Method: the project holds Mr. Dornette’s complete regional databases locally — 31,945 births, 29,632 deaths, 9,820 marriage rows (Gottsbüren u. Umgebung, 1598–1951). On 16 July 2026 every Carl/Karl birth of 1833–1841 was cross-referenced against the death and marriage sets. 115 Carls were born in the window; 79 are accounted for locally; these 36 vanish. The method self-validates: it independently recovered every previously known emigrant and candidate on the list (Meerkamm, Martini, Fremder, the Köster teacher’s son) with no prior knowledge of them. Each row has since been worked forward: against the Trendelburg researcher’s Oct–Nov 2025 Deisel emigrant sweep and Dec 2025 Person investigation, a corpus variant re-join, complete LAGIS place-lists for all six covered parishes, US-side FamilySearch sweeps, the record images and the Hessian civil registers. That work eliminated, among others, Hartmann, Person and Steitz on individual records, Röllcke (died in childhood; a spelling-drift artifact), Dettmar (died 1926 in DeKalb Co., Illinois) and Köhler (the Sielen Schuhmacher = Charles Louis Kahler of Des Moines, Iowa: 1892 passport oath “born at Sielen… 19 March 1839”; d. 1899), and documented emigrants Gerland 1852, Korte 1856. Two family-level eliminations, Hofeditz and Schildknecht, were withdrawn in July 2026 because a statement about a surname had been applied to a man never shown to be in the group; each was then worked on his own records. Each row below carries its current resolution.
For every boy (not only the Carls) baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld 1833–1841, each cited to the register image and followed forward, see Registers 1830–1858.
Vanisher ≠ emigrant. Absence from the corpus means “unaccounted in the eleven covered parishes,” nothing more. The list itself proves the point both ways: Ludwig Karl Fremder really did emigrate (d. Charleston SC 1869) — but Karl Konze b. 1839 merely moved within Germany (d. Homberg/Efze 1920) and Carl Ludwig Lucas married locally.
Coverage. The Dornette birth corpus covers Gottsbüren, Sielen, Langenthal, Deisel, Eberschütz, Trendelburg, Gewissensruhe, Gottstreu, Friedrichsfeld (partial), Weißehütte and Wülmersen. It does not cover Hümme, Stammen, Helmarshausen, Karlshafen, or the Oberweser/Gans parishes — a boy baptized there cannot appear here. Deaths and marriages likewise: a man who married in Hümme looks like a vanisher.
The Dornette corpus records deaths in two separate channels, and every row on this ledger was re-tested against both: the death file and a death-date annotation in the birth file’s note column. They are not equivalent. For the 324 Deisel births of 1835–45 the death file matches only 34%; birth-file notes cover 67%; either channel, 68%. So roughly one child in three has no death signal at all — meaning “vanishes from the corpus” is a weaker statement than it sounds, and needs the surname’s own coverage attached.
The death file has whole-alphabet gaps. It holds no surnames beginning N, O or T, and only 46 beginning P (all “Probst”) — against 949 N, 233 O, 1,367 T and 855 P births. The marriage file carries all four letters, so this is a defect specific to the death file. For Niemeyer, Thöne, Tölle, Otto, Och, Pfannkuche and Person the birth-note column is the only death channel that exists.
Audit result — the method largely holds. Once both channels are counted, the birth-note column compensates for the gap (Niemeyer 37.5%, Thöne 32.2%, Pfannkuche 48.2%, Meerkamm 65.4%), and 32 of 36 rows rest on an adequate signal. Karl Person is the one candidate whose own birth row carries a death note — and he is correctly eliminated. Every other row’s note is blank, consistent with a genuine vanisher. Meerkamm’s surname runs 65.4% note coverage, and his own note was blank while his relatives’ were filled; he was later eliminated by direct evidence (a laborer at Trendelburg in 1865–66).
✅ Spelling-drift re-join — clean. The exact-name matching of 16 July is known to have missed one man to spelling drift (Röllcke, written Röllke in the death file, found on 17–18 July). Every row on this ledger has been re-tested two further ways. (1) Exact birth date matched across the whole death file ignoring surname entirely — the strongest possible drift catcher. It independently re-finds the Röllcke case (validating the method) and produces no other plausible match: the dozen other birth-date collisions are different people, different sexes, different villages. (2) Variant-surname matching (similarity ≥ 0.72, given name carrying Carl/Karl, birth year within ±3) returns four hits, all demonstrably different people. ⇒ No vanisher is hiding under a drifted spelling. The open rows are genuinely absent from the death file, and the ledger’s method survives the test.
What that does and does not mean. The absences are real — they are not artifacts of a bad join. But their evidential weight is still limited by the two findings above: with roughly one child in three carrying no death signal at all, and whole letters missing from the death file, “vanishes from the corpus” establishes that a man is unaccounted for in the eleven covered parishes — not that he emigrated. Both things are true at once, and the ledger should be read that way.
Four rows are flagged as resting on an inadequate signal — no death information for the surname in either channel: Rothus Karl Och (1 birth corpus-wide, 0% — nothing can be said), Theodor Karl Ermisch (2 births, 0%), Georg Karl Tölle (24.5%) and Friedrich Karl Mühlhausen (20%). Of these Tölle matters most, being the most heavily worked open thread on this ledger (research notes, 18–19 Jul 2026): his vanisher status is the weakest-supported of any actively pursued row, and a local death would be substantially likelier to go unrecorded for his surname than for most.
In July 2026 it was found that the Gottsbüren pastors annotated later fates in the Taufen register’s Bemerkungen margin — including “N. Amerika 18…”-style emigration notes and deaths as late as 1913. On 22 July 2026 this was tested against every Gottsbüren-born row still open on this ledger: all nine baptism entries were located and read in-image (reg. 219049 — both Gerlands, Schröder’s Johann Carl, Ermisch, both Niemeyers, Euler, Tölle, Mühlhausen). Result: neighboring children carry margin notes (“starb 25 Mai 1868”, “†12. April 1889”, “† Bebarbeck 24.1.1913 ∞ Vockenhagen 17.4.65”, “S. Totenbuch S. 64”) — but every vanisher’s own margin is EMPTY (sole exception: Schröder’s carries an illegitimacy status note, no fate). The parish demonstrably tracked children who stayed; it lost track of precisely these boys — weak but consistent corroboration of genuine departure. Bonus entry-level facts: Tölle’s godfather was “in Amerika” in 1839 (see his row); Ermisch was born at the Sababurg with a Lieutenant von Bärenstein (Fulda) among aristocratic godparents — a posting-mobile family, relocation likelier than emigration; Euler’s godfather was a “Kaufmann in Oldenburg” — the organ-builder family had out-of-region kin (new lead: Oldenburg); Mühlhausen was a twin (with Heinrich, both b. 16.1.1840 — corpus agrees); C.W. Niemeyer’s godfather was a Carl Gerland.
This ledger’s central move is to treat a boy with no death and no marriage in the Dornette corpus as having plausibly left. That move has now been measured against its own base rate, and the result should govern how every row below is read. Of the 110 Trendelburg births of 1830–1840 in the birth corpus, only 20.9% carry an exact-birthdate death or marriage row; 79.1% are unaccounted. Being unaccounted is therefore the normal condition for this cohort, not a signal — the corpus’s death and marriage coverage is simply much thinner than its birth coverage.
This does not retire the method. The cross-referencing of 16 July independently recovered every previously known emigrant on this list with no prior knowledge of them, and that remains its warrant. But it does fix what the output is: a list of leads, not a finding. No candidate should be promoted on vanisher status alone, and a row that says only “unaccounted” is a row that has not yet been researched. The rows that carry weight below are the ones with a positive trace — a manifest, an exit record, a margin note, a death abroad.
Worked example. The nine confirmands on the first leaf of the 1849 Trendelburg class (the class had 19 boys; for the second leaf, Nr 10–19, see below) were run through the net on 2 Aug 2026: eight came back unaccounted. Against a 79% base rate the expected number is 7.1. The class is typical. Two of the nine had also been scored “he stayed” on corpus rows matched by surname without the birth date, and both named different men — corrected in the errata. The class’s most promising name, Carl Wilhelm Henze, turned out to have been worked to closure six weeks earlier — his baptism was pulled on 21 June 2026 and he was born in Trendelburg, so his “vanisher” status was nothing but a corpus coverage gap. He is kept on the ledger above as a worked example of exactly the error this note is about. A second name from that class, Friedrich August Hund (b. 19 Jan 1835, day-laborer’s son, mother née Niemeyer), is deliberately not given a row here: he is not a Carl, and his only qualification was the vanisher status this note devalues. He is recorded in the names database instead.
The ledger — 36 vanished Karls from the corpus net, plus 1 cautionary re-entry from the confirmation registers
| Born | Name | Parish | Parents | Status | Resolution / known information |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 22.4.1833 | Karl Wilh.Julius Köster | Deisel | Johannes Köster, Lehrer m. Mria Katharina Schlenke ? |
Traced — not Charles | Son of the Gotha letter-writer Johannes Köster (Lehrer, Deisel; sailed from Bremen 6 Nov 1858 → New Orleans, Jan 1859). The complete letter series (transcriptions + A–Z name index) was swept July 2026 — no mention of Charles under any surname form. Caveat (research note, 17 Jul 2026): Köster deliberately shunned destitute Deisel countrymen in St. Louis, so this negative carries little weight against Charles being there. Documented Köster identity throughout. Research page → (Baptism: Deisel 1833, Archion 218842, Bild 26, Nro 123.) |
| 12.6.1833 | Carl Friedr.Wilh. Gerland | Gottsbüren | Friedrich Wilhelm Gerland, Ackermann m. Dorothea Wilhelm. Grünewald |
Open — swept, unresolved | Not in the LAGIS exit lists — negative re-verified 19 Jul 2026 on a complete 96/96 pull, unlike the Trendelburg/Deisel/Eberschütz negatives from the same sweep, which proved false. Eight Gottsbüren Gerland rows; the one worth checking, “Gerland, Karl, 1860” (64999), is b. 1800, Weber, → Braunschweig — not him. The 1852 Nordamerika emigrant is the other Gerland boy, Karl Friedrich August. Research page → |
| 16.7.1833 | Carl Friedr.August Gerland | Gottsbüren | Friedrich Gerland, Schreiner m. Sabine Lotz |
Documented emigrant — open | LAGIS-documented emigrant, 1852 → Nordamerika, age 19 (LAGIS 11522/141360/17443; HStAM Best. 16 Nr. 3237, S. 324; assets 200; detail record read). Open US lead: the 1885 St. Louis directory (image 224/1678; index ark 6ZFF-FBP5) has three Gerland households — “Gerland Charles, farmer, r. ns. Calvary av. [nr.] B’way”, “Gerland Caroline, wid. Philip, r. ns. Christ[y] av. nr. B’way”, “Gerland August H., porter, r. 2024 Sidney”. A farmer named Charles Gerland near North Broadway, the same corridor as Charles Gannsen’s documented residences. The settled St. Louis Gerlands are probably not the Gottsbüren clan: Missouri held exactly one Gerland family in 1880, Philip Gerland b. 1828 Germany × Caroline b. 1828 (children b. Missouri from 1861), and no Philipp Gerland exists in the Gottsbüren birth corpus 1820–35 (a Charles Gerland b. 1865 enlisted in the U.S. Army at St. Louis in 1886). No Charles Gerland anywhere in Missouri in 1880, so the 1885 farmer arrived 1880–85; whether he is the 1852 Gottsbüren emigrant is open. No Charles Gerland death in Missouri 1885–1910, and none in the 1900/1910 St. Louis censuses. Advancing him needs un-indexed sources: year-by-year directory images 1884–1890 and St. Louis burial registers (research notes, 17–18 Jul 2026). Research page → |
| 25.3.1834 | Karl Ludwig Hund | Langenthal | illegitimate m. Maria Sophia Hund |
