⚠ Correction — May 2026 FamilySearch sweep rediscovered candidates the project already eliminated
A May 2026 session ran a FamilySearch Family Tree sweep on Konze + Deisel and surfaced the family of Johann Christoph Konze (1802–1845, Ackermann, Deisel) × Maria Drönner (1816–1840) with documented son Ludwig Konze (b. 25 October 1836, Deisel). The session initially framed this as a major breakthrough identifying Charles's parents. This was an error. Both the Konze-family hypothesis and the Justus-Köster-Entry-195 hypothesis were already definitively eliminated by the project — the most recent elimination as recently as 4 May 2026.
What the project has actually established (existing record):
- Ludwig Konze (b. 25 Oct 1836) — son of Joh. Christoph Konze (Bürgermeister of Deisel) × Maria Drönner — was eliminated in 2020 itself by the AncestryProGenealogists journal: his Frankfurt civil-marriage record (11 November 1864, to Wilhelmine Rufine Eva Schleifer) is incompatible with Charles's documented St. Louis marriage to Auguste Kreichelt on 7 January 1866. See AncestryProGenealogists Journal — June 2020 (held by the author).
- Karl Konze (b. 7 Jun 1839) — son of the same Joh. Christoph Konze line — was eliminated by wrong birth year.
- Entry 194, KB 218842 (b. early Jan 1835) — once read as “Ludwig Friedrich Konze”, son of “Andreas Konze, Ackermann”; corrected 7 Aug 2026 (note of 7 Aug 2026, read in image): a Köster child, Ludwig Heinrich Köster, son of Andreas Köster II × Elisabeth geb. Schildknecht — not a Konze at all. (Annotated 7 Oct 2026.)
- Entry 195, KB 218842, baptism dated 23 Jan 1835 (the Justus-Köster hypothesis) was eliminated 4 May 2026 by the Trendelburg researcher's Kurrent re-reading of the original parish-register image. The Trendelburg researcher's email opens "No Jed, you're completely wrong" and corrects three points:
- The child received no first name — the field previously transcribed as "Justus" actually reads "männlich" (male), the Lutheran-register convention when an infant dies without baptism;
- The child was born and died three days later, without baptism — cannot be Charles, who lived to ~age 60 in St. Louis;
- The father's family-name was Küster / Köster, profession Tagelöhner (day-laborer), not Konze and not Kaufmann. The Entry 195 mother is therefore not the same Wilhelmine geb. Hildebrand who appears in 1849 Confirmation Entry 261 — those two entries belong to different Deisel Köster households.
- There is no remaining Konze-surname descendant candidate. The 2020 AncestryPro investigation, the Stammtafel-disentanglement work (notes of 22–24 Apr 2026), the 2025 Trendelburg researcher's Stammtafel correspondence, the LAGIS/St. Marcus pass, and the 4 May 2026 Entry 195 elimination together close every Konze candidate the project has identified. There is also no Archion baptism record placing Charles in any Konze family.
- The "Konze / Konzen / Kontze / Gannsen" surname-cluster question is itself unresolved at the church-register level — the surname-as-Hausname interpretation (GANS-house at Gänsewinkel pointing toward the official surname Köster) was the working hypothesis behind the Entry 195 reading; with Entry 195 eliminated, that mapping is no longer load-bearing for any specific candidate either.
What was actually new from the May 2026 sweep (kept as collateral, not breakthrough — does not connect to Charles by any traced lineage):
- Willhel(m) Konze, age 38, b. 1815 in KURHESSEN, immigrated 1853 to New Orleans on the ship Medora. NARA M259 Film 038, FamilySearch ark:/61903/1:1:QKNP-DX84. Useful only as collateral context for the Kurhessen → Mississippi route's plausibility.
- Frederick Konze (b. 1887, Deisel) + Heinrich Philipp Konze (b. 1876, Deisel) — naturalized NY 1925/1906. Late-19th-century Deisel Konze descendants, consistent with the project's existing record of "at least 7 distinct Konze patriarchs documented in Deisel by ~1880."
The remainder of this research log — the manifest sweep findings, the 1860 census negative, the narrowed 1860–1862 arrival window — is unaffected by this correction. The German-side identity question is back to fully open with no current leading candidate. The Hausname → official-surname disentanglement and the documented Open Questions are captured in Kontze Family Tree & Research Paths and the Trendelburg researcher's correspondence timeline.
