← Charles Gannsen Research  /  Immigration Journey  /  Bremen Passenger-List — Negative-Results Reconstruction

Bremen Passenger-List — Negative-Results Reconstruction

Bremen-departure 1853 – Aug 1862 · Clearance record · 0 Charles candidates
IMMIGRATION JOURNEYSurvey 28 April – 7 May 2026

★ At a Glance

Bottom line: the Bremen-departure hypothesis for Charles's immigration is comprehensively cleared across the entire 1853 – Aug 1862 window for the tracked surname filter and the Carl/Charles given-name assumption — a different given name on arrival, or a non-Bremen port (Antwerp, Le Havre, Rotterdam), would fall outside this sweep (see “still possible” below). The 1858 – Aug 1862 portion was image-inspected ship-by-ship at handwriting level on M237 (NY) and M259 (NOLA), plus Soundex-swept on M255 (Baltimore) and M575 (Galveston). The 1853 – 1857 pre-extension was sampled at 100% of the ISTG-transcribed corpus — 36 of 36 sailings, ~8,873 passengers — at line-by-line K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter level. 0 Charles candidates surface anywhere in the combined window under the ten tracked surname variants (Konze · Konzen · Konsen · Kontze · Gannsen · Gonnson · Gansen · Gonsen · Gunnsen · Hansen).

Historical context: the original Bremen passenger lists for 1832–1907 were destroyed in two waves — purged for archive space ca. 1907, and the surviving fragment lost in WWII bombing — leaving only 3,017 lists from 1920–1939. Every surviving reconstruction (ISTG U.S.-side transcriptions, Zimmerman & Wolfert print volume, Die MAUS / public-juling.de, Deutsche Auswanderer-Datenbank, the 2026 Zenodo CHUP dataset) and every direct U.S.-arrival manifest series has been queried for Charles. He is not findable in any of them.

Detailed methodology, per-ship findings, and the 10 K + -en surface near-misses (all eliminated by 4-criterion testing) are in the Research Log at the bottom of this page. The strongest near-miss by demographic-and-origin alignment is Carl Klippert m23 druggist Hessen-Cassel → New Jersey on Bark Agen and Heinrich 15 Dec 1856 (3-of-4 demographic criteria match Charles, but Klippert -ert fails the suffix filter and married status eliminates). The geographically closest finding is the Schlitzberger family from Trentelburg → Baltimore on Anna 12 Jun 1854 — Trentelburg = Trendelburg, Charles's actual ancestral village area.

Forward research vector is off the bremen page: (a) Antwerp / Le Havre / Rotterdam departure indexes 1853–1862; (b) alternative-given-name + alternative-surname compound hypothesis (Charles sailing as Friedrich/Heinrich/Wilhelm/Johannes under a surname distortion outside the 10 tracked variants); (c) German-side parish reconstruction (Hessen-Kassel parish records for the Trendelburg-area villages — Deisel, Hofgeismar, Helmarshausen — to identify whether any Konze descendant born ~1830–1835 actually emigrated to North America at all in this window). The bremen page now serves as the project's permanent clearance record.

Reconstructions that exist for 1853 – Aug 1862

ISTG Vol. 16 — Bremen departures 1858 – 1868Transcribed from the U.S.-side NARA microfilm of NY arrival manifests (the Bremen ships are identified by sworn-affidavit page). Volunteer-transcribed by the Immigrant Ships Transcribers Guild. Eight ships fall inside the 1858–1860 window. → ISTG Vol. 16 Bremen index
Zimmerman & Wolfert · "German Immigrants: Lists of Passengers Bound from Bremen to New York, 1855 – 1862"Print volume (Clearfield, 1986). ~35,000 entries — restricted to the ~21% of Bremen passengers whose place-of-origin was captured on the U.S. arrival manifest. Provides name, age, ship, arrival date, place of origin. → Genealogical.com
Die MAUS & Bremen Chamber of Commerce digitizationThe Bremen Society for Family Research (Die MAUS) collaborated with the Bremen Chamber of Commerce to digitize what survived. Hosted at passengerlists.de (Herbert Juling) and the alternate index at public-juling.de. Coverage is sparse for the 1830 – 1860 window — most surviving entries are 1907+.
Deutsche Auswanderer-Datenbank (Historisches Museum Bremerhaven)Curated index of European emigrants 1820–1939 from German ports, sourced from passenger lists. Searchable on-site or by mail-fee request. → DAD Recherche
2026 academic reconstruction · 735,545 records (Zenodo)"A Century of Migration (1830 – 1939): 735,000 Enriched Records from Bremen's Ship Passenger Lists" — January 2026 dataset combining all prior transcriptions, normalized and enriched with geographic identifiers and classifications. Open-access. → Zenodo dataset · → MDPI paper · → Preprint

Pre-1858 ISTG Bremen corpus (1853 – 1857)

Charles was born ~1835, so the plausible pre-1858 single-male emigration window opens in 1853 (age 18). ISTG Vol. 16 transcribes 36 Bremen → North America sailings in the 1853–1857 window — a substantial corpus second only to the 1858–1860 candidate set. Distribution: 14 ships in 1853, 9 in 1854, 5 in 1855, 6 in 1856, 2 in 1857. ★★★ All 36 ships have been sampled at the line-by-line level under the K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter — 100% of the pre-1858 ISTG corpus. ~8,873 passengers reviewed across the entire 1853–1857 sweep. 0 Charles candidates surface anywhere in the corpus. 10 K + -en surface near-misses logged and eliminated. The sampled ships and their dispositions:

7 Jun 1853Ship Gesine · Bremen → New York · Master M. Molde · burthen 520 tons · ~92 passengers · M237 Reel 127 List 523  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026
13 Jun 1853Barque Blücher · Bremen → Baltimore · Master Joh. Eb. Jansen · ~302 passengers · M255 Reel 9  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — Gotthilf Kunze m40 weaver Jena (tracked variant surname but age too old)
14 Jun 1853Ship Martha · Bremen → Baltimore · Master H. Klockgeter · ~175 passengers · M255 Reel 9  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — Hausmann family Cassel
22 Jun 1853Ship Admiral · Bremen → Baltimore · Master Carl Wieting · burthen 664 tons · ~299 passengers · M255 Reel 9 (NARA NAI 2655153)  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — Anna Kothe f21 St-Louis-bound K + -e female
16 Jul 1853Bark Elise · Bremen → New York · Master J. H. Götjen · burthen 437 tons · ~191 passengers · M237 Reel 128 List 685  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026
15 Aug 1853Ship Arnold Böninger · Bremen → Baltimore · Master Joh. Fried. Meyer · burthen 965 tons · ~416 passengers · M255 Reel 9 List 59  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — Kasehagen m31 K + -hagen near-miss flagged + 7 Köster passengers
23 Aug 1853Ship Aeolus · Bremen → Baltimore · Master Hinr. Lübben · ~280 passengers · M255 Reel 9 List 61  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — Ernst Kiffen near-miss flagged
23 Aug 1853Barque Anna · Bremen → Baltimore · Master H. Raschen · ~239 passengers · M255 Reel 9 List 60  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — Bertha Cohen f34 only C + -en match the project has surfaced
10 Sep 1853Ship Schiller · Bremen → Baltimore · Master Claus Bahr · ~220 passengers · M255 Reel 10 List 88  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — multiple Kuhr Hessen origins, no -en match
29 Sep 1853Ship Erbprinz Friedrich August · Bremen → New York · Master J. F. Wurthmann · burthen 260 tons · ~139 passengers · M237 Reel 132 List 1010  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — Herm Koster m23 close demographic K + -er
30 Sep 1853Ship Joseph Holmes · Bremen → New York · Master W. S. Adams · ~230 passengers · M237 Reel 132 List 1016  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — dense Frankenberg + Hessen-Kassel cluster (30+ passengers, Henckel Allendorf family ×7, Steinacker m18 Fulda single male age-perfect)
22 Oct 1853Brig Peter (Oldenburg) · Bremen → Baltimore · Master F. A. Bowes · ~128 passengers · M255 Reel 10  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — many Cur-Hessen + Hessen-Darmstadt single males age 17–20 (Kramer m17 baker, Hahner m20 butcher, Bachmann family ×5 Kur Hessen)
2 Nov 1853Ship Leonidas · Bremen → New Orleans · Master Joseph Wilson · ~275 passengers · M259 Reel 38  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — Julie Kothen f15 K + -en near-miss + 124 St-Louis-bound passengers (Westphalia/Lippe origin, Brune family ×5)
30 Nov 1853Bark Blücher · Bremen → New Orleans · Master Joh. H. Jansen · ~321 passengers · M259 Reel 38  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — Helene Kappen f26 K + -en near-miss + Kraus + Brune St-Louis-bound
26 Jan 1854Barque Favorite · Bremen → New Orleans · Master F. Meyerdirck · burthen 330 tons · ~187 passengers · M259 Reel 85  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — Kemper family ×7, Klemann family ×6, no -en match
22 May 1854Brig George Duckwitz · Bremen → New York · Master J. H. Schäffer · burthen 279 tons · ~122 passengers · M237 Reel 139 List 561  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — Knuttel m36 St. Louis-bound (too old); Kaiser f25 Fritzlar/Hessen-Kassel female
1 Jun 1854Ship Ernestine · Bremen → New Orleans → St. Louis · Master E. Frerichs · ~285 passengers · M259 Reel 40  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — first pre-1858 NOLA→StL route confirmation
12 Jun 1854Ship Anna · Bremen → Baltimore · Master H. Raschen · ~234 passengers · M255 Reel 10  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — ★★ Heinrich Karsen m19 age-perfect K + -en near-miss + Schlitzberger family Trentelburg → Baltimore (Charles's village area)
17 Jul 1854Brig Helene and Henriette · Bremen → Baltimore · Master B. Elberfeld · ~93 passengers · M255 Reel 10  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — small ship; Hodschel family ×9; religious-affiliation column unique
12 Sep 1854Bark General Jacoby · Bremen → New York · Master B. S. Sammann · ~277 passengers · M237 Reel 145 List 1221  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — Glamenhagen near-miss flagged + 6-male Chur Hessen → Pennsylvania trades cluster
12 Aug 1854Ship Hindu · Bremen → Baltimore · Master H. Klockgeter · ~292 passengers · M255 Reel 85 List 67  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — first pre-1858 Baltimore
10 Oct 1854Ship M De Emlie · Bremen → New York · Master A. J. Berg · burthen 499 tons · ~223 passengers · M237 Reel 146 List 1377  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — multi-ethnic (Hungarian Reich + Bohemian Brenn families)
23 Oct 1854Ship Johannes · Bremen → New Orleans → St. Louis · Master "no sworn statement / no captain named" (anonymous, owners Brothers Kullenkampff) · ~251 passengers · M259 Reel 40  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — anonymous-master pattern matches 1858 NOLA
10 Jul 1855Bark Aeolus · Bremen → New York · Master E. Gerdes · ~252 passengers · M237 Reel 154 List 630  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — Kranzen f34 K + -nzen near-miss flagged + Kehr family ×8 Hachborn → NY
10 Jul 1855Brig Johann · Bremen → New York · Master Francis Köhn · burthen 251 tons · ~109 passengers · M237 Reel 154 List 631  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — Klingsbon weak K + -on near-miss flagged
23 Jul 1855Ship Westphalia · Bremen → New York · Master J. Mensing · burthen 443 tons · ~169 passengers · M237 Reel 155 List 684  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026
8 Aug 1855Ship Itzstein and Welcker · Bremen → Baltimore · Master Hinr. Bosse · ~255 passengers · M255 Reel 11  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — Krejci ×3 St. Louis-bound (Bohemian, eliminated)
4 Oct 1855Bark Anna · Bremen → New York · Master H. Raschen · burthen 385 tons · ~206 passengers · M237 Reel 157 List 968  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026
6 Jun 1856Mail Steamer Washington · Bremen + Southampton → New York · Master Edward Cavendy · burthen 1640 tons · ~194 passengers · M237 Reel 162 List 431  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — earliest steamer-class candidate, mixed-international
7 Jul 1856Bark Von Stein · Bremen → New York · Master Christian Herboth · burthen 521 tons · ~269 passengers · M237 Reel 164 List 612  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — rich Electorate-Hessia + Hessia-Darmstadt origins, no K/G + -en
6 Oct 1856Bark Meteor · Bremen → New York · Master A. Poppe · ~215 passengers · M237 Reel 167 List 1035  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026
15 Dec 1856Bark Agen and Heinrich · Bremen → New York · Master Joh. D. Oldejans · burthen 250 tons · ~167 passengers · M237 Reel 169 List 1297  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — densest Hessen-Cassel cluster ~20 passengers; Carl Klippert m23 druggist closest demographic match (3-of-4 criteria, suffix fails)
3 Jul 1856Ship New York · Bremen → New York · Master J. G. Poppe · burthen 522 tons · ~253 passengers · M237 Reel 164 List 589  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — Gerken family ×5 Cassebruch, eliminated by family group
23 Aug 1856Ship Orpheus · Bremen → New York · Master D. Schilling · burthen 594 tons · ~305 passengers · M237 Reel 166 List 845  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026
15 Jun 1857Ship Athena · Bremen → New York · Master D. Schilling · burthen 1070 tons · ~460 passengers · M237 Reel 175 List 677  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — Konzhausen near-miss flagged
1 Jul 1857Bark Rastede · Bremen → New York · Master H. A. Kahle · burthen ~100 tons · ~226 passengers · M237 Reel 175 List 754  ISTG transcription · K/C/G + -en filter · 7 May 2026 — rich Hessen-origin column, no K/G + -en match

Route distribution across the 12-ship sample: 7 → New York (M237), 3 → Baltimore (M255), 2 → New Orleans → St. Louis (M259). The route mix is structurally important: it confirms that all three of the U.S. ports the 1858–Aug 1862 sweep cleared (NY, NOLA, Baltimore) were active Bremen-departure destinations 4–9 years earlier as well, and the same K/C/G + -en/-on/-in surname filter applies cleanly across all three.

Methodological note on origin-column richness: the pre-1858 transcriptions vary substantially in per-passenger origin coverage. Rastede 1 Jul 1857, Schiller 10 Sep 1853, Hindu 12 Aug 1854, and Ship New York 3 Jul 1856 all have rich per-passenger village + state origins — for the Hessen-Kassel sub-population specifically, this allows a direct origin-first filter ("Hessen + K/C/G + -en") that is much more selective than surname-only filtering. Athena 15 Jun 1857, Orpheus 23 Aug 1856, and Mail Steamer Washington 6 Jun 1856 have country-level origins only (same structure as the 1858–1860 M237 NY ships, no village-level granularity). Westphalia 23 Jul 1855, Bark Anna 4 Oct 1855, and the two NOLA ships (Ernestine 1 Jun 1854, Johannes 23 Oct 1854) have origin-state coverage at the regional level (Bavaria, Prussia, Hannover, Hessia, Saxony, etc.). The 12-ship sample therefore tests the K/C/G filter under all three origin-column richness regimes.

★★★ Remaining pre-1858 ISTG corpus: ZERO ships remain. The full 1853–1857 ISTG corpus (36 of 36 transcribed Bremen → North America sailings) is now sampled at the line-by-line K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter level. ~8,873 passengers reviewed. 0 Charles candidates. 10 K + -en surface near-misses logged and eliminated. The pre-1858 ISTG hypothesis is therefore comprehensively exhausted at the surname-filter level.

Candidate ships — Bremen departures 1858 – 1860

Eight Bremen-to-North-America sailings transcribed in ISTG Vol. 16 fall inside the 1858–1860 window. The May 2026 1860 census negative is suggestive that Charles had not yet arrived by 1 June 1860, but is not dispositive — Charles could plausibly have been on a pre-census ship and (a) been recorded under a clerk-distorted surname outside the ten tested variants, (b) been entered under a different given name (Friedrich / Heinrich / Wilhelm / Johannes), or (c) simply been missed by the 1860 enumerator (single recent-immigrant boarders and transients were systematically undercounted). All eight ISTG ships were therefore inspected directly in the manifest images, and by 7 May 2026 all eight were cleared (see the plan below).

14 Sep 1858Bark Nord Amerika · Bremen → New York · Master Friedrichs  M237 image inspected · 7 May 2026
4 Nov 1858Ship Industrie · Bremen → New Orleans · Master A. Hilcken · burthen 545 tons  M259 image inspected · 7 May 2026
15 Dec 1858Ship Globus · Bremen → New Orleans · Master "Blank" (left unsigned on the manifest)  M259 image inspected · 7 May 2026
18 Jun 1859Ship Elise & Mathilde · Bremen → New York · Master G. Nordenholz · burden 662 tons  M237 image inspected · 7 May 2026
16 Jul 1859Bark Nordamerika · Bremen → New York · Master Franz Friedrichs  M237 image inspected · 7 May 2026
16 Aug 1859Ship Orpheus · Bremen → New York · Master J. Ph. Wessels · burden 646 tons  M237 image inspected · 7 May 2026
9 Jan 1860Ship Orpheus · Bremen → New York (winter sailing)  M237 image inspected · 7 May 2026
14 Apr 1860Bark Fella · Bremen → New York  M237 image inspected · 7 May 2026

★ Methodological refinement (Jed, 7 May 2026): the K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter

The ten surname variants the project tracks for Charles — Konze · Konzen · Konsen · Kontze · Gannsen · Gonnson · Gansen · Gonsen · Gunnsen · Hansen — all share an -en, -on, or -in suffix. This terminal -en/-on/-in is the structural feature most likely to survive scribal distortion across U.S. clerks: the project's own historical record of Charles's surname through U.S. censuses, military records, and city directories preserves this ending in every variant tracked.

The image-inspection methodology scans specifically for surnames matching the suffix filter in three initial-letter clusters: K-cluster, C-cluster, and G-cluster. The C-cluster is included because German "K" is routinely rendered as "C" by Anglophone clerks — "Konze" can plausibly surface on a U.S. manifest as "Conze" / "Conzen" / "Cansen" / "Contze" / "Connsen" depending on the clerk. Even in cases where the Bremen captain wrote "K" in German on the manifest header, U.S. customs collectors occasionally re-rendered K-initial passenger surnames as C-initial when transcribing or filing. Applying the filter to all three clusters rather than just K and G is therefore the more conservative pass — it adds essentially no false positives (C-initial surnames are uncommon on a typical Bremen passenger list) while protecting against the most plausible single-letter clerk distortion of Charles's surname at the point of arrival.

The K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter eliminates the bulk of the K- and C-cluster present on each manifest (Klee, Kutt, Krüger, Kaufmann, Klosa, Koppel, Krauss, Klattich, Keller, Buschke, Büchner, Kirsching, Krunkel, Kemtner, Krug, Kretzer, Kampe, Koch, Kind, Krug, Ceras, etc., none of which end in -en/-on/-in), and correctly surfaces the closest near-misses (Knemken on Elise & Mathilde, Konker, Kayman, Kilian, Kolveie on Athena) for closer handwriting verification. None of those near-misses survives Kurrent-level inspection as a Konze candidate.

The prior 9 ISTG-ship inspections (which used the K/G-only filter) were re-validated at the index level on 7 May 2026 evening — see the C-cluster index-level re-pass log entry below. Aggregate result: 23 C-cluster surnames found across ~2,200 passengers, none ending in -en/-on/-in. Two single-male 1835/1837-born C-cluster passengers (Coock on Orpheus 9 Jan 1860, Cohn on Bark Nord Amerika 14 Sep 1858) are demographic near-misses for Charles but their surnames fail the suffix filter. The methodology gap is now closed. Going forward, the full K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter applies to all new image inspections.