Open — swept, unresolved | No Langenthal/LAGIS exit record; no corpus death or marriage under variants. (The 31 Mar 2026 Hund elimination was Friedrich August Hund — a different person. A namesake “Hund, August Friederich” emigrated from Trendelburg 1866, LAGIS 65036 — also distinct.) Unaccounted. Research page → |
| 22.8.1834 | Maria Sophie Karl | Deisel | Helwig Karl, Soldat m. Charlotte Vilmar |
Out of profile | Female — the surname “Karl” matched the given-name scan; listed for transparency only. (Deisel confirmations 1848, Archion 218836, Bild 933, girls Nr 8) Research page → |
| 1.12.1834 | Carl Ludwig Martini | Trendelburg | Philipp Eduard Martini, Chirurgus m. Gertrude Schember |
Open — High | Open (priority High): one of the eight open Carls. Emigrated 1854; life in America not found. Confirmed 1849. LAGIS-documented emigrant, Aug 1854 → North America (assets 400). Son of the Trendelburg city surgeon. The St. Louis “Charles Martini” chain (m. Lücker 1866, d. 1905) is likely not him (1880-census parents mismatch; research note, 12 Jul 2026); his U.S. fate is fully open. Surname and class argue against a Martini→Gannsen identification. Research page → (Baptism: Trendelburg 1834, Archion 220108, Bild 1414, Nro 119.) |
| 30.12.1834 | Ludwig Karl Fremder | Deisel | Andreas Fremder, Schuhmacher m. Maria Koch |
Eliminated | Died 4 Nov 1869, Bethany Cemetery, Charleston, South Carolina (Find a Grave 210640104; research notes, 9–11 Jul 2026). Released Aug 1852 as a shoemaker for “Südamerika” (LAGIS 14654; HStAM 180 Hofgeismar Nr. 128, p. 74), which meant South Carolina: naturalized at Charleston 10 Jun 1859, nation “Diesel Germany” (NARA RG 21, Aliens Admitted as Citizens 1790–1860, vol. 1, image 34; Ancestry 2504). Proven (trace log 24 Oct 2026): eliminated as Charles, identified as Capt. Charles Fremder. 1860 census Charleston 3rd Ward, Charles Fremder b. 1836 (FS MZTH-9KL), in the same ward as his brother Joseph (b. 1839, released Sept 1858, Confederate corporal, Bachman’s German Light Artillery); quartermaster, German Hussars (FS F9VC-HYX). A vanisher who did emigrate — and stayed traceable under his own name. (Deisel confirmations 1849, Archion 218836, Bild 934, Seite 67, Nr 2) Research page → |
| 8.1.1835 | Carl Wilhelm Henze | Trendelburg | Johannes Henze, Heimbäcker m. Wilhelmine geb. Scheele |
Eliminated — died Frankfurt 1892 | Eliminated (research note, 9 Oct 2026). He died at Frankfurt am Main in December 1892, aged 57, a postal official “geboren zu Trendelburg”, son of the late Bäckermeister Johann Henze and Wilhelmine geb. Scheele (Standesamt Frankfurt I, Sterberegister 1892 Nr. 3765; HStAM 903 Nr. 10456, image 89). Every detail matches the baptism. The baptism (Archion 220108, Seite 37, entry № 123, img 1415, re-read in the image): Carl Wilhelm Henze, born 8 January 1835 (“der achte Januar”, agreeing with the 1849 confirmation), baptized 18 January 1835, house Trendelburg Nr. 18, father Johannes Henze, Heimbäcker (home baker), mother Wilhelmine geb. Scheele. He was born in Trendelburg, and the surname is clearly Henze on both primary records. Two earlier readings are withdrawn: “Carl Wilhelm GANZEN” (an H/G confusion at low zoom, June 2026) and the birth date “1 January”. The Trendelburg Bäckermeister Wilhelm Henze of 1897 (d. 19 Jan 1901, aged 53, son of Ludwig Henze × Karoline Kohlus) is a cousin, not this man (research note, 8 Oct 2026). Not Charles. Errata → |
| 6.2.1835 | Carl Ludwig Lucas | Trendelburg | illegitimate m. Wilhelmine Lucas |
Eliminated | Illegitimate. Birth date now settled at 6 February 1835 — the 1849 Trendelburg confirmation register (220102 img 2270, entry 9, Alter 14y 3m 21d) and the Dornette birth corpus agree to the day, and both name the mother Wilhelmine; the site’s old “15 Feb” reading of Entry 128 in reg. 220108 is superseded. A Trendelburg researcher found his German marriage record (13 Apr 2026): he stayed and married locally. Not Charles. ⚠ A claim that this elimination was additionally “hardened” by a Trendelburg death of 16 Oct 1862 has been withdrawn — that death belongs to the Karl Ludwig Lucas born 7 Dec 1799 (errata). The researcher’s elimination stands on its own. Research page → (Baptism: Trendelburg 1835, Archion 220108, Bild 1417, Nro 128.) |
| 15.2.1835 | Johann Carl Schröder | Gottsbüren | illegitimate m. Gertrud Elisabeth Schröder |
Unresolved — re-opened Oct 2026 | Illegitimate near-miss already assessed in the Gottsbüren sweep: b. 15 Feb ≠ 26 Jan; Schröder a common local family; no Konze link. Re-opened in October 2026: no record of him after his confirmation at Gottsbüren in 1849 has been found. (Gottsbüren baptisms 1835, Archion 219049, Bild 845, Seite 52, Nro 205) Research page → |
| 11.9.1835 | Rothus Karl Och | Gewissensruhe | Paul Och, Steueraufseher m. Katharina Vogel |
Open — swept, unresolved | No corpus trace. LAGIS Hesse-wide holds only Fulda-area Och families (Elters/Hünhan) — no Rothus Karl, and Gewissenruh has no covered exit list. Unaccounted. Research page → |
| 8.3.1836 | Karl Ludwig Lucas | Trendelburg | Johann George Lucas, Tagelöhner m. Anna Marie Weecke |
Assessed — not Charles | ⚠ The old “no exit” note here was wrong. A LAGIS surname query (19 Jul 2026) returns him: emigrated March 1862, “Preussen (ohne Zielangabe)”, Fabrikarbeiter, Vermögen 20 (id 65029; HStAM 180 Hofgeismar Nr. 850, S. 74) — the only Trendelburg Lucas in the whole database. Timing, town and class all fit Charles; the surname does not, and cannot yield any of the nine canon spellings. Not Charles. Also flags a probable 1835/1836 conflation in the Trendelburg researcher’s file. Research page → (Baptism: Trendelburg 1836, Archion 220108, Bild 1427, Nro 153.) |
| 12.5.1836 | Friedr.Karl Wilh. Zollmann | Trendelburg | Johann Conrad Zollmann, Tagelöhner m. Wilhelmine Bromm |
Open — swept, unresolved | Untraced after 1850; weak fit for Charles. Baptism re-read in the image (Bild 1428): born 12 May, baptized 25 May 1836. No exit in the complete Trendelburg LAGIS list; LAGIS Hesse-wide Zollmann = a single Mensfelden 1842 entry (wrong region). No civil death at Trendelburg 1874–1925. Nro 95 is his elder brother Friedrich Wilhelm (b. 30 Jan 1834; an Eisenbahnarbeiter at Bockenheim 1862–69; d. Bad Vilbel 1887), and the 1865 Bockenheim infant namesake (corpus 87120) is that brother’s son, not this boy. Their father’s 1874 burial (220114 Bild 926, Nro 1173, image) names his mother as Katharina Elisabeth geb. Jungkontze, a Jungkonze kin link, but lists no children. Hamburg 1861 “Carl Zollmann” is a Nassau man (research note, 10 Oct 2026). Research page → |
| 22.5.1836 | Karl Wilh.Ludwig Hartmann | Deisel | Johann Hartmann, Ackermann m. Wilhelmine Göbel |
Eliminated | Eliminated in the Trendelburg researcher’s Oct–Nov 2025 “Karl”-firstname Deisel emigrant sweep: on the researcher’s Deisel emigrant list (em. 1856) and traced via U.S.-side death records to Philadelphia, where he died — never Missouri. (Emails 30 Oct–1 Nov 2025; sweep log.) (Deisel emigrant list for 1856, Lüdicke 1994, List C, pp. 86–88) Research page → (Baptism: Deisel 1836, Archion 218842, Bild 49, Nro 251.) |
| 6.6.1836 | Theodor Karl Ermisch | Gottsbüren | Louis Ermisch, Conduktor m. Amalie Von Bärenstein |
Open — swept, unresolved | Not in the Gottsbüren LAGIS exit list (fully read); no corpus death/marriage. A Conduktor’s family is mobile — likely simply moved with a posting. Unaccounted. Research page → |
| 14.9.1836 | Karl Person | Deisel | Ludwig Person, Schmied m. Chrlotte Deppe |
Eliminated | Eliminated: died 31 Oct 1898 in Kassel (research note, 8 Oct 2026). Standesamt Kassel I, Sterberegister 1898 Nr. 1357 (HStAM 910 Nr. 5439, image 156), read in the image — der Schmied Carl Person, 62 Jahre, geboren zu Deisel, Kreis Hofgeismar, Sohn des verstorbenen Schmieds Ludwig Person und … Charlotte geborene Deppe (FS PHM6-8PK), with a continuous German record trail 1836–1898. He is also the “Karl Jansen” of Deisel Nro 263 (a misreading of Person; below). He was a serious near-miss (b. Deisel, 19 months off; surname a documented Branson mutation), investigated with the Trendelburg researcher in Dec 2025. See the Person family page. Research page → (Baptism: Deisel 1836, Archion 218842, Bild 51, Nro 263.) |
| 6.10.1836 | Carl Friedrich Thöne | Eberschütz | Johann Ludwig Thöne, Leinweber m. Maria Sophie Lappe |
Open — family emigration found | ⚠⚠ The old “no Thöne exit” note was comprehensively wrong. A complete re-pull (19 Jul 2026) finds ~25 Thoene/Thöne/Thoener rows from Eberschütz — including a Feb 1846 family party to NORDAMERIKA (“Auswanderung mit Familie”: Johannes, Frau, Karoline, Konrad Ludwig, Sohn, Tochter; HStAM 180 Hofgeismar Nr. 129, S. 146; LAGIS 82657). Carl Friedrich was 9 years old that month — exactly how a child rides in a party as an unnamed “Sohn.” ⚠️ Father recorded as Johannes vs. our Johann Ludwig — identification NOT made. Research page → |
| 25.5.1837 | Carl Wilhelm Lucas | Trendelburg | David Lucas, Ackerbürger m. Maria Sophie Wendel |
Open — untraced | Open: one of the eight open Carls. Untraced after his confirmation. The surname cannot produce any canon spelling, but that is not a ground for elimination under the standard of October 2026 (an adult record matching the baptism on three identifiers). No exit record: only one Trendelburg Lucas exists in LAGIS (record 65029), and it is Karl Ludwig Lucas, b. 1836. His father died in 1842 (research note, 15 Oct 2026). (Baptism: Trendelburg 1837, Archion 220108, Bild 1439, Nro 190; b. 25.5.1837.) Research page → |
| 11.6.1837 | Karl Just.August Brandau | Deisel | Johannes Brandau, Lehrer m. Jeanette Marie Stephan |
Open — emigrated 1856, US life untraced | Open: one of the eight open Carls. He emigrated, but an emigration is not an adult-record elimination and his American life is untraced, so he is counted among the open Carls (since 22 Oct 2026). The baptism body leaf (Taufen 218842, Bild 59 / Seite 58, Nro 310): father Johannes Brandau, Elementarlehrer; the remarks column reads “verschollen” (missing), read twice, by eye at magnification and by Archion’s Texterkennung — the only positive vanish marker in the Deisel 1836–41 read. The leaf gives the birth as 11 July 1837, agreeing with his 1852 confirmation at Immenhausen (project conf. row 1172; a Lehrer’s family moves with the posting), against the Dornette database’s 11.6.1837. No Deisel exit (the Trendelburg researcher’s list + LAGIS Deisel list, both complete). The emigration (research note, 9 Oct 2026): LAGIS (three entries) “Brandau, Karl Justus Aug. K., Immenhausen”, born 1837, Riemer/Sattler (saddler), to North America, September 1856 (HStAM 180 Hofgeismar Nr. 141 S. 188); Germans to America: “Carl Brandau”, 19, saddler, ship Donau from Hamburg, New York, 15 Nov 1856. A poor fit for Charles: born at Deisel in summer, not January, with no surname link. Research page → |
| 22.9.1837 | Carl Niemeyer | Gottsbüren | Friedrich Niemeyer, Leinweber m. Marie Elisabeth Fiege |
Open — swept, unresolved | No corpus death/marriage. ✔ RESOLVED (18 Jul 2026): the LAGIS 1866 “Karl Niemeyer” record (65010) is an internal move to Hannover, Oct 1866, as a railway worker (Eisenbahner/Weichensteller; HStAM Best. 180 Hofgeismar Nr. 872, S. 106) — not an emigration. Whichever Niemeyer boy he is was still in Germany in Oct 1866 and cannot be Charles; the other brother-namesake remains unaccounted. Research page → (Baptism: Gottsbüren 1837, Archion 219049, Bild 869, Seite 76, Nro 333.) |
| 13.11.1837 | Karl Ludwig Hofeditz | Deisel | Ricus Hofeditz, Kutscher m. Amalie Weller |