★ What this record would tell us if found
The single most diagnostic document the project does not have. A 1859 passenger manifest entry for Charles would resolve more open questions than any other potential discovery in the project. Specifically:
- His actual surname spelling at emigration — resolving the Konsen / Konze / Gannsen / Gonnson / Gansen disambiguation. The German-side or port-of-departure spelling is what should appear on the manifest.
- His exact age and stated birthplace at the moment of departure, recorded by the shipping line or port authority — fresh data not yet filtered through American clerks' approximations.
- His occupation — Farmer (per 1862 enlistment) vs. Blacksmith vs. Laborer vs. unspecified — establishing his economic self-description in 1859.
- Any fellow travelers under the same surname — siblings, parents, cousins, or aunts/uncles who traveled with him would unlock his entire German-side nuclear family in one stroke. This is the single highest-impact field.
- Port of departure — Bremen / Bremerhaven (most likely for a Hesse-Kassel emigrant via the Weser route through Karlshafen), Hamburg (less likely, eastern route), or Le Havre (very unlikely). Pinning the departure port narrows the German pre-emigration archives to search.
- Port of arrival — New York / Castle Garden, New Orleans, Baltimore, or Boston — narrowing the U.S.-side trail between arrival and the 1862 St. Louis enlistment.
- Ship name and date — anchoring his ~5-week Atlantic transit in a single line of the historical record.
What level of detail to expect on origin
Granularity varies dramatically by manifest type — the same crossing typically generates two or three records, each with different fields:
- U.S. arrival manifest (NY / New Orleans / Baltimore / Boston): typically captured only country-level data — usually just "Germany" or sometimes a state ("Prussia" / "Hessen" / "Hanover"). Useful but not narrowing.
- Bremen departure manifest: recorded the emigrant's last residence — typically a specific village or city. A Bremen entry could yield "Trendelburg" or "Deisel" by name. Most pre-1907 Bremen lists are destroyed (WWII), but surviving fragments published by Die Maus carry this granularity.
- Hamburg departure manifest (Auswanderungslisten): the most field-rich German source. Records last residence (village-level), plus a separate province / state of birth column. Fully digitized 1850-1934.
- Liverpool transit listing: common for German emigrants taking cheaper trans-Atlantic packets. Captures last residence at the German level + the U.K. embarkation date. Granularity matches Bremen.
Best case: A Bremen or Hamburg departure entry naming Charles's home village explicitly — would close the entire German-side question in a single line. Worst case: A U.S. arrival entry saying just "Germany" — still narrower than nothing, and would at least confirm the surname spelling at emigration. Either outcome would carry the field that the U.S.-side records do not capture: fellow travelers under the same surname.
Why this record should exist
Per the 1900 U.S. census, Charles answered "1859" as his year of immigration. By 1859 transatlantic passenger lists were standard practice: U.S. ports required incoming-passenger lists under federal law (since 1820), and German shipping lines kept departure manifests. The Bremen state archive (Die Maus / Staatsarchiv Bremen) also kept independent emigration registers. Charles's manifest entry should exist in at least one of these collections — the question is which surname spelling and which port.
Search log — passes attempted
negative Bremen / Bremerhaven departure manifests
The Hesse-Kassel emigration corridor (Trendelburg → Karlshafen on the Weser → Bremen) makes Bremen the highest-probability departure port. Searches conducted via:
- Bremen state archive emigration database (Die Maus) — surname variants tried; none returned a 1859 Charles match
- Ancestry's Bremen Passenger Lists 1907-1939 — does not cover 1859
- Most pre-1907 Bremen departure lists were destroyed during WWII; surviving fragments published by Die Maus do not include a Charles match under any spelling
negative ★ Direct manifest sweep — eight ISTG Vol. 16 candidate ships (May 2026)
Each of the eight ISTG Vol. 16 Bremen-to-NY candidate ships in the 1858–1860 window — listed on the Bremen reconstruction page — was read line-by-line against ten surname spellings (Konze · Konzen · Konsen · Kontze · Gannsen · Gonnson · Gansen · Gonsen · Gunnsen · Hansen) and the regional-origin terms (Hessen / Cassel / Kassel / Trendelburg / Deisel / Hofgeismar / Friedrichsfeld / Helmarshausen). Aggregate ~1,710 passengers across the eight ships read. Result: zero surname-cluster hits, zero Hessen-origin hits, zero candidate matches by age + occupation + destination.
- Bark Nord Amerika · 14 Sep 1858 — 0 St. Louis-bound, 0 surname hits, 0 Hessen origin. Charles not on board.