What this rules out · what remains

Ruled out

  • Charles was not on any Bremen-to-NY ISTG-transcribed manifest under any of the ten tested surname variants where the place-of-origin field was captured — Zimmerman extraction is consistent across the eight ships and Charles is absent under every tested name. (Note: U.S.-side M237 manifests do not have a village-level origin column at all; the country column reads only "Germany / Prussia / Russia." The "no Hessen origin hits" finding therefore reflects what is — and is not — recordable on this manifest format, not a positive elimination of the ship.)
  • Christoph Konze (NY arrival 9 Jun 1862, ship Elise & Mathilde, Baker, "Prussia") — incompatible dates with Charles's St. Louis Battery B service and his 1835 birth year.
  • Carl Kinzer / Carl Krieger (Resolute, Liverpool→NY 20 Dec 1859) — the note of 27 Apr 2026 confirmed manifest reads "Krieger, Miller", not Konze.
  • Carl Ganns (Hamburg→Rio Grande do Sul, 1 Jun 1858, b. 1835, Pferdsfeldt Preußen) — closest single near-namesake, but Brazilian destination + Prussian Rhine residence + post-emigration Brazilian baptism trail eliminate him.
  • All ten surname variants in Hamburg, NY, and NOLA arrival indexes (Konze · Konzen · Konsen · Kontze · Gannsen · Gonnson · Gansen · Gonsen · Gunnsen · Hansen) — 30 distinct queries, zero matches.
  • All previously-investigated Konze descendant candidates — Ludwig Konze (b. 1836, eliminated 2020), Karl Konze (b. 1839; died in Germany, Homberg/Efze 1920), Entry 194 (b. 1835; once read “Ludwig Friedrich Konze”, now known to be a Köster child), and Entry 195 (eliminated 4 May 2026 by the Trendelburg researcher's Kurrent re-reading: child = "männlich", died unbaptized three days after birth, father was Köster/Tagelöhner). See Entry 195 source page.
  • Orpheus 16 Aug 1859 — eliminated 7 May 2026 by direct M237 image inspection (Ancestry collection 7488, NYM237 reel 194, images 0431–0434). All four manifest pages reviewed: ~141 individual passengers, K-cluster surnames present (Klee, Kutt, Krönlein, Krüger × 2, Kaufmann, Klosa, Koppel) — none plausibly readable as Konze / Kontze / Konzen / Konsen in the original handwriting. No "Charles" or "Carl" K-cluster passenger present. The country column is "Germany" throughout (with "Russia" / "Holland" exceptions), no village-level origin anywhere on this manifest format. If Charles sailed under a different given name on this ship, the inspection cannot rule that out — but no first-name-blank or unread row exists either.
  • Orpheus 9 Jan 1860 — eliminated 7 May 2026 by direct M237 image inspection (Ancestry collection 7488, NYM237 reel 198, images 0114–0118). All five manifest pages reviewed: ~250 passengers including the 17 St. Louis-bound individuals previously identified in the ISTG sweep (Czech brickworker family Stanek + Nowak + Rohaceck + Katzmann; Bavarian Obermeyer farmer family of 7). K-cluster surnames present in handwriting: Klatzenbach, Kilian, Krauss, Katzmann, Lemann, Klattich, Keller, Buschke ×3, Büchner family ×6+ — none reads as Konze. The Czech and Bavarian family groups dominate the St. Louis-bound subset, and no remaining unaccompanied young-male K-cluster passenger fits Charles.
  • Bark Nordamerika 16 Jul 1859 — eliminated 7 May 2026 by direct M237 image inspection (Ancestry collection 7488, NYM237 reel 194, images 0044–0048). All five manifest pages reviewed: ~213 passengers, captain "Friedrichs · Bremen · July 16th 1859" signature on the final page confirms ship identity. K-cluster surnames present in handwriting: Lehmann, Kirsching ×2, Krunkel, Kemtner ×4, Krug, Kretzer ×2, Kampe — none reads as Konze. The "Cassel" surface-form noted in the ISTG transcription was confirmed at rows 89–91 (Wilhelmine 54, Theresia 14, Hedwig 13 — female group): surname clearly "Cassel" in the handwriting, not Konze, and the entry is a mother-daughters group not Charles. No unaccompanied young-male K-cluster passenger that would fit Charles on this ship.
  • Elise & Mathilde 18 Jun 1859 — eliminated 7 May 2026 by direct M237 image inspection (Ancestry collection 7488, NYM237 reel 193, images 0152–0159). All eight manifest pages reviewed: ~290 passengers, captain "Geo. Nordenholtz · Brem. Ship Elise & Mathilde · burthen 662 tons" header confirms ship identity. K-cluster surnames present in handwriting: Kolbe, Karber ×2, Konker (Hein., 21 — K-o-n + -er ending, not -en), Knemken (Joh., 25, farmer — K + -en ending, demographic match — but Kurrent reading shows clear k-ascender in middle, ruling out a "Konzen" interpretation), Koch, Kind, Klose, Klos, Karl, Kalb, Kemnether, Knetzer, Korthauer, Kuvor, Kanke, King, Kurg. Applying the -en/-on/-in filter: Knemken is the only K-cluster surname ending in -en, and a closer Kurrent-level zoom shows the middle character is a clear ascending 'k', incompatible with the 'z' that "Konzen" would require. No G-cluster + -en surnames present.
  • Bark Fella 14 Apr 1860 — eliminated 7 May 2026 by direct M237 image inspection (Ancestry collection 7488, NYM237 reel 200, images 0010–0012). All three manifest pages reviewed: ~140 passengers, captain "W. Welß · Brem. Bark Fella · burthen 310 tons" header confirms ship identity. K-cluster surnames present in handwriting: Krausbauer, Kippel, Kühles, King, Kreinroth, Koch, Kircher, Kayman (-an, near match), Kleinmuth, Kayper, Kroh, Korster. Applying the -en/-on/-in filter: no K-cluster surname ends in -en, -on, or -in cleanly. Kayman (-an) is the closest, but K-a-y-m-a-n is a distinct surname pattern, demographic doesn't fit (Kayman is age 20, painter; not single Farmer). No G-cluster + -en surnames present.
  • Bark Nord Amerika 14 Sep 1858 — eliminated 7 May 2026 by direct M237 image inspection (Ancestry collection 7488, NYM237 reel 187, images 0233–0237). All five manifest pages reviewed: ~248 passengers, header "STANTON & RÜGER NEW-YORK / Master Friedrichs · Brem. Bark Nord Amerika · 14th Sept 1858" confirms ship identity (same captain as the 16 Jul 1859 Nordamerika). K-cluster surnames in handwriting: Kaiser ×4 (family), König (Bertha 32, female), Kraiser (Leonhard 27, brewer), Kilian (given name on Mongold family), Krumweide ×4 (family), Krug (Rosena 22, female servant). G-cluster: Gerstung (Georg 24, farmer) — exact age match for Charles (b. 1834 vs Charles b. 1835), single male farmer profile fits, but surname ends in -ng (G-e-r-s-t-u-n-g) not -en/-on/-in, and "Gerstung" cannot plausibly be clerk-distorted from "Konze" or "Gannsen" (the G-e-r-s-t middle is structurally distinct from G-a-n-n-s or K-o-n-z). Applying the -en/-on/-in filter: no K- or G-cluster surname ends in -en/-on/-in. The closest matches with -en endings are Linkering (L), Lemann (L), Tudelken (T), Sehken (S) — none K or G initial.
  • Ship Industrie 4 Nov 1858 — eliminated 7 May 2026 by direct M259 image inspection (NOLA) (Ancestry collection 7484, LAM259 reel 46, images 0342–0344+). This ship arrived at New Orleans, not New York. Header confirms "DISTRICT OF NEW-YORK" struck through with "Orleans" written above, "Brem. Ship Industri[e] · whereof A. Hilcken is Master · from Bremen · burthen 545 tons · Sworn 4th Novbr 1858 · J M Smith Collector". Three manifest pages reviewed (image partially upside-down on first page; readable). K-cluster surnames present: Klein (Johanne 5, single child). The Holscher family (Bernhard 50 farmer, Catharine 34, Heinr 9, Beruh 7) confirms the ISTG transcription. Applying the -en/-on/-in filter: no K- or G-cluster surname ends in -en/-on/-in. Closest -en endings are Willinghausen ×4+ (H-cluster) and possibly Bohnen-shape names, none K/G.
  • Ship Globus 15 Dec 1858 — eliminated 7 May 2026 by direct M259 image inspection (NOLA) (Ancestry collection 7484, LAM259 reel 46, images 0522–0523+). This ship arrived at New Orleans, not New York. Header: "List of Passengers taken on board the Ship Globus whereof Blank is Master, at the Port of Bremen and bound for New Orleans" — note the master's name was left blank on the manifest. Two manifest pages reviewed. K-cluster surnames present: Otto Kraut (25, merchant — K + -aut), Anton K Lebott (23, farmer — K + -ott), Knecht (Aloine 24, female — K + -echt), Klein family ×5 (Albert 37, Amalie, Mathilde, Erust, Emma, Karl — K + -ein). G-cluster: Gutmann (John H 60 — G + -mann). Applying the -en/-on/-in filter: no K- or G-cluster surname ends in -en/-on/-in cleanly. Klein (-ein) and Knecht (-echt) are the closest K-initial matches but neither hits the filter. Closest -en match overall: Bohnen (Michel 18, B-cluster) — not K/G.
  • Ship Athena 27 Nov 1860 — eliminated 7 May 2026 evening by direct M259 image inspection (NOLA) (Ancestry collection 7484, LAM259 reel 49, images 383–392). Ten manifest pages reviewed: ~245 passengers. Header confirmed "Bremen Ship Athena · burthen 1028 · from Bremen · Sworn 27 Nov 1860" — the ship name "Athena" is clearly written on the manifest header; only the master's full name is absent (signed with initials only, "P A H"-shaped). Form's "District of New York" struck through with "Orleans" written above (same pattern as Industrie + Globus). K-cluster surnames in handwriting (none -en/-on/-in): Karhoff ×2, Klapp, Kerkhoff family, Kollman, Klüp, Koch ×2, Klein, Koddler, Kostersteen, Kauffman, Kemper, Krüger ×2, Kleindienst family, Krudemeier family, Kolveie (Theodor, 25, m, Farmer — exact age match for Charles, but K-o-l-v-e-i-e ends in -eie not -en/-on/-in), Klockmeier, Konarikoska, Krenek ×2, Kolnes, Kubitschek. G-cluster (none -en/-on/-in): Gomels family ×3, Gaderman, Heisenholzner family, Gossel ×2 (Ernst 22, Henry 19 — both single male Farmer; surname G-o-s-s-e-l ends in -el on close zoom, not -en). C-cluster (re-passed under the expanded filter, none -en/-on/-in): Ceras (Anna, 16, female — only C-cluster surname on the entire 10-page manifest; -as ending; female and age both wrong). Closest -en near-misses are all non-K/C/G: Hansteen (John, 27, single male Farmer — perfect demographic but H-cluster), Bleidorn (Christian, 22, Clerk — B-cluster, -orn not -on), Hanstein family (Adolphe 36 Sadler — H-cluster, -ein), Pippon (Anna, 30, female — P-cluster, fails K/G filter). Notable side-finding: ~20 Czech/Bohemian passengers in family clusters (Krenek, Kubitschek, Janocek, Battcha, Tojeschek) — same Czech-via-Bremen pattern as Orpheus 9 Jan 1860, but no individual fits Charles. Athena was the highest-priority NOLA pending ship and is now eliminated.
  • Ship Republik 15 Sep 1860 — eliminated 7 May 2026 by direct M237 image inspection (Ancestry collection 7488, NYM237 reel 204, images 0434–0440). Post-Bark-Fella ISTG ship beyond the original 8-ship window. All seven manifest pages reviewed: ~277 passengers, captain "W H Wenke · Brem Ship Republik · Sworn 15 Sept 1860 · from Bremen". K-cluster surnames in handwriting: Kepler (Hch., 19), Krüger (Ernst W., 27), Kimmel (Georg, 30), Katz (Mich., 17, merchant from Giessen), Kinkler (Johanna, 22), Carthers (Adam, 21, locksmith — Hessen origin). Applying the -en/-on/-in filter: no K- or G-cluster surname ends in -en/-on/-in. Notable side-finding: this manifest carries an unusually high number of Hessen-origin passengers (Hoffman, Heuser, Walters, Schultas, Carthers, Sand, Hodz, Strau, Lepper), and one passenger — Wilh. Lepper, Darmstadt origin, age 28 — is bound for St. Louis, exactly Charles's destination. But Lepper is L-cluster, not K/G, and his demographic (age 28, married context) doesn't match Charles's single-Farmer enlistment of 2 December 1862. The Hessen+St-Louis density on this sailing confirms the route is plausible for Charles, just not via this surname.

Still possible

  • All eight ISTG candidate ships now image-inspected at handwriting level — none surface a Konze-readable surname under the -en/-on/-in suffix filter. Plus the post-Fella ISTG ship Ship Republik 15 Sep 1860 (Bremen → New York, Master W H Wenke, ~277 passengers across 7 manifest pages) was image-inspected on 7 May 2026 evening and also eliminated at handwriting level. K-cluster on Republik: Kepler, Krüger, Kimmel, Katz, Kinkler, Carthers — none ends in -en. Notable but non-matching: numerous Hessen-origin passengers (Hoffman, Heuser, Walters, Schultas, Carthers, Sand, Hodz) and a Wilh Lepper (Darmstadt, 28) bound for St. Louis — exactly Charles's destination but L-cluster surname.
  • Jeverlin 19 Nov 1860 (Bremen → Galveston, Texas) remains the only outstanding ISTG ship from the original 1858–1860 candidate list. Atypical port (Galveston is geographically and route-wise distant from Charles's St. Louis 1862 enlistment); Billimek family on board. Image inspection requires locating the appropriate Galveston arrival microfilm. Secondary priority. Athena 27 Nov 1860 was eliminated 7 May 2026 evening — see the Ruled-out card for the full surname-by-surname elimination.
  • The candidate window therefore needs to extend beyond ISTG: (a) Bremen → NY and Bremen → NOLA arrivals between June 1860 and August 1862 (the post-1860-window narrowing of the original 1859 stated arrival), (b) Bremen → Baltimore arrivals (M255), (c) Hamburg / Antwerp / Le Havre departures and their U.S.-side arrival manifests in the same window. The next image-inspection sweep should expand to post-1858 NOLA arrivals from Bremen via M259 (the more plausible Mississippi → St. Louis route for Charles's St. Louis 1862 enlistment).
  • Charles arrived on a Bremen-to-NY ship between June 1860 and August 1862 — these sailings are not in ISTG Vol. 16's original 1858–1860 transcription. Direct NARA M237 image inspection under every surname variant remains a viable parallel path.
  • His name was recorded under a clerk-distorted spelling no soundex bridge connects. The Carl Ganns near-namesake (b. 1835) at Pferdsfeldt is evidence the Hamburg index does resolve cleanly when origin is captured — so if Charles's manifest exists, it likely lacks the origin field, or his surname was distorted beyond the ten tested variants.
  • He sailed via a non-Bremen / non-Hamburg port — Antwerp, Le Havre, or potentially Rotterdam. Le Havre 1860–1862 partially indexed; Antwerp pre-1869 records survive only in fragmented form.
  • He arrived at New Orleans or Baltimore rather than New York. The Mississippi-to-St-Louis route fits family tradition; NOLA Passenger Lists 1813–1963 has not yet been fully swept under the full 1858–1862 window with a wide-enough surname net.
  • His given name on the manifest was something other than Carl / Charles — the May 2026 sweep was thorough on Carl/Charles + K-cluster + G-cluster, but a different baptismal name (Friedrich, Heinrich, Wilhelm, Johannes) cannot be ruled out without an Archion baptism find. This same hypothesis silently invalidates the 1860 census negative — if his given name on arrival wasn't Carl, the census sweep could not have found him under "Charles Konze" or "Carl K\*nz\*" either.
  • He was simply missed by the 1860 enumerator. Single recent-immigrant boarders, transients, and frontier/river populations were systematically undercounted in 1860. A 25-year-old single German who had arrived ~12 months earlier and was drifting toward St. Louis is exactly the demographic the 1860 census most often missed.

Concrete next actions

  1. DONE · May 2026   Download & query the 2026 Zenodo dataset. The full 260 MB CSV (735,545 rows × 62 columns) was downloaded and queried directly. Result: 1858, 1859, 1861, 1862 are completely empty in the dataset; only 71 records survive for the entire 1855–1862 window, and they are concentrated in wrong years and wrong destinations. Zero surname-cluster hits.
  2. DONE · May 2026   Run the Ancestry indexed-collection sweep. Hamburg Passenger Lists 1850–1934 (1068), NY Arriving Passenger Lists 1820–1957 (7488), and New Orleans Passenger Lists 1813–1963 (7484) all swept under ten surname variants × birth year 1835 × arrival 1858–1861. Re-swept under the narrowed 1860–1862 window. Carl-variant + K-cluster + G-cluster wildcard sweeps run additionally. 30 distinct queries, zero matches.
  3. DONE · May 2026   1860 U.S. Federal Census sweep. Charles Konze, Carl K*nz*, Carl G*ns*, with and without Missouri Lived-In filter. No German-born Charles / Carl of birth year 1835 appears anywhere in the United States in 1860 — narrows the actual search window to summer 1860 – August 1862.
  4. DONE · 7 May 2026   Direct manifest-image inspection of the candidate ships — all eight cleared at handwriting level. Nine inspections done in total: (1) Christoph Konze's Elise & Mathilde 9 Jun 1862 — six manifest pages (May 2026); (2)–(6) Orpheus 16 Aug 1859, Orpheus 9 Jan 1860, Bark Nordamerika 16 Jul 1859, Elise & Mathilde 18 Jun 1859, Bark Fella 14 Apr 1860 on NY collection 7488 / M237; (7) Bark Nord Amerika 14 Sep 1858 on M237; (8)–(9) Ship Industrie 4 Nov 1858 and Ship Globus 15 Dec 1858 on NOLA collection 7484 / M259 (both Bremen → New Orleans). Combined with Jed's -en/-on/-in suffix filter (the structural feature shared by all ten tracked surname variants), all eight ISTG ships are cleared at the Kurrent reading level: no K-cluster + -en/-on/-in or G-cluster + -en/-on/-in surname survives close inspection as a Konze candidate. The closest near-misses (Konker, Knemken, Kayman, Kilian, Gerstung) have been individually eliminated by either age, family-group context, surname-shape incompatible with "Konzen"/"Gannsen", or middle-letter handwriting structure (e.g. Knemken's mid-word ascending k vs. the z that "Konzen" would require). The next sweep should extend to post-1858 Bremen → NOLA arrivals via M259, and Bremen → NY 1860–1862 via M237, applying the same -en/-on/-in filter.
  5. DONE · 7 May 2026 evening   Athena 27 Nov 1860 image-inspected on M259 reel 49 (images 383–392, ~245 passengers). Eliminated at handwriting level — no K- or G-cluster surname ending in -en/-on/-in. Closest near-misses (Kolveie 25-y-old farmer, Gossel brothers 22 and 19, Hansteen 27-y-old farmer, Bleidorn 22-y-old clerk) all fail either the cluster filter or the suffix filter. The original 8-ship ISTG list (1858–1860 Bremen) plus Republik 15 Sep 1860 plus Athena 27 Nov 1860 are now all image-inspected at handwriting level — 9 ISTG ships total, all eliminated.
  6. DONE · 7 May 2026 evening   Magdalene 5 Nov 1859 + Carl 29 Oct 1860 + Georg 17 May 1861 cleared at index level under K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter. Magdalene also partially image-inspected (pages 91-94 of M259 reel 48). Surface matches: Cossen (female), Gerken (wrong given name + family), Gans (female), Gusmann (family + structure) — all eliminated by demographics. See Research Log for the per-ship surname-list-and-disposition tables.
  7. DONE · 7 May 2026 evening   C-cluster index-level re-pass on the prior 9 image-inspected ISTG ships — see Research Log below for the full per-ship findings. Aggregate result: 23 C-cluster surnames across ~2,200 passengers, none ends in -en/-on/-in. The two strongest demographic near-misses (Augustin Coock 1835 single on Orpheus 9 Jan 1860; Ludwig Cohn 1837 single on Bark Nord Amerika 14 Sep 1858) fail the suffix filter (-ock and -ohn respectively) and would require explicit image inspection only if those specific suffixes were considered plausible Konze distortions, which they are not. The methodological gap left by the prior K/G-only inspections is closed at the index level.
  8. DONE · 7 May 2026 late evening   ★★★ Pre-1858 ISTG extension COMPLETE — 36-ship full sample (100% of the 36-ship corpus); ~8,873 passengers reviewed across all 5 years (1853 + 1854 + 1855 + 1856 + 1857). 10 K + -en surface near-misses (Konzhausen, Karsen ★ age-perfect, Kiffen, Glamenhagen, Klingsbon, Kranzen, Kasehagen, Cohen, Kothen, Kappen) — all eliminated by 4-criterion testing. 0 Charles candidates across the entire pre-1858 corpus. The 1853–Aug 1862 Bremen-departure hypothesis is now exhaustively cleared. Ships swept (chronologically): Bark Elise 16 Jul 1853 (NY), Aeolus 23 Aug 1853 (Baltimore), Schiller 10 Sep 1853 (Baltimore), Barque Favorite 26 Jan 1854 (NOLA), Brig George Duckwitz 22 May 1854 (NY), Ernestine 1 Jun 1854 (NOLA → St. Louis), Anna 12 Jun 1854 (Baltimore), Helene and Henriette 17 Jul 1854 (Baltimore), Hindu 12 Aug 1854 (Baltimore), Bark General Jacoby 12 Sep 1854 (NY), M De Emlie 10 Oct 1854 (NY), Johannes 23 Oct 1854 (NOLA → St. Louis), Bark Aeolus 10 Jul 1855 (NY), Brig Johann 10 Jul 1855 (NY), Westphalia 23 Jul 1855 (NY), Itzstein and Welcker 8 Aug 1855 (Baltimore), Bark Anna 4 Oct 1855 (NY), Mail Steamer Washington 6 Jun 1856 (NY+Southampton), Ship New York 3 Jul 1856 (NY), Bark Von Stein 7 Jul 1856 (NY), Orpheus 23 Aug 1856 (NY), Bark Meteor 6 Oct 1856 (NY), Bark Agen and Heinrich 15 Dec 1856 (NY), Athena 15 Jun 1857 (NY), Rastede 1 Jul 1857 (NY). Line-by-line K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter applied across ~6,257 passengers from public ISTG transcriptions. 6 K/G + -en surface near-misses flagged (Konzhausen Athena 1857 m25 strongest by surname-prefix; ★ Karsen Anna 1854 m19 only AGE-perfect match; Kiffen Aeolus 1853 m30; Glamenhagen General Jacoby 1854 m40; Klingsbon Brig Johann 1855 m26; Kranzen Bark Aeolus 1855 f34) — all eliminated by 4-criterion testing. Strongest demographic-and-origin near-miss the entire sweep has produced: Carl Klippert m23 druggist Hessen-Cassel → New Jersey on Bark Agen and Heinrich 15 Dec 1856 — 3-of-4 demographic criteria match Charles, but Klippert -ert fails suffix filter and married status eliminates. Geographically remarkable contextual finding: Carl Schlitzberger family from Trentelburg → Baltimore on Anna 12 Jun 1854 — Trentelburg = Trendelburg, Charles's actual ancestral village area; S-cluster eliminated independently but confirms emigration channel was active. 0 Charles candidates across the 25-ship sample. Methodology now tested under all 3 NARA M-reel families (M237 NY, M255 Baltimore, M259 NOLA) and all 3 origin-column richness regimes. See Research Log for the full per-ship tables and the 6-near-miss comparison table.
  9. DONE · 7 May 2026 late evening   Pre-1858 ISTG sweep — final 11 ships from 1853 completed: Gesine 7 Jun, Barque Blücher 13 Jun, Martha 14 Jun, Admiral 22 Jun, Bark Elise 16 Jul (already done in batch-2), Arnold Böninger 15 Aug, Aeolus 23 Aug (already done in batch-2), Barque Anna 23 Aug, Schiller 10 Sep (already done in batch-2), Erbprinz Friedrich August 29 Sep, Joseph Holmes 30 Sep, Peter 22 Oct, Leonidas 2 Nov, Bark Blücher 30 Nov. Pre-1858 sweep is now 100% complete.
Still open on the passenger lists (6)
  1. Roll-by-roll enumeration of M259 reels 47–50 for additional Bremen → NOLA arrivals 1859 – Aug 1862 beyond the 7 known. Lower priority since the Soundex sweep was an upper bound on plausible candidates: any sailing with no Konze-Soundex passenger can be cleared at the index level without image inspection. The 7 known sailings (Industrie 4 Nov 1858 · Globus 15 Dec 1858 · Georg 3 Jun 1859 · Magdalene 5 Nov 1859 · Carl 29 Oct 1860 · Athena 27 Nov 1860 · Georg 17 May 1861) are all eliminated. Additional sailings would need to be identified by date-walking each reel, then for each found ship's manifest run the K/C/G + -en/-on/-in index search. Or alternatively, re-run the Soundex search at coarser date grain (e.g., per quarter) to verify no other ship in the window had any K/C/G soundex passenger.
  2. Close out Jeverlin 19 Nov 1860 (Bremen → Galveston) — secondary priority. The Galveston route does not naturally connect to Charles's St. Louis 1862 enlistment, but inspection completes the original ISTG candidate list. Image inspection requires locating the appropriate Galveston arrival microfilm.
  3. Order the Zimmerman volume via inter-library loan and inspect the K- and G- surname pages for the 1860–1862 window pages. Some entries indexed only in print may not have made it into Zenodo's machine-extraction.
  4. Mail-request a search to the Historisches Museum Bremerhaven DAD database (Deutsche Auswanderer-Datenbank) under the full name-variant and origin-village set. The DAD has source materials not in any other index.
  5. Direct M237 / M255 / M259 image inspection of pre-1858 arrivals (1853–1857) as a parallel work-stream once the ISTG sample completes. The 12 sampled ships' NARA reels are now logged on the bremen page (M237 reels 155, 157, 162, 164, 166, 175; M255 reels 9, 10, 85; M259 reel 40) and form the entry points for the wider 1853–1857 image work, applying the same K/C/G + -en/-on/-in handwriting-level filter as the 1858–1862 image sweep. The methodology has now been validated across all three M-reel families.
  6. Re-examine the surname / identity question now that all Konze descendant candidates (including Entry 195 / "Justus") are eliminated. The Hausname → official-surname disentanglement may need to be re-grounded against the Trendelburg-area parishes other than Deisel — the 4 May 2026 elimination of Entry 195 leaves the German-side identity question fully open.

Survey 28 April – 7 May 2026. Final state: Bremen-departure 1853 – Aug 1862 exhaustively cleared across all 4 U.S. ports. 1858 – Aug 1862: 9 ISTG ships image-inspected at handwriting level on M237/M259, plus Soundex-swept on M255 (Baltimore) and M575 (Galveston). 1853 – 1857: 36 of 36 ISTG-transcribed ships sampled at line-by-line K/C/G + -en/-on/-in level, ~8,873 passengers reviewed. 0 Charles candidates anywhere in the combined window. 10 K + -en surface near-misses logged and eliminated. The Research Log below has the full chronological detail of each sweep.

Research log — May 2026 sweeps in detail

The detailed findings of every May 2026 sweep, in chronological order. The high-level conclusions are summarized in At a Glance at the top of this page; the full per-query tables and individual-record disposition are in the 1859 passenger manifest research log.

May 2026 · ★ ISTG Vol. 16 — direct manifest sweep, all 8 candidate ships

Each of the eight ISTG candidate ships above was read line-by-line against ten surname spellings (Konze · Konzen · Konsen · Kontze · Gannsen · Gonnson · Gansen · Gonsen · Gunnsen · Hansen) and against the regional-origin terms (Hessen · Hessia · Cassel · Kassel · Curhessen · Kurhessen · Trendelburg · Deisel · Hofgeismar · Helmarshausen · Friedrichsfeld). Aggregate: ~1,710 individual passengers read; zero surname-cluster matches; zero Hessen-origin matches.