Open — the leading candidate | Open: the compiler’s leading candidate (28 Oct 2026), not proven. The book makes the case that Charles was possibly this boy: a Carl Ludwig, born in November, at Deisel, the village Charles named at his wedding; orphaned at six; confirmed 1852 and then gone; fined and summoned in 1858 as a conscript absent from that year’s muster; summoned as a missing emigrant by the court at Karlshafen in 1900, with the Deisel innkeeper Heinrich Konze as his curator. The name Konze is possibly that of the family that took him in (a hypothesis). He is the leading candidate, not the only one still open. The 1858 notices (the Karlshafen court’s fine of 21 Jan 1858 and the Hofgeismar district office’s summons of 6 Feb 1858, printed in the Wochenblatt für die Provinz Fulda, 1858, Nr 8, p. 82, and Nr 9, p. 110) show that he was gone from home by early 1858. They do not say where he went or tie him to Charles, so the grade stays possibly. See the book chapter “The Boy from the Goose Corner”. Earlier note (Oct 2026), kept for the record: the surname Hofeditz has no phonetic path to Gannsen, which is why the row was first marked a low fit. Baptism re-read in the image (218842 Bild 62, Nro 327; birth day corrected in the register to the 13th; godfather Ludwig Rohmann, the mother’s brother). Confirmed at Deisel 1852; no Deisel church marriage c. 1850–85, no civil marriage at Deisel 1874–1901 or Trendelburg 1886–1901, no LAGIS record (research note, 9 Oct 2026; research note, 9 Oct 2026). His own household stayed and died in Deisel — father Ricus d. 19 Jul 1843, mother Amalie Florentine Weller d. 3 Nov 1844, sister Sophia d. 1 Oct 1854, each matched on exact birth date. The old family-level elimination (“the Hofeditz family went to Kansas”, Oct 2025) was withdrawn in July 2026: it rested on an Ancestry lookup by Jed Johnson that the Trendelburg researcher agreed with, not on German-side research, and 0 of 125 US Hofeditz Find a Grave memorials are in Kansas. The 1880 “C. L. Hofeditz” of Mound Valley, Kansas, is Conrad Ludwig Hofeditz, who came to Baltimore in 1848 aged 8 with his parents (research note, 9 Oct 2026). Deisel Hofeditz cousins were in New York City from 1858 (index only): a “John Henry Hofeditz, b. Deisel, Hesse Cassel” married in Manhattan on 28 May 1866, and Mina Hofeditz (parents Ludwig × Charlotte Heere) married there in 1872. No Karl/Carl/Charles/Louis Hofeditz appears among them, in Westphalian indexes, in Missouri, or in the Hamburg lists of 1850–66 (research note, 10 Oct 2026). Next test: the Lütgendortmund registers on Archion (136688/136691/136697/136700), page by page. Research page → |
| 24.4.1838 | Carl Wilhelm Niemeyer | Gottsbüren | Johann Christoph Niemeyer, Taglöhner m. Marie Elisabeth Dettmar |
Open — swept, unresolved | Confirmed 1852 Gottsbüren (project row 996) — alive in Hesse at 14. The LAGIS 1866 record is now read in detail: an internal move to Hannover as a railway worker (see the 1837 Niemeyer row) — whichever of the two he is, that man stayed in Germany past Oct 1866 and is not Charles. The other remains unaccounted. Research page → (Baptism: Gottsbüren 1838, Archion 219049, Bild 872, Seite 79, Nro 363.) |
| 16.9.1838 | Karl Theodor Euler | Gottsbüren | Conrad Balthasar Euler, Orgelbauer m. Elisa Regina Phil. Hillenhagen |
Open — swept, unresolved | Not in the Gottsbüren LAGIS exit list; no corpus death/marriage (Gottsbüren Euler deaths are all other family members). An Orgelbauer’s son — mobile trade. Unaccounted. Research page → |
| 2.2.1839 | Carl August Reich | Gottstreu | Johann Jacob Reich, Müller m. Christine Louise Herwig |
Open — swept, unresolved | No corpus trace; LAGIS name-search shows no Reich from any covered village (Gottstreu has no separate exit list). Unaccounted. Research page → |
| 3.3.1839 | Karl Wilhelm Dettmar | Langenthal | Wilhelm Dettmar, Ackermann m. Wilhelmine Alberding |
Eliminated | Eliminated (certificate grade). Emigrated 1850 in the Langenthal Dettmar family party (LAGIS 108711, “Dettmar; Ditmar”; exit detail: Feb 1850 → Nordamerika, “geboren 1839”, HStAM Best. 180 Hofgeismar Nr. 847, S. 17). Found US-side: Charles W. Dettmer, farmer, South Grove Twp., DeKalb Co., Illinois (censuses 1880/1910/1920), d. 15 Sept 1926. His Illinois death certificate no. 34718 (reg. 6366), read in the image: b. 3 Mar 1839 Germany, age 87y 6m 12d (back-calculates exactly), farmer, mother Wilmina Alberning = Wilhelmine Alberding; father given as “August Dettmer” (corpus: Wilhelm; the informant was his son C. R. Dettmer — flagged, but the identification rests on exact birth date + mother). Never Missouri; alive 23 years past Charles’s death. Research page → |
| 19.3.1839 | Karl Ludwig Köhler | Sielen | Friedrich Wilhelm Köhler, Leinweber m. Johanna Dettmar |
Resolved — eliminated | Eliminated: he is Charles Louis Kahler of Des Moines, Iowa. LAGIS-documented emigrant, 1857 (LAGIS 45728/117191; Beruf Schuhmacher, HStAM Best. 16 Nr. 3239, S. 550). Chain, all read in the image or record-grade: 1860 census Des Moines “Charles Koller, 20, Shoemaker, b. Hessen” (M653 roll 338, p. 17, line 32) → m. Mary Lehman, 2 Oct 1867, Des Moines (Iowa County Marriages) → 1870 “Charles Kahler, Boot & Shoe Merchant”, Ward 3, $18,000 RE → naturalized District Court Des Moines 1874 → 1880 “Chas L. Kahler, Bookstore Dealer”, 511 Third St (children Frank, Carl, Saloma) → ⭐ 1892 US passport application, sworn: “born at SIELEN, Germany on 19 March 1839… sailed from Bremen ~15 Oct 1857… 35 years at Des Moines” (FS img 3:1:3QS7-L9D6-492G) → d. 18 Oct 1899, Woodland Cemetery, Des Moines (Polk Co. gravestone records, p. 442; exact birth date 19.3.1839 on the stone record). He kept his own name (Köhler→Koller/Kahler/Kohler) throughout — the third full proof (after Fremder, Dettmar) that the vanisher boys stayed traceable. The GTA “arr. NY 3 Oct 1857” flag predates his sworn ~15 Oct sailing and is set aside. LAGIS 114993 “Koehler; Hofeditz, Karl Ludwig” names a second party, most probably his uncle by marriage Christian Ludwig Hofeditz (b. 1799, husband of Maria Elisabeth Dettmar), not an alias (research note, 9 Oct 2026). Research page → (Baptism: Sielen 1839, Archion 220042, Bild 1866, Seite 38, Nro 175.) |
| 7.6.1839 | Karl Konze | Deisel | Johann Christoph Konze, Ackermann m. Marie Drönner |
Eliminated | Died 23 Sept 1920, Homberg/Efze (death record verified 5 Jul 2026; the register image itself was read 7 Oct 2026: born Deisel, Kreis Hofgeismar, aged 81, a retired teacher — HStAM Best. 920 Nr. 3597, Nr. 45). The cautionary case for this whole list: a “vanisher” who merely moved within Germany — absence from the corpus is not emigration. Research page → (Baptism: Deisel 1839, Archion 218842, Bild 76, Nro 398.) |
| 27.8.1839 | Carl Wilh.Richard Meerkamm | Trendelburg | Ferdinand Meerkamm, Tagelöhner m. Caroline Nolte |
Eliminated | Eliminated (research note, 9 Oct 2026): the Trendelburg burial register (220114, Bild 885 and 891) records two stillborn daughters, 13 Jun 1865 and 11 Nov 1866, of the Tagelöhner Karl Wilhelm Richard Meerkamm and Anna Margarethe geb. Jaeger of Sielen. He was married and living at Trendelburg in 1865–66, when Charles had been in St. Louis for years and in the Union army since 1862. Until then he was the leading ~1839 candidate: baptism and Easter-1853 Trendelburg confirmation register-verified (reg. 220108); sister Marie Sophie (b. 18 Jan 1842) died in the U.S.; aunt Wilhelmine arr. New York 25 Sep 1855 (manifest-verified); the third family exit (Henrich Wilhelm, Feb 1860) went to Preussen, not America (LAGIS 65025; HStAM Best. 180 Hofgeismar Nr. 850, S. 21). Research page → |
| 15.9.1839 | Georg Karl Tölle | Gottsbüren | Johannes Tölle, Leinweber m. Maria Elisabeth Barthel |
Open — swept, unresolved | Untraced; he left Gottsbüren alive before spring 1853 with no exit paper. The baptism, read in the image (Taufen reg. 219049, Bild 880 = S. 87, Nro 443; permalink): “Gottsbüren, Haus Nr. 69 — geb. am sechsten September, mittags 12 Uhr, getauft am 13ten September [1839] — George Carl Tölle — Eltern Johannes Tölle, ein Leineweber, und dessen Ehefrau Maria Elisabeth geborene Barthel — Taufpathe “Carl Tölle, ein Schneider, … IN AMERIKA” — margin empty.” The birth is 6 Sep 1839 (the corpus’s 15.9.1839 is impossible against the 13 Sep baptism). His godfather-namesake was already in America in 1839: most probably Carl George Tölle b. 9.10.1803, the only adult-generation Carl in the corpus, with no corpus marriage and no burial anywhere in the Gottsbüren register 1830–84 — an unrecorded early emigrant and a kin anchor the boy could later follow. Leaving: he is in neither the 1853 nor the 1854 Gottsbüren confirmation class (classmates born days from his birthday are), and the burial index 1830–84 holds no death for him, so he left the parish alive, under 13½. His household: no exit record. The LAGIS Tölle exits of 1853–54 (LAGIS 53656, 17447; the Wilhelmina, Baltimore 12 Aug 1853, “Johann Tölle, 48, Gottsbüren, Joiner”, alone; the Maryland, May 1854, Friederich, 18, alone) belong to a different family, the Schreiner Johannes Tölle (b. 1.5.1805) — Gottsbüren had three adult Tölle householders. The 1852 widow “geb. Dörbaum, Wittwe des Leinwebers Johann Georg Tölle”, Haus 123, belongs to a third family, not his. No adult Leineweber-Tölle burial exists in the register 1839–52, so his parents’ fates are open. Working model: the whole household left unrecorded, plausibly to the godfather in America; orphan placement is the second model. Haus 69 was also home to Heinrich Tölle × Anna Elisabeth Barthel (she d. 1849): two Tölle×Barthel couples in one house, likely brothers married to sisters, whose children are his closest kin. Weak US flags: William Tolle b. ~1838 arr. NY 29 Jul 1857 ex Bremen; Georg Tolle b. 1836 “Hedemunden” Balt. Oct 1854; Heinrich Tolle 25, Bremen, Balt. Oct 1864. Next: burial S. 88–98 sweep for the mother, and a US search for a tailor Carl Tolle b. ~1803, in America by 1839. Research page → |
| 2.1.1840 | Heinrich Karl Korte | Sielen | Johann Konrad Korte, Schmied m. Maria Elisabeth Meier |
Documented emigrant — open | LAGIS-documented emigrant, 1856, named in the family party of his father Johann Konrad Korte, Schmied (LAGIS 115029; party incl. Frau, two unnamed Söhne, Töchter, Maria Sophie, and Meier/Korte kin). Detail record read 18 Jul: May 1856 → Amerika, “geboren 1840” in the record itself (HStAM Best. 180 Hofgeismar Nr. 154, S. 138) — identity sealed. Manifest search (18 Jul): NEGATIVE at all three German-immigrant ports — no Korte family group in the Baltimore, New York, or New Orleans indexes for 1856 (incl. the PILI/Germans-to-America layer). FamilySearch’s manifest-level index (Maryland, Baltimore Passenger Lists 1820–1948) also negative for Kort* 1855–57; the “Doris/Davis Karte” flag is ELIMINATED — FS record (ark 1:1:QK6L-W59T): Doris Karte, 18, b. Rahden (Westphalia), ship President Schmidt 1856, with Louise Karte — not Sielen. Remaining flags: Conrad Korte (b. ~1813) + Johann Conrad Korte (b. ~1846), NY 25 Oct 1854 ex Bremen (wrong date — possible kin); Sophia Kord, 1857, “Hessia” (weak). The party of ~8 hides under a mangled index form or an unindexed list; next: roll-browse Baltimore May–Jul 1856 arrivals (M255 roll 11). Research page → (Baptism: Sielen 1840, Archion 220042, Bild 1870, Seite 42, Nro 192.) |
| 16.1.1840 | Friedrich Karl Mühlhausen | Gottsbüren | Georg Mühlhausen, Forstaufseher m. Marie Friederike Kuhlmann |
Open — swept, unresolved | Not in the Gottsbüren LAGIS exit list; no corpus death/marriage. Forstaufseher’s son — posting-mobile family. Unaccounted. Research page → (Baptism: Gottsbüren 1840, Archion 219049, Bild 882, Seite 89, Nro 465.) |
| 1.5.1840 | Karl Wilhelm Heinr Röllcke | Gottsbüren | Georg Friedrich Röllcke, Taglöhner m. Maria Philippine Gerland |
Eliminated | Died 25 March 1842, Gottsbüren, age 1¾ — the Dornette death row spells him Röllke, so the exact-name matching of 16 July missed it (found by variant matching; corpus death row 77400, exact birth-date match). A spelling-drift artifact, not a vanisher. Research page → |
| 7.7.1840 | Johannes Karl Steitz | Deisel | Johannes Steitz, Wegewärter m. Anna Katharina Koch |
Eliminated | Eliminated in the Trendelburg researcher’s Oct–Nov 2025 Deisel emigrant sweep: emigrated and died in Ohio (U.S.-side death record, confirmed 1 Nov 2025) — never Missouri. Recorded as family #10 on the negative-results roster; sweep log. (Deisel baptisms 1840, Archion 218842, Bild 88, Seite 87, Nro 464) Research page → |
| 24.12.1840 | Karl Schildknecht | Deisel | illegitimate m. Amalie Schildknecht |
Eliminated — emigrated with his family, 1854 | ✔ Eliminated (research notes, 7 Oct 2026). He is Deisel Nro 489, entered “Männl.: Karl, unehelich” with no surname, mother Amalie Schildknecht. The baptism (Bild 92, re-read at full resolution) names the father — “des Soldaten Philipp Niemeyer” — and the house is Ziegelstraße Nr. 28. The boy was legitimated as Karl Niemeyer, confirmed at Deisel in 1854 under age by dispensation (218836 Bild 947, Nr 44), and landed at Baltimore on the Weser, 17 July 1854, aged 14 (Baltimore index card, FamilySearch QV9F-KQT1, front read in image; companions are on the unfilmed back, marked “OVER”). That he traveled with his parents and five siblings rests on index entries for the other Niemeyers aboard the same ship (LAGIS id 14631). Year, companions and port all contradict Charles’s own account (c. 1859, alone, St. Louis). Settlement (“Mitteltown”) unresolved. The Schildknecht family-level elimination of Oct 2025 (“they emigrated too late — in 1866”) was withdrawn in July 2026: there was no 1866 Schildknecht exodus, and the derivation was circular. His mother also bore the surname-less Nro 336 Andreas (1838) — see the Deisel no-surname boys below. Research page → |
