Charles; Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [BIGY] [LEDGER]
  25. 1900 U.S. census, City of St. Louis, Missouri, population schedule, Ward 9, ED 129, sheet 5-B (penned). In June 1900 he was boarding at 170 Sidney Street. Place-keyed and name-keyed searches of the Hamburg passenger lists (Ancestry, https://www.ancestry.com, collection 1068), National Archives AAD Germans to America data, and the New York (M237). Bremen’s own departure lists for these years were destroyed in 1875. [C1900] [SHIPS]
  26. Wochenblatt für die Provinz Niederhessen (Kassel), Nr. 20, 16 Feb 1858; Wochenblatt für die Provinz Fulda (Fulda), 1858, Nr. 8, p. 82, image 96; Wochenblatt für die Provinz Oberhessen (Marburg), 1858, Nr. 39, p. 723, image 730. [WB1858] [WBFULDA58] [WBOBERH58]
  27. Hessisches Staatsarchiv Marburg (HStAM), Protokolle, II Deisel 3 Bd. 3c, pp. 1019–1020, images 229 and 230. [PROT57]
  28. Deutscher Reichsanzeiger und Preußischer Staatsanzeiger, Nr. 54, 1 Mar 1900, images 14–15. [RA1900]
  29. Hessisches Staatsarchiv Marburg, Arcinsys catalog: Best. 180 Hofgeismar Nr. 128; Hessisches Staatsarchiv Marburg, catalog in Arcinsys, consulted Oct 2026. [HSTAM] [HSTAMX]
  30. The two Deisel volumes are HStAM Best. 180 Hofgeismar Nr. 128 and Nr. 841.
  31. Martina Lüdicke, „Verschwunden ist der Strand…“ Studien zur Auswanderung nach Amerika aus Kurhessen in den Jahren 1831–1866, dargestellt am Beispiel des Dorfes Deisel (Kreis Hofgeismar) [“The shore has vanished…”: studies of emigration to America from Kurhessen in the years 1831–1866, shown by the example of the village of Deisel (Kreis Hofgeismar)] Die Geschichte unserer Heimat 14 (Hofgeismar: Verein für hessische Geschichte und Landeskunde, Zweigverein Hofgeismar, 1994). Read in full in a copy borrowed through interlibrary loan, 5 Nov 2026. Pages 33 (figure 2), 81 (table 9) and 86–89 (the list and its sources). Letter to the Hessisches Staatsarchiv Marburg, 6 November 2026. The Trendelburg release volumes resume in 1860. Both files are in HStAM 180 Hofgeismar: Nr. 115, and Nr. 640, the district’s emigration file for 1852–70, which possibly holds only general orders. [LUED]
  32. “Periodische Übersichten über die stattgefundenen Auswanderungen” [Periodic summaries of the emigrations that took place], vol. 4 (1858–1861), image 207, fol. 204. For 1858–60 the government at Kassel sent only district totals to the ministry. [H3243]
  33. Martina Lüdicke, „Verschwunden ist der Strand…“ Studien zur Auswanderung nach Amerika aus Kurhessen in den Jahren 1831–1866, dargestellt am Beispiel des Dorfes Deisel (Kreis Hofgeismar) [“The shore has vanished…”: studies of emigration to America from Kurhessen in the years 1831–1866, shown by the example of the village of Deisel (Kreis Hofgeismar)] Die Geschichte unserer Heimat 14 (Hofgeismar: Verein für hessische Geschichte und Landeskunde, Zweigverein Hofgeismar, 1994). Read in full in a copy borrowed through interlibrary loan, 5 Nov 2026. Page 18, after Auerbach 1985, 21. [LUED]
  34. St. Louis city directories (Kennedy’s, Edwards’, Gould’s), 1860–1904, read year by year in the images. Kennedy’s 1859 directory and the St. Louis aliens’ declarations of 1853–65 survive on fiche or film that can be seen only at the Family History Library. [DIRS]
  35. Compiled Military Service Record, Charles Gannsen, Battery B., rolls 327 and 762; Missouri State Archives, Soldiers’ Records: War of 1812 – World War I, service cards. [CSR] [MOCARDS]
  36. Roster of the Department of Missouri, Grand Army of the Republic, p. 39. Westliche Post, June 1895 – January 1896, read page by page. [GAR]
  37. Roster of the Department of Missouri, Grand Army of the Republic, p. 39. [GAR]
  38. St. Louis Probate Court, application for guardianship, 15 Sep 1900, images 984–985. [GUARD]
  39. Autosomal tests of a descendant of Charles at FamilyTreeDNA, AncestryDNA and MyHeritage. [AUTO]
  40. A descendant of Henry C. Johnson, the present holder of the portrait and the deed. [MAXE]

Supplements

Records, images and data on this website that go with this chapter.