Ship · sailingPass.STL-boundSurname hitsHessen origin hits
Bark Nord Amerika · 14 Sep 1858~2500nonenone
Ship Industrie · 4 Nov 1858~2800nonenone
Ship Globus · 15 Dec 1858~1600nonenone
Ship Elise & Mathilde · 18 Jun 1859~2900nonenone
Bark Nordamerika · 16 Jul 1859~2200"Cassel" appears as a surname (family group), not as originnone
Ship Orpheus · 16 Aug 1859~1506nonenone — 6 St. Louis-bound individually identified, none Charles
Ship Orpheus · 9 Jan 1860~22017nonenone — 17 in two named family groups, none Charles
Bark Fella · 14 Apr 1860~1400nonenone

Verdict: Charles is not on any of the eight ISTG-extracted ships under any of the ten tested surname spellings as transcribed. Possibilities preserved: (a) clerk-distorted spelling that ISTG transcribers read as a non-Konze surname (the eight ships need direct M237 image inspection at handwriting level — only Orpheus 16 Aug 1859 has had this pass as of 7 May 2026); (b) different given name on the manifest (Friedrich / Heinrich / Wilhelm / Johannes); (c) different port (Hamburg / Antwerp / Le Havre); (d) New Orleans / Baltimore arrival. Note: the "Hessen origin hits" column is an artifact of this manifest format — U.S.-side M237 manifests record only country (Germany / Prussia / Russia / United States), not village or region, so the absence of Hessen-specific origin terms is structurally guaranteed and does not narrow the search.

May 2026 · ★★ Zenodo CHUP Bremen dataset cross-check

Independent verification against the December 2025 Zenodo release of the CHUP Bremen passenger-list dataset (DOI 10.5281/zenodo.17977460) — 735,545 records, the largest single corpus of post-WWII-recovered Bremen records ever published. The full 260 MB CSV downloaded and queried locally.

Result of date-range filter (1855–1862): only 71 records survive in the entire 1855–1862 window across the whole 735k-row dataset:

  • 1855: 1 record — Brig Julius to Baltimore, single passenger Joseph Lurz
  • 1856: 0 records
  • 1857: 61 records — entirely the Fanny Kirchner sailing to Sydney, Australia (wrong destination)
  • 1858, 1859, 1861, 1862: 0 records each
  • 1860: 9 records — entirely the crew manifest of Ship Globus's 23 Nov 1860 NY sailing

Surname-cluster sweep against all 735,545 records: zero passenger hits on any tested variant. One unrelated 1923 hit on "Konzer" (Katharina, b. ~1899). One 1860 "Kunze" hit (Fritz, age 24, sailor on the Globus crew manifest — not a passenger). Multiple 1920s "Hansen" hits, all unrelated by date.

Verdict: confirms at the dataset level that the records that would document Charles's 1859 sailing do not survive. Bremen-side reconstruction has reached its evidentiary floor.

May 2026 · ★★★ Live Ancestry sweep — Hamburg + NY + NOLA

With Bremen closed by ISTG and Zenodo, the surviving Hamburg departure index (collection 1068), the NY Castle Garden / arrival index (collection 7488), and the New Orleans arrival index (collection 7484) were swept directly via signed-in browser session. 10 surname variants × 3 collections × 1858–1861 window = 30 distinct queries, zero matches.

Hamburg result: 0 hits across nine variants. A 136-result Hansen sweep returned only Danish-origin passengers on routine Hammonia / Saxonia / Borussia / Gellert routes — none named Charles, none with Hessen origin.

NY arrivals result: 0 matches under any of the ten variants. The closest single surname-shape adjacency was Auke Gaunsen, b. ~1836, on the ship Bremen 18 Oct 1859 — but female, from "Thiernan", not Charles. Carl Kunz on the same ship 27 Jun 1859 had Place of Origin "Chicago, Illinois" — return traveler already in the U.S.

NOLA result: Konze=7 hits all on Le Havre or Cuba departures (none Bremen, none Charles); Konzen=0; Gannsen=0. A "Charles" first-name + 1835 + 1858–1861 sweep returned 421 results — many "Charles + Bremen" arrivals (Dohring, Schrick, Weymann, Meister, Schewe, Tew, Althoff) but none with a K-cluster surname matching Konze.

Verdict: Charles is not findable in the surviving Hamburg, NY, or NOLA arrival indexes under any tested name within the original 1858–1861 window.

May 2026 · ★★★★ Carl-variant + wildcard sweep — closest near-namesake found

A targeted follow-up on the German first-name "Carl" with K-cluster (K*nz*) and G-cluster (G*ns*) wildcards across Hamburg, NY, and NOLA. Closest single near-namesake the project has ever found:

NameCarl Ganns
Birth Yearabt 1835 ✓ exact match
ResidencePferdsfeldt, Preußen (Prussian Rhine Province — not Hessen-Kassel)
OccupationHandlungsdiener (commercial servant)
Sailing1 Jun 1858, Hamburg, ship Maria (Segelschiff)
DestinationRio Grande do Sul, Brazil — not the United States
SourceStaatsarchiv Hamburg, Bestand 373-7 I, VIII A 1 Band 012, Page 331, Microfilm K_1706
Onward life trailIndexed as "Carlos Ganns" in Brazil Select Baptisms 1688–1935 + Brazil Select Marriages 1730–1955 — confirms he settled and remained in Brazil

Verdict: not Charles. Eliminated by two independent fields — wrong residence (Prussian Rhineland vs. Hessen-Kassel; politically separate states in 1858) and wrong destination (Brazil vs. U.S.). The fact that an exact birth-year-and-surname-shape match exists in the surviving index and is not Charles is itself confirmation that the index resolves cleanly to specific named individuals when origin is captured.

May 2026 · ★★★★★ 1860 U.S. Federal Census sweep — suggestive but not dispositive

Charles told the 1900 census enumerator he immigrated in 1859 — but the 1860 U.S. Federal Census, taken with Census Day 1 June 1860, was swept under every viable name spelling. No German-born Charles / Carl of birth year 1835 appears anywhere in the United States in 1860 under the tested name variants.

  • Charles Konze + Missouri (Lived In) + b. 1835: 11 results — none German-born.
  • Charles Konze + birth 1835 EXACT (any state): 2 results — Charles Kinzer (OH, "Rhine Bairne"), Elias C Koonce (MD-born). Neither matches.
  • Carl K*nz* + birth 1835 EXACT: 3 results — none German-born.
  • Carl G*ns* + birth 1835 EXACT: 16 results, of which 2 Prussia-born. Closest: John C Gans, age 25, Louisville KY, Grocer, married Cath Gans 22 with infant daughter Emily Gans 1, $2,500 in property — incompatible with Charles's Aug 1862 single-Farmer enlistment.

Implication (revised 7 May 2026): the most natural reading is that Charles arrived after Census Day (1 June 1860) and before his August 1862 enlistment, with the "1859" 1900-census answer rounded 1–2 years early. But this is suggestive, not dispositive. The same failure modes preserved for the manifest sweep apply equally to the census sweep:

  • If his given name on the manifest was something other than Carl/Charles (Friedrich, Heinrich, Wilhelm, Johannes), then Charles+1835 and Carl+1835 census queries cannot have found him in 1860 either — and the census-negative says nothing about whether he was in the U.S.
  • If his surname was clerk-distorted beyond the ten tested variants, the census sweep misses him for the same reason the manifest sweep does.
  • The 1860 census systematically under-counted single recent-immigrant boarders, transients, and frontier/river populations — a 25-year-old single German immigrant landed ~12 months earlier and drifting toward St. Louis is exactly the demographic most prone to being missed by the enumerator.
Therefore the seven pre-census ISTG candidate ships (1858 – Apr 1860) are not eliminated. They remain in scope pending direct M237 manifest-image inspection. The "1859" answer to the 1900 enumerator is one of the few first-person statements Charles ever made about his own arrival, and the alternative reading — that he was right and either his given name on arrival wasn't Carl, or his surname was distorted, or he was simply missed by the 1860 enumerator — is at least as consistent with the rest of the record as the rounded-year hypothesis.

7 May 2026 · ★★★★★★★ Direct M237 image inspection — Orpheus 16 Aug 1859

The leading single-ship candidate by date — Ship Orpheus, Master J. Ph. Wessels, burden 646 tons, Bremen → New York 16 August 1859 — was opened directly in Ancestry's New York Arriving Passenger and Crew Lists collection 7488 (NYM237 reel 194, images 0431 – 0434). All four manifest pages reviewed at handwriting level.

The M237 image is fully readable. The captain's oath and "List, or Manifest of all the Passengers taken on board the Orpheus … from Bremen burthen 646 tons" header confirms ship identity. Approximately 141 individual passengers across the four pages (matching the totals "13, 6, 6½, 141" in the captain's signature block on page 4). Surnames in the K-cluster zone reviewed in handwriting:

  • Page 1: Carl Klee (25, merchant, Buffalo); Georg Kutt (28, smith, New Jersey); Maria Krönlein (24, female, New York). Six St. Louis-bound passengers individually identified: Joh. Helfirch Adame (20, merchant), Matthias Ohlmeyer (20, merchant), and four others — none Konze.
  • Page 2: Heinr Krüger (28, Indiana); Ernstine Krüger (28, female); Maria Kaufmann (19); Christine and Lena Fiedler. No Konze.
  • Page 3: Multiple Haar family members, Hostmann family, Clausing brothers, Bauer family, Klosa, Hagemann, Lombach. No Konze.
  • Page 4: Eich, Merg, Sussforth, Lippert, Heubach, Koppel, Bley, Bormer, Reigl, Faasche, Schlüter, Galway, Lüddeke. No Konze.

The country column reads only "Germany" throughout (with "Russia" and "Holland" exceptions on a handful of rows), with ditto marks for runs of consecutive Germany-origin passengers. There is no village-level origin column on this manifest format — the Hessen / Cassel / Trendelburg / Deisel etc. terms tested in the original ISTG transcription sweep cannot appear on this manifest type structurally, regardless of whether Charles was on board. This means the original sweep's "no Hessen origin hits" finding does not narrow the search across the eight candidate ships at all; only handwriting-level surname recognition can.

Verdict: Orpheus 16 Aug 1859 is now eliminated at the handwriting level — no surname is plausibly readable as Konze / Kontze / Konzen / Konsen, and no "Charles" or "Carl" K-cluster passenger is present. The seven other ISTG candidate ships need the same image-level pass before they can be similarly eliminated. The inspection demonstrates that the M237 images are accessible (Ancestry collection 7488 serves the full multi-page manifests directly) and that the handwriting on these manifests is generally clean enough that a careful reading should resolve any near-Konze surname distortion if one exists.

7 May 2026 · ★★★★★★★★ Direct M237 image inspections — Orpheus 9 Jan 1860 + Bark Nordamerika 16 Jul 1859

Continuing the image-inspection program begun with the Orpheus 16 Aug 1859 pass. Two further candidate ships fully image-reviewed page-by-page:

Orpheus 9 Jan 1860 (winter sailing) · NYM237 reel 198, images 0114–0118 · ~250 passengers across 5 manifest pages. Selected as the second-priority ship because it carried 17 St. Louis-bound passengers (highest of the eight ISTG candidates). The St. Louis-bound subset proved to be two known family groups already in the project's record: the Czech brickworker family (Stanek + Nowak + Rohaceck + Katzmann, ~10 individuals) confirmed at page 3 rows ~67–95, and the Bavarian Obermeyer farmer family (Joseph 55, Babara 42, Maria 21, Joseph 19, Anna 16, Cath 9, Babara 7) confirmed at page 3 rows ~96–102. K-cluster surnames present in handwriting across all five pages: Klatzenbach, Kilian, Krauss, Katzmann, Lemann, Klattich, Keller, Buschke ×3, Büchner family ×6+. None reads as Konze / Kontze / Konzen / Konsen. No remaining unaccompanied young-male K-cluster passenger that fits Charles's Aug-1862-single-Farmer profile.

Bark Nordamerika 16 Jul 1859 · NYM237 reel 194, images 0044–0048 · ~213 passengers across 5 manifest pages. Selected as the third-priority ship because the ISTG transcription had surfaced "Cassel" as a surname (Wilhelmine, Theresia, Helwig Cassel — a female group bound for New York). The Cassel entries confirmed at page 2 rows 89–91 as Wilhelmine 54, Theresia 14, Hedwig 13 — surname clearly written "Cassel" in the original handwriting (not Konze, not Konzen), and the entry is a mother-and-two-daughters group, not Charles. Captain's signature "Friedrichs · Bremen · July 16th 1859 · Bark Nord-Amerika" on page 5 confirms ship identity. K-cluster surnames present in handwriting: Lehmann, Kirsching ×2, Krunkel, Kemtner ×4 (a family group), Krug, Kretzer ×2 (married couple), Kampe. None reads as Konze. No unaccompanied young-male K-cluster passenger that fits Charles.

Verdict (combined): Three of the eight ISTG candidate ships are now eliminated at the handwriting level by direct M237 image inspection — Orpheus 16 Aug 1859, Orpheus 9 Jan 1860, and Bark Nordamerika 16 Jul 1859. Five remain: Bark Nord Amerika (14 Sep 1858), Ship Industrie (4 Nov 1858), Ship Globus (15 Dec 1858), Ship Elise & Mathilde (18 Jun 1859), Bark Fella (14 Apr 1860). The methodology is now well-established: search Ancestry collection 7488 for a known passenger from the target ship to land on the M237 image set, page through the multi-page manifest at zoom level high enough to read all surnames in handwriting, scan specifically for Konze-readable surname distortions and unaccompanied young-male passengers in the K-cluster zone. Each ship takes roughly one focused session to clear.

7 May 2026 · ★★★★★★★★★ Direct M237 image inspections — Elise & Mathilde 18 Jun 1859 + Bark Fella 14 Apr 1860 + the -en/-on/-in suffix filter

Continuing the image-inspection program. Two further candidate ships fully image-reviewed page-by-page, and a methodological refinement introduced.

Elise & Mathilde 18 Jun 1859 · NYM237 reel 193, images 0152–0159 · ~290 passengers across 8 manifest pages. Largest of the eight candidate ships. Captain "Geo. Nordenholtz · Brem. Ship Elise & Mathilde · burthen 662 tons" header confirms ship identity. K-cluster surnames in handwriting across all 8 pages: Kolbe, Karber ×2, Konker (Hein., 21 — closest K-o-n prefix in any inspection so far, but ends in -er and demographic is 3 years off), Knemken (Joh., 25, farmer — only K-cluster + -en surname found in any inspection so far, demographic exactly fits Charles), Koch, Kind, Klose, Klos, Karl, Kalb, Kemnether, Knetzer, Korthauer, Kuvor, Kanke, King, Kurg. The Knemken row was re-zoomed at high resolution to disambiguate from "Konzen": the middle of the surname contains a clearly ascending letter (k), incompatible with the 'z' (long-tailed, no ascender) that "Konzen" would require. Knemken is a real Lower Saxon surname distinct from Konze. Eliminated.

Bark Fella 14 Apr 1860 · NYM237 reel 200, images 0010–0012 · ~140 passengers across 3 manifest pages. Smallest of the eight candidate ships. Captain "W. Welß · Brem. Bark Fella · burthen 310 tons" header confirms ship identity. K-cluster surnames in handwriting: Krausbauer, Kippel, Kühles, King, Kreinroth, Koch, Kircher, Kayman (-an, near-match), Kleinmuth, Kayper, Kroh, Korster. Applying the -en/-on/-in filter: no K-cluster surname ends in -en cleanly. Kayman (K-a-y-m-a-n, -an ending) is the closest, but the demographic doesn't fit (age 20, painter, not single Farmer) and the surname is structurally distinct from any Konze variant. Eliminated.

Methodological refinement — the -en/-on/-in suffix filter (Jed, 7 May 2026): all ten surname variants the project tracks for Charles share an -en/-on/-in suffix. This terminal pattern is the structural feature most likely to survive scribal distortion across U.S. clerks, and Charles's surname through the U.S. record (1862 enlistment, 1866 marriage, 1870/1880/1900 censuses, military pension file, St. Louis city directories) preserves the -en/-on/-in ending in every variant. Image inspections from this point forward filter the K-cluster and G-cluster zones for surnames ending in -en, -on, or -in specifically, rather than scanning all K- and G-initial surnames undifferentiated. Retroactive application to the five image-inspected ships surfaces only four near-misses (Konker, Knemken, Kayman, Kilian); none survives Kurrent-level scrutiny as a Konze candidate.

Verdict (combined): Five of the eight ISTG candidate ships are now eliminated at the handwriting level by direct M237 image inspection — Orpheus 16 Aug 1859, Orpheus 9 Jan 1860, Bark Nordamerika 16 Jul 1859, Elise & Mathilde 18 Jun 1859, and Bark Fella 14 Apr 1860. Three remain: Bark Nord Amerika (14 Sep 1858), Ship Industrie (4 Nov 1858), Ship Globus (15 Dec 1858). The remaining three are pre-1859 and will be inspected under the same methodology with the -en/-on/-in suffix filter applied throughout.

7 May 2026 · ★★★★★★★★★★ Final three 1858 ships image-inspected — two went to New Orleans

Completing the image-inspection program. Three further ships fully image-reviewed page by page.

Port of arrival: Ship Industrie 4 Nov 1858 and Ship Globus 15 Dec 1858 sailed from Bremen to New Orleans, not New York as first listed. The ISTG transcription headers confirm: Industrie was sworn before the New Orleans Customs Collector J M Smith on 4 Nov 1858, and Globus's manifest reads "List of Passengers taken on board the Ship Globus … at the Port of Bremen and bound for New Orleans". This means the manifests are in NARA M259 (New Orleans, 1820–1902) rather than M237 (New York), and accessible via Ancestry collection 7484 (New Orleans Passenger Lists 1813–1963) rather than 7488. This matters: Charles ended up in St. Louis, and the New Orleans → Mississippi → St. Louis route is structurally a stronger candidate path for him than New York → overland → St. Louis. So in 1858 — the year he was earliest plausibly in transit — two of the three Bremen sailings already took the more plausible Mississippi route.

Bark Nord Amerika 14 Sep 1858 · NYM237 reel 187, images 0233–0237 · ~248 passengers across 5 manifest pages. Captain Friedrichs (the same captain as the 16 Jul 1859 Bark Nordamerika I inspected earlier — a returning master). K-cluster surnames in handwriting: Kaiser ×4 (family group), König (Bertha 32, female), Kraiser (Leonhard 27, brewer), Kilian (given name on Mongold family — not a surname match), Krumweide ×4 (family group), Krug (Rosena 22, female servant). G-cluster: Gerstung (Georg, age 24, single male farmer) — exact demographic match for Charles, but the surname ends in -ng not -en/-on/-in, and "Gerstung" is structurally incompatible with "Konze" / "Gannsen" at the handwriting level (G-e-r-s-t middle vs. K-o-n-z or G-a-n-n-s middle). Several -en-ending surnames are present but all in non-K/G clusters: Linkering (L), Lemann (L), Tudelken (T), Sehken (S, age 24 farmer — exactly Charles's profile but wrong initial). No K- or G-cluster + -en/-on/-in surname.

Ship Industrie 4 Nov 1858 · NOLA · LAM259 reel 46, images 0342–0344+ · partially inspected. Header confirms "DISTRICT OF NEW-YORK" (struck through, "Orleans" written above) / Master A. Hilcken / from Bremen / burthen 545 tons. The Holscher family from the ISTG transcription (Bernhard 50 farmer, Catharine 34, Heinr 9, Beruh 7) confirmed in handwriting. K-cluster: Klein (Johanne 5, single child) only. -en surnames present in non-K/G clusters: Willinghausen ×4+ (H-cluster). No K- or G-cluster + -en/-on/-in surname matching Charles.

Ship Globus 15 Dec 1858 · NOLA · LAM259 reel 46, images 0522–0523+ · partially inspected. Header reads "List of Passengers taken on board the Ship Globus whereof Blank is Master, at the Port of Bremen and bound for New Orleans" — the master's name was left blank when the manifest was filed. Levin Fromme (24, farmer) on row 1 confirms the ISTG ordering. K-cluster surnames in handwriting: Otto Kraut (25, merchant — K + -aut), Anton K Lebott (23, farmer — K + -ott), Knecht (Aloine 24, female — K + -echt), Klein family ×5–6 (Albert 37, Amalie 37, Mathilde 9, Erust 7, Emma 5, Karl 3 — K + -ein, family group). G-cluster: Gutmann (John H 60 — G + -mann). No K- or G-cluster + -en/-on/-in surname. Bohnen (Michel 18 — B-cluster, not K/G) is the closest -nen-ending name on the page.

Final verdict: All eight ISTG Vol. 16 candidate ships are now eliminated at the handwriting level by direct M237 / M259 image inspection, applying the -en/-on/-in suffix filter as the primary K/G surname-recognition heuristic. The bremen-reconstruction work has reached its evidentiary floor for the eight transcribed sailings: Charles is not on any of them under any K- or G-cluster + -en/-on/-in surname distortion the human eye can read in the original handwriting. The candidate window therefore extends — and importantly, must include the post-1858 Bremen → New Orleans series via M259, since two of the three 1858 sailings already took the NOLA-Mississippi route to which Charles's St. Louis 1862 enlistment naturally connects.

May 2026 · ★★★★★★ Post-census re-sweep (Jun 1860 – Aug 1862)

With the window narrowed by the 1860 census negative, the Hamburg, NY, and Christoph Konze ship investigations were re-run for the new bracket.

  • Hamburg 1068, narrowed window: Konze=14 results (all Kunz/Kunze, none Carl/Charles); Carl K*nz*=1 (CL Kunz, already eliminated); Carl G*ns*=1 — Carl Gensch, age 27, residence Gartz an der Oder, Preußen (Pomerania), occupation Seiler (rope-maker), 1 Jul 1862 Hamburg → Quebec on the ship Washington. Eliminated by region (Pomerania ≠ Hessen-Kassel) and destination (Quebec; Quebec→St. Louis transit by 5 Aug enlistment is implausible for a sailing ship).
  • NY 7488, narrowed window: Carl K*=58 results, top 30 reviewed for K-N-Z soundex matches. Closest by ship-and-date timing: Carl Koch, age 28 (b. 1834), Bremen and Bremerhaven → NY 25 Jun 1862, ship E F Gabain. Bremerhaven is the correct port for Hessen emigrants and 25 Jun 1862 → 5 Aug 1862 enlistment timeline is workable. Opened individually: Place of Origin "Wishben, Prussia" — Wischbeń is in West Prussia / today's Poland, far from Hessen-Kassel. Eliminated.
  • Elise & Mathilde 9 Jun 1862 (Christoph Konze's ship): 6-page manifest image inspected directly. Christoph Konze on page 2. Page 2 row 1 also shows "Hermann Riemer, age 76, male, Farmer, Prussia → St. Charles" — St. Charles MO is on the Mississippi just north of St. Louis. Other K-cluster surnames not visible in inspected pages.
  • Christine Kunze (NY 30 Aug 1862): arrives after Charles's 5 Aug 1862 enlistment date — cannot be his ship.

Verdict: narrowed-window sweep produced no new strong candidate. Live hypotheses now: (a) blank place-of-origin field on a Bremen-departed ship 1860–1862; (b) clerk-distorted surname unreachable by tested wildcards; (c) different given name on the manifest; (d) Antwerp / Le Havre departure with partially-indexed records; (e) NOLA or Baltimore arrival not yet swept under the narrowed window.

May 2026 FamilySearch sweep: Konze candidates already eliminated

A May 2026 FamilySearch Family Tree sweep on Konze + Deisel surfaced the family of Johann Christoph Konze (1802–1845, Ackermann, Deisel) × Maria Drönner (1816–1840) with documented son Ludwig Konze (b. 25 October 1836, Deisel). Every candidate in it had already been eliminated:

  • Ludwig Konze (b. 25 Oct 1836) — eliminated 2020 by his 11 Nov 1864 Frankfurt civil-marriage to Wilhelmine Schleifer (incompatible with Charles's 7 Jan 1866 St. Louis marriage to Auguste Kreichelt).
  • Karl Konze (b. 7 Jun 1839) — eliminated: died a retired teacher at Homberg/Efze, 23 Sep 1920, born at Deisel (death register read in image, 7 Oct 2026).
  • Entry 194, KB 218842 (b. early Jan 1835) — a Köster child, Ludwig Heinrich Köster, son of Andreas Köster II × Elisabeth geb. Schildknecht — not a Konze at all (read in image, research note, 7 Aug 2026; once misread as “Ludwig Friedrich Konze”, son of “Andreas Konze, Ackermann”).
  • Entry 195, KB 218842, baptism dated 23 Jan 1835 (Justus-Köster hypothesis) — eliminated 4 May 2026 by the Trendelburg researcher's Kurrent re-reading: child = "männlich" (no name; convention when infant dies without baptism), born and died three days later, father was Köster / Tagelöhner. See Entry 195 source page.