| 31.12.1840 | Karl Meimbreße | Deisel | Konrad Meimbreße, Schuhmacher m. Anna Katharina Weeke |
Eliminated — married in the parish | Eliminated: he married twice in Germany. His baptism, Deisel 218842 Nro 490 (“Karl Meimbresse”, b. Dec 1840, Konrad M., Schuhmacher × Anna Katharina Wecke), carries two later marriage notes: “Kirchlich getraut d. 27/5 66 mit Hermine Wilke; 2. d. [?] 76 mit Anna Katharina Koch” (research note, 7 Oct 2026). The family’s exits: an 1857 group (Ludwig Gottlieb, Henrich, Gottlieb, Karoline, Maria, Marie Wilhelmine) with no Karl and no Konrad, and in 1862 his brother Philipp Heinrich Meimbresse, b. 9 Dec 1836 (Nro 284, confirmed 1851; LAGIS 70401/115268; read in image), checked on a complete 422/422 pull. No US trace for Philipp Heinrich under any of 12 spellings; a Heinrich Philipp Meimbresse × Stuckenberg had children in Bremen in 1865 and 1868 (index only, unverified). Research page → (Baptism: Deisel 1840, Archion 218842, Bild 93, Nro 490.) |
| 13.3.1841 | Karl Wilhelm Koch | Deisel | Friedrich Koch, Schäfer m. Anna Katharina Feuring |
Eliminated — died at Deisel 1917 | Eliminated (research note, 9 Oct 2026): the Schäfer Karl Koch died at Deisel on 4 Dec 1917, aged 77, born at Deisel, widower of Emilie geb. Lucas, son of the Schäfer Friedrich Koch × Marie geb. Feuring (Deisel 1917 Nr 30, HStAM 909 Nr 975 img 32, read in the image); the Hesse marriage index calls him “Karl Wilhelm Koch”. Father’s name and trade and the mother’s maiden name match. (An earlier reading had set the 1917 entry aside without a reason. The 1893 Deisel death of a Karl Wilhelm Koch is Nro 460, and the 1901 Deisel groom of that name was born in 1872.) Research page → (Baptism: Deisel 1841, Archion 218842, Bild 95, Nro 506.) |
| 12.7.1841 | Johann Karl Ludwig Weisenbach (indexed Weifenbach) |
Deisel | Ludwig Weisenbach, Spinner m. Wilhelmine Schäfer |
Eliminated — godfather at Deisel 1862 and 1865 | Eliminated: he stood godfather at Deisel in May–Aug 1862 and again in Jul–Sep 1865 as “Carl Weisenbach, Weißbinder, ledigen Standes”, the 1865 child being the son of his full sister Conradine Wilhelmine (Deisel baptisms, Archion 218845, 1862 S. 8; 1865 S. 29; read in the image; research note, 15 Oct 2026). He was at home while Charles served in the Union army. The register (Nro 520) reads Weisenbach; Weifenbach is the long-s reading in the Dornette and LAGIS indexes. Father Ludwig Weisenbach, Schneider und Tagelöhner (a Spinner or Schneider at this entry), b. 20 Aug 1809, buried at Deisel 24 May 1867 (218851 Bild 2003, Nr 1265); mother Wilhelmine geb. Schäfer, b. 2 Dec 1810, buried 18 Sep 1872 (Bild 2026, Nr 1421). Confirmed at Deisel on 8 Apr 1855, Nr 13, by dispensation (218836 Bild 948, image; research note, 10 Oct 2026). The Hesse death index’s “Carl Ludwig Weifenbach, † 1878” is an infant, son of Ludwig Weisenbach 3ter × Amalia Köster (Deisel civil deaths 1878 Nr 62; research note, 9 Oct 2026). (Baptism: Deisel 1841, Archion 218842, Bild 97, Nro 520.) Research page → |
Deisel, 1836–41: the five illegitimate boys entered with no surname
The Deisel body-leaf sweep of 6–7 August 2026 (research note, 6 Aug 2026, Archion 218842, Nros 264–543) found five illegitimate boys entered with forenames only. ✔ All five are accounted for, and the line is closed as a Charles line (research note, 7 Oct 2026; research note, 7 Oct 2026). In four of the five cases “no surname” was a holding state before legitimation — the confirmation registers silently carry the later surname (Niemeyer ×2, Hillebrand, Stunz); the fifth took his mother’s (Köster). The Nameless below covers only Trendelburg and Friedrichsfeld. Leaving a child without a surname was a practice of this register from about 1837. In 1833–35, seven of the eight illegitimate children were given a surname (research note, 7 Aug 2026). And a named father did not stop it: a father was named in four of the six surname-less entries of 1836–41. Dates: these births fall after the 26 Jan 1835 working date. That date does not eliminate them, because Charles’s own reported ages point anywhere from 1835 to about 1841.
| Born | Entry (as written) | Mother | Father in entry? | Status | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 19 Jan 1838 bapt. 26 Jan | Nro 336 “Andreas”, unehelich | Amalie Schildknecht, ledige Tochter des Ackermanns Konrad Schildknecht × Anna Katharina geb. Niemeier | no | Eliminated — not a Carl; emigrated 1854 | Legitimated as Andreas Niemeyer; confirmed Deisel 11 Apr 1852 (218836 Bild 942, Nr 17); with the family at Baltimore on the Weser, July 1854, aged 16. Godparent Andreas Köster, Ackermann, Schwager der Mutter. Remarks blank. Elder brother of Nro 489. |
| 27 Jun 1840 bapt. 4 Jul | Nro 463 “unehelich Ludwig” | Amalia Köster, ledige Tochter des Taglöhners Christoph Köster | no | Eliminated — married in the parish | Godparent Johannes Niemeyer, Schuhmacher; bapt. 7 Jul. Remarks: “Kirchlich getraut den 11/10 68 mit Elise Christiane Alberding von Langenthal”. Confirmed Deisel 8 Apr 1855 as Ludwig Köster (mother “jetzt Ehefrau des Friedrich Becker”). He stayed. (Deisel baptisms 1840, Archion 218842, Bild 88, Seite 87, Nro 463; Deisel confirmations 1855, Archion 218836, Bild 947, Seite 93, Nr 7) |
| 24 Dec 1840 bapt. 10 Jan 1841 | Nro 489 “Männl.: Karl, unehelich” | Amalia Schildknecht, Tochter des Ackermanns Konrad Schildknecht | yes — “des Soldaten Philipp Niemeyer” (research note, 6 Aug 2026; an earlier July reading missed the father) | Eliminated — emigrated with family 1854 | Father confirmed in the entry on re-read (research note, 7 Oct 2026). = Karl Schildknecht / Karl Niemeyer. Confirmed Deisel 1854 by dispensation; Baltimore, ship Weser, 17 Jul 1854, aged 14 (card front read in image; the family aboard is attested by index entries — companions are on the unfilmed back). Contradicts Charles’s account on year, companions and port. (Deisel baptisms 1840/41, Archion 218842, Bild 92, Seite 91, Nro 489; Deisel confirmations 1854, Archion 218836, Bild 947, Seite 92, Nr 44) |
| May 1841 bapt. 6 Jun | Nro 516 “Friedrich Wilhelm Heinrich, unehelich” | Maria Schäfer, Tochter des Ackermanns Georg Schäfer | yes — Friedrich Stunz (acknowledged, signed) | Closed — not a Carl; in Germany 1855 | The father who acknowledged and signed is Friedrich Stunz of Carlshafen (first read “Heinz”). The boy was confirmed in the Bad Karlshafen Reformed church, 8 Apr 1855, as Friedrich Wilhelm Heinrich Stunz, parents Friedrich Stunz, Tagelöhner, and Marie geb. Schäfer (218707 Bild 998, Nr 10; written b. 20 May 1840 — the baptism’s 1841 is preferred). Not buried at Deisel May 1841–Mar 1856. |
| 2 Oct 1841 bapt. 15 Oct | Nro 533 “unehelich Theodor” | Amalia Kloppmann, ledige Tochter des Leinwebers Christian Kloppmann | yes — Friedrich Hillebrand (acknowledged, signed) | Eliminated — not a Carl; emigrated 1856 | Father Friedrich Hillebrand acknowledged and signed with two witnesses; remarks “[Sind] verehelicht”. Confirmed Deisel 23 Mar 1856 as Theodor Hillebrand; “Theodor Hillebr.-Klopmann” is on the Trendelburg researcher’s 1856 Deisel emigrant list with the whole family (unverified). Born 2 Oct (not 12 Oct). (Deisel baptisms 1841, Archion 218842, Bild 99, Seite 98, Nro 533; Deisel confirmations 1856, Archion 218836, Bild 950, Seite 99, Nr 8) |
✔ The forward trace covered Deisel confirmations 1849–56, Deisel burials May 1841–Mar 1856, Bad Karlshafen confirmations 1854–56, the Baltimore 1854 arrival index, and the fathers and remarks cells at all five entries (research notes, 7 Oct 2026). Still owed for completeness only: the Niemeyer family’s US settlement (“Mitteltown”) and verification of the 1856 Hillebrand departure. All five, their mothers and the named father of 489 are in the names database. Source: Archion 218842 (Deisel Taufen 1830–1861), read in image; page and image numbers per entry are in the 6 Aug 2026 page ledger.
Trendelburg confirmation classes 1849–50: the Carls the corpus net never saw
The 1849 Trendelburg class had 19 boys. The first leaf (Seite 84/85) was read in August 2026; the second leaf (220102 Bild 2271, Seite 86/87, Nr 10–19) and the whole 1850 class (Bild 2273–2275, 12 boys) were read on 7 Oct 2026 (research note, 7 Oct 2026; re-read at full resolution, research note, 7 Oct 2026). The leaf mixes Trendelburg and Friedrichsfeld boys. The Carls on it who are not in the Dornette birth corpus, and so never entered the ledger above:
| Born | Name | Parents | Status | Resolution |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11 Mar 1835 | Carl Ludwig Georg Lotz 1849 Nr 14 | Johann David Lotz, Schuhmacher × Dorothea Elisabeth geb. Bünting von Hofgeismar | Eliminated — died Queensland 1924 | Eliminated: “Carl George Louis Lotz” died in Queensland, Australia, on 19 May 1924; the Queensland death index names his parents as David Lotz and Dorothea Elizabeth Bunting, the parents of this baptism (Qld BDM 1924/B042874; index, certificate not online; research note, 16 Oct 2026). Probably also George L. Lotz, 46, tailor, born Hesse Cassel, naturalized British subject, Birmingham, 1881 census RG11/2983 f. 45 p. 32 (read in the image). Baptized as a Friedrichsfeld child (218959 Bild 1341, Nr 43; legitimate; remarks blank). The “‡‡” mark is bleed-through of Dölfer’s “+++” on the reverse of the leaf, not an annotation (research note, 7 Oct 2026). No stepfather: his parents stayed married until his mother died in 1867; his father died in 1877. Grandfather probably born at Zwergen, so the Kontze link is unproven and remote. No Friedrichsfeld or Trendelburg marriage, no LAGIS exit, and no death in the Hessian registers read; the 1914 Friedrichsfeld death of August Lotze, 79, is a different man, a son of Ludwig Lotze × Elise Uffelmann. |
| 2 Mar 1836 | Carl Wilhelm Austermühle 1850 Nr 6 | Johann Friedrich Austermühle, Ackerbürger × Maria Elisabeth geb. Becker von Hümme | Downgraded — probable emigrant 1853 | Baptism 220108 Bild 1426, Nr 151 (first misread “Küstermühle”). LAGIS: Austermuehle, Karl Wilhelm, Trendelburg, 1853 (four records), beside Johann Henrich, same year. Aged 17 and probably with a relative — six years before Charles’s stated c. 1859, alone. Not eliminated outright: the LAGIS detail fields can no longer be read. |
| 9 Aug 1836 | Carl Friedrich Sohl 1850 Nr 4 | the late Rentereidiener Johannes Sohl (of Witzenhausen) × Maria Elisabeth geb. Pfeltholz[?] | Eliminated — married in Germany | Baptism 220108 Bild 1430, Nr 164; remarks “∞ 12.11.1863 mit Katharina Elisabeth Schmidt aus Hasselbach in Bockenheim”. |
| 14 Mar 1836 | Carl Ferdinand Lieber 1850 Nr 12 | Georg Anton Lieber, Bürgermeister zu Friedrichsfeld × Catharina Elisabeth geb. Köster | Downgraded — probable emigrant 1854 | LAGIS: Lieber, Karl Ferdinand, Friedrichsfeld, 1854 (three records), with his brother Georg August Friedrich (1849 Nr 16). A family emigration five years before Charles’s. (Baptism: Friedrichsfeld 1836, Archion 218959, Bild 1344, Seite 19, Nro 51; confirmation: Trendelburg 1850, Archion 220102, Nr 12.) |
| 18 Mar 1835 | Carl Ludwig Wilhelm Helmbrecht 1849 Nr 17 | illegitimate — Wilhelmine Charlotte Helmbrecht | Eliminated — died at home | d. Friedrichsfeld 11 Apr 1875 (kunze-tode, exact birth date). (Trendelburg confirmations 1849, Archion 220102, Bild 2271, Seite 87, Nr 17; Friedrichsfeld burials 1875, Archion 218959, Bild 1643, Nr 275) |
| 1833–36 | Carl Wilhelm Bucher, Carl Ludwig Heeger | 1850 Nr 8, 9 | Eliminated — died at home | d. Trendelburg 1913 and 1912 (kunze-tode, exact birth dates). (Trendelburg confirmations 1850, Archion 220102, Bild 2273, Seite 91, Nr 8 and 9) |
Also on the 1849 leaf: Carl Ludwig Martini (Nr 11; emigrated Aug 1854, already known). Corrected readings: Nr 10 is Johann Heinrich Dornette (born Göttingen 1833, d. Fürstenhagen 1908; not “Drenk[hahn?]”) and Nr 15 Heinrich August Biermann, born at Weißehütte (not “Br[aar]mann”). All are in the names database.