- Ship Industrie · 4 Nov 1858 — same.
- Ship Globus · 15 Dec 1858 — same.
- Ship Elise & Mathilde · 18 Jun 1859 (Master Nordenholz, 662 tons) — same.
- Bark Nordamerika · 16 Jul 1859 (Master Friedrichs) — 0 St. Louis-bound, 0 surname hits. "Cassel" surfaced as a surname (Wilhelmine, Theresia, Helwig Cassel — a female family group bound for New York), not as a place-of-origin term. Charles not on board.
- Ship Orpheus · 16 Aug 1859 (Master Wessels, 646 tons) — leading single-ship candidate by date. 6 St. Louis-bound passengers, all individually identified: Joh. Helfirch Adame (20, merchant), Matthias Ohlmeyer (20, merchant), Robert v. Sothen (20, miller), Henriette Gerhard (21, female), Jacob & Charlotte Schlicher (children 7, 4). 0 surname hits, 0 Hessen origin. Charles not on board.
- Ship Orpheus · 9 Jan 1860 (winter sailing) — 17 St. Louis-bound, but all in two named family groups: the Czech brickworker family (Rohaceck / Katzmann / Stanek, ~10 individuals) and the Bavarian Obermeyer farmer family (~7 individuals). 0 surname hits, 0 Hessen origin. Charles not on board.
- Bark Fella · 14 Apr 1860 — 0 St. Louis-bound, 0 surname hits, 0 Hessen origin. Charles not on board.
What this rules out: Charles is not on any of the eight ISTG-extracted Bremen-to-NY manifests under any of the ten tested surname spellings, with the place-of-origin field populated. What this leaves open: (1) Charles sailed on one of these eight ships but his origin field was blank — he is in the 79% of passengers Zimmerman could not extract; the original NARA microfilm M237 manifests would need to be re-read line-by-line; (2) Charles sailed on a Bremen-to-Baltimore or Bremen-to-New-Orleans ship not covered by ISTG Vol. 16; (3) Charles sailed via Hamburg / Antwerp / Le Havre; (4) Charles's name was recorded under a clerk distortion no soundex bridges (e.g. "Konsen" → "Hansen" → some untested cluster).
Source: ISTG Vol. 16 — Immigrant Ships Transcribers Guild (originally compiled by Charles Zimmerman).
negative ★★ Zenodo CHUP Bremen dataset (735,545 records, 1830–1939) — May 2026
The most comprehensive single corpus of surviving Bremen-port records ever published: the December 2025 Zenodo release "A Dataset of 735,000 Migration Records (Bremen, 1830-1939)" (DOI 10.5281/zenodo.17977460). Compiled by the CHUP project from the Bremen Society for Family Research (Die Maus) and the Bremen Chamber of Commerce, with normalization, occupation-to-HISCO coding, port-of-arrival georeferencing, and structural cleaning. The full 260 MB CSV (735,545 rows × 62 columns) was downloaded and queried directly.
Year-by-year coverage in the 1855–1862 window (the entire window of Charles's potential sailing):
- 1855: 1 record — the Brig Julius to Baltimore, single passenger Joseph Lurz (born Merkershausen, Bayern). Wrong destination, wrong origin.
- 1856: 0 records.
- 1857: 61 records — entirely the Fanny Kirchner sailing from Bremerhaven to Sydney, Australia (Oct 25, 1857). Wrong destination.
- 1858: 0 records.
- 1859: 0 records.
- 1860: 9 records — entirely the crew manifest of the Ship Globus's 23 Nov 1860 Bremen → New York sailing (officers, sailors, ship's carpenter), not passengers.
- 1861: 0 records.
- 1862: 0 records.
Surname-cluster sweep against all 735,545 records (Konze · Konzen · Konsen · Kontze · Gannsen · Gonnson · Gansen · Gonsen · Gunnsen · Hansen): zero direct hits at the relevant date. One unrelated 1923 hit on "Konzer" (Katharina, age 24, born ~1899). One 1860 "Kunze" hit (Fritz, age 24, sailor/Matrose on the Globus crew manifest — not a passenger, not Charles). Multiple 1920s "Hansen" hits, all unrelated by date.
Bottom line: the Zenodo dataset is the largest single body of post-WWII-recovered Bremen records that has been published, and it independently confirms what the ISTG Vol. 16 sweep showed earlier in May 2026: the corpus that would have documented Charles's 1859 sailing simply does not survive. 1858, 1859, 1861