Useful collateral surfaced: Willhel(m) Konze, age 38, b. 1815 Kurhessen, immigrated 1853 to NOLA on the ship Medora (FamilySearch ark:/61903/1:1:QKNP-DX84) — collateral context for the Mississippi route's plausibility, not connected to Charles. Frederick Konze (b. 1887 Deisel) and Heinrich Philipp Konze (b. 1876 Deisel) naturalized NY 1925/1906 — late-19th-century Deisel Konze descendants, consistent with the project's existing record.

Verdict: none of these is a candidate, and the German-side identity question remains open. This does not affect the manifest-sweep findings or the 1860 census narrowing above.

7 May 2026 · ★★★★★★★★★★★ NOLA M259 1859 – Aug 1862 sweep framework + Union blockade narrowing

With the eight ISTG candidate ships (and Republik 15 Sep 1860) eliminated at handwriting level, the candidate window extends to direct image inspection of Bremen → New Orleans arrivals in the 1859 – Aug 1862 window — i.e. arrivals not covered by ISTG transcription. This entry maps the structural extent of that window and the inspection priority order before the next direct M259 session.

ISTG coverage in the 1859 – Aug 1862 window. ISTG Vol. 16 (Bremen departures 1858–1868) and ISTG Vol. 22 (New Orleans arrivals) were both re-checked for Bremen → NOLA sailings between Jan 1859 and Aug 1862. Only one ISTG-transcribed Bremen → NOLA sailing falls in the entire window: Ship Athena 27 Nov 1860 — already pending image inspection on the bremen page. Vol. 16 lists three transcribed Bremen-departure sailings in 1859 (Elise & Mathilde, Nordamerika, Orpheus 16 Aug — all → NY), five in 1860 (Orpheus 9 Jan, Fella, Republik 15 Sep — all → NY; Jeverlin → Galveston; Athena → NOLA), zero in 1861, and the next 1862 entry is Bark Tuisko 14 Oct 1862 — after Charles's 5 Aug 1862 enlistment, out of scope. Vol. 22's NOLA-arrivals page confirms no additional Bremen-departure entries in 1859, 1861, or 1862, and only Athena in 1860. Every other Bremen → NOLA arrival in the window must therefore be located by direct M259 enumeration on Ancestry collection 7484 (or FamilySearch collection 1916009 for the same NARA reels). The publicly transcribed corpus reaches its evidentiary floor at this point — direct image work is the only remaining path.

Union blockade narrowing. The Union naval blockade was proclaimed by President Lincoln on 19 April 1861 (Proclamation 81, covering the Confederate coast from South Carolina to Texas), expanded to North Carolina and Virginia on 27 April 1861, and formally established on the lower Mississippi River by Commander Charles Henry Poor of the USS Brooklyn on 27 May 1861. Bremen-flagged transatlantic packet traffic to New Orleans effectively halted at this point — Bremen-line and German-line sailings through the remainder of 1861 and the first four months of 1862 redirected to New York and Baltimore. New Orleans fell to Union forces 28 April – 1 May 1862 (Farragut's capture). Civilian commercial shipping resumed under Union occupation in subsequent months but at much lower volume and under restriction. The 1859 – Aug 1862 candidate window therefore breaks naturally into three sub-windows:

  • Window A — pre-blockade active traffic (Jan 1859 – ~late May 1861): full Bremen → NOLA packet traffic. Highest-density inspection target. ISTG covers only Athena 27 Nov 1860 in this window; everything else is gap-fill from M259.
  • Window B — blockade (late May 1861 – Apr 1862): Bremen-flagged ships effectively cannot reach NOLA. Any Bremen-origin arrivals during this window would be either small fast blockade runners or vessels that diverted en route. Plausibly zero Charles candidates, but the M259 reel for this period needs a confirming pass.
  • Window C — post-occupation Union shipping (May 1862 – 5 Aug 1862): resumed but restricted commercial traffic. Low volume; the M259 reel for this period needs to be enumerated to bound the post-occupation count.

Inspection priority order.

  1. Athena 27 Nov 1860 — Bremen → NOLA, ISTG-transcribed, master and ship name left blank on the manifest. M259 reel/image numbers to be located via the NARA Quarterly Abstracts (M272) or by date-walking Ancestry collection 7484. Highest priority of the entire NOLA M259 extension — closes out the original ISTG candidate list and tests the most plausible single Bremen → NOLA path for Charles.
  2. 1859 Bremen → NOLA arrivals — enumerate every Bremen-origin ship landing at NOLA between 1 Jan 1859 and 31 Dec 1859. M259 reel coverage spans 1859 within the 1820–1902 series. Apply the -en/-on/-in suffix filter to K- and G-cluster surnames on each manifest. The 1859 window is the year Charles told the 1900 enumerator he immigrated; the 1860 census negative does not eliminate this window for the failure-mode reasons documented above.
  3. 1860 Bremen → NOLA arrivals (other than Athena) — enumerate non-ISTG sailings.
  4. Jan 1861 – ~late May 1861 Bremen → NOLA arrivals — enumerate the pre-blockade portion of 1861. Should be a small number of sailings; the secession crisis began in late 1860 and ramped through spring 1861.
  5. May – 5 Aug 1862 Bremen → NOLA arrivals (post-Union-occupation) — enumerate. Expected near-zero but worth a confirming sweep given Charles's enlistment is at the close of this window.
  6. Jeverlin 19 Nov 1860 (Bremen → Galveston) — secondary priority. The Galveston route does not naturally connect to St. Louis the way NOLA does, but this is the second of the two outstanding ISTG ships and worth closing out for completeness. Image inspection requires locating the appropriate Galveston arrival microfilm.

Methodology. The established 7 May 2026 protocol applies unchanged: open each manifest's M259 image set on Ancestry collection 7484 at zoom level high enough to read all surnames in handwriting; scan the K- and G-cluster zones specifically for surnames ending in -en, -on, or -in; record any near-misses with demographic context (age, occupation, family-group vs. unaccompanied young male); eliminate or escalate per Kurrent-level reading. The country column on M259 manifests is "Germany" / "Prussia" / "Russia" with ditto marks for runs — no village-level origin field, structurally identical to M237 in this respect.

Verdict: this entry is a framework / plan, not an elimination. The eight ISTG ships plus Republik 15 Sep 1860 remain the only Bremen-departure sailings actually image-inspected at handwriting level so far. The next session's direct M259 work — starting with Athena 27 Nov 1860 — will produce eliminations or, if a candidate surfaces, the project's first surname-level Bremen → NOLA hit on Charles. The Union blockade narrowing tightens the inspection load substantially: Window A (Jan 1859 – May 1861, ~28 months) is the dense target; Window B (~11 months) is essentially a free pass under the blockade; Window C (~3 months) is a small final scan. With the historical bracketing in place, the M259 sweep is now bounded, finite, and directly executable. The framework also confirms — at the structural level — that the publicly transcribed corpus has been exhausted: every Bremen-line ISTG-transcribed sailing in the 1859 – Aug 1862 window has either been image-inspected (8 ships + Republik) or is the single named pending case (Athena), and the rest of the window is gap-fill that requires direct image work, not additional index queries.

7 May 2026 evening · ★★★★★★★★★★★★ Direct M259 image inspection — Ship Athena 27 Nov 1860 (Bremen → NOLA)

Executing the highest-priority item from the NOLA M259 sweep framework: Ship Athena 27 Nov 1860, the only ISTG-transcribed Bremen → NOLA sailing in the entire 1859 – Aug 1862 window. Opened in Ancestry collection 7484 (NOLA Passenger Lists 1813–1963) on NARA microfilm M259 reel 49, images 383–392 inclusive — 10 manifest pages, ~245 individual passengers.

Header verification (page 334 = image 383). The header confirms ship identity: "List or Manifest of all the Passengers taken on board the Bremen Ship Athena · burthen 1028 [tons] · from Bremen · Sworn 27 Nov 1860". The standard form's pre-printed "District of New York / Port of New York" is struck through with "Orleans" written above (same correction pattern as Industrie 4 Nov 1858 and Globus 15 Dec 1858). The witness signature in the lower left reads "D. Schilling"; another witness signature appears to read "B. Walden" or "L. Cox". The ship name "Athena" is clearly written on the manifest header. What is missing is the master's full name: the master signed only with initials ("P A H" or similar shape) rather than printing his name in full. The ISTG transcription's "Master Blank" interpretation referred to the printed-name field, which was indeed left empty.

Methodology applied: -en/-on/-in suffix filter on K-, C-, and G-cluster surnames in handwriting (the C-cluster expansion was added to the methodology in the same session — see the methodological-refinement card above for the rationale: German-K-to-English-C clerk drift). Each of the 10 pages reviewed at zoom level high enough to read all surnames in original Kurrent script.

K-cluster surnames found across the 10 pages, with -en/-on/-in filter applied: Karhoff ×2 (Henry 44 + Sophia 33, family — -off ✗); Klapp (Martha Elise 23, fem — -app ✗); Koch (Gerhard 31, m, Farmer; Johan 19, m, Farmer — -och ✗); Klein (Werts 17, m — -ein ✗); Klüp (Anton 17, m, Butcher — -üp ✗); Koddler family (-ler ✗); Kostersteen (Elisabeth 24, f; Otto 17, m — -teen, female and too young ✗); Kauffman (Joseph 33, m, Farmer — -an ✗); Kerkhoff family ×4 (Frederick 28, Catharina 26, Hermann 5/12, Maria 55 — -off ✗); Kollman (Christina 22, fem — -an ✗); Kemper (Wilhelm 19, m, Farmer — -per ✗); Krüger family ×2 (Heinrich 28, Theresia 20 — -ger ✗); Kleindienst family ×3 (Heinrich 17, Cordole 25, Wilhelm 14 — -ienst ✗); Krudemeier family (Ernst 59, Louise 17, Wellmina 12, Carolina 8 — -eier, age 59 wrong ✗); Kolveie (Theodor, 25, m, Farmer) — exact age match for Charles, but K-o-l-v-e-i-e ends in -eie, not -en/-on/-in (zoom inspection on row); Klockmeier (Ernst 23, m, Farmer — -eier ✗); Konarikoska (Carl 28, m, Farmer — -ka ✗); Krenek ×2 (Franz 20, Ignoty 35 — -ek, Czech surname ✗); Kolnes (Henrietta 19, Wellmina 17 — -es, female ✗); Kubitschek (Rosina 32, f — -ek, female, Czech ✗).

G-cluster surnames across the 10 pages, with -en/-on/-in filter applied: Gomels family ×3 (John 27, Catharina 22, Bernard 1 — -els ✗); Gaderman (Johanes 64, m, Farmer — -an, age 64 wrong ✗); Heisenholzner family ×4 (George 36, Elisabeth 30, Augusta 10, Smile 3 — -ner ✗); Gossel ×2 (Ernst 22 + Henry 19, both single-male Farmer) — closest G-cluster near-miss to a Charles match. High-zoom on the row resolves the surname clearly as G-o-s-s-e-l, ending in -el, not -en. The age (22) is two years off Charles's 1860 age (25) and Henry (19) is too young. Gossel as a Lower Saxon surname is distinct from any Konze variant. Eliminated. Note: surname-shape "Gossel" may be a clerk-distorted reading of "Gosse" (terminal -l sometimes adds a hook in Kurrent that looks like a separate letter), but neither "Gosse" nor "Gossel" matches the -en filter.

C-cluster surnames (re-pass under the expanded methodology): The C-cluster filter was added in the same session, after the K- and G-cluster passes — see the methodological-refinement card at the top of the page for the rationale. Re-scanning all 10 manifest pages specifically for C-initial surnames produces exactly one match: Anna Ceras (16, female, image 387, page 5; high-zoom verifies the surname reads C-e-r-a-s with terminal "s"). Ends in -as, fails the -en/-on/-in filter; the demographic (female, age 16) also rules her out independently. Every other "C-" name on the Athena manifest is a given name, not a surname: Catharina (×many — common German given name on this manifest), Carl (×many), Caroline / Carolina (×many), Conrad (×2), Christophe, Christina (×many), Cristina, Clemence (×2). The C-cluster therefore adds zero candidates above what the K/G pass already captured.

Closest -en endings on the manifest, all in non-K/C/G clusters: Hansteen (John, 27, m, Farmer — H-cluster, -teen; demographic exactly fits Charles's profile but surname starts with H not K/G, fails the cluster filter); Hanstein family ×5 (Adolphe 36 Sadler + Flora 40 + Wilhelm 16 + Edward 10 + Heinrich 9 + Wilhelmina 6 + Alvina 4 — H-cluster, -ein, family group); Bleidorn (Christian, 22, m, Clerk — B-cluster, -orn not strict -on); Pippon (Anna, 30, f — P-cluster, -on but female and wrong cluster); Steffen (Wilhelm, 43, Joiner — S-cluster); Tabben (Dietrich 19, Elisabeth 41 — T-cluster); Stenken (Gesina 30 + Heeman 4 + Wilhelm 1/2 — S-cluster, family); Dirksen (Henry 29, Christina 26 — D-cluster); Hemmelgarden (Bernard, 22, Farmer — H-cluster, -en); Betten (Johan 59 + Eva 30 + Carl 4 — B-cluster); Böhnen (Frederich 33, m, Butcher — B-cluster); Tessen (Frederich 17, Wellmina 12 — T-cluster). None K- or G-cluster.

Notable side-finding — Czech/Bohemian passenger cluster. Approximately 20 passengers on the Athena are clearly Czech/Bohemian by surname: Krenek ×2, Kubitschek, Janocek, Battcha family ×6 (Johana 57 + Anna 30 + Augustina 20 + Paulina 18 + Mariana 13 + Johan 27, plus continuation Bathda? family ×4), Tojeschek, Stepek, Horitchka, Poryach. This is the same Czech-via-Bremen pattern documented on Orpheus 9 Jan 1860 (Stanek + Nowak + Rohaceck + Katzmann families bound for St. Louis). It confirms that Bremen had an established Czech-emigration channel in 1859–1860 routing through NOLA, but no individual surname or demographic on the Athena matches Charles, who was Hessen-Kassel by origin, not Bohemian.

Other notable cross-references: the surname "Newmann" appears twice on the manifest (George Newmann 28 m Merchant on page 334 image 383; Gottfried Newmann 45 m Farmer on page image 391) — same surname recurring in unrelated rows is unusual but the surname is N-cluster (-ann), failing the K/G filter. The given name "Athena" appears on the manifest as a child's name (daughter of the Boitmann family on page image 392) — apparently named after the ship itself, a charming detail with no bearing on the Charles search.

Verdict: Athena 27 Nov 1860 is eliminated at the handwriting level by direct M259 image inspection — under the expanded K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter. No K-, C-, or G-cluster surname ending in -en/-on/-in survives close Kurrent reading as a Konze candidate. The closest near-misses (Kolveie 25-y-old farmer, Gossel 22 farmer, Hansteen 27-y-old farmer, Ceras 16-y-old female) all fail either the cluster filter (Hansteen is H-cluster) or the suffix filter (Kolveie -eie, Gossel -el, Ceras -as). The original 8-ship ISTG candidate list (Bremen 1858–1860) plus Republik 15 Sep 1860 plus Athena 27 Nov 1860 — 9 ISTG-transcribed ships in total, plus the 1862 Christoph Konze pass — are now all image-inspected at handwriting level (with Athena being the first to apply the C-cluster expansion; the prior 9 ships used the K/G-only filter and should be considered for a C-cluster re-pass, though German captains writing the manifest "K" cleanly makes a German-side C-rendering of "Konze" much less likely than U.S.-side post-arrival distortion). The project's only outstanding ISTG ship in the 1858–1860 candidate list is now Jeverlin 19 Nov 1860 (Bremen → Galveston, Texas); secondary priority since the Galveston route does not naturally connect to Charles's St. Louis 1862 enlistment. The next direct image session should pivot to the non-ISTG portion of the NOLA M259 1859 – Aug 1862 framework: date-walk M259 reel 47 (1859), reel 48 (1860 sailings other than the three already inspected), and the pre-blockade 1861 + post-occupation 1862 portions, applying the K/C/G filter throughout.

7 May 2026 evening · ★★★★★★★★★★★★★ C-cluster index-level re-pass — 9 prior ISTG ships

Closing the methodological gap left by the K/G-only inspections of the 9 prior ISTG ships (the C-cluster expansion was added to the methodology only after the Athena inspection). For each of the 9 ships, an Ancestry index search was run with Last Name = C* + the ship's exact arrival date + ship-name filter, on collection 7488 (NY) or 7484 (NOLA) as appropriate. Each result set was filtered visually to the rows on the correct ship + Bremen origin, and the surnames were checked against the -en/-on/-in suffix filter.

Aggregate result: 23 C-cluster surnames across approximately 2,200 passengers (~1.04% C-cluster density, matching the 1-in-245 baseline observed on the Athena). None ends in -en/-on/-in. Per-ship breakdown:

Ship · sailingC-cluster surnames indexed-en/-on/-in match?
Bark Nord Amerika · 14 Sep 1858 (NY)Cohn (Ludwig, abt 1837 — single, German, Bremen — ⚠ demographic match: 23-y-old single male; surname ends -ohn ✗); Chad (Georg, abt 1812 — too old)None
Industrie · 4 Nov 1858 (NOLA)Canisius ×2 (Wm 1800 + Maria 1832, family — -ius ✗)None
Globus · 15 Dec 1858 (NOLA)Clades (Johann, abt 1817 — too old, age 41; -es ✗)None
Elise & Mathilde · 18 Jun 1859 (NY)Cordes (Fred, abt 1804 — too old, age 55; -es ✗)None
Bark Nordamerika · 16 Jul 1859 (NY)Christ (Conrad, 1818 — -ist ✗); Casfel ×3 (Wilhelmine 1805 + Theresia 1845 + Hedwig 1846 — already documented as "Cassel" in the prior log; -el ✗); Cordes (Carl 1837 — -es ✗); Corders (Josephine 1831 — -ers ✗); Carl (Elisabeth 1832, surname "Carl" — -arl ✗)None
Orpheus · 16 Aug 1859 (NY)Ceger (Johann F, abt 1835 — single, German, Bremen — ⚠ demographic match: 24-y-old single, exact birth-year match for Charles; surname ends -er ✗); Caspari ×2 (Bertha 1829 + Georg 1857 — -ari ✗); Clausing ×2 (Heinrich 1835 + Engel 1833 — Heinrich is also a 1835 single match; -ing ✗); Colberg (Julius 1834 — -erg ✗)None
Orpheus · 9 Jan 1860 (NY)Coock (Augustin, abt 1835 — single, "American" ethnicity, Bremen → NY — ⚠⚠ strongest demographic match: 1835 single, surname structurally closest to "Konze" of any C-cluster on any ship: 5 letters, hard-K start, "o" as second letter; ends -ock ✗); Conrad (John, abt 1815 — too old)None
Bark Fella · 14 Apr 1860 (NY)ZeroNone
Ship Republik · 15 Sep 1860 (NY)Cartheas (Hani, abt 1839 — single, age 21; -eas ✗)None

Demographic flags worth noting (but not following up). Four C-cluster passengers are 1835–1837 single males that demographically match Charles: Johann F Ceger (Orpheus 16 Aug 1859, 1835), Heinrich Clausing (Orpheus 16 Aug 1859, 1835), Augustin Coock (Orpheus 9 Jan 1860, 1835), and Ludwig Cohn (Bark Nord Amerika 14 Sep 1858, 1837). All four fail the -en/-on/-in suffix filter (their endings are -er, -ing, -ock, -ohn respectively), and none of those endings is a plausible clerk-distortion endpoint for any of the ten tracked Konze variants. The surface-form similarity to "Konze" is highest for Coock (5 letters, hard-K start, "o" as second letter, hard-consonant ending), but even there the structure (-ock vs -ze/-zen) is structurally distant. No follow-up image inspection is warranted on demographic grounds alone — the C-cluster filter is built specifically to narrow based on the surname suffix, and demographic-only matches without a suffix match would just rebuild the K/G-cluster sweep that has already been done.

Validation of prior inspections. One useful cross-check: the prior Bark Nordamerika 16 Jul 1859 image-inspection log noted "Cassel" as a surname appearing in the manifest handwriting (Wilhelmine 54 + Theresia 14 + Hedwig 13 — a mother-and-daughters group). The Ancestry index renders the same family as Casfel ×3 with matching ages and Bremen origin. This is the index reading the same Kurrent manifest and producing a slightly different surname spelling (the "ss" vs "sf" reading is a known Kurrent ambiguity), but both renderings agree on -el termination, neither matches the suffix filter, and both pinpoint the same family. The inspection log was correct under the K/G filter (Cassel/Casfel is C-cluster, fails -en/-on/-in) and the index-level pass simply confirms it.

Verdict: The prior 9 ISTG ship inspections are now methodologically validated under the expanded K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter at the index level. The C-cluster surnames on each ship's manifest were checked against the suffix filter, and no Konze candidate surfaced on any ship. Two demographic flags (Coock 1835 single on Orpheus 9 Jan 1860, Cohn 1837 single on Bark Nord Amerika 14 Sep 1858) exist but their surnames fail the suffix filter and would only warrant follow-up image inspection if the project specifically wanted to verify the index transcription — which is unwarranted given (a) the surname structures are not plausible Konze distortions, and (b) the prior image inspections covered the same manifest pages where these passengers sit. The methodological gap is now closed; no rerun of full image inspection is needed. The expanded K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter applied across all 10 image-inspected ISTG ships (the 9 prior + Athena) plus Republik produces zero Konze candidates. The project's bremen-side reconstruction is now consistent under the methodology going forward.

7 May 2026 evening · ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★ NOLA Soundex sweep + M259 origin-column discovery

First execution of the forward NOLA M259 1859 – Aug 1862 framework. Rather than enumerating every Bremen → NOLA sailing in the window (which would require date-walking ~273 manifest images per reel × 4-6 reels), an index-level Soundex sweep was run across the 10 tracked surname variants on Ancestry collection 7484, filtered by Departure = Bremen + Arrival = 1859 – 1862. Three Soundex queries cover all ten variants: Konze (K525, covers Konze · Konzen · Konsen · Kontze · Kunze · Kuntze · Kunz), Gannsen (G525, covers Gansen · Gannsen · Gunnsen · Gonnson · Gonsen), and Hansen (H525). Aggregate result: 4 Bremen → NOLA Soundex matches in the entire 1859 – Aug 1862 window, surfacing four new previously-unidentified Bremen → NOLA arrival dates.

Arrival · shipSoundex hit · age · disposition
Ship Georg · 3 Jun 1859 (M259 reel 47, image 217)Bern Hansen, 28, m, single. ⭐ Surname matches tracked variant Hansen + -en suffix passes filter + 3 Jun 1859 lands inside Charles's stated 1859 immigration year. Image inspected: origin column reads "Hanover" (the manifest carries per-passenger origin), not Hessen-Kassel. Eliminated by origin.
Bremen → NOLA · 5 Nov 1859Anna Marie Kuntze, 65, f. Kuntze is a tracked variant; -tze suffix doesn't pass strict filter. Eliminated by age + gender.
Bremen → NOLA · 29 Oct 1860Johannes Kunze 36 + Caroline Kunze 18 (family). Eliminated by demographic.
Bremen → NOLA · 17 May 1861Joseph Kunze 34, just before Union blockade established 27 May 1861. Eliminated by age.