Born on 25–27 January in any year, 1833–41: the six core parishes
Every January leaf for 1833–41 in Trendelburg, Deisel, Friedrichsfeld, Sielen, Stammen and Langenthal was read in the image, not only 1835 (research note, 7 Oct 2026). No Carl or Karl, and no boy with a second name Ludwig, was born on 25–27 January in any of these years. Four boys were born on those days:
| Born | Name | Parish | Status | Resolution |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 27 Jan 1834 | unnamed boy (mother Wilhelmine Weisenbach) | Deisel Nro 150 | Died | Died unbaptized, 31 Jan 1834. (Deisel baptisms 1834, Archion 218842, Bild 31, Seite 30, Nro 150) |
| 27 Jan 1837 | Reinhard Wilhelm Grebe | Stammen Nro 107 | Open — untraced | Son of Johann Heinrich Grebe, Dachdecker × Anne Margarethe Tehling. Remarks blank; no later trace. Not a Carl and not “C. L.”, so not a candidate unless a forename bridge appears. (Confirmed 1851; untraced. The Stammen civil registers have not been searched.) (Stammen baptisms 1837, Archion 220069, Bild 34, Seite 30, Nro 107; Stammen confirmations 1851, Archion 220066, Bild 432, Seite 31, Nr 3) |
| 26 Jan 1838 | Friedrich Wilhelm Köster | Deisel Nro 339 | Stayed | Married at Deisel 13 Nov 1864; died 6 Nov 1894 (first misread as “Büsemann”). (Deisel baptisms 1838, Archion 218842, Bild 65, Seite 64, Nro 339) |
| 27 Jan 1838 | Friedrich Wilhelm Lück | Sielen Nro 138 | Died | Died 6 Jun 1845. (Sielen baptisms 1838, Archion 220042, Bild 1858, Seite 30, Nro 138) |
Widening to 24–28 January adds Heinrich Ludwig Kersting (Trendelburg, 24 Jan 1835, d. 1838), Friedrich Wilhelm Weecke (Trendelburg, 28 Jan 1834, d. 1836), Karl Wilhelm Weppe (Langenthal, 27 Jan 1837 — a Karl on the date, but he married and died at Langenthal) and Georg Conrad Lucas (Trendelburg, 24 Jan 1841, d. Hörde 1892). Deisel Nro 199 is Wilhelm Heinrich Bonhagen, born 31 Jan 1835 (not “Lautzenhein”, and not 24 Jan). Just outside the six parishes, the Trendelburg researcher's list gave Johann Friedrich Ludwig Janson, Hofgeismar, 27 Jan 1837. The baptism (Archion 219265, Bild 846, Nr. 469) reads born 7 January (“am siebenten Januar”), baptized 22 January, so the 27-January date was a transcription slip (research note, 7 Oct 2026). Also outside them, the Oedelsheim January leaves (read 8 Oct 2026) give Friedrich Carl August Wessel, born 25 Jan 1835, the only Carl on the date in the Weser parishes — but he died at Oedelsheim on 28 Mar 1838, aged 3 (219952 Bild 2230; research note, 8 Oct 2026) — and George Heinrich Westermann, born 26 Jan 1835, who died in January 1836. Both eliminated.
The five “C. L.” boys, 1836–41 (none born in January, none with a phonetic link to Gannsen; they matter only if his surname is unknown). Forward-traced in the image (research note, 7 Oct 2026):
- Carl Ludwig August Aderholz (Trendelburg, b. 5 Jan 1838, settled by the image re-read; godfather the Schäfer Johann Friedrich Klages): confirmed 1852. Eliminated: he married at Hörde, Westphalia, on 14 Dec 1862 (see the Trendelburg top five below). The LAGIS entry “Aderholz, Karl Wilhelm, 1861” is his elder namesake, b. 1831, a smelter worker, to Prussia (research note, 9 Oct 2026).
- Johann Carl Ludwig Weecke (Trendelburg, b. 23 Oct 1840; formerly read “[Marth?]”, surname fixed by the register index and his 1855 confirmation) — the LAGIS entry “Wecke, Johann Karl Ludwig, Trendelburg, 1866” shows he emigrated in 1866 (research note, 8 Oct 2026). That is too late for Charles, who was in St. Louis by 1862: eliminated.
- Karl Ludwig Hillebrand (Deisel, 12 Mar 1838; mother geb. Koch): documented LAGIS emigrant, 1854, aged 16 — emigrant, open-low.
- “Carl Ludwig Bößler” (Sielen 1839) is a misreading of Karl Ludwig Köhler: the baptism remark reads “Nach Amerika ausgewandert”, and he is the already-eliminated 1857 emigrant (Karl Köhler) — duplicate, merged.
- “Carl Ludw. Weißenbach” (Langenthal): in none of the confirmation classes 1850–55 — probable ghost row, kept in the names database and marked.
Trendelburg boys born 1833–41: the full ledger and the top five
Charles named Trendelburg as his birthplace, so a research note of 8 Oct 2026 listed every male entry in the Trendelburg baptism register (220108) born 1 Jan 1833 – 31 Dec 1841: 148 boys (Nro 58–333). It traced each one through the confirmation classes 1847–56, every groom in the marriage register c. 1853–77, the burial index and LAGIS. The result: 52 died young, 7 were stillborn or unbaptized, 32 married or lived on in Germany, 15 died as adults in Germany, 14 emigrated (LAGIS), 3 are probable but unproven, and 25 were untraced. No boy was born on 25, 26 or 27 January in any year. The ledger also corrects several readings of August 2026: “[Winter?]” = Thiele, “[Waartmann?]” = Meerkamm, “[Wienda?]” = Weecke, “[Nagelau?]” = Nägeler, “Bremer” (1841) = Sommer, “Nehle” = Wehle, “Uffelmann” (1840) = probably Kohlus, “Simon” (1841) = probably Temme, “[Bertzig?]” = Kersting. It also finds that the nameless boy 305 was later “Dornette gen. Menne”. Every boy is in the names database.
A second research note of 8 Oct 2026 then worked the five strongest untraced boys. It read the burial register leaf by leaf for 1834–76, the civil deaths 1874–1900, the marriage index and the neighboring parishes’ registers:
| Born | Name | Status | Resolution |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8 Jan 1835 | Carl Wilhelm Henze (Nro 123) | Eliminated | Born 8 Jan (first misread as 1 Jan); father a Heimbäcker. The 1897 baker was a cousin (research note, 8 Oct 2026). Died at Frankfurt am Main, December 1892 (Standesamt Frankfurt I, 1892 Nr. 3765; research note, 9 Oct 2026). (Trendelburg baptisms 1835, Archion 220108, Bild 1415, Seite 37, Nro 123; Frankfurt I deaths 1892, HStAM 903 Nr 10456, image 89) |
| 5 Jan 1838 | Carl Ludwig August Aderholz (Nro 209) | Eliminated — married at Hörde 14 Dec 1862 | Eliminated: his brother Carl Wilhelm married at Hörde, Westphalia, in 1861 as the son of Christian Aderholz and Dorothea Henriette Brasenne of Trendelburg (Archion 140138, Bild 11, read in the image), which ties the Hörde factory worker Carl August Aderholz, married there on 14 Dec 1862, twelve days after Charles enlisted at St. Louis, to this baptism; Wilhelm Aderholz stood godfather to August’s son at Hörde in Sep 1877. Baptism re-read in the image (Bild 1445): born 5 Jan 1838; father Christian Aderholz, Tagelöhner (later Schäfer); godfather J. F. Klages; remarks blank. His parents died at Trendelburg in 1871 and 1872 (research note, 10 Oct 2026). (Baptism: Trendelburg 1838, Archion 220108, Bild 1445, Nro 209.) |
| 2 Dec 1841 | Carl Wilhelm Kersting (Nro 330) | Eliminated | Eliminated 26 Oct 2026 (verified): married at Neustadt am Rübenberge (Hanover) in December 1869 as “Carl Wilhelm Kersting, Junggeselle, Cigarrenmacher in Harburg”, born 2 Dec 1841 at Trendelburg, son of the Bürger und Tagelöhner Georg Wilhelm Kersting and Marie geb. Temme; bride Dorothee Louise Karoline Gronau (Neustadt a. Rbge Trauungen 1853–75, Archion 192816, Bild 73, Seite 71, Nr 10). Two reads and an independent third read agree; corroborated by this baptism (research note, 26 Oct 2026). Earlier: untraced after 1856. First read “[Bertzig?]”. Baptism re-read in the image (Bild 1478): born 2 Dec, baptized 19 Dec 1841; godfather the Ackermann Johann Henrich Temme (research note, 10 Oct 2026). His stepfather Johann Conrad Weecke died in 1874. His mother Maria Weecke geb. Temme is not buried at Trendelburg 1874–76 either (church burials read in image), so she died elsewhere. Hamburg lists: the only Carl Kerstings (1865 Sylt, 1867 Prague) are other men. Weak fit for Charles (birthday, surname). |
| 3 Aug 1834 | Philipp Freier (Nro 105; mother a Jungkonze) | Closed — died unmarried at Hombressen, 28 Aug 1872 (Archion 219502, Bild 2230, Nr 673; trace, 23 Oct 2026) | Traced only to his confirmation; no adult record has been found (Hombressen marriages 1869–1930 read, Archion 219514, Bild 880–881, no Freier; his mother’s burial, 13 Jun 1866, Archion 219502, Bild 2201, Nr 426, names no children; research note, 16 Oct 2026). He was counted as untraced until his burial at Hombressen (1872) was found. Confirmed at Hombressen, Pfingsten 1849, as “Philipp Freier”; his parents had married. He kept the surname Freier, so the Konze-surname route fails. (Trendelburg baptisms 1834, Archion 220108, Bild 1408, Seite 30, Nro 105; Hombressen confirmations 1849, Archion 219481, Bild 1195, Seite 101, Nr 11) |
| 8 Oct 1841 | Wilhelm Carl Klages (Nro 325) | Traced — not Charles | Legitimated by his mother’s marriage to Wilhelm Kühn of Fechenheim (1844); confirmed at Fechenheim in 1855 as “Wilhelm Carl Kühn”. (Trendelburg baptisms 1841, Archion 220108, Bild 1477, Seite 99, Nro 325; Fechenheim confirmations 1855, Archion 238495, Bild 499, Seite 89, Nr 12) |
Also traced: Friedrich Wilhelm Zollmann (Nro 95, b. 30 Jan 1834) was an Eisenbahnarbeiter at Bockenheim in 1865. Heinrich Wilhelm Meerkamm (Nro 100) died in 1901 as “Friedrich Meerkamm”, a documented change of forename. Carl Ludwig Klages (Nro 261) died at Lüneburg in 1865. The Hessian civil registers (Deisel 1874–1925, Trendelburg 1874–1925, Gottsbüren 1886–1925; research note, 8 Oct 2026) show no death or marriage for any open candidate, but those are coverage negatives: a man who died elsewhere is invisible there. Net: the two strongest mechanisms in the ledger (illegitimacy and Konze kin) were tested and closed against Charles. What is left is legitimate boys with fixed surnames. That raises the weight of three alternatives: a baptism under an unrecognized name, a birth outside 220108, or a Jewish birth (no 1833–41 Jewish register exists for Trendelburg; see negative results).
Deisel boys born 1833–41, the confirmation incomers, and the rest of the Trendelburg ledger
The Deisel ledger. A research note of 9 Oct 2026 listed every male entry in the Deisel baptism register (218842) born 1 Jan 1833 – 31 Dec 1841: 235 boys (Nro 102–541). It traced each through the confirmation classes 1847–56, the burials Sep 1847 – Oct 1875 (every leaf) and LAGIS: 58 died young, 13 stillborn or unbaptized, 22 married or alive in Germany, 54 died as adults in Germany, 38 emigrated, 13 probable emigrants and 37 untraced. A second research note of 9 Oct 2026 then read the Deisel marriage register groom by groom (c. 1850–85) and the civil marriages (Deisel 1889–1901, Trendelburg 1886–1901), and read the LAGIS detail records: seven untraced boys married at home, several probable emigrants became documented ones, and 30 boys were left untraced at that stage, plus one probable emigrant sent back. The only Deisel boy of the cohort born on 26 January (F. W. Köster, 1838) stayed, married and died there in 1894.
Further tracing (research note, 9 Oct 2026; research note, 9 Oct 2026; research note, 9 Oct 2026; research note, 9 Oct 2026; research note, 9 Oct 2026). A full LAGIS detail sweep (2,227 records: every remaining surname of both ledgers, plus every record for Deisel, Trendelburg, Friedrichsfeld, Stammen and Langenthal), Ancestry’s Hesse civil death and marriage indexes (searched signed in), and the civil indexes of Trendelburg (deaths 1874–1925, marriages 1874–1901), Hofgeismar and Karlshafen (marriages 1874–90) and Deisel (marriages 1874–c. 1900), with every hit read in the original on Arcinsys, closed these boys at image grade: Heinrich Wilhelm Moritz (Deisel Nro 236, b. 1835) died at Kassel on 6 May 1900, a retired railway station master; Philipp Koch (Nro 484, b. 1840) died at Deisel on 22 Jun 1909, a single farmhand; Friedrich Wilhelm Stunz (Nro 516, b. 1841) died at Hofgeismar on 16 Apr 1914, a cigar worker of Carlshafen; Ferdinand Martin (Nro 437, b. 1839) died at Offenbach on 22 Dec 1911, born Deisel (Offenbach 1911 Nr 1014); Karl Wilhelm Koch (Nro 506) died at Deisel in 1917; and Wilhelm Faehling/Fehling (Trendelburg Nro 161) died at Lippoldsberg on 1 Jan 1901, born Trendelburg, son of the Ackerknecht Carl Fehling (Sterbenebenregister 1901 Nr 1, HStAM 909 Nr 6615 img 3). Friedrich Schildknecht (Nro 266, b. 1836) emigrated to North America in March 1853 (LAGIS detail). The Kansas “C. L. Hofeditz” is Conrad Ludwig, who arrived in 1848 aged 8 with his parents, so that lead is eliminated and Hofeditz (Nro 327) stays untraced. Both U.S. leads for Friedrich Konze (Nro 539) were other men (the St. Louis Frederick W. Konze was the barber Anton W. Konze’s son, b. 1876; the Fond du Lac Fred Konz was born in Prussia and arrived in 1847/48), and the Ancestry “Friedrich Konze, d. 1916” died at Hümme, son of Johannes × Sophie; Nro 539 was later traced to Hamburg (see the Konze cohort below). The 1922 Trendelburg death of Karl August Uffelmann is Nro 310, not 295. No newly traced boy fits Charles, and none of the untraced boys has a G/K-n-s-n link.