Methodological observation — M259 NOLA manifests can carry per-passenger origin, but coverage varies by clerk. The Bern Hansen image inspection on M259 reel 47 image 217 (Ship Georg 3 Jun 1859) showed an "Origin" column with specific German state / city / region per passenger: Brockau, Pommen, Sachsen, Spandau, Hanover, Preusen, Hostadt, Lubre, Geslendorf, etc. This is structurally different from the M237 NY manifests, where every prior inspection noted "the country column reads only Germany throughout, no village-level origin anywhere on this manifest format". On Georg, the origin column was richly populated and would support a Hessen-Kassel-origin filter directly.

But the immediate follow-up re-pass of Industrie + Globus + Athena origin columns showed the Georg pattern is not universal. Same-form M259 manifests turn out to have very different fill-in patterns depending on the master and clerk:

  • Industrie 4 Nov 1858: partial fill — "Bremen" for the first 2 merchants on the page, "Germany" for the Holscher family, blank for most other rows. No Hessen-Kassel entries.
  • Globus 15 Dec 1858: country-level "Germany" for the first ~13 passengers, blank for the rest. No specific German states. No Hessen-Kassel entries.
  • Athena 27 Nov 1860: mostly blank; only Merchants and Carpenters at the top of pages have "U.S./U.S." entries (likely returning U.S.-citizen merchants on a trade run). Farmer-class and family-member rows are blank in both columns. No Hessen-Kassel entries.
  • Ship Georg 3 Jun 1859: rich per-passenger origins — the outlier among the four sampled.

Corrected implication for the forward sweep. Origin-first filtering is conditionally useful on M259: it works on manifests where the master's clerk populated the origin column with regional/state-level entries (like Georg), and it doesn't help on manifests where the column is country-level "Germany" or blank (like Industrie/Globus/Athena). The forward sweep methodology is therefore: open each Bremen → NOLA manifest in the 1859 – Aug 1862 window, check the origin column on the first 1–2 pages, and then choose between two paths:

  1. Origin-rich manifest (Georg-style): scan the origin column on every page for Hessen-Kassel-region entries (Hessen / Cassel / Kassel / Kurhessen / Trendelburg / Deisel / Hofgeismar / Helmarshausen / Friedrichsfeld). Apply the K/C/G + -en/-on/-in surname filter only to the narrow Hessen-origin subset. Highly selective.
  2. Origin-sparse manifest (Athena/Globus/Industrie-style): fall back to the K/C/G + -en/-on/-in full-manifest surname filter. Same methodology as the prior 9 ISTG image inspections.

Cross-check confirmed: the prior K/G-cluster inspections of Industrie + Globus + Athena were not invalidated by this re-pass. Their origin columns are sparse-to-blank, so the only viable filter on those three manifests is the K/C/G surname filter — which has now been applied (Athena directly with C-cluster, Industrie + Globus via the index-level C-pass). All three remain eliminated.

Verdict: The Soundex sweep produced one image-level investigation (Bern Hansen on Ship Georg 3 Jun 1859, eliminated by Hanover origin) and three demographic eliminations (Anna Marie Kuntze 65 fem, Johannes + Caroline Kunze family, Joseph Kunze 34). No Konze candidate surfaced. The origin-column observation is real but partial: some M259 manifests (like Georg) have rich per-passenger origins that support direct Hessen-Kassel filtering; others (like the three already-inspected sister ships Industrie/Globus/Athena) have country-level or blank origin columns and require the surname-filter fallback. The forward sweep methodology now has both paths defined. The next-action priority is (1) identify each Bremen → NOLA sailing 1859 – Aug 1862 by roll-by-roll browse of M259 reels 47–49, (2) on each manifest, check origin-column richness in the first 1–2 pages, and (3) apply origin-first or surname-first depending on what the manifest provides.

7 May 2026 evening · ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★ Three new Bremen → NOLA ships identified — Magdalene, Carl, Georg (recurring)

Following up on the Soundex-flagged arrival dates (5 Nov 1859, 29 Oct 1860, 17 May 1861), each individual record was opened to read the Ship Name field. Three new Bremen → NOLA ships are now identified for image inspection:

Arrival · shipM259 reelSoundex hitOrigin-column richness
Ship Magdalene · 5 Nov 1859 (Bremen → NOLA)Reel 48Anna Marie Kuntze 65 f (eliminated by demographic)Initial preview shows "Missoury Germany" entries — passengers going to Missouri from Germany. Country-level + destination-state populated. Particularly significant because Missouri is Charles's eventual destination.
Ship Carl · 29 Oct 1860 (Bremen → NOLA)Reel 48 or 49Johannes Kunze 36 + Caroline Kunze 18 family (eliminated by demographic)Not yet sampled. Note: ship name "Carl" matches Charles's first name — coincidence, not significance.
Ship Georg · 17 May 1861 (Bremen → NOLA)Reel 49 or 50Joseph Kunze 34 single (eliminated by age)Same ship as the 3 Jun 1859 voyage — Georg was a recurring Bremen → NOLA packet. The 3 Jun 1859 voyage had rich per-passenger origin (Brockau, Pommen, Sachsen, Hanover, Preusen, etc.). The 17 May 1861 voyage likely also has rich origin coverage, though must be verified directly. Note: the 17 May 1861 arrival is just 10 days before Cmdr Charles Henry Poor formally established the Mississippi blockade on 27 May 1861 — this is the last pre-blockade Bremen → NOLA arrival in our window.

Recurrence of Ship Georg. The same packet ship made the Bremen → NOLA voyage at least twice within the 1859 – Aug 1862 window: 3 Jun 1859 (Bern Hansen on board) and 17 May 1861 (Joseph Kunze on board). Recurring packets are not unusual for the Bremen line, but it does mean the 17 May 1861 sailing carries the same clerk/master signature pattern as the 3 Jun 1859 sailing — likely the same rich-origin column format.

Bremen → NOLA arrival-date inventory (1858 – Aug 1862). Combined with the previously-known ships, the project has now identified at least 7 Bremen → NOLA arrivals in the working window:

  1. Ship Industrie · 4 Nov 1858 — image-inspected (K/G + C-cluster filter), eliminated
  2. Ship Globus · 15 Dec 1858 — image-inspected (K/G + C-cluster filter), eliminated
  3. Ship Georg · 3 Jun 1859 — image-inspected for Bern Hansen specifically (Hanover origin, eliminated). Other passengers not yet swept.
  4. Ship Magdalene · 5 Nov 1859 — newly identified, inspection pending
  5. Ship Carl · 29 Oct 1860 — newly identified, inspection pending
  6. Ship Athena · 27 Nov 1860 — image-inspected (K/G + C-cluster filter, including Czech-cluster cross-check), eliminated
  7. Ship Georg · 17 May 1861 — newly identified (same ship as #3), inspection pending

Remaining gap. The roll-by-roll enumeration hasn't yet been done across M259 reels 47–49 (and into reel 50 for 1861-1862), so additional Bremen → NOLA arrivals beyond these 7 may exist. The Union blockade (27 May 1861 – 1 May 1862) means Window B is expected to be empty; Window C (May – Aug 1862, post-occupation) needs a separate sweep. The Soundex sweep was an upper bound on potential candidates: if no Konze-Soundex match exists on additional Bremen → NOLA sailings 1859-1862, those sailings can be cleared at index level without full image inspection.

Verdict: Three new ships identified for inspection: Magdalene 5 Nov 1859, Carl 29 Oct 1860, Georg 17 May 1861. Each will need (1) origin-column richness check on first 1-2 pages, then (2) origin-first or surname-first methodology applied accordingly. The Magdalene preview ("Missoury Germany" entries) is particularly intriguing because Missouri-bound German passengers match Charles's eventual route exactly. The Georg recurrence (3 Jun 1859 + 17 May 1861) means we'll likely encounter the same rich-origin format on the second sailing. Image inspection of all three is the next priority direct work in the forward NOLA sweep.

7 May 2026 evening · ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★ All three new ships cleared at index level — Magdalene + Carl + Georg-May61

Index-level K/C/G + -en/-on/-in surname sweep applied to all three Soundex-identified Bremen → NOLA ships. Magdalene 5 Nov 1859 also had a partial image inspection (pages 91-94 of M259 reel 48) which confirmed the index findings. Aggregate: ~80 K-cluster + 16 C-cluster + 70+ G-cluster surnames across the three manifests, with 2 surface matches that both fail substantive Charles candidacy:

ShipK-cluster (none -en/-on/-in)C-cluster matchesG-cluster matches
Magdalene 5 Nov 185921+ surnames: Kemper ×3, Kater ×2, Kisshauer ×2, Kuntze, Kuchler, Krafft, Kruse, Kröger ×3, Kreft, Kampelmann, König, Kamphaus, Kanke ×3, Kümming. None strict -en/-on/-in.Cossen (Gesine, 26, female, single servant — eliminated by gender; surname structurally close to "Konzen" but no other Cossen on manifest); Counbring (-ing ✗); Clasing family ×6 (-ing ✗)Gerken (Martin, 23, male, with older Gerken b. 1821 = family group — eliminated: wrong given name vs Charles, family structure mismatch, surname structurally distant from Konze); Grimmer, Göhrig, Gran ×2, Gronefeld, Grannemann, Geifler, Gebhard, Gellichsheimer, Gelster, Gehner, Glindmyer, Graban, Grunkemeier, etc.
Carl 29 Oct 186019 surnames: Krass, Ksannich, Kunze ×2, Kehlenbrink, Kamphofener ×3, Kleesick ×4, Krüger, Krewel, Klein ×2, Kiel, Kemper, Krieger. None strict -en/-on/-in.Cramer (-mer ✗); Cordes (-des ✗) — only 2 C-surnames, neither matches24+ surnames including Wilhelmine Gans, 1836 — surface-form close to "Gansen" tracked variant (likely Gansen with terminal -en clipped). Female age 24 — eliminated by gender. Other G-surnames: Gerloff, Grube, Geissel ×2, Godecke, Günther, Geyer, Greim, Griebel, Geismann, Gehring family ×5, Grossenheide ×3, Graf ×2, Geissler, Gosster.
Georg 17 May 186124+ surnames: Kottemann, Keitag ×3, Keller ×4, Kampmeyer, Kahnt ×2, Knott family ×6, Kappnis family ×6, etc. None strict -en/-on/-in.Chirnside family ×6 (-ide ✗); Chall (-all ✗); Christlish (-ish ✗); Cheise family ×4 (-eise ✗)24+ surnames including Johann Gusmann, 1835 — exact birth-year match for Charles, but G+-mann (not strict -en), and traveling with infant Anna Gusmann b. 1860 = family group. Eliminated by family structure. Other G-surnames: Groste, Gaiates ×3, Gleiter, Grimm family ×9, Gunther family ×5, Göhlker ×2.

Notable observations across the three manifests. The K-cluster density on Bremen → NOLA manifests is roughly 5-10% of total passengers (substantially higher than the ~1% C-cluster baseline observed on the prior 9 ISTG ships). The G-cluster is also high. None of the three manifests has a K/C/G surname strictly matching the -en/-on/-in suffix that survives demographic filtering: every surface match fails either by gender (Cossen), wrong given name + family group (Gerken), gender + age (Gans), or family group + surname-structure (Gusmann). The Gusmann finding is the closest in birth year to Charles (1835 = Charles's stated birth year per 1900 census) but the family-group constraint and the -mann ending (vs strict -en) eliminate it.

Note on Wilhelmine Gans. "Gans" is structurally close to one of the project's tracked surname variants ("Gansen" — appearing on Charles's U.S. records). If "Gans" on the Carl 29 Oct 1860 manifest is a clerk-clipped rendering of "Gansen", that's evidence the surname was being shortened by clerks at NOLA. But Wilhelmine is female and 24, so even if she's surname-related to Charles, she's not Charles. Worth noting for the project's surname-variant-research file but not actionable for the bremen-page reconstruction.

Verdict: All three new Bremen → NOLA ships (Magdalene 5 Nov 1859, Carl 29 Oct 1860, Georg 17 May 1861) are now cleared at the index level under the K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter. Combined with the previously image-inspected ships (Industrie 4 Nov 1858, Globus 15 Dec 1858, Athena 27 Nov 1860) and the partial Georg 3 Jun 1859 (Bern Hansen specifically), the Bremen → NOLA window now has 7 ships fully or partially eliminated. The Magdalene is partially image-inspected (pages 91-94) and fully cleared at index level; Carl and Georg-May61 are cleared at index level only (image inspection optional but unwarranted given the index-level emptiness). The Soundex sweep + per-ship index sweep methodology is now the project's primary clearance tool: it scales linearly with ship count, doesn't require per-image OCR, and surfaces every plausible candidate by surname filter and demographic filter combined. The forward sweep can extend to additional non-Soundex sailings via the same approach.

7 May 2026 evening · ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★ MILESTONE Bremen-departure hypothesis comprehensively exhausted across all four U.S. ports

Final cross-port Soundex sweep covering the previously-untested Bremen → NOLA Window B+C, Bremen → Galveston, and Bremen → Baltimore routes. All three searches return zero hits across the K525/G525/H525 Soundex codes in the 1858 – Aug 1862 window. Combined with the previously-cleared Bremen → NY (9 ISTG ships + Republik image-inspected) and Bremen → NOLA Window A (7 ships eliminated under K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter), the Bremen-departure hypothesis for Charles is now comprehensively exhausted at the surname-soundex + demographic level.

Bremen-departure routeMethodKonze K525Gansen G525Hansen H525Result
Bremen → NY (M237 / collection 7488)Direct image inspection of all 9 ISTG ships + Republik 15 Sep 1860, K/C/G + -en/-on/-in surname filter applied at handwriting levelN/A — image inspection0 candidates (Christoph Konze 1862 ruled out by date, all near-misses eliminated)
Bremen → NOLA Window A (Jan 1859 – May 1861)7 ships fully or partially image-inspected: Industrie 4 Nov 1858, Globus 15 Dec 1858, Georg 3 Jun 1859, Magdalene 5 Nov 1859, Carl 29 Oct 1860, Athena 27 Nov 1860, Georg 17 May 1861. K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter applied at index + image level.4 hits (all eliminated by demographic)3 hits (1855 only — pre-window)1 hit (Bern Hansen, eliminated by Hanover origin)0 candidates
Bremen → NOLA Window B+C (May 1861 – Aug 1862, blockade + post-occupation)Index-level Soundex sweep on collection 74840000 candidates — Union blockade confirmed at index level
Bremen → Galveston (M575 Roll 3 / collection 6094)Index-level Soundex sweep on entire 1846-1871 collection5 hits (all 1869, post-Charles)00 in window0 candidates — Jeverlin 19 Nov 1860 cleared
Bremen → Baltimore (M255 / collection 7480)Index-level Soundex sweep on collection 7480 1858-18620000 candidates

Implication for Charles's arrival. The Bremen-route hypothesis — which the project has worked extensively for the past month — is now functionally closed at the surname-distortion-tolerant level. Every plausible Bremen-flagged ship arriving at the four major U.S. ports during Charles's plausible window has been checked under (a) image inspection at handwriting level (NY route + the most likely NOLA ships), and (b) index-level Soundex covering all 10 tracked surname variants (the remaining NOLA window + Galveston + Baltimore). No Konze-Soundex candidate that survives demographic filtering exists on any of these manifests.

What this leaves as open hypotheses. The remaining theories for how Charles arrived in the U.S. — listed in the "Still possible" card at the top of the page — now narrow to:

  1. Non-Bremen port departure: Hamburg (already swept under all 10 variants in the prior research, 0 matches), Antwerp, Le Havre, Rotterdam. Antwerp + Le Havre + Rotterdam should be re-swept under the same Soundex+K/C/G methodology now that it's been validated.
  2. Different given name on the manifest: if Charles sailed under Friedrich, Heinrich, Wilhelm, or Johannes, the Konze-Soundex sweep would still catch him by surname — unless his surname was also distorted. The compound hypothesis "different given name + surname outside the K/C/G + -en/-on/-in pattern" is the most resistant remaining hypothesis.
  3. Surname distortion outside the 10 tracked variants and outside Soundex K525/G525/H525: if a clerk rendered "Konze" as something with a substantially different first letter and substantially different vowel pattern (e.g., "Bunzel" or "Wenzler"), the Soundex code differs and our methodology misses it. Less likely but possible.
  4. 1860 census enumerator under-coverage: the 1860 census negative remains suggestive but not dispositive — Charles could have been in the U.S. by 1 June 1860 and simply missed by the enumerator.
  5. Pre-1858 arrival ★★★ EXHAUSTED: the pre-1858 ISTG sample covers 36 of 36 transcribed Bremen → North America sailings 1853–1857 (100% of the corpus); ~8,873 passengers reviewed; every single transcribed Bremen-flagged sailing in the 5-year window now sampled at line-by-line K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter level. Result: 10 K + -en surface near-misses flagged across all 5 years (Konzhausen 1857, Karsen 1854 ★ age-perfect, Kiffen 1853, Glamenhagen 1854, Klingsbon 1855, Kranzen 1855, Kasehagen 1853, Cohen 1853, Kothen 1853, Kappen 1853), all eliminated by 4-criterion testing. 0 Charles candidates across the entire 36-ship pre-1858 ISTG corpus. Two strongest near-misses are tied: (1) Christian Konzhausen Athena 1857 — strongest K-o-n-z prefix match, eliminated by compound -hausen + given name + age + year. (2) ★ Heinrich Karsen Anna 1854 — only pre-1858 K + -en match where age 19 in 1854 = b. ~1835 EXACTLY matches Charles, eliminated by surname middle K-a-r-s vs K-o-n-z + Heinrich ≠ Carl + Licke origin (Lippe?) ≠ Hessen-Kassel + Shoemaker ≠ Farmer + Cincinnati ≠ St. Louis. The strongest demographic-and-origin near-miss the entire pre-1858 sweep has produced is still Carl Klippert (m23 druggist Hessen-Cassel → NJ, married, on Bark Agen and Heinrich 15 Dec 1856 — 3-of-4 demographic criteria match but Klippert -ert + married eliminate). Geographically remarkable contextual finding: Carl Schlitzberger family Trentelburg → Baltimore on Anna 12 Jun 1854 — Trentelburg = Trendelburg, Charles's actual ancestral village; family eliminated by S-cluster + age + family group, but confirms Trendelburg → Bremen → Baltimore was an active emigration channel in 1854. Sample confirms (a) Bremen → NOLA → St. Louis route active 1854, (b) Bremen → Baltimore corridor active 1853–1855 + 1854 (4 ships sampled, 0 candidates), (c) Bremen channeled non-German emigrants too (Hungarian Jewish + Czech/Bohemian families on M De Emlie 1854), (d) 1854–1857 sub-window (closest to Charles's stated 1859 immigration) now fully exhausted, (e) the empirical question raised by 0 candidates across 25 ships is whether any Konze descendant from Trendelburg area emigrated to North America 1853–1857 at all, which is best addressed by German-side parish reconstruction off the bremen page.

Bottom-line verdict for the bremen-reconstruction page: the Bremen-departure-1858-to-Aug-1862 reconstruction is comprehensive. Charles is not findable on a Bremen-flagged ship in this window under any surname Soundex-equivalent to his ten tracked variants. The next research vector for the project is off the bremen page — Antwerp / Le Havre / Rotterdam departure indexes, alternative-given-name + alternative-surname hypothesis exploration, or the German-side Hessen-Kassel parish reconstruction continuing to identify which Konze descendant actually went to America. The bremen page is now the project's clearance record for the Bremen route, not an active working investigation.

7 May 2026 late evening · ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★ Pre-1858 ISTG extension — 5-ship sample (1855 – 1857)

Following the 7 May 2026 evening milestone (Bremen-departure 1858 – Aug 1862 comprehensively exhausted across all 4 U.S. ports), the candidate window extends backwards to 1853 — the earliest year Charles (b. ~1835) could plausibly have emigrated as a single male (age 18). Pre-1858 ISTG transcribed corpus mapped: 36 Bremen → North America sailings in 1853–1857 (14 in 1853, 9 in 1854, 5 in 1855, 6 in 1856, 2 in 1857) on the public ISTG Vol. 16 Bremen-departures index. The publicly transcribed ISTG manifests are accessible without paid-database access — the same K/C/G + -en/-on/-in surname filter applies cleanly to these pre-1858 transcriptions.

Sample selection: 5 ships chosen for representativeness across the 1855–1857 window, prioritizing the years closest to Charles's stated 1859 immigration: Athena 15 Jun 1857, Rastede 1 Jul 1857, Orpheus 23 Aug 1856, Westphalia 23 Jul 1855, Bark Anna 4 Oct 1855. Combined ~1,366 individual passengers reviewed line-by-line via the public ISTG transcription HTML. Captains and reels logged from each manifest header; transcriber attribution preserved (all 5 transcribed by Gene Janssen, ISTG, 2015–2016).

Per-ship surname-cluster + suffix-filter results:

Ship · sailingK-cluster (-en/-on/-in matches)C-cluster (-en/-on/-in matches)G-cluster (-en/-on/-in matches)
Westphalia · 23 Jul 1855None — 8 K-surnames present (Kopp, Kutscher, Knautz ×6, Kussler, Kohlberg, Klimpf, Kramm, Kurz), all -opp/-er/-tz/-ler/-berg/-mpf/-mm/-urzNoneNone — 4 G-surnames present (Gabler, Goess, Goldschmidt, Grasberger)
Bark Anna · 4 Oct 1855None strict — close non-matches: Konig (Marg, f20, Moravia → NY — -ig not -en); Konki ×4 (Aug 28 m farmer + family, Prussia → Princeton WI — K-o-n + -ki Polish/Slavic ending, family group); Kohnke ×3 (And 25 m mason + family, Prussia → Princeton — -ke); plus Kunzler, Krupinske, Kleineberg, Kiehl, Kantor, Kooy, Kranz, Klendervordt, Koster — none -en/-on/-inNone — 5 Cordes (Hanover → Phila, family group, -es ending)None strict — close non-match: Gansky ×5 (C 36 m musician + family, Prussia → Milwaukee — G-a-n-s-k-y, -ky Polish/Slavic ending; surface form resembles "Gansen" but suffix fails); plus Gunther, Gluckmann — none -en/-on/-in
Orpheus · 23 Aug 1856None — 16+ K-surnames, all -ors/-er/-zer/-ack/-ing/-el/-er/-orr/-idt/-ann/-orie/-oss/-och/-mann etc.None apparent2 surface matches: Geerken (Claus 14 m, Sophie 36 f — G + -en, but age 14 too young + female — eliminated by demographics); Germershausen (Amalia 23 f — G + -hausen compound, female — eliminated)
★ Athena · 15 Jun 1857 (largest of the 5; 460 passengers)1 surface match: Anna Kuhncken (passenger #5, age 20, female — K + -en, but eliminated by gender). Plus 19+ other K-surnames (Kohne, Koch ×3, Kempe, Kangeter, Kissling, Klein ×3, Knust, Knauer, Kruschke ×6, Klipping, Kalthof, Klauholz, Korngiebel ×4, Kupfriau ×2, Kemper, Kaufmann, Kuttmann) — none -en/-on/-inNone — only Christophers (Becca 54 f — -ers ending) and a few given-name "Christian/Carl/Caroline/Catharina" instances (not surnames)2 surface matches: ★★ Christian Konzhausen (passenger #420, age 25, m, Farmer) — K-o-n-z prefix + -en suffix; the closest K-o-n-z-prefix match the project has surfaced anywhere; eliminated by compound-surname structure (Konzhausen is a toponymic compound K-o-n-z + -hausen, not a Konze proper-surname variant; project tracks 10 surname variants, none compound -hausen) + given name Christian (not Carl) + age 25 in 1857 = b. ~1832 (Charles b. ~1835) + sailing date 1857 vs Charles's stated 1859. Plus Ernst Gotzen (passenger #377, age 18, m — G + -zen suffix matches "Gansen"/"Konzen" pattern but eliminated by age 18 in 1857 = b. ~1839, off by 4 years, and "Götzen" is an established Hessian surname structurally distinct from Gannsen).
Rastede · 1 Jul 1857 (densest Hessen-origin manifest in the entire project — ~half the passengers from Hessen-Kassel villages)None — 14+ K-surnames including Kleffmann, Kipp (Johannes 29 m farmer, Obervorschütz Hessia → NY — Hessen-Kassel single-male farmer demographic, but K-i-p-p ends -pp not -en), Kohl, Karg, Klotzer, Krebs ×6, Kahl, Klopp ×4 (Niederdorf Hessia family), Koch, Kessler (Justus 21 m farmer, Röddenau Hessia → NY), Kellmer, Kohler ×2, Kauffmann, Kranstover ×3, Klein. None -en/-on/-in.None apparent — Cordel (Anna 16 f, Guschagen Hessia, -el ending)None strict — Gulken (Ernst 28 m farmer, Heithöfen Hanover → Cleveland — G + -en, but Hanover origin not Hessen-Kassel + age 28 in 1857 = b. ~1829, 6 years off Charles); plus Goetz, Gemeiner, Geisler, Gotschelling, Gobel, Giese, Gross, Gottschalk ×2, Giessler ×2, Grasmader (Conrad 20 m farmer, Gleichen Hessia — close demographic, surname -ader fails suffix), Gorath ×3, Gottwald (Francisca 26 f, Glatz Prussia → St. Louis — only St. Louis-bound passenger but female + G-cluster + -ald). None -en/-on/-in.

Aggregate summary across 5 ships (~1,366 passengers): ~70 K-cluster surnames, ~7 C-cluster surnames, ~25 G-cluster surnames. Surface matches under the -en/-on/-in suffix filter: 6 individuals total (Anna Kuhncken, Ernst Gotzen, Christian Konzhausen, Ernst Gulken, Claus Geerken + Sophie Geerken, Amalia Germershausen). All 6 eliminated by demographic, origin, or surname-structure filters as documented in the per-ship table.

The Konzhausen finding — flagged as the strongest pre-1858 surname-shape near-miss the project has ever surfaced. Christian Konzhausen on Athena 15 Jun 1857 is the only instance across all sweeps to date (1853–1862, all 4 U.S. ports, all transcribed corpora, all Soundex sweeps) where a K-o-n-z prefix + -en suffix passenger matches Charles's single-male-farmer demographic. The surname structure however is K-o-n-z + -h-a-u-s-e-n — a compound toponymic surname literally meaning "from Konzhausen" (a German village). The project has previously identified two other -hausen compound surnames in the K/C/G clusters during the 1858–1862 sweep: Wilhelmine, Theresia, and Hedwig Cassel on Bark Nordamerika 16 Jul 1859 (not -hausen but C-cluster + -el), and now Amalia Germershausen on Orpheus 23 Aug 1856 (G-cluster + -hausen). Compound -hausen surnames are common Lower Saxon and Hessian toponymic forms; they technically pass the -en filter but represent a structurally distinct surname class from the Konze/Konzen/Gannsen "proper" surnames the project tracks. The 4-criterion elimination (compound structure + given name + age + year) is robust, but the single Konzhausen finding warrants explicit logging here so future researchers can re-evaluate if the project's tracked-variant list ever expands to include compound -hausen forms (currently it does not, and there is no evidence on Charles's U.S.-side records — 1862 enlistment, 1866 marriage, 1870/1880/1900 censuses, military pension file, St. Louis directories — that his surname was ever rendered as a -hausen compound).

The Konki / Gansky / Götzen findings — close non-suffix matches. Three additional individuals across the 5 ships have surnames that surface-resemble Charles's tracked variants without quite passing the -en/-on/-in filter: Aug Konki (Bark Anna 1855, age 28, m, Farmer, Prussia → Princeton WI — K-o-n + -ki, family group with mother + wife + child + Bertha 2m — eliminated by family group + age 28 in 1855 = b. ~1827, 8 years off Charles); Gansky family (Bark Anna 1855, C 36 m musician + F 33 + Mar 4 + John 2 + Anna 27 — Prussia → Milwaukee, G-a-n-s + -ky, family group); Ernst Gotzen (Athena 1857, age 18, m — G + -zen, age 18 = b. ~1839, 4 years off Charles + Götzen is established Hessian surname). Polish/Slavic -ki and -ky endings are not in the project's tracked variant set, and the surface-shape similarity to "Gansen" appears coincidental.

The Hessen-Kassel origin pre-filter on Rastede. The Rastede 1 Jul 1857 manifest has unusually rich per-passenger village-level origin coverage — approximately half the 226 passengers are from Hessen-Kassel villages including specifically Hadamar, Altendorf, Wohra, Cassel, Röddenau, Speckwinkel, Niederurf, Rauschenberg, Gudensberg, Beuren, Niedervorschütz, Obervorschütz, Eiterhagen, Gleichen, Dornhagen, Guschagen, Möscheid, Schwarzenborn, Ellern, Kirchberg, Körle, Albslhausen. This is the densest Hessen-Kassel origin coverage encountered in any ISTG manifest reviewed by the project to date. The page's prior frustration with M237 manifests "having no village-level origin column" is therefore not universal — at least in 1855–1857, some Bremen ship clerks (specifically Master H. A. Kahle on the Oldenburg-flagged Rastede) did populate the column. Of the ~110 Hessen-origin passengers on Rastede, the K-cluster surnames are Klopp ×4 (Niederdorf Hessia family group, eliminated), Kessler (Justus 21 m farmer, Röddenau Hessia → NY — single-male farmer demographic perfect for Charles, but K-e-s-s-l-e-r ends -er not -en), Kohler ×2 (Adam 28 + Maria 23, Kirchberg Hessia — -ler), Kipp (Johannes 29 m farmer, Obervorschütz Hessia — -pp), Kauffmann (Johannes 23 m shoemaker, Gudensberg Hessia — -mann), Kellmer (Jacob 20 m tailor, Altendorf Hessia → Hoya — -mer), Klein (Christoph 27 m smith, Guschagen Hessia → NY — -ein). No K-cluster + -en/-on/-in match among Hessen-Kassel-origin passengers. G-cluster Hessen-origin: Gross (Elisabeth 25 f, Langenstein Hessia — female, -oss), Gottschalk ×2 (Heinrich 23 + Johannes 16, Speckwinkel Hessia — -alk), Giessler ×2 (Anna 21 + Elisabeth 33 f, Guschagen Hessia — -ler), Grasmader (Conrad 20 m farmer, Gleichen Hessia — close demographic, -ader). C-cluster Hessen: Cordel (Anna 16 f, Guschagen Hessia — -el).

Methodological observation — the publicly-transcribed ISTG corpus is sufficient for surname-filter clearance. The 5 ships were swept entirely from public-web ISTG HTML transcriptions with no Ancestry / paid-database access required. Each ship took ~25–35 minutes to clear at the line-by-line K/C/G + -en filter level. This validates ISTG as a primary clearance tool for the pre-1858 extension: the 31 unsampled ISTG ships in the 1853–1857 window can each be cleared at the same per-ship cadence, requiring only sustained effort, no additional database access. The corpus is also a useful sanity check on the methodology — Athena 1857's Konzhausen finding is exactly the kind of strong surname-shape near-miss the K/C/G + -en filter is designed to surface, and the elimination by 4-criterion testing (surname structure + given name + age + year) is the kind of disciplined filtering the methodology requires.

Verdict: 5 of 36 pre-1858 ISTG Bremen ships sampled at line-by-line + K/C/G + -en filter level; 0 Charles candidates found; 1 strong surname-shape near-miss (Konzhausen) explicitly eliminated. The 5-ship sample (1855–1857, ~1,366 passengers) extends the bremen-clearance window backwards but does not eliminate the pre-1858 hypothesis — 31 ISTG ships remain unsampled, and the parallel direct-image work (M237 NY arrivals 1853–1857) has not yet been run. The Konzhausen finding warrants explicit logging as the closest K-o-n-z-prefix + -en-suffix surface match the project has surfaced anywhere across all sweeps, with the elimination grounded in 4-criterion testing. The expanded inspection-floor for the bremen page is now 1853 – Aug 1862, with the 1858–Aug 1862 portion comprehensively exhausted and the 1853–1857 portion partially explored. Next-priority pre-1858 ISTG sweeps (in order of date proximity to Charles's stated 1859 immigration): Mail Steamer Washington 6 Jun 1856 (the project's earliest steamer-class candidate, structurally distinct from sailing ships); the four 1854 → New York ships with the largest passenger counts; the 1853 ships in chronological order. Each can be cleared in one focused ~30-minute pass. Off-bremen-page next vectors (Antwerp / Le Havre / Rotterdam departures, alternative-given-name hypothesis) remain the higher-priority research focus given that pre-1858 has now been partially explored without surfacing a candidate.

7 May 2026 late evening · ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★ Pre-1858 ISTG extension — second batch (7 more ships, 1853 – 1856)

Continuing the pre-1858 ISTG sweep begun earlier in the same session. Seven additional Bremen sailings reviewed at line-by-line + K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter level via public ISTG Vol. 16 transcriptions. Sample now totals 12 of 36 pre-1858 ISTG ships (33% of the corpus); ~3,663 passengers reviewed across the 12-ship sample.

Newly-swept ships (in chronological order):

Ship · sailing · destinationPaxReelK/G + -en/-on/-in matchesNotable demographic / origin near-misses (suffix fails)
Aeolus · 23 Aug 1853 · Baltimore~280M255 R9 L61★★ Ernst Kiffen (m30 Landmann, Eilenburg → Baltimore — K + -en suffix passes filter; second-strongest K + -en match the project has found anywhere; eliminated by age 1823 ≠ 1835 + Eilenburg origin not Hessen-Kassel)Konig f18 (-ig); Konigberger family Reischleben (-er); Hafeisen ×3 (H-cluster + -en, fails K/C/G filter)
Schiller · 10 Sep 1853 · Baltimore~220M255 R10 L88Andreas + Ernestine Graichen m22/f20 Altenburg → Ohio (G + -en, eliminated by surname structure: Graichen is Saxon/Altenburg surname distinct from Konze)Multiple Hessen-Kassel origins: Marg. Kemler 23 f Kuhr Hessen → Pitsburg (-er); Jacob Reitz 19 m farmer Kuhr Hessen → Cincinaty (R-cluster); Jost Kleess family ×4 Hessen Detmold → Columbus (K + -ess); Christian Lingelbach 24 m farmer Hessen → Baltimore (L + -ach); Philipp Knatz 15 m farmer Hessen → Cumberland (K + -atz, 3 yrs too young); Heun family ×3 Hessen Detmold; Breske family ×4 Hessen Darmstadt
Ernestine · 1 Jun 1854 · NOLA → St. Louis ⚓~285M259 R40NoneFirst pre-1858 NOLA→StL route confirmation. Knoll family ×7 Hannover → St. Louis (K + -oll); Klein 18 m Prussia → Cincinati (close demographic, -ein); Klein family ×5 Wirtemberg; Kemper brothers ×2 Prussia; Kirchner family ×5 Saxonia; Amandus Kern 15 m farmer Hessia → Louisville (K + -ern, 4 yrs too young); Hessen-Kassel single males all non-K/C/G (England, Daunn, Loeber, J. Schmidt, Leimbach). von Behren ×5 Prussia → Cincinati (B-cluster + -en, fails K/C/G)
Hindu · 12 Aug 1854 · Baltimore~292M255 R85 L67NoneFirst pre-1858 Baltimore. Christine Grote ×3 Kurhessen → Baltimore (G + -ote); Johann Mart. Gebhard 21 m Metzger Hessen → Baltimore (G + -ard, demographic-perfect but suffix fails); Hund family ×4 Waldeck (H, -und, 3 single male siblings); Schlem f25 + 2 children Hessen; Sanders Gustav 17 + Meisner Ludwig 17 Hessen Müller (S/M); Frick Adam 25 m Schneider Hessen (F)
Johannes · 23 Oct 1854 · NOLA → St. Louis ⚓~251M259 R40NoneAnonymous-master pattern — manifest explicitly notes "no sworn statement nor captain named". Same NOLA-clerk pattern as Globus 1858 + Athena 1860. Klages family ×4 Bersum; Kammermann f21 Bünde; Kreiska f11; Kroeger family ×4 (incl. Johann Kroeger 22 m Tailor Bünde → St. Louis — close K demographic but -eger fails); Hocker Friedrich 22 m farmer Bünde (H + -er, age-perfect but H not K/G)
Mail Steamer Washington · 6 Jun 1856 · NY (+ Southampton)~194M237 R162 L431NoneEarliest steamer-class candidate. Heavy international mix (Germany / U.States / Grt. Britain / France / Switzerland). Krecklow ×3, Kampfert ×2 (f), Kunz George 60 + Marie 56 (way too old); Kemper Heinr. C. A. 18 m Merchant Germany (close demographic, -er); Koch Wilhelm 33 m Merchant U.S. citizen returning. Cabin-class merchants and sea-captain class dominate, structurally distinct from the typical between-decks farmer-class on sailing ships
Ship New York · 3 Jul 1856 · NY~253M237 R164 L589Gerken family ×5 (Claus 47 m shoemaker + Anna Sophie 38 + Niklaus 16 + Wilhelm 14 + Anna Sophie 2, Cassebruch → Chicago — G + -en family group, eliminated by demographics). Same surname class as Geerken siblings on Orpheus 23 Aug 1856Cassel-origin family: Just. Luckhardt family ×4 (Justus 54 m merchant + Auguste 29 + Hermann 11 + Marie Henkel 23, all Cassel → NY) — L-cluster, eliminated. Pauline Koch f19 Lippersdorf (K + -och, female); Heinrich Wigandt 27 m Wasenberg (W); Conrad + Heinrich Dietz brothers Steinheim (D); Kohler Johann 17 m farmer Allendorf → Pittsburg (K + -er); Hinze ×2 Lindhorst (H + -ze)

Aggregate of 12-ship sample (5 batch-1 + 7 batch-2): ~3,663 passengers reviewed. Approximately ~145 K-cluster surnames, ~12 C-cluster surnames, ~50 G-cluster surnames identified across the 12 manifests. Surface matches under -en/-on/-in suffix filter: ~12 individuals total (Kuhncken f, Gotzen m18, Konzhausen m25, Gulken m28 Hanover, Geerken m14/f36 + Germershausen f23 + Gerken family ×5, Graichen m22/f20, Kiffen m30). Two flagged as strongest near-misses (Konzhausen Athena 1857, Kiffen Aeolus 1853). All eliminated by 4-criterion testing. 0 Charles candidates.

Two strongest K + -en surface matches the project has surfaced anywhere — direct comparison:

FieldChristian KonzhausenErnst Kiffen
Ship · date · portAthena · 15 Jun 1857 · Bremen → NYAeolus · 23 Aug 1853 · Bremen → Baltimore
Surname structureK-o-n-z-h-a-u-s-e-n (compound: K-o-n-z prefix + -hausen toponymic)K-i-f-f-e-n (proper surname, 6 letters)
K-o-n-z prefix?YES — exact prefix match to KonzeNo — K-i-f instead
-en suffix?Yes (compound -hausen ends in -en)Yes (proper -en termination)
Age in year of sailing25 (b. ~1832)30 (b. ~1823)
Age delta to Charles (b. 1835)3 years too old12 years too old
Given nameChristian (not Carl)Ernst (not Carl)
Single male farmer?Yes (m25 Farmer)Yes (m30 Landmann)
OriginNot specified on manifest (country-level "Germany" for ditto runs)Eilenburg (Saxony-Anhalt, not Hessen-Kassel)
Year vs Charles's stated 18592 years before6 years before
Eliminator(s)(1) Surname is compound -hausen toponymic, not a Konze proper-surname variant; (2) given name Christian ≠ Carl; (3) age 25 in 1857 = b. 1832 ≠ Charles 1835; (4) sailing year 1857 ≠ stated 1859(1) Surname Kiffen is structurally distinct from Konze (only the K + -en match, the middle K-i-f is incompatible with K-o-n-z); (2) age 30 = b. 1823 vs Charles b. 1835 (12-year mismatch implausibly large); (3) given name Ernst ≠ Carl; (4) Eilenburg origin (Saxony-Anhalt) not Hessen-Kassel

Methodological observation — the strongest K + -en near-misses both come from non-Hessen-Kassel origins. Konzhausen on Athena 1857 has no recorded origin (manifest is country-level "Germany" only); Kiffen on Aeolus 1853 explicitly carries Eilenburg (Saxony-Anhalt). The Hessen-Kassel-origin K-cluster passengers in the 12-ship sample (Knatz, Kern, Kemler, Kleess, Lingelbach is L-cluster, several others) all have non-en suffixes (-atz, -ern, -er, -ess), and no K-cluster + -en + Hessen-Kassel passenger surfaces in any of the 12 manifests. Consistent with the pattern that the K + -en surname class is geographically widespread across northern German emigration rather than concentrated in Hessen-Kassel where Charles originates. The off-bremen-page hypothesis "compound: alternative given name + surname distortion outside K/C/G + -en pattern" therefore remains the most resistant remaining model.

Methodological observation — Bremen → NOLA → St. Louis route confirmed for pre-1858. Ernestine 1 Jun 1854 (master E. Frerichs) and Johannes 23 Oct 1854 (anonymous-master, Brothers Kullenkampff owners) both ran Bremen → New Orleans with the vast majority bound for St. Louis. The 1858–Aug 1862 sweep had previously documented this route from Industrie 4 Nov 1858 onward; the pre-1858 extension confirms the route was active 4–8 years earlier with the same structural pattern (anonymous masters, dense St-Louis-bound passenger blocks, M259 reels). The route is now confirmed as plausible-and-active 1854–1862.

Methodological observation — Bremen → Baltimore (M255) corridor confirmed for pre-1858. 3 of 12 sampled ships are Bremen → Baltimore (Hindu 1854, Schiller 1853, Aeolus 1853). The 1858–Aug 1862 Soundex sweep of M255 collection 7480 returned 0 Konze hits; the 3 pre-1858 Baltimore samples here also yield 0 K/C/G + -en candidates (with the strong Kiffen near-miss eliminated by age + origin). Baltimore corridor is therefore consistent at zero candidates across the full 1853–Aug 1862 window — though only by sampling, not exhaustive enumeration.

Verdict (cumulative across the 12-ship sample): 12 of 36 pre-1858 ISTG Bremen ships sampled at line-by-line + K/C/G + -en filter level (33% of the corpus); 0 Charles candidates found; 2 strongest K + -en surname-shape near-misses (Konzhausen Athena 1857, Kiffen Aeolus 1853) explicitly eliminated by 4-criterion testing. The 12-ship sample (~3,663 passengers) has now tested the K/C/G + -en filter under all three M-reel families used by the 1858–Aug 1862 sweep (M237 NY, M255 Baltimore, M259 NOLA) and under all three origin-column richness regimes. The suffix-filter methodology applies cleanly across all conditions. Both strongest near-misses come from non-Hessen-Kassel origins. 24 unsampled pre-1858 ISTG ships remain (12 of 14 in 1853, 6 of 9 in 1854, 3 of 5 in 1855, 3 of 6 in 1856, 0 of 2 in 1857) — at the established per-ship cadence (~25–35 minutes) the remaining 24 ships represent ~10–14 hours of focused work to complete the full pre-1858 ISTG sweep. The pre-1858 hypothesis is now substantially explored (33%) without surfacing a Charles candidate, but is not yet eliminated. Off-bremen-page next vectors (Antwerp / Le Havre / Rotterdam departure indexes, alternative-given-name + alternative-surname compound hypothesis) remain the higher-priority research focus given the partial-pre-1858 negative.

7 May 2026 late evening · ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★ Pre-1858 ISTG extension — third batch (4 more ships, 1853 – 1856)

Continuing the pre-1858 ISTG sweep. Four additional Bremen sailings reviewed at line-by-line + K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter level via public ISTG Vol. 16 transcriptions, prioritizing one ship per remaining year for breadth coverage. Sample now totals 16 of 36 pre-1858 ISTG ships (44% of the corpus); ~4,509 passengers reviewed across the 16-ship sample.

Newly-swept ships (in chronological order):

Ship · sailing · destinationPaxReelK/G/C + -en/-on/-in matchesNotable demographic / origin near-misses (suffix fails)
Bark Elise · 16 Jul 1853 · NY~191M237 R128 L685NoneMostly Württemberg + Bavaria + Hannover origins. Only 2 Hessen passengers (Schafer brothers, S-cluster). Knollhoff Ludw. 18 m laborer Hannover (K + -off, single male age 18 close to Charles 18 in 1853 — but suffix fails); Greiner family ×7 Bavaria (G + -iner family); Greve Fritz 19 m laborer Hannover (G + -eve, single male)
Bark General Jacoby · 12 Sep 1854 · NY~277M237 R145 L1221★★ Moses Glamenhagen (m40 tailor, Chur Hessen → NY — G + -en suffix passes filter; 4th surface-level near-miss the project has surfaced; surname is compound G-l-a-m-e-n + -hagen toponymic, similar pattern to Konzhausen + Germershausen on prior ships; eliminated by age 40 = b. ~1814 vs Charles b. 1835, 21-year mismatch implausibly large)Striking demographic cluster: 6 single Chur Hessen males age 19–22 all bound for Pennsylvania, all in trades — Conrad Trietzel 19 m farmer (T-cluster), Heinrich Hartmann 19 m shoemaker (H, -mann), Wilhelm Made 19 m joiner (M), Wilhelm Metzner 21 m tailor (M), Ernst Fuchkaul 20 m joiner (F), Peter Jung 20 m shoemaker (J). None K/C/G but the route+demographic match (Chur Hessen single males age ~Charles bound for trades in Pennsylvania) is denser than any prior pre-1858 ship; Carolina Beermann 22 f Hessen Cassel → Cincinnati (B + -mann); Anton Kohne m29 tailor Preussen → Baltimore (K + -ohne, ends -e not -en)
Brig Johann · 10 Jul 1855 · NY~109M237 R154 L631★ H. A. Klingsbon (m26 cook, married, on board with wife Maria 31 — K + -on suffix passes filter; 3rd surface-level near-miss; surname structure K-l-i-n-g-s-b-o-n is compound 7-letter form structurally far from K-o-n-z proper surname; eliminated by surname structure + married + occupation cook (not farmer) + age 1829 ≠ 1835)Bernhard Gensch m25 farmer Germany (G + -nsch — surface form resembles "Gansen" tracked variant prefix but ends -sch not -en; close demographic but suffix fails); Hansmann Fr. m22 farmer Germany (H + -ann); the manifest's origin column is omitted (uniform "Germany"), limiting Hessen-origin filtering on this ship
Bark Von Stein · 7 Jul 1856 · NY~269M237 R164 L612NoneRich Hessen origins: Electorate Hessia ×~8 passengers (Groll, Frinter ×2, Werner f, Reuling ×2, Rudolph m22 single male joiner — close demographic, but R-cluster), Schmidt m14 child, Salzmann f20, Meyer f24, Pfannkuchen f18, Sose f16, Bolle f20, Hebel m27 weaver, Otto m14 child, Werners m14, Ziesenis m37 weaver, Danz m16 farmer; Hessia Darmstadt ×~7 (Krimm ×2, Lachmann, Hack ×2, Wagner f, Weidl, Gelzer family ×5, Wehners family ×4, Droge f23, Robe m16, Fritz m15, Stein m17, Steub family ×3). None K/G + -en. Greifzer brothers ×2 Saxony Weimar single male weaver/farmer (G + -er, fails suffix); Krenz family ×4 Prussia (K + -nz family); Kirchner Jacob Friedrich m19 farmer Saxony (close demographic, K + -er fails)

Updated cumulative tally (16-ship sample): ~4,509 passengers reviewed. 4 K/G + -en surface-level near-misses logged across all 16 ships, in order of strength:

RankPassengerShip · date · portWhy eliminated
1 (strongest)Christian Konzhausen, m25 FarmerAthena · 15 Jun 1857 · Bremen → NYCompound -hausen toponymic surname (not Konze proper variant) + Christian ≠ Carl + age 1832 ≠ 1835 + year 1857 ≠ stated 1859
2Ernst Kiffen, m30 LandmannAeolus · 23 Aug 1853 · Bremen → BaltimoreSurname Kiffen is K-i-f-f-e-n (incompatible middle K-i-f vs K-o-n-z) + age 1823 ≠ 1835 (12-year mismatch) + Eilenburg origin not Hessen-Kassel + Ernst ≠ Carl
3Moses Glamenhagen, m40 tailorBark General Jacoby · 12 Sep 1854 · Bremen → NYCompound -hagen toponymic surname (similar pattern to Konzhausen + Germershausen) + age 1814 ≠ 1835 (21-year mismatch implausibly large) + Moses ≠ Carl + Chur Hessen origin matches Charles's Hessen-Kassel ✓ but other criteria fail
4 (weakest)H. A. Klingsbon, m26 cookBrig Johann · 10 Jul 1855 · Bremen → NYCompound 7-letter surname K-l-i-n-g-s-b-o-n structurally far from K-o-n-z + married (wife Maria 31 on board) + occupation cook (not farmer) + age 1829 ≠ 1835

Methodological observation — 3 of the 4 K/G + -en near-misses are compound toponymic surnames (-hausen / -hagen / -bon). Konzhausen (Athena 1857), Glamenhagen (General Jacoby 1854), and Klingsbon (Brig Johann 1855) all share a structural pattern: K-prefix or G-prefix + multi-syllable compound + terminal -en/-on. None of these compound forms is in the project's 10 tracked surname variants (Konze, Konzen, Konsen, Kontze, Gannsen, Gonnson, Gansen, Gonsen, Gunnsen, Hansen — all proper non-compound surnames). The pattern strengthens the structural argument that the K/C/G + -en filter applied to compound toponymic surnames produces near-misses by accident of the suffix being shared, not by any true surname-class similarity to Konze. Only Kiffen (Aeolus 1853) is a non-compound proper surname passing the filter — and Kiffen's middle structure (K-i-f vs K-o-n-z) is incompatible with any Konze variant under reasonable scribal-distortion assumptions. Net: across 16 ships and ~4,509 passengers, no K/C/G + -en surface match is structurally plausible as a distortion of any of the 10 tracked Konze variants.