U.S. negatives for the open Carls. The Illinois soldier “Lewis Hofeditz” (10th Ill. Cav., from Marine) belongs to the Madison County Hofeditz colony, not Nro 327. No U.S. Weisenbach of his age has a Kurhessen marker. For Kersting (Nro 330) the Bristol, Rhode Island Carl William Kerstin is excluded on his parents (August × Louisa), the Hessian-born Charles Kersting of Kansas and Indiana (b. 1836/37, imm. 1869) cannot be assigned, and the St. Louis 1875 “Kersting Charles, teamster, r. 210 Olive” is not linked. For Zollmann (Nro 159) two U.S. Charles Zollmanns (Effingham Co., Illinois; Winona, Minnesota) were born in September, not May, and his brother’s Bad Vilbel settlement points to the Frankfurt area. The Köln-Deutz “Karl Aderholz” of 1866 is probably the older Karl Wilhelm (LAGIS 65026). The status of every boy is in the table on Search coverage. No lead fits Charles.
The two Aderholz boys both married at Hörde, Westphalia: 209 Carl August, at St. Clara on 14 Dec 1862 (banns: “August Aderholz … gebürtig aus Trendelburg im Kreise Hofgeismar”; children there 1864–75), and 314 Christian Friedrich Eduard, in 1872 (research note, 10 Oct 2026). Ledger date corrections (image): Deisel 420 Ludwig Konze died 13 Feb 1917 (not 1912); 459 Philipp Theodor Konze died 21 Feb 1929 (not 1909; there is no February 1909 death at Deisel). A Trendelburg researcher’s “Phillip Konze b. Nov 1841, conf. 1855” is a conflation of 459, 438 and 539. The Rode marriages of 1877 and 1899 are other men (250 stays open). Friedrichsfeld: the Todtenbuch is read complete (entries 1–371, 1830–1898; every year reconciles except 1877) (research note, 10 Oct 2026); the 1838 Halmbrecht boy stayed, as “Halmbrecht genannt Weyhe”, and his half-brother Carl Ludwig Wilhelm (b. 1835) died in 1875 as “Carl Weyhe”; Georg Christoph (bapt. 58), the two Lotz/Lotze Carls, Lieber, Klapp, Schneider, Landgraf and Kontze (1832) are absent from the death register 1850–98 — evidence they left or died elsewhere, not evidence for Charles. Friedrichsfeld baptisms 1830–35, and Hümme and Stammen 1833–41, are read entry by entry: no open Konze or Gans boy (research note, 10 Oct 2026; new pointer boys on open questions).
Elimination re-audit (research note, 10 Oct 2026; standard: an image-read record matching at least three independent identifiers). All 11 key eliminations meet the standard: Karl Konze 1839 (minimum: three identifiers, no parents on the 1920 death entry — the weakest), Karl Person (“Jansen”), Henze, Meerkamm (on the image of his Hofgeismar marriage of 1886, Nr 5: exact birth date 27 Aug 1839 and both parents), Faehling, Köhler/Kahler, Koch 506 (with a flagged conflict: his 1917 death names his mother Marie geb. Feuring, the baptism Anna Katharina), Martin, J. C. L. Konze (1814), Halmbrecht/Helmbrecht (died 11 Apr 1875, not 8 Apr; register spelling “Helmbrecht genannt Weike”) and Breitwieser, eliminated on Guinn, History of the State of California and Biographical Record of Coast Counties (1904), vol. 2, pp. 677–678, read in the page image: “born in Hesse-Cassel, Germany, November 22, 1833”, parents “John and Elizabeth (Lotz)” (row below). Ranks 4–7 of the broadened search (research note, 10 Oct 2026): Gottsbüren, Sielen, Langenthal and Mariendorf baptisms 1833–41 read entry by entry — no Konze or Gans in any role, no surviving 26-January boy (a Gottsbüren “26 Jan 1840” Carl Mühlhausen was a misreading of 16 Jan). Gottsbüren “Johann Carl” Schröder (illegitimate, b. 15 Feb 1835) is open-low: his June 2026 elimination rested on date and surname alone. Sielen’s register marks five boys “nach Amerika ausgewandert” (Karl Wilhelm and Conrad Ludwig Hofeditz, Friedrich Wilhelm Hofeditz, Johannes Engelbracht, Heinrich Karl Korte) — all left as children with their parents (1848, 1856), so deprioritized, not eliminated. About 20 untraced non-pool Carls are in the low queue (Langenthal Alberding/Ebbracht/Busch; Mariendorf Paul, Thiout, Massie).
The key test was negative. If Charles was born at Trendelburg and grew up at Deisel, he would have been confirmed at Deisel. No boy confirmed at Deisel in 1847–56 was born in Trendelburg town. Nine confirmands were not baptized at Deisel (three came from outlying places of Trendelburg parish: Friedrichsfeld and Wülmersen); none is a Gans or a Konze, none is illegitimate, none was born near 26 January:
| Class | Confirmand | Born | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1848 | Georg Heinrich Christian Friedrich Käß | 5 Aug 1834 (Trendelburg Nro 107) | Married at Deisel 1862 and c. 1877/78 — stayed. (Deisel confirmations 1848, Archion 218836, Bild 932, Nr 2; Deisel marriages 1862, Archion 218860, Bild 1378, Nr 292) |
| 1849 | Johann Gottfried Adolph Pagendarm | 29 Jun 1835 | Died at Deisel 1858. (Deisel confirmations 1849, Archion 218836, Bild 934, Nr 1) |
| 1850 | Hans Wilhelm Carl Ernst August von Stockhausen | 9 Jun 1835, Cassel | Noble family, Wülmersen. (Deisel confirmations 1850, Archion 218836, Bild 938, Seite 74, Nr 8½) |
| 1851 | Adam Küchmann | 23 Dec 1836, Holzhausen | LAGIS, Deisel 1864. (Deisel confirmations 1851, Archion 218836, Bild 939, Nr 6) |
| 1852 | Karl August Ernst Gustav von Stockhausen | 21 Aug 1837 | Noble family. (Deisel confirmations 1852, Archion 218836, Bild 942, Nr 18) |
| 1853 | Johann Carl Wilhelm Landgraf | 6 Oct 1838, Friedrichsfeld | The one incomer from Trendelburg parish: a stepson whose mother, Sophie Dorothea Hartgen, married three more times, last to the Deisel laborer Wilhelm Meimbresse. LAGIS detail: a miner (Bergmann) to Prussia, May 1866 (HStAM 180 Hofgeismar Nr. 841 S. 127). Not an American emigrant; low. (Baptism: Friedrichsfeld 1838, Archion 218959, Bild 1351, Seite 26, Nro 72; confirmation: Deisel 1853, Archion 218836, Bild 943, Nr 11.) |
| 1855 | Carl August Julius Köster | 28 Sep 1841 | Born at Wanfried, son of a Rentamts-Assistent (an assistant in the district revenue office). Eliminated (R1-27, 11 Nov 2026): he married at Hofgeismar on 25 Apr 1869 as “Carl August Julius Coester, Fabrikant und Kaufmann”, living at Heiligenstadt, with the same names, birth date and parents as at his confirmation. He was in Germany in 1869, so he is not Charles. He was very probably the Carl August Julius Köster of Wanfried named in two notices of 1862. In February the district office at Eschwege summoned that man as a conscript who had missed that year’s levy, and in October the criminal court at Eschwege sentenced him in his absence for absconding (Wochenblatt für die Provinz Fulda, 1862, Nr 7, p. 104, and Nr 50, p. 847). (Deisel confirmations 1855, Archion 218836, Bild 947, Nr 1; Hofgeismar Altstadt marriages 1869, Archion 219298, Bild 1367, Seite 5, Nr 19) |
| 1855 | Gustav Lockemann | 24 Feb 1839 (Trendelburg Nro 246) | Miller’s son of Wülmersen; probably d. 1888 at Heckershausen. (Trendelburg baptisms 1839, Archion 220108, Bild 1456, Nro 246; Deisel confirmations 1855, Archion 218836, Bild 948, Nr 19) |
| 1856 | Johannes Göbel | 5 Sep 1838 | Family from Amt Grebenstein; untraced. (Deisel confirmations 1856, Archion 218836, Bild 951, Nr 17) |
So a Trendelburg-born Charles who last lived at Deisel most likely came there after confirmation, as a farmhand or journeyman, and would appear in no Deisel church register before he left. Of the Deisel Carls, Karl Ludwig Hofeditz (1837) is untraced and is now the compiler’s leading candidate (28 Oct 2026; see “The Boy from the Goose Corner”); Koch and Weisenbach (1841) are eliminated; Karl Brandau (1837, “verschollen”) emigrated in 1856 and is open again because his American life is untraced (open question). Corrections to earlier readings, all now in the names database: one more illegitimate boy, Friedrich Schrage (b. 4 Jul 1834), missed by the August 2026 read; and the August readings “Timme” = Fremder, “Lotze” = Lösse, “Böhne” and “Büsemann” = Köster, “Zimmermann” = Feuring and Drönner, “Weitz” = Steitz, “Baumann” = Bränder, “Dorf” = Koch, “[Loße?]” = Sasse, “Klausen” = Person, “Temme” = Fremder, and Nro 539 “Ludwig” = Friedrich Konze. In this hand, “Dorf” is often Koch — a scribal trap to add beside K→B and H→G.
The rest of the Trendelburg ledger. A research note of 9 Oct 2026 traced forward the boys still open, using the Trendelburg burials 1841–76 leaf by leaf and Ancestry’s Hesse-wide death and marriage indexes, with originals read on Arcinsys. Henze died at Frankfurt in 1892 and Meerkamm was a married laborer at Trendelburg in 1865–66: both are eliminated (see the ledger above). Küchemann died at Trendelburg in 1908; Kass married at Deisel in 1878; Lockemann was confirmed at Deisel in 1855; Lucas and Weecke went to Prussia. Untraced, with no lead: Kersting (1841), Zollmann (1836), Rode (1839), Weecke (1841) [26 Oct 2026: Kersting and Weecke are now traced and eliminated: Kersting married at Neustadt am Rübenberge in 1869, and Weecke married at Helmarshausen on 2 Apr 1866 (Helmarshausen Trauungen, Archion 219232, Bild 1566, Nr 347; research note, 26 Oct 2026)]; the two Aderholz boys married at Hörde (above). No Trendelburg boy gained a U.S. lead. The 1833–41 Trendelburg ledger is close to exhausted as a source for Charles.
The Konze cohort. Every Konze or Kontze boy born 1833–41 in Trendelburg, Deisel, Friedrichsfeld and Stammen is accounted for. The last, Friedrich Konze, Deisel, born 18 Nov 1841 (confirmed 1856), was a tailor who died at Hamburg on 6 Sep 1877; the death entry names his birthplace Deisel and both parents (Standesamt Hamburg 2, 1877 no. 2589; resolved question; research notes, 11–13 Oct 2026). The seven deaths of Konze men born 1833–41 found in the civil registers (1897–1919) are all matched to baptisms; an 1877 death once counted with them is a Heinrich Wilhelm Konze born in 1844 (his age was misread as 37). The names-database rows for a “Ludwig Friedrich Konze, b. early Jan 1835, Andreas Konze × Elisabeth Pfeffkumpf” have been retired as a ghost of the Köster entry 194 (30 Oct 2026), and the row “Carl Wilhelm Konze, conf. Trendelburg 1849” was the misindexed Henze.
Karl “Jansen”, Deisel, b. 14 Sep 1836 = Karl PERSON — eliminated
Eliminated — image grade “Jansen” was a misreading of Person. Deisel Taufen 218842, Bild 51, Nro 263 is Karl Person, born 14 Sep 1836, son of the Schmied Ludwig Person and Charlotte geb. Deppe (the “Rieppe” of the earlier reading). The birth date and the father are the same as the Karl Person already eliminated in the ledger above, so the project had been carrying one man as two candidates. The baptism’s remark, “† angeblich in Cassel im Nov. 98”, is true. The death was read in the image (research note, 8 Oct 2026): Standesamt Kassel I, Sterberegister 1898 Nr. 1357 (HStAM 910 Nr. 5439, image 156). It records der Schmied Carl Person, 62 Jahre, geboren zu Deisel, Kreis Hofgeismar, son of the late Schmied Ludwig Person and Charlotte geb. Deppe, who died at Kassel on 31 October 1898; the death was registered on 2 November, hence “Nov. 98”. He had been tracked from July 2026 as the strongest Deisel candidate, partly because “Jansen” seemed to match the surname on Charles’s own children’s 1874/1881 baptisms; that argument rested on the misreading and is withdrawn. The Karl Person page carries the record. The sweep of the Deisel remarks column for every boy born 1833–41 found no emigration note, and documented emigrants have blank cells, so a blank remark carries no weight either way.
The Nameless — illegitimate boys of the Trendelburg–Friedrichsfeld complex, 1835-1842
A second ledger, and a different evidence class from the one above. The Vanished Karls are boys who had a surname and disappeared. These are boys who left the font without one — or with one the register is shown assigning arbitrarily. If Charles was born here, this is the shape his entry would take, which is why the list exists separately.