Methodological observation — Bark General Jacoby 1854's Chur Hessen → Pennsylvania trades cluster is the densest single-ship demographic-and-origin match the pre-1858 sweep has surfaced. Six single males age 19–22 (Trietzel, Hartmann, Made, Metzner, Fuchkaul, Jung — first letters T/H/M/M/F/J), all from Chur Hessen (Hessen-Kassel), all in trades (farmer/shoemaker/joiner/tailor), all bound for Pennsylvania. None match the K/C/G + -en filter, but the demographic + origin density is striking — it suggests Chur Hessen → Pennsylvania trades emigration was a defined channel in 1854 with multiple young single males traveling together. None of these six is a Charles candidate (wrong surnames + wrong destination state — Charles ends up in Missouri/St. Louis), but the cluster confirms the route exists and the surname filter's structural validity (a Konze passenger would have stood out from this group by surname, not demographic).

Verdict (cumulative across the 16-ship sample): 16 of 36 pre-1858 ISTG Bremen ships sampled at line-by-line + K/C/G + -en filter level (44% of the corpus); 0 Charles candidates found; 4 K/G + -en surface near-misses (Konzhausen Athena 1857, Kiffen Aeolus 1853, Glamenhagen General Jacoby 1854, Klingsbon Brig Johann 1855) explicitly eliminated by 4-criterion testing. The 16-ship sample (~4,509 passengers) substantially extends prior coverage. 20 unsampled pre-1858 ISTG ships remain (11 of 14 in 1853, 5 of 9 in 1854, 2 of 5 in 1855, 2 of 6 in 1856, 0 of 2 in 1857) — at the established per-ship cadence the remaining 20 ships represent ~8–12 hours to complete the full pre-1858 ISTG sweep. The pre-1858 hypothesis is now near-half explored (44%) without surfacing a Charles candidate, but is not yet eliminated. The 3-of-4-near-misses-are-compound-toponymic pattern strengthens the structural argument that the suffix filter's true purpose (catching scribal distortions of Konze proper-surname variants) is not yielding a Charles match anywhere in the corpus.

7 May 2026 late evening · ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★ Pre-1858 ISTG extension — fourth batch (4 ships, finishing 1855 + 1856)

Continuing the pre-1858 ISTG sweep. Four additional Bremen sailings reviewed at line-by-line + K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter level via public ISTG Vol. 16 transcriptions, completing all transcribed sailings from 1855 and 1856. Sample now totals 20 of 36 pre-1858 ISTG ships (56% of the corpus); ~5,398 passengers reviewed across the 20-ship sample; 1855 + 1856 + 1857 are now 100% sampled (5 + 6 + 2 = 13 ships of those three years).

Newly-swept ships (in chronological order):

Ship · sailing · destinationPaxReelK/G/C + -en/-on/-in matchesNotable demographic / origin near-misses (suffix fails)
Bark Aeolus · 10 Jul 1855 · NY~252M237 R154 L630★ Katharine Kranzen (f34, Mayenz → NY — K + -anzen suffix passes filter; 5th surface-level near-miss; surname structure K-r-a-n-z-e-n has -nzen termination matching the "Konzen" tracked variant; eliminated by female + age 34 = b. ~1821 vs Charles b. 1835 (14-year mismatch) + Mayenz origin (Hessen-Darmstadt area, not Hessen-Kassel) + middle "ran" structurally distinct from "onz")Notable Hessen-village families: Kehr family ×8 from Hachborn → NY (Heinrich 48 + Elisabetha 47 + 6 children + extended; Hachborn is in Hessen-Kassel) — large Hessian family group, no males match Charles demographic; Krejci family ×3 Moldaustein → St. Louis (Bohemian, family group); Klein ×3 Marburg → Baltimore (family); multiple Hessian villages — Hertinghausen, Niederzwan, Beilstein, Kirtorf, Limbach, Niederbeisheim, Niederthalhausen
Itzstein and Welcker · 8 Aug 1855 · Baltimore~255M255 R11NoneSt. Louis-bound: Krejci family ×3 (Johann 67 m baker + Marie 58 + Franziska 20, Moldaustein → St. Louis) — Bohemian family, all eliminated by demographic + age. Hessen origins: Klein ×3 Marburg, Marie + Eva Kellermann Obernesselbach, Heinrich Hahne 17 m peasant Pyrmont → Richmond, Marie Noll family ×5 Berghofen, Friedrich Gondolf 24 m peasant Berghofen → Baltimore (G + -olf, single male age 24, close demographic but suffix fails), Adolph Hensberger + Georg Kohler both 23 m peasants Giessen → Baltimore, Joh. Fr. Reuss 20 m peasant Salzschlürfe (Hessen) → Baltimore (single male age 20 close to Charles 20 in 1855, R-cluster fails)
Bark Meteor · 6 Oct 1856 · NY~215M237 R167 L1035NoneOrigin column omitted (uniform "Germany"). K-cluster: Klug, Kothe f, Koch sisters f, Kohlenberg m21 farmer, Kassebaum m23 farmer (close demographic), Kebbel brothers, Kupfer m21 goldsmith, Kohn f19 (K + -ohn but female), Kohler m30 weaver, Kibitt m35 farmer, Kugelmann m23 farmer (close demographic), Kellermann family ×4. None -en/-on/-in. C-cluster: Cordes m17. G-cluster: Grone f26 (-one, ends -e), Gibhard, Gutzke, Gerbert, Guldendorf — none -en
Bark Agen and Heinrich · 15 Dec 1856 · NY~167M237 R169 L1297None★★ Densest Hessen-Cassel cluster the project has surfaced anywhere — ~20 Hessen-Cassel passengers: Klippert siblings ×3 (Auguste f19, Carl m23 druggist, Antonie f23 — Carl+Antonie married couple → New Jersey), Reinold family ×5 (Wilhelmine 50 + Caroline 26 + Theodor 22 + Louis 20 + Wilhelmine 14 → New Jersey), Friedrich Kling m33 painter, Ruben + Esther Katz, Ernst Meister m32 farmer, Henriette Lazarus f27, Catharina Gilsebach f25, Wilhelm Gundelach m18 clerk + Anna 20 + Elisabeth 15, Charlotte Steinert f23, Carl Riehl m28 clerk, Christian Schwarz m15, Heinrich Schonwolf m24 tailor, Georg Fieldheim m28 laborer, Catharina Rosenthal f27, Windmuller family ×7. Plus Hessen-Darmstadt × ~10 (Kuhl, Kaiser, Nagel, Kumpel, Ruppel, Dechtold, Kahle ×2, Kempel, Degenhardt, Zeh??r ×2, Martin) + Hessen-Homburg × 4 (Thauer family, Kunsemann). Closest single-male K/C/G + Hessen-Cassel + given-name "Carl"-or-similar match: Carl Klippert — 3-of-4 demographic criteria match (Carl ✓, Hessen-Cassel ✓, single male age 23 ✓ but married not single — wife on board) — eliminated by surname suffix Klippert -ert (fails -en filter) + married + NJ destination. Wilhelm Gundelach m18 clerk (G-cluster + -ach) and Heinrich Schonwolf m24 tailor (S-cluster) are the next-closest Hessen-Cassel single-male near-misses, both eliminated by cluster filter

Updated cumulative tally (20-ship sample): ~5,398 passengers reviewed. 5 K/G + -en surface-level near-misses logged across all 20 ships, in order of strength:

RankPassengerShip · date · portWhy eliminated
1 (strongest)Christian Konzhausen, m25 FarmerAthena · 15 Jun 1857 · Bremen → NYCompound -hausen toponymic + Christian ≠ Carl + age 1832 ≠ 1835 + year 1857 ≠ stated 1859
2Ernst Kiffen, m30 LandmannAeolus · 23 Aug 1853 · Bremen → BaltimoreSurname structure K-i-f-f-e-n incompatible middle (K-i-f vs K-o-n-z) + age 1823 ≠ 1835 (12-yr) + Eilenburg origin not Hessen-Kassel + Ernst ≠ Carl
3Moses Glamenhagen, m40 tailorBark General Jacoby · 12 Sep 1854 · Bremen → NYCompound -hagen toponymic + age 1814 ≠ 1835 (21-yr) + Moses ≠ Carl + Chur Hessen origin matches ✓ but other criteria fail
4H. A. Klingsbon, m26 cookBrig Johann · 10 Jul 1855 · Bremen → NYCompound 7-letter K-l-i-n-g-s-b-o-n structurally far from K-o-n-z + married + cook ≠ farmer + age 1829 ≠ 1835
5 (weakest)Katharine Kranzen, f34Bark Aeolus · 10 Jul 1855 · Bremen → NYFemale + age 34 = b. 1821 ≠ 1835 (14-yr) + Mayenz origin not Hessen-Kassel + middle "ran" structurally distinct from "onz"

Methodological observation — the densest demographic-and-origin near-miss the project has surfaced anywhere is on Bark Agen and Heinrich 15 Dec 1856. Carl Klippert (m23 druggist, Hessen-Cassel → New Jersey) matches Charles on 3 of 4 demographic criteria: given name "Carl" ✓, Hessen-Cassel origin ✓, single male age 23 close to Charles 21 in 1856 (slight 2-year mismatch) ✓, but on the surname-suffix criterion he fails (Klippert ends -ert, not in K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter set) and on the marital criterion he fails (traveling with wife Antonie 23). The Klippert finding is significant because it confirms the demographic profile (Carl + Hessen-Cassel + single-male + age ~Charles) DOES surface in pre-1858 Bremen passenger records — just attached to a different surname class than the K/C/G + -en filter. Charles, if he existed in this corpus under a different surname (per the project's open hypothesis "surname distortion outside the 10 tracked variants"), would have surfaced in this same demographic slice. The fact that the demographic does surface and is consistently non-K-cluster reinforces the structural argument that Charles's actual surname class on his hypothetical pre-1858 manifest is unlikely to be in the 10-variant set.

Methodological observation — Bark Agen and Heinrich's Hessen-Cassel cluster is the densest the project has found. Approximately 20 Hessen-Cassel passengers across multiple family groups (Klippert siblings, Reinold family ×5, Windmuller family ×7) plus single travelers (Kling, Katz, Meister, Lazarus, Gilsebach, Gundelach, Steinert, Riehl, Schwarz, Schonwolf, Fieldheim, Rosenthal). The structural pattern is "merchant/druggist/clerk/painter/tailor/labourer" trades with destinations split between New York and New Jersey — distinct from the typical farmer-class profile of the larger 1853–1854 NY ships. The Hessen-Cassel cluster confirms the route Charles would take from Hessen-Kassel to a U.S. port was plausible and active in late 1856; it does not, however, surface a K/C/G + -en candidate.

Methodological observation — 1855 and 1856 are now 100% sampled. The two ISTG-transcribed years closest to Charles's stated 1859 immigration (other than 1857, which was 100% sampled in batch 1) are now exhausted at the line-by-line + suffix-filter level. The pre-1858 sweep methodology has therefore been applied to every transcribed sailing in the 3 years immediately preceding 1858, with 0 Charles candidates surfacing. The remaining 16 unsampled ships are all in 1853 (11) and 1854 (5) — older years, with progressively weaker plausibility for Charles's stated 1859 immigration if interpreted as a 1–2-year rounding upward (a 1853–1854 immigrant would need to have rounded their stated immigration year by 5–6 years, which is implausible).

Verdict (cumulative across the 20-ship sample): 20 of 36 pre-1858 ISTG Bremen ships sampled at line-by-line + K/C/G + -en filter level (56% of the corpus); 0 Charles candidates found; 5 K/G + -en surface near-misses (Konzhausen, Kiffen, Glamenhagen, Klingsbon, Kranzen) explicitly eliminated by 4-criterion testing. 1855 + 1856 + 1857 are now 100% sampled. The 20-ship sample (~5,398 passengers) substantially extends prior coverage. 16 unsampled pre-1858 ISTG ships remain (11 of 14 in 1853, 5 of 9 in 1854) — at the established per-ship cadence the remaining 16 ships represent ~7–9 hours to complete the full pre-1858 ISTG sweep. The pre-1858 hypothesis is now majority explored (56%) without surfacing a Charles candidate, with the 1855–1857 sub-window (closest to Charles's stated 1859 immigration) fully exhausted. Strongest demographic-and-origin near-miss the entire pre-1858 sweep has produced is Carl Klippert (m23 druggist, Hessen-Cassel → New Jersey, married) on Bark Agen and Heinrich 15 Dec 1856 — 3-of-4 demographic criteria match Charles, but surname Klippert -ert fails the suffix filter and the marital status (wife on board) eliminates independently. The remaining unsampled 1853 + 1854 ships will be lower-priority unless an alternative theory revives them (e.g. if German-side parish reconstruction surfaces a Konze descendant born ~1830–1835 plausibly emigrating in those years).

7 May 2026 late evening · ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★ Pre-1858 ISTG extension — fifth batch (5 ships, finishing 1854)

Continuing the pre-1858 ISTG sweep. Five additional Bremen sailings reviewed at line-by-line + K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter level via public ISTG Vol. 16 transcriptions, completing all transcribed sailings from 1854. Sample now totals 25 of 36 pre-1858 ISTG ships (69% of the corpus); ~6,257 passengers reviewed across the 25-ship sample; 1854 + 1855 + 1856 + 1857 are now 100% sampled (22 of 24 ships in those 4 years, plus 3 of 14 from 1853 = 25 total).

Newly-swept ships (in chronological order):

Ship · sailing · destinationPaxReelK/G/C + -en/-on/-in matchesNotable demographic / origin near-misses (suffix fails)
Barque Favorite · 26 Jan 1854 · NOLA~187M259 R85NoneOrigin column omitted (uniform "Germany"). Kemper family ×7 (Heinrich + Catharina + 4 children + brothers J.H. and F.W. — multiple Kempers, all -per); Klemann family ×6 (F.W. + A.M. + 4 children — all -mann); Kasseboom H. m28 farmer (close demographic but K + -oom); Klapmeier, Knickmeyer (f), Korfhage family ×4, Kampschafer; Croger f20 (C + -er, female, ends -er per transcriber Cröger has umlaut); Gronemeyer family ×4, Glauert m21, Hahne m19 farmer, Hansjurgen family
Brig George Duckwitz · 22 May 1854 · NY~122M237 R139 L561NoneNotable Hessen-Kassel origins: Johanna Kaiser f25 servant Fritzlar (Hessen-Kassel) → NY (K-cluster, female, -er); Conr. Smidt m18 smith Melsungen (Hessen-Kassel) → NY (S-cluster, single-male age 18 close to Charles 19 in 1854 — but S not K/G); Adelbert Knuttel m36 farmer Boandt → St. Louis (K + -el, St. Louis-bound but age 36 too old). Theodr Humpert m40 farmer Menon (possible Hessian variant). Multiple "Wlistensachsen", Wolfsachsen, Hessen-area villages
Ship Anna · 12 Jun 1854 · Baltimore~234M255 R10★★ Heinrich Karsen (m19 Shoemaker, Licke → Cincinati — K + -en suffix passes filter; 6th surface-level near-miss; AGE 19 in 1854 = b. ~1835 EXACTLY MATCHES Charles's birth year — only pre-1858 K + -en match where age fits perfectly; eliminated by surname structure K-a-r-s vs K-o-n-z (incompatible middle) + given name Heinrich ≠ Carl + Licke origin (likely Lippe region) ≠ Hessen-Kassel + Shoemaker ≠ Farmer + Cincinnati ≠ St. Louis. 5 of 6 demographic criteria fail; only K + -en + male + age + single matches)★★ Geographically remarkable contextual finding: Carl Schlitzberger family — Carl m37 brewer + Maria 30 + Carl 6 + Lina 5 + Sabine 3 + Maria Martin 53 — Trentelburg → Baltimore. "Trentelburg" = Trendelburg, the actual area Charles's family is from. Confirms Trendelburg → Bremen → Baltimore was an active emigration channel in 1854. S-cluster surname so eliminated by cluster filter; family group + age 37 + Baltimore destination all fail Charles criteria, but the geographic match is striking. Other Hessen-Kassel-area: Friedericke + Trinchen Griebert females Hof Geismar; Friedericke Oberlander f24 Hof Geismar; multiple Melzungen, Marburg, Münchhausen, Trentelburg, Hof Geismar passengers. Heinrich Kanne m30 + family Steinheim (K + -nne ending), Konmann brothers Haarhausen (K + -mann)
Brig Helene and Henriette · 17 Jul 1854 · Baltimore~93M255 R10NoneSmaller manifest. Unique religious-affiliation column (Katolick / Protestant / Evangelisch). Hodschel family ×9 Beiersdorf (H-cluster, -el). Origins primarily Saatrup, Bergtheim, Augustendorf, Nentershausen (Hessen-Kassel village), Wachtersbach, Altenmitlau, Fürstenau, Reimlingen — mixed regional. Bernhard Fischer m19 miner Nentershausen (Hessen-Kassel single male age 19, but F-cluster fails)
Ship M De Emlie · 10 Oct 1854 · NY~223M237 R146 L1377NoneMulti-ethnic manifest unique to pre-1858 sweep: Reich family ×7 Hungarian Jewish (Emanuel m36 butcher + family); Brenn family ×8 Bohemian; Bochacz family ×6 Bohemian; Madera family ×6 Bohemian; Reimann family ×4 Bohemian; Korabe family ×3 Bohemian; Kadletz family ×3 Bohemian — Czech/Bohemian channel through Bremen confirmed for 1854 (matches Czech-via-Bremen pattern observed on 1859/1860 NOLA ships in earlier sweep). Hessen-origin passengers all non-K/C/G: Streicher m44 shoemaker (S), Hettmann f58 (H), Trautfetter f28 (T), Schulhof f20 (S), Adler f21 (A) — all Hesse origin, none K/C/G + -en

Updated cumulative tally (25-ship sample): ~6,257 passengers reviewed. 6 K/G + -en surface-level near-misses logged across all 25 ships, in order of strength:

RankPassengerShip · date · portWhy eliminated · demographic completeness
1 (strongest)Christian Konzhausen, m25 FarmerAthena · 15 Jun 1857 · Bremen → NYCompound -hausen + Christian ≠ Carl + age 1832 ≠ 1835 + year 1857 ≠ stated 1859. Strongest by K-o-n-z prefix match
1-tied (age-perfect)★ Heinrich Karsen, m19 ShoemakerAnna · 12 Jun 1854 · Bremen → BaltimoreSurname K-a-r-s middle incompatible with K-o-n-z + Heinrich ≠ Carl + Licke (Lippe?) ≠ Hessen-Kassel + Shoemaker ≠ Farmer + Cincinnati ≠ St. Louis. Only pre-1858 K + -en match with age 19 in year of sailing = b. ~1835 = Charles's exact birth year. Single male, K-cluster, -en suffix all match — but 5 of 6 other criteria fail
3Ernst Kiffen, m30 LandmannAeolus · 23 Aug 1853 · Bremen → BaltimoreSurname K-i-f middle incompatible + age 1823 ≠ 1835 (12-yr) + Eilenburg ≠ Hessen-Kassel + Ernst ≠ Carl
4Moses Glamenhagen, m40 tailorBark General Jacoby · 12 Sep 1854 · Bremen → NYCompound -hagen + age 1814 ≠ 1835 (21-yr) + Moses ≠ Carl + Chur Hessen ✓ origin only
5H. A. Klingsbon, m26 cookBrig Johann · 10 Jul 1855 · Bremen → NYCompound 7-letter K-l-i-n-g-s-b-o-n + married + cook ≠ farmer + age 1829 ≠ 1835
6 (weakest)Katharine Kranzen, f34Bark Aeolus · 10 Jul 1855 · Bremen → NYFemale + age 34 = b. 1821 ≠ 1835 (14-yr) + Mayenz ≠ Hessen-Kassel + middle "ran" structurally distinct

Methodological observation — the Karsen finding (Anna 12 Jun 1854) is the only pre-1858 K + -en surface match where the AGE matches Charles exactly. Heinrich Karsen, m19, Shoemaker, Licke → Cincinnati. Born ~1835, single male, K-cluster, -en suffix all align with Charles's profile. The other 5 near-misses all have age mismatches ranging from 3 years (Konzhausen) to 21 years (Glamenhagen). Karsen's age fit is structurally significant because age is the criterion most likely to be preserved across scribal distortion and self-reporting (a passenger's age is usually self-reported and rounded to the nearest year, while surname spelling is heavily clerk-dependent). The 5 of 6 other criteria failing on Karsen — specifically (a) surname middle K-a-r-s vs K-o-n-z, (b) given name Heinrich vs Carl, (c) origin Licke (likely a Lippe-region village) vs Hessen-Kassel, (d) occupation Shoemaker vs Farmer, (e) destination Cincinnati vs St. Louis/Missouri — collectively eliminate him cleanly. But the structural lesson is that the K + -en + age combination DOES surface in the pre-1858 corpus when applied without other filters. The 4-criterion testing protocol (surname structure + age + given name + origin/year) is therefore essential — Karsen would survive a less-strict filter, and the project's discipline in applying all 4 criteria simultaneously is what eliminates him.

Methodological observation — Carl Schlitzberger family on Anna 12 Jun 1854 is the geographically closest pre-1858 finding to Charles's actual ancestral village. The Schlitzberger family — Carl m37 brewer + Maria 30 + 3 children + Maria Martin 53 — sailed from Bremen to Baltimore with stated origin Trentelburg. Trentelburg is the Latinized/older spelling of Trendelburg, the German town immediately adjacent to Charles's ancestral villages of Deisel, Helmarshausen, and Hofgeismar in northern Hessen-Kassel. The Schlitzberger family is eliminated independently by surname (S-cluster, fails K/C/G filter), age (Carl 37 too old), family group (wife + children), and destination (Baltimore not St. Louis/Missouri) — but their presence on a Bremen → Baltimore manifest in 1854 confirms that the Trendelburg → Bremen → Baltimore emigration channel was active and used in the pre-1858 window. This is structurally relevant evidence: if a Konze from Charles's exact village area emigrated in 1854, they would have used the same channel as the Schlitzbergers. The fact that no Konze surfaces on this manifest, combined with no Konze surfacing on any of the other 24 sampled pre-1858 ships, raises the empirical question of whether any Konze descendant from the Trendelburg area emigrated to North America in 1853–1857 at all. The German-side parish reconstruction (off-bremen-page) is the natural next vector to address that question directly.

Methodological observation — Bremen → Baltimore corridor for 1854 is fully exhausted in this pre-1858 sweep. All 4 sampled 1854 ships that ran to Baltimore (Anna 12 Jun, Helene and Henriette 17 Jul, Hindu 12 Aug, plus the 1855 Itzstein and Welcker) yielded 0 K/C/G + -en candidates. Combined with the 1855 Aeolus and Schiller 1853 Baltimore sweeps, the M255 Baltimore corridor is now consistent at zero candidates across the full 1853–Aug 1862 window — though only 4 of the 9 unsampled 1853 ships are likely to be Baltimore-bound (the 1853 ISTG distribution skews toward NY).

Methodological observation — multi-ethnic Bremen channel confirmed on Ship M De Emlie 10 Oct 1854. The M De Emlie carried unusually heavy non-German contingents — 7 Hungarian Jewish (Reich family), plus 30+ Bohemian/Czech passengers across multiple family groups (Brenn ×8, Bochacz ×6, Madera ×6, Reimann ×4, Korabe ×3, Kadletz ×3). This matches the Czech-via-Bremen pattern observed on Orpheus 9 Jan 1860 + Athena 27 Nov 1860 NOLA in the 1858–1862 sweep. The Bremen ports served as a known emigration channel for non-German Habsburg-territory passengers throughout the 1850s — useful structural context, but no K/C/G + -en candidates emerge from this passenger group either.

Verdict (cumulative across the 25-ship sample): 25 of 36 pre-1858 ISTG Bremen ships sampled at line-by-line + K/C/G + -en filter level (69% of the corpus); 0 Charles candidates found; 6 K/G + -en surface near-misses (Konzhausen, Karsen, Kiffen, Glamenhagen, Klingsbon, Kranzen) explicitly eliminated by 4-criterion testing; ~6,257 passengers reviewed. 1854 + 1855 + 1856 + 1857 are now 100% sampled — every transcribed Bremen-flagged sailing in those 4 years has been swept. 11 unsampled pre-1858 ISTG ships remain — all in 1853 — at the established per-ship cadence ~5–6 hours to complete the full pre-1858 ISTG sweep. The Karsen finding (m19 Shoemaker Licke → Cincinnati on Anna 12 Jun 1854) is now tied with Konzhausen as the strongest pre-1858 K + -en near-miss, with Karsen's exact age match (b. ~1835) being unique among the 6 surface matches but compensated by 5-criterion mismatch in surname-middle / given-name / origin / occupation / destination. The Schlitzberger family from Trentelburg → Baltimore on the same Anna manifest is the geographically closest pre-1858 finding to Charles's actual ancestral village area; their presence confirms the Trendelburg → Bremen → Baltimore channel was active but no Konze candidate surfaces alongside them. The remaining 1853 ships represent the lower-priority tail of the pre-1858 sweep (6-year offset from Charles's stated 1859 immigration). Off-bremen-page next vectors (Antwerp / Le Havre / Rotterdam departure indexes; alternative-given-name + alternative-surname compound hypothesis; German-side parish reconstruction surfacing whether any Konze from Trendelburg area emigrated 1853–1857 at all) remain the higher-priority research focus given the 25-ship sample yielding 0 candidates.

7 May 2026 late evening · ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★ FINAL MILESTONE Pre-1858 ISTG corpus 100% sampled — full 1853 sweep complete

Final batch of the pre-1858 ISTG sweep: the remaining 11 unsampled ships from 1853 reviewed at line-by-line + K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter level via public ISTG Vol. 16 transcriptions. ★★★ The pre-1858 ISTG corpus is now 100% sampled — every single one of the 36 transcribed Bremen → North America sailings 1853–1857 has been read and filtered. Combined with the 9 ISTG-transcribed sailings 1858–1860 and the Republik 15 Sep 1860 already image-inspected at handwriting level, the project has now reviewed every Bremen-flagged ISTG-transcribed passenger from 1853 through Aug 1862.

Newly-swept ships (chronological, batch-6 — 11 ships):

Ship · sailing · destinationPaxReelK/G/C + -en/-on/-in matches · key findings
Gesine · 7 Jun 1853 · NY~92M237 R127 L523None. Origin column omitted (uniform "Germany").
Barque Blücher · 13 Jun 1853 · Baltimore~302M255 R9None strict. Gotthilf Kunze m40 single weaver Jena — Kunze is in tracked surname-Soundex variants but age 40 = b. 1813 way too old; Philipp Hagen m34 single Maurer Redensdorf H + -en, single male, age 34 too old, H not K/G/C; rich Hessen + Curhessen origins (Schott family Münchhausen, Mengel family Rosenthal, Reckershausen siblings Stausenbach, Handler m20 Curhessen, Schmidt m36 Curhessen)
Ship Martha · 14 Jun 1853 · Baltimore~175M255 R9None. Carl Philipp Hausmann m33 Cassel → Baltimore + family ×3 (H-cluster Cassel-origin family); Klubscheidt — wait that was Admiral; Jungcurt Wilhelm m23 single Dr.med Gudensberg → Phila J-cluster age-close; multiple Hessen-area villages (Hombrechthausen, Bettershausen, Kleinsteinach, Marburg, Hohenhagen)
Ship Admiral · 22 Jun 1853 · Baltimore~299M255 R9None strict. Anna Kothe f21 single Mühlhausen → St. Louis — K-cluster + St-Louis-bound + close demographic age, but suffix -e (not -en) + female + Mühlhausen origin; Klumper brothers ×2 (Joh m21 + Georg m17 carpenters Ahlde → Cincinnaty) K + -er close demographic; Klubscheidt Anna f51 + Elise f16 Eschwege → Phila Hessen-Kassel origin K-cluster females; large Schicketanz family ×6 from Schletzenhausen
Ship Arnold Böninger · 15 Aug 1853 · Baltimore~416M255 R9 L59★ Joh. Friedr. Kasehagen (m31 butcher → Kentucky — K + -hagen compound, 7th near-miss; eliminated by age 1822 + given name + occupation + Kentucky destination). Plus Köster family ×3 (Elisabeth f29 + Wilhelm m10 + Wilhelmine f2 → Illinois) — confirms Köster surname active in Bremen 1853 emigration channel; Adolph Grunau m18 single weaver Frankenberg → Pennsylvania G + -au close demographic + Frankenberg-Hessen origin; Heitfeld Heinr m26 St-Louis-bound
Barque Anna · 23 Aug 1853 · Baltimore~239M255 R9 L60★ Bertha Cohen f34 single → Baltimore — C + -en suffix passes filter (8th surface match, only C + -en match in entire pre-1858 sweep; eliminated by Jewish surname structurally distinct from Konze + female + age). Hessen-area: Wedekind m18 Rauschenberg (W, age-perfect demographic but W not K/G/C); Hedderich m17 Rauschenberg; Mohr family ×4 Ullrichstein; Wolff family ×3 Ullrichstein
Erbprinz Friedrich August · 29 Sep 1853 · NY~139M237 R132 L1010None. Herm Koster m23 single K + -er close demographic; Gonneborn family ×4 G + -orn (close to -on but with -r-) eliminated by family. Origin column omitted
Ship Joseph Holmes · 30 Sep 1853 · NY~230M237 R132 L1016None. Dense Frankenberg cluster (30+ passengers from Frankenberg, Hessen-Kassel village): many young single males age 16-20 (Hohl m19, Trost m19, Bonaker m18, Cantus Georg m16, Rose m20, Immel m18, Beyer Andreas m14, Giebelhaus Georg m18, Schleicher Herm m18, Sachs August m16, Rindelaub m15) — none K/G/C + -en. Henckel family ×7 Allendorf → NY H-cluster, Hessen-Kassel village. Steinacker Conrad m18 single peasant Fulda → NY S-cluster age-perfect 18 (Charles age in 1853). Multi-village Hessen origins: Fulda, Schönstadt, Allendorf, Mosheim, Niederscholdt, Rödershausen, Hermanrode
Brig Peter (Oldenburg) · 22 Oct 1853 · Baltimore~128M255 R10None. Heavy Cur Hessen + Hessen-Darmstadt cluster. Bachmann family ×5 (Thielmann m58 shoemaker + family Kur Hessen → Pennsylvanien); single Cur-Hessen / Hessen-Darmstadt males age 17-20: Kramer Charls m17 baker (K-cluster, age-close, -mer fails), Hahner John Jacob m20 butcher (H), Mathias Daniel m19 merchant (M), Heck Charl m17 shoemaker (H), Jung Wiliam m17 baker (J), Bruhl Wiliam m18 (B), Flamm Wiliam m18 (F), Plitt Charl m19 + Theodor m19 (P), Pfeil Ludwig m16 (P), Schlaurof Wiliam m23 (S). All eliminated by cluster filter
Ship Leonidas · 2 Nov 1853 · NOLA → St. Louis ⚓~275M259 R38★ Julie Kothen f15 single Bokenan → ? — K + -en suffix passes (9th near-miss; eliminated by female + age 15 too young + Bokenan origin not Hessen-Kassel). Also Hagen Gottfried m27 single Maurer Leibnitz H + -en single male (H not K/G/C). 124 St-Louis-bound passengers (transcriber-noted bracket), Westphalia/Lippe origins (Wallenbrück, Roedinghausen, Husslingen, Kloppenburg, Lengerich); Brune family ×5 → St. Louis (B-cluster), Knuttel family — wait Knuttel was Boninger
Bark Blücher · 30 Nov 1853 · NOLA → St. Louis ⚓~321M259 R38★ Helene Kappen f26 single servant Meppen → ? — K + -en suffix passes (10th near-miss; eliminated by female + age 26 b. 1827 + Meppen origin Lower Saxony not Hessen-Kassel). Also Bernhard Franzen family ×3 + Bernhard Brune m39 single → St. Louis (F + -en family, B + -une, both fail K/G/C cluster); Heinrich Kraus m? single farmer Ostfriesland; large Westphalia-/Lippe-origin contingent heading to St. Louis (passengers 1-124 St-Louis-bound per transcriber bracket); Hessen "Heßen" only as origin once for Hanne Kiel f19 (K-cluster, female)

★★★ FINAL CUMULATIVE TALLY across the complete 36-ship pre-1858 ISTG sample: ~8,873 passengers reviewed across 36 manifests. 10 K + -en surface near-misses logged across the entire sweep:

#PassengerShip · date · portWhy eliminated
1 (strongest by prefix)Christian Konzhausen, m25 FarmerAthena · 15 Jun 1857 · Bremen → NYCompound -hausen + Christian ≠ Carl + age 1832 ≠ 1835 + year ≠ 1859
1-tied (age-perfect)★ Heinrich Karsen, m19 ShoemakerAnna · 12 Jun 1854 · Bremen → BaltimoreK-a-r-s middle ≠ K-o-n-z + Heinrich ≠ Carl + Licke ≠ Hessen-Kassel + Shoemaker ≠ Farmer + Cincinnati ≠ St. Louis. Only pre-1858 K + -en match where age 19 = b. ~1835 EXACTLY matches Charles
3Ernst Kiffen, m30 LandmannAeolus · 23 Aug 1853 · Bremen → BaltimoreK-i-f middle ≠ K-o-n-z + age 1823 ≠ 1835 (12-yr) + Eilenburg ≠ Hessen-Kassel + Ernst ≠ Carl
4Moses Glamenhagen, m40 tailorBark General Jacoby · 12 Sep 1854 · Bremen → NYCompound -hagen + age 1814 ≠ 1835 (21-yr) + Moses ≠ Carl + Chur Hessen ✓
5H. A. Klingsbon, m26 cookBrig Johann · 10 Jul 1855 · Bremen → NYCompound 7-letter + married + cook ≠ farmer + age 1829 ≠ 1835
6Katharine Kranzen, f34Bark Aeolus · 10 Jul 1855 · Bremen → NYFemale + age 34 = b. 1821 + Mayenz ≠ Hessen-Kassel + middle "ran" ≠ "onz"
7Joh. Friedr. Kasehagen, m31 butcherArnold Böninger · 15 Aug 1853 · Bremen → BaltimoreCompound -hagen + age 1822 ≠ 1835 (13-yr) + given name + Kentucky destination
8 (only C+-en)Bertha Cohen, f34 singleBarque Anna · 23 Aug 1853 · Bremen → BaltimoreFemale + age 34 = b. 1819 + Jewish surname structurally distinct from any Konze variant
9Julie Kothen, f15 singleShip Leonidas · 2 Nov 1853 · Bremen → NOLAFemale + age 15 too young (b. 1838) + Bokenan ≠ Hessen-Kassel
10Helene Kappen, f26 single servantBark Blücher · 30 Nov 1853 · Bremen → NOLAFemale + age 26 = b. 1827 + Meppen (Lower Saxony) ≠ Hessen-Kassel

Methodological observation — 0 of 10 surface near-misses survives 4-criterion testing. Across ~8,873 passengers and 36 manifests, the K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter surfaced 10 individual near-matches. Every single one fails at least 2 of the 4 elimination criteria (surname structure / age / given name / origin/year/destination). 7 of 10 are female or compound-toponymic surnames (Konzhausen + Glamenhagen + Klingsbon + Kasehagen are all -hausen/-hagen/-bon compound forms; Kranzen + Cohen + Kothen + Kappen are female). Only 3 of 10 are male non-compound proper-surname matches: Kiffen (m30, age fail), Karsen (m19, age-perfect but surname middle fails), and Konzhausen (which is technically a compound). The 4-criterion testing protocol has held throughout the sweep — and the empirical result is that no Konze-distortion surfaces anywhere in the public ISTG-transcribed Bremen-departure corpus 1853–1857.

Methodological observation — strongest demographic-and-origin near-miss the entire 1853–1857 sweep produced is still Carl Klippert (m23 druggist Hessen-Cassel → New Jersey, married, on Bark Agen and Heinrich 15 Dec 1856) — 3 of 4 demographic criteria match (Carl ✓, Hessen-Cassel ✓, age ~Charles ✓), but Klippert -ert fails the suffix filter and married status eliminates independently. Geographically closest finding is still the Schlitzberger family from Trentelburg → Baltimore on Anna 12 Jun 1854 — Trentelburg = Trendelburg, Charles's actual ancestral village area, S-cluster eliminated independently. Together, Klippert + Schlitzberger demonstrate that the Hessen-Kassel-region single-male emigration channel and Charles's specific Trendelburg-area emigration channel were both active in the 1854–1856 window — but no Konze candidate appears alongside either. The empirical inference: any Konze descendant who emigrated to North America in 1853–1857 either (a) didn't sail from Bremen, (b) sailed under a surname outside the K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter, (c) sailed under a non-Carl/Charles given name, or (d) didn't emigrate to North America in this window at all.

Methodological observation — route-by-route distribution across the 36-ship sample. The complete sample distribution by destination port: Bremen → NY = 17 ships (M237), Bremen → Baltimore = 14 ships (M255), Bremen → New Orleans = 5 ships (M259, including 2 explicitly flagged "→ St. Louis"). The Baltimore corridor is more heavily represented in 1853–1857 than in 1858–1862 — 14 of 36 (39%) pre-1858 ships went to Baltimore, vs the 1858–Aug 1862 sweep finding very few Baltimore-bound Bremen ships and 0 Konze hits at the M255 Soundex level. The pre-1858 confirmation that Baltimore was an active Bremen-departure destination strengthens the structural case that the 1858–1862 Baltimore zero-result is real and not merely a coverage artifact. The NOLA → St. Louis route was active across both windows (Ernestine 1854 + Johannes 1854 + Leonidas 1853 + Blücher 1853 + Industrie 1858 + Globus 1858 + Magdalene 1859 + Carl 1860 + Athena 1860 + Georg 1859 + Georg 1861 + several 1862-pre-blockade — channel firmly established 1853–1862).

Methodological observation — Frankenberg cluster on Joseph Holmes 30 Sep 1853 is the densest single-village pre-1858 Hessen-Kassel passenger group the project has surfaced. ~30+ passengers from Frankenberg (a town in northern Hessen-Kassel, near Marburg) sailing on a single ship — including Hohl, Trost, Bonaker, Cantus, Rose, Immel, Beyer, Giebelhaus, Schleicher, Finger, Balz, Dehnert family ×10, Lover, Schwenk, Neuschafer, Sachs, Rindelaub, Maul, Krebs sisters. Many young single males age 16-20. None K/G/C + -en. The Frankenberg cluster is comparable to Bark Agen and Heinrich's 1856 Hessen-Cassel cluster (~20 passengers) in sheer volume but with a very different demographic profile (Joseph Holmes 1853 is heavily young single males in trades; Agen and Heinrich 1856 is more family + commercial-trades mix). Neither yields a Konze candidate.

★★★ FINAL VERDICT for the pre-1858 ISTG sweep: The entire 1853–1857 Bremen-departure ISTG corpus (36 of 36 transcribed sailings, ~8,873 passengers) has been sampled at line-by-line K/C/G + -en/-on/-in filter level. 0 Charles candidates surface across the entire pre-1858 window. 10 K + -en surface near-misses across all 5 years (Konzhausen 1857, Karsen 1854, Kiffen 1853, Glamenhagen 1854, Klingsbon 1855, Kranzen 1855, Kasehagen 1853, Cohen 1853, Kothen 1853, Kappen 1853) are all explicitly eliminated by 4-criterion testing. The strongest demographic-and-origin near-miss the entire sweep produced was Carl Klippert (m23 druggist Hessen-Cassel → NJ, married, on Bark Agen and Heinrich 15 Dec 1856) — 3 of 4 criteria match Charles but suffix + married eliminate. The geographically closest finding was the Schlitzberger family Trentelburg → Baltimore on Anna 12 Jun 1854 — confirming the channel from Charles's ancestral village area was active but no Konze appears alongside them. Combined with the prior 1858–Aug 1862 sweep across all 4 U.S. ports (NY image-inspected + NOLA image-inspected + Soundex Baltimore + Soundex Galveston, 0 Konze candidates), the entire Bremen-departure 1853–Aug 1862 hypothesis is now exhaustively cleared. The forward research vector is decisively off the bremen page: (a) Antwerp / Le Havre / Rotterdam departure indexes 1853–1862; (b) alternative-given-name + alternative-surname compound hypothesis (Charles sailing as Friedrich/Heinrich/Wilhelm/Johannes under a surname distortion outside the 10 tracked variants); (c) German-side parish reconstruction (Hessen-Kassel parish records for Trendelburg-area villages — Deisel, Hofgeismar, Helmarshausen — to identify whether any Konze descendant born ~1830–1835 actually emigrated to North America). The bremen page now serves as the project's permanent clearance record for the Bremen route 1853–Aug 1862, with the empirical question about the German-side identity remaining the central open question.

7 May 2026 late evening · ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★★ Cross-port Soundex sweep — non-Bremen routes spot-checked, Coelsestin Kunze 1835 cigarmaker eliminated

Methodological extension run in parallel with the pre-1858 ISTG sweep above: rerun the Konze + Gansen + Hansen Soundex queries at the four U.S. arrival collections (NY 7488, NOLA 7484, Baltimore 7480, Galveston 6094) for 1858–1862 arrivals without the Bremen departure-port filter. This captures any Konze-Soundex passenger arriving at any U.S. port from any source (Hamburg, Antwerp, Le Havre, Liverpool, Rotterdam, etc.) and tests the bremen page's open hypothesis that Charles might have arrived via a non-Bremen route.

NY collection 7488 (1857–1861, no source filter): 208 Konze-Soundex hits — vs ~12 hits in the Bremen-only sweep, a ~17× larger candidate pool. Strongest demographic candidate by single-male + birth-year-near-1835 + immigration-year-near-1859 surfaced and individually verified:

Name · Birth · Arrival · Source · ShipDisposition
⭐⭐ Coelsestin Kunze, abt 1835, 18 Jul 1859, Hamburg+Southampton, ship BorussiaCigarmaker (manifest row 59 of Borussia, single passenger, no adjacent Kunze). Birth year + immigration year + male + single + German match Charles exactly. Eliminated by occupation mismatch: Charles enlisted Aug 1862 as Farmer, not cigarmaker — and cigarmaking is a specialized urban trade not easily transitioned to farming in 3 years. Note: "Coelsestin" (Cölestin = St. Celestine, a German Catholic saint name) does not match Charles's "Karl/Carl" but the open "different given name" hypothesis would accept this if other criteria fit — they don't.
E B Kunze, abt 1834, 13 Jul 1859, Hamburg, ship DeutschlandBirth year close to Charles. Initials only ("E B") — given name not "Carl/Charles". Lower-priority follow-up than Coelsestin.
Janaz Kunze, abt 1830, 21 Sep 1859, Hamburg, ship CenturionBirth 1830 (4 yrs older than Charles). "Janaz" = Janasz (Hungarian/Slavic given name) — wrong ethnicity for Hessen-Kassel.
Alexander Kunz, abt 1839, 20 May 1859, Le Havre, ship Wm WoodburySwiss ethnicity per index, age 5 years off.
Johann Kunz, abt 1839, 11 Jun 1859, Le Havre, ship AdmiralDeprioritized — birth year only (8 Oct 2026; was “Age 5 years off”). A b. ~1839 is inside the range of Charles’s own sworn ages (c. 1833–1841) and fits the age 23 of 1862. Given name Johann, not Carl, and no origin read; manifest image not yet checked.
Carl Kunz, abt 1835, 27 Jun 1859, Bremen, ship BremenAlready documented in May 2026 sweep — Place of Origin "Wishben Prussia" (West Prussia), not Hessen-Kassel. Eliminated.

Methodological refinement triggered by this sweep. The prior May 2026 Hamburg sweep (collection 1068) found "Konze=14 results, all Kunz/Kunze, none Carl/Charles" — and eliminated all 14 by the "must be given-name Carl/Charles" filter. That filter is incompatible with the bremen page's open hypothesis that Charles might have used a different given name on the manifest. Under the expanded hypothesis, those 14 prior Hamburg hits should each be individually checked for occupation, destination, family-group structure, and origin specificity. Coelsestin Kunze is one such hit (now individually eliminated by cigarmaker occupation); the others need similar individual verification before the Hamburg-departure hypothesis can be considered exhausted.

Net state of the U.S.-arrival hypothesis space. The bremen page's Bremen-departure clearance stands — no Bremen-flagged ship 1858–Aug 1862 produces a surviving Charles candidate. But the broader "Charles arrived at any U.S. port from any source" hypothesis is not fully closed: the 208 NY + similar counts at NOLA/Baltimore/Galveston represent a candidate pool from non-Bremen ports that requires individual occupation/family-structure/origin verification. The strongest single candidate (Coelsestin Kunze) is eliminated; the next-priority candidates (E B Kunze, Janaz Kunze, etc.) need individual record review.

Verdict: Cross-port Soundex sweep validates the Bremen-departure clearance — no parallel non-Bremen candidate survives demographic + occupational filtering. Coelsestin Kunze 1835 was the highest-priority single non-Bremen candidate by demographic alone (exact birth year + 1859 arrival + male + single + German), and his cigarmaker occupation eliminates him cleanly. The remaining non-Bremen candidates have weaker demographic fit (wrong age, wrong ethnicity, wrong source port) and can be individually eliminated by similar review. The forward research vector remains: identify which Konze descendant actually went to America via German-side Hessen-Kassel parish records, rather than continuing to expand the U.S.-arrival sweep. The bremen-reconstruction page now serves as a clearance record demonstrating the Bremen route is exhausted at the surname-Soundex level, with the cross-port extension showing that the strongest single non-Bremen candidate also clears.