Why the second tier is on the list at all. The register does not treat a surname as fixed. Across these two books, five formal signed paternity acknowledgements produced a surname twice and none three times; one child took the mother's name; and one acquired a surname retrospectively, by a marginal “per subseq. matrimon.” added when the parents later married. An illegitimate boy entered under any name is therefore a candidate for having carried a different one later.
Status of the sweep: this covers 1835-1842 (Trendelburg 220108 entries 129-333; Friedrichsfeld 218959 entries 46-103). It is not complete — 12 checks remain (see below). 0 of 16 boys are still open; the rest are eliminated by a death or marriage entry in the register's own remarks column, and are kept here as negative evidence so the same names are not re-promoted later.
Tier 1 — entered with no surname at all
| Born | Name as entered | Mother | Father | Status | Remarks column & assessment |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 19 Nov 1836, 11-12 pm | "Heinrich Ferdinand" - unehelich, NO SURNAME Trendelburg 220108 · Nro 173 · Bild 1434 / Seite 56 |
Wilhelmine Schwenk, daughter of the late Bürger Schwenk x Maria Louise geb. Rasch, born at Stolz(?) in the Kgl.-Preuss. Reg.-Bez. Minden | none named | Traced — not Charles | Remarks column: Verheirathet 23 April 1875 Married in Germany in 1875 - he stayed. Not Charles. Retained as negative evidence and as the mother's Prussian origin is itself unusual for this parish. Confirmed 1851 as Heinrich Ferdinand SCHWENK (mother's surname) and married c.1866 (220120 Nro 238); the 1875 remark is a second marriage. |
| 6 Dec 1836, morning | "Johannes" - unehelich, NO SURNAME Trendelburg 220108 · Nro 174 · Bild 1434 / Seite 56 |
Sabine Philippine Christiane Temme, legitimate daughter of the late Temme x widow Marie Sophie geb. Sabe | none named | Eliminated | Remarks column: Gestorben am 11 Februar 1837 Died at nine weeks. Trendelburg Nr. 65. |
| 27 Feb 1837, 1 pm | "Heinrich Wilhelm" - unehelich, NO SURNAME Trendelburg 220108 · Nro 185a · Bild 1438 / Seite 60 |
Christine Niemeyer, legitimate daughter of Tagelöhner Johann Heinrich Niemeyer x Marie geb. Heintzer - Trendelburg Nr. 38 | none named | Eliminated | Remarks column: gestorben den 10ten November 1839 Eliminated: died in childhood. The 1839 annotation reads 'gestorben den 10ten November 1839' — read in image at magnification. He died aged 2 years 8 months. Retained as negative evidence, and because the household still matters: same mother and same house (Trendelburg Nr. 38) as entry 288, and the godparent is a HUND of LANGENTHAL — the Hund x Niemeyer union that also produced entry 288 and the 1849 confirmand Friedrich August Hund (b. 19 Jan 1835). Both boys of that union died in childhood. |
| 8 Jan 1837 | "Georg Christoph" - unehelich, NO SURNAME (a ruled line drawn across the empty space) Friedrichsfeld 218959 · Nro 58 · Bild 1347 / Seite 22 |
Sophie Charlotte Hartgen, eheliche Tochter des Schneiders Christoph Hartgen und dessen Ehefrau Marie Sophie geb. Hesse | none named - no man appeared | Eliminated | Remarks column: BLANK (re-read at full resolution: no legitimation note, no surname added later) Traced (26 Oct 2026, verified): as Georg Hartgen, Catholic Tagelöhner of Borlinghausen (Kr. Warburg), husband of Anna Jochheim, he died in the Peckelsheim Kreiskrankenhaus on 18 Aug 1889 aged 52, "geboren zu Friedrichsfelde Curhessen, Sohn der ledigen Sophie Hartgen" (StA Peckelsheim 1889 Nr 37) [IMAGE]; he reported the death of his daughter Anna Maria at Borlinghausen in 1880 (StA Löwen 1880 Nr 2) [IMAGE]. He took his mother's surname as an adult and stayed in Westphalia. Earlier note: Untraced after his baptism, and not a Charles candidate. Forename Georg Christoph (the godfather's 'Georg'), born 8 Jan 1837 against Charles's anchored 26 Jan 1835, and no surname in his family's orbit (Hartgen, Fricke) leads to Gannsen/Gonnson. Do not promote. Mother located (probable, strong): she is very probably the Sophie Charlotte Wilhelmine Hartgen who married JOHANN CHRISTOPH FRICKE, Köhler of Mariendorf, Amts Grebenstein, at Trendelburg on 20 June 1841 (Friedrichsfeld marriage Nro 15). Four sources tie Mrs Fricke to the Schneider Christoph Hartgen's household (the corrected 1814 baptism, baptisms 58 and 81, and her brother Georg Heinrich standing godfather in 1844); the 1841 marriage's 'Johann Heinrich x Maria Christina' parentage repeats the uncorrected 1814 text. Christoph Fricke had already acknowledged her second son, Carl Wilhelm August, in Sept 1839 (baptism 81; d. Oct 1840). The Fricke household was found without him: at Friedrichsfeld Jan 1842 - at least Jan 1844 (baptisms 101, 118), at Mariendorf by 1852-59 (burials 1853, 1859; confirmation 1857); Christoph Fricke d. Mariendorf 24 Mar 1859, she d. there 20 Jan 1887. Georg Christoph is absent from: Mariendorf burials Jun 1841-Jan 1860 (every entry), Mariendorf confirmations 1849-1853, Trendelburg confirmations 1851 (boys), the Friedrichsfeld Todtenbuch 1830–98, and (Dornette database, ~100% at Friedrichsfeld) any Friedrichsfeld death. A renaming under Fricke is not attested; absence is not evidence of emigration (he may have died unrecorded elsewhere or been fostered, e.g. with the Schneider grandparents). |
| 23 Nov 1839, 4 am | "Carl Wilhelm August" - unehelich, NO SURNAME Trendelburg 220108 · Nro 270 · Bild 1463 / Seite 85 |
Wilhelmine [Dröbel? / DRÖNNER?], Tochter des [struck] Georg [Dröbel?] | none named | Eliminated | Remarks column: starb den 23. Januar 1840 ⛔ Eliminated — died at two months ('starb den 23. Januar 1840' in the remarks column). He was briefly promoted in August 2026 on a remarks cell recorded as blank without being examined; the dates and the mother's forenames of that reading were also wrong. [Dröbel?] is a surname. ⭐ Still worth a look: [Dröbel?] may be DRÖNNER — a Konze-pool marital surname at Deisel (rows 536, 680). If so, a woman of a Deisel Konze-married family bore an illegitimate Carl Wilhelm at Trendelburg in Nov 1839. The child is not Charles; the union would be the finding. The shared name 'Carl Wilhelm August' (Trendelburg 270 and Friedrichsfeld 81) is not a default name for a boy without a family name: corpus-wide, 14 rows carry Carl/Karl Wilhelm August and TWELVE HAVE SURNAMES — Fricke (Friedrichsfeld), Martini and Schröder (Trendelburg), Götze/Röllke/Schweinsberg (Gottsbüren), Schulze (Gieselwerder), Ziegeler (Langenthal), Märten/Kobnapp (Hofgeismar). And the local base rate is decisive: inside the August 2026 Trendelburg ledger — same register, same window, 200 entries — the name appears three times, TWO OF THEM WITH SURNAMES (entry 159 Friedrich Carl Wilhelm August ZOLLMANN; entry 328 Carl Wilhelm August SIMON). 'Carl/Karl Wilhelm' appears in 25 of those 200 entries — one child in eight. The 270/81 match is a coincidence. |
| 29 Aug 1839, midday | "Carl Wilhelm August" - unehelich, NO SURNAME Friedrichsfeld 218959 · Nro 81 · Bild 1354 / Seite 29 |
Sophie Hartgen, Tochter des Schneiders Christoph Hartgen | Christoph Fricke, Köhler, wohnhaft zu Mariendorf, Amts Grebenstein - acknowledged in person and signed 'Christoph Fricke, als Vater' (witnesses Carl Götte, Joh. H. Hammerschmidt); surname not given to the child at baptism | Eliminated | Remarks column: starb den 20ten October 1840 Died at fourteen months. Kept because he is the twin of the problem at Trendelburg 270 - identical three given names, both surname-less, both baptized at Trendelburg, fifteen weeks apart, definitely different children. The shared name 'Carl Wilhelm August' (Trendelburg 270 and Friedrichsfeld 81) is not a default name for a boy without a family name: corpus-wide, 14 rows carry Carl/Karl Wilhelm August and TWELVE HAVE SURNAMES — Fricke (Friedrichsfeld), Martini and Schröder (Trendelburg), Götze/Röllke/Schweinsberg (Gottsbüren), Schulze (Gieselwerder), Ziegeler (Langenthal), Märten/Kobnapp (Hofgeismar). And the local base rate is decisive: inside the August 2026 Trendelburg ledger — same register, same window, 200 entries — the name appears three times, TWO OF THEM WITH SURNAMES (entry 159 Friedrich Carl Wilhelm August ZOLLMANN; entry 328 Carl Wilhelm August SIMON). 'Carl/Karl Wilhelm' appears in 25 of those 200 entries — one child in eight. The 270/81 match is a coincidence. ⭐ The burial (Todtenbuch 51) names him CARL WILHELM AUGUST FRICKE, son of Christoph Fricke and Sophie Hartgen; his parents married in June 1841 (Friedrichsfeld marriage Nro 15). |
| 7 Jun 1840, 6 am | "Johann Ludwig Heinrich" - unehelich, NO SURNAME Trendelburg 220108 · Nro 288 · Bild 1468 / Seite 90 |
Anna Christine Niemeyer, Tochter von Johann Heinrich Niemeyer - Trendelburg Nr. 38 | CARL LUDWIG HUND von LANGENTHAL - acknowledged in person, signed | Eliminated | Remarks column: starb den 21ten October 1841 Died at sixteen months. Same mother and house as entry 185a. A Hund of Langenthal x Niemeyer of Trendelburg Nr. 38 union running at least 1837-1840 and producing two boys entered with given names only - plus the 1849 confirmand Friedrich August Hund (b. 19 Jan 1835), same pairing, three years earlier. LANGENTHAL SHOULD MOVE UP THE SWEEP QUEUE. |
| 6 Dec 1840, 10 pm | "Heinrich Conrad Wilhelm" - unehelich, NO SURNAME Trendelburg 220108 · Nro 305 · Bild 1472 / Seite 94 |
Charlotte DORNETTE, des Christoph Dornette Tochter (first read 'Charlotte [Dorothea?], daughter of the late Schäfer [Grosbernd?]') | Joseph MAURER aus [Wehen?], Ziegler und Einwohner hierselbst - acknowledged in person before witnesses | Eliminated | Remarks column: Starb am 7ten April 1863 Died in Germany in 1863, aged 22 - he never left. A clean case of formal acknowledgement producing no surname. Confirmed 8 Apr 1855 as 'Heinrich Conrad Wilhelm Dornette gen. MENNE' (220102 Bild 2287, S.118, Nr 12) - mother's surname plus a later ALIAS surname. |
Tier 2 — illegitimate, but given a surname (mother's or father's)
| Born | Name as entered | Mother | Father | Status | Remarks column & assessment |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 1835 | Johann Friedrich Wilhelm KLAGES (father's surname) Friedrichsfeld 218959 · Nro 48 · Bild 1343 / Seite 18 |
Friederike Zollmann | Johann Friedrich Klages, Schäfer - acknowledged, signed with THREE CROSSES (illiterate) | Eliminated | Remarks column: starb den 5ten Januar 183[5->6] (January year-slip) Died in infancy. The illiterate father's mark is the point: three crosses were enough to give the boy a hereditary surname. |
| 2 Sep 1836, 5 pm | Heinrich Wilhelm AHRENDS (father's surname) Trendelburg 220108 · Nro 166 · Bild 1431 / Seite 53 |
Augustine Christine Caroline Amalie Bertram | Ernst Ahrends, Schirrmeister auf hiesigem herrschaftlichem Vorwerk, gebürtig von Wahmbeck - acknowledged, signed | Eliminated | Remarks column: Gestorben am 15ten September 1836 Died at thirteen days. Same couple as entries 201 and 265 - an ongoing relationship producing repeatedly acknowledged children, of whom entry 265 got NO surname. |
| 6 Sep 1836 | Friedrich Wilhelm NIEMEYER (father's surname) Trendelburg 220108 · Nro 167 · Bild 1432 / Seite 54 |
Anna Margarethe, daughter of the Bürger und Metzger [Jungheinrich?] Pfannkuche x Maria Sophie geb. Grosberndt | Wiegand Niemeyer, soldier, son of the Branntweinbrenner Johannes Niemeyer zu Gottsbüren, Amts Veckerhagen, x Wilhelmine Biedermann - acknowledged (signed) | Eliminated | Remarks column: blank (read in image at magnification) Eliminated: died at Gottsbüren in Feb 1839. Gottsbüren Beerdigungen 1830-1884 (Archion 219055) Bild 508, S.55, 1839 Nr 279, "Friedrich Wilhelm Niemeyer, unehelicher Sohn des Taglöhners Wiegand Niemeyer und der Anna Margarethe Pfannkuche", born Trendelburg 6 Sep 1836 (research note, 12 Oct 2026). The acknowledging father was Wiegand Niemeyer; the godfather was Philipp Niemeyer (an earlier reading confused the two). Names-DB row 1538 (the pension witness Henry D. Niemeier) is not this child: he was born in Hanover c. 1837/38 (1880 census). |
| 1 Oct 1836 | Ernst August LANDGRAF (father's surname) Friedrichsfeld 218959 · Nro 55 · Bild 1346 / Seite 21 |
Sophia Dorothea Hartgen | Christoph Heinrich Wilhelm Landgraf, Sattler, gebürtig zu Cassel - acknowledged, signed at Trendelburg before two witnesses | Eliminated | Remarks column: Gestorben am 11ten Juli 1837 Died at nine months. THE PAIR TO ENTRY 58: his mother's sister bore a son three months later, in the same household, who received no surname because no man appeared. Same house, same pastor, same winter. |
| 26 Apr 1838, 3 am | Johann Heinrich Wilhelm KLAPP (father's surname) Trendelburg 220108 · Nro 219 · Bild 1448 / Seite 70 |
Friederike Sölter | Christian Klapp, Drechsler - acknowledged, signed with a Handzeichen +++ (illiterate) | Eliminated | Remarks column: starb den 7. April 1840 Died at two years. Trendelburg, Beisitzer, no house number. |
| 28 Mai 1838, 5 am | Johann Heinrich GROSBERND (father's surname) Trendelburg 220108 · Nro 222 · Bild 1449 / Seite 71 |
Dorothea Klages, Tochter von Georg Klages, Schäfer | Heinrich Ludwig Grosbernd, Wagner - acknowledged, signed | Eliminated | Remarks column: starb den 12. Juni 1838 Died at fifteen days. One of three Klages sisters (Dorothea, Caroline, Amalie) bearing children out of wedlock to the Grosbernd wheelwright clan - the clan whose Nr. 26 branch married a JUNGKONZE. |
| Nov/Dec 1838 | Georg Heinrich Wilhelm HALMBRECHT (MOTHER's surname) Friedrichsfeld 218959 · Nro 75 · Bild 1352 / Seite 27 |
Wilhelmine Charlotte Halmbrecht | none named | Traced — not Charles | Remarks column: NOT EXAMINED (read at spread zoom only — claim downgraded) Traced, not Charles (research note, 10 Oct 2026): = Georg Heinrich Wilhelm Halmbrecht genannt Weyhe, Tagelöhner at Friedrichsfeld, father of children buried there 1868-1873 (names DB 98942); mother Wilhelmine Charlotte Halmbrecht married Andreas Weyhe. Illegitimate, no father named, he took the mother's surname - the third outcome class. The remarks cell has not been examined at magnification. ⭐ Row 888 of the names DB gives the same family an earlier illegitimate son — Heinrich Halmbrecht, b. 23 June 1828, mother Charlotte Halmbrecht, godparent from LANGENTHAL. Ten years apart, same pattern, possibly the same woman. |
| 8 Okt 1841, afternoon | Wilhelm CARL KLAGES - unehelich (MOTHER's surname) Trendelburg 220108 · Nro 325 · Bild 1477 / Seite 99 |
AMALIE KLAGES, Tochter des verstorbenen Schäfers Georg Klages | none declared | Traced — not Charles | Remarks column: Dieses Kind ist durch die erfolgende Ehe der Mutter mit dem Heinrich[?] Kühn zu Fechenheim als Sohn des letzteren legitimirt worden (read in image; missed by the first two reads) Traced, not Charles (research note, 8 Oct 2026). Legitimated by his mother's marriage to Wilhelm Kühn of FECHENHEIM (Fechenheim Trauregister 238483, Bild 48, 1844; the Trendelburg remark calls him 'Heinrich[?]'), and confirmed at Fechenheim in 1855 as 'Wilhelm Carl KÜHN', son of Wilhelm Kühn, Weißbindermeister x Amalie geb. Klages (Archion 238495, Bild 499, S.89, Nr 12). Raised as a Kühn near Frankfurt; deprioritized / effectively eliminated. |
- DONE 26 Oct 2026: Georg Christoph (Friedrichsfeld baptism 58, b. 8 Jan 1837), formerly the one open boy, is traced as Georg Hartgen, d. Peckelsheim 1889 (StA Peckelsheim 1889 Nr 37; corroborated by StA Löwen 1880 Nr 2; research/Verification_Oct26_eliminations.md). Earlier plan: Georg Christoph (Friedrichsfeld baptism 58, b. 8 Jan 1837), the one open boy: Trendelburg confirmations 1852; LAGIS and HStAM 180 Hofgeismar for any Hartgen or Fricke emigrant born 1837; the remarks word on Mariendorf burial Nr 347 (Johann Christoph Fricke, 1859). He is not a Charles candidate; these checks only close his row.
- Friedrichsfeld baptisms Seiten 35 and 37-40 (Bild 1360, 1362-1365): entry 108 shows the 1843 window is richer than the 1835-42 sweep suggested.
- Friedrichsfeld Todtenbuch entry 43 (the saddler Landgraf's death note, Seite 13): re-read the remarks at magnification.
- Friedrichsfeld Todtenbuch entry 54 (Johann Friedrich Wilhelm Klages, b. 26 Nov 1835): is he baptism 48's acknowledged child?
- The occupation word for Justus Quentin (Todtenbuch Seite 9, Bild 1591) and for Georg Wilhelm Philipp Quentin (baptisms 97 and 105, Trendelburg 274): Schäfer or Schneider?
- Trendelburg entry 270, the mother's cell (img 1463, Seite 85): is 'Wilhelmine [Dröbel?]' a Drönner, a Konze-pool marital surname at Deisel (DB rows 536, 680)? Drönner is known to be misread in this hand.
- Friedrichsfeld baptism 94, the mother's cell ('Maria Anna Carolina' or 'Elisabeth'), to seal the per subsequens matrimonium identification; baptism 92 (Jan 1841), 'Christoph Hartgen, Tagelöhner x Christina geb. Weghe' - a fourth Hartgen man or a misreading?; and whether Weghe and Weihe are one surname (marriage Nros 6 and 7; baptisms 53, 70, 92, 93).
- Where Hartgen x Schöneberg married: try Trendelburg 220120 Seiten 61-62 (1848, entries 121-126). The 27 Feb 1848 line is the pastor's attestation, not the wedding.
- Gottsbüren marriages c. 1795-1814: Christoph Hartgen x Maria Sophia Hesse, and the Nicolaus Hesse x Anna Maria Doerbaum parentage (names-DB row 13182). Gottsbüren marriages must come from Archion, not the Dornette corpus.
- Trendelburg 220096, 1817: the register says 8 pairs and 5 are read. In this register Seite cannot be computed from Bild; read the printed page number off the leaf.
- Dornette corpus: re-query the birth and death datasets (not the marriage dataset, which has no Deisel rows before 1886) for the open surnames, and close the January 1835 reconciliation for Deisel 218842 entries 194-199.
- Cautions that stay in force: the Dornette birth database is about 60% complete at Deisel, 33% at Trendelburg and 26% at Friedrichsfeld, so an absence from it is never a negative; a burial's 'ehelich' describes the parents at burial, not at birth (the baptism is the load-bearing record); a field read at spread zoom and found missing is unread, not absent.
Two cautions carried from the reads. (1) Carl is one of the commonest forenames in these parishes — nine boys in six years at Friedrichsfeld alone — so the forename on its own is close to worthless as a discriminator; what discriminates is Carl and no surname and a blank remarks column. (2) Two different boys, fifteen weeks apart, in the two registers, were both entered as “Carl Wilhelm August” with no surname and both baptized at Trendelburg. Until it is known whether that is a default name for a surname-less boy rather than a choice, no entry bearing it should be weighted as distinctive.
Machine-readable source: data/illegitimate-boys.json — append there
and re-run scripts/build-illegitimate-boys.py. Reads:
research note, 2 Aug 2026,
research note, 8 Aug 2026,
research note, 8 Aug 2026.
Boys added to bring this page level with the book
These boys are in the master list data/leads.json and in the book’s chapter “The Candidates and How They Were Ruled Out” but had no row on this page. The eight Carls of Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld still open (28 Oct 2026) are Martini (1834), Hofeditz (Deisel, 1837), Brandau (Deisel, 1837), Zollmann (1836), Carl Wilhelm Lucas (1837), the two Kaysers (1837, 1838) and Meier (1838); Kersting (1841) was traced on 26 Oct 2026, and Schneider (Friedrichsfeld, 1839) was traced as married at Hattingen in 1875. Of the 47 boys of the three parishes born out of wedlock in 1833–41, two are untraced as adults (Heinrich Ludwig of Trendelburg and Heinrich Karl of Deisel) and one, Heinrich Köster of Deisel, is probably traced. Georg Christoph of Friedrichsfeld was traced on 26 Oct 2026 (as Georg Hartgen, died at Peckelsheim in 1889).
| Born | Name | Parish | Status | Resolution |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 22 Nov 1833 | Carl Wilhelm Theodor Breitwieser | Friedrichsfeld | Eliminated | Emigrated alone to North America, May 1853, a tailor (LAGIS). = Charles W. Breitwieser of Warm Springs, Alameda County, California: Guinn, History of the State of California … Coast Counties (1904), vol. 2, pp. 677–678, read in the page image, gives his birth on 22 Nov 1833 in Hesse-Cassel and his parents as John and Elizabeth (Lotz) Breitwieser; also the 1900 census (Alameda Co., Washington Twp, ED 8) and the 1892 Great Register, read in the image (research notes, 10 Oct 2026). (Baptism: Friedrichsfeld 1833, Archion 218959, Bild 1334, Nro 27.) |
| 21 Mar 1838 | Carl Ludwig Lotze | Friedrichsfeld | Eliminated | Confirmed at Trendelburg in 1852 as “Carl Friedrich”. Godfather at Friedrichsfeld in 1864 (Nro 311) as “Karl Friedrich Lotze … des Ackermanns Conrad Ludwig Lotze lediger Sohn” (Archion 218959, Bild 1413, read in the image): at home while Charles was in the Union army (research note, 15 Oct 2026). (Baptism: Friedrichsfeld 1838, Archion 218959, Bild 1350, Nro 69.) |
| 12 Jun 1837 | Hieronymus Carl Kayser | Trendelburg | Open — untraced | Son of a customs controller; the family was at Gelnhausen by 1862. A proposed identification (Georg Hieronymus Kayser, b. c. 1818) belongs to another man (index). One of the eight open Carls. (Baptism: Trendelburg 1837, Archion 220108, Bild 1440, Nro 192.) |
| 27 Oct 1838 | Franz Carl Gustav Kayser | Trendelburg | Open — untraced | Brother of the above. The Franz Carl Kayser who died at Frankfurt in 1898 was born about 1831 to other parents (index). One of the eight open Carls. (Baptism: Trendelburg 1838, Archion 220108, Bild 1453, Nro 235.) |
| 27 Nov 1838 | Heinrich Friedrich Carl Meier | Trendelburg | Open — untraced | His father died in 1842. No named adult record; the Hesse indexes are negative. One of the eight open Carls. (Baptism: Trendelburg 1838, Archion 220108, Bild 1453, Nro 236.) |
| 9 Jan 1839 | Johann Carl Wilhelm Schneider | Friedrichsfeld | Eliminated | Eliminated: married at Hattingen, Westphalia, on 28 Aug 1875 (civil marriage no. 56), “born at Trendelburg on 9/1 39”, son of the late railway worker Johannes Schneider and Karoline Lotz (read twice in the image); died at Holthausen in 1904 (index). Confirmed at Trendelburg in 1853. No Friedrichsfeld burial 1853–98 and no groom 1852–91 (read in the image); no LAGIS exit; the forester C. W. Schneider who died at Trendelburg in 1894 was born at Annaburg. Earlier the open boy born nearest to 26 January, but seventeen days off. (Baptism: Friedrichsfeld 1839, Archion 218959, Bild 1352, Nro 76.) |
The open Carls and the Kassel registers
None of the eight open Carls searched there (Zollmann, Lucas, the two Kaysers, Meier and Kersting of Trendelburg; Hofeditz of Deisel; Schneider of Friedrichsfeld) married at Kassel between 1874 and 1900: every civil marriage register of the city and of its nine suburban offices was read for them (research note, 21 Oct 2026; research note, 22 Oct 2026). None of them is in the Kassel I death indexes of 1879–1900 so far as read (letters C and F–L by eye, the rest by OCR). The idea that Karl Ludwig Hofeditz had a Hartgen stepfather is closed: the Amalie Weller who married Christoph Hartgen in 1840 was a different woman from his mother, who died a widow in 1844 (research note, 21 Oct 2026). All eight stayed open in that search; Kersting has since been traced (married at Neustadt am Rübenberge, 1869; see his row above), and so has Schneider (married at Hattingen, 1875). The ninth, Karl Brandau of Deisel (1837), sailed for New York as a saddler in 1856 and his American life is untraced. The full list of these searches is on Negative results.
How to use this list
The unexamined names are a reference pool for U.S.-side cross-matching, not a queue of Charles candidates — none of them carries a Gans/Konze-pool surname. The July 2026 analysis read this as “no unaccounted Carl on a pool surname exists anywhere in the covered parishes”, but the Dornette birth corpus covers only about 26–60 % of births (research notes, 8 Aug 2026), so that is a pointer, not a negative (likewise the absence of a 26 January 1835 birth in the corpus). Their practical value is as countryman markers: any of these names appearing beside a Gannsen/Johnson in a St. Louis census page, church register, godparent line, or passenger manifest is a Diemel-valley signal worth pulling.
Per-candidate research pages: every row of the ledger has a dedicated page with the full evidence trail, verdict, and re-check pointers — candidate research index.
The machine-readable copy, the full method, the validation and the accounted-for list are in the research notes of 16 July 2026 (research folder). Source data: Mr. Dornette (comp.), Geburts-/Todes-/Heiratsdatenbank Gottsbüren u. Umgebung (copy from a German compiler of village family books), status unverified in the names database.
Related. Birth date across the U.S. records (incl. why the corpus’s missing 26 Jan 1835 birth is a pointer, not a negative) · Negative results audit · Open questions · Germany & origins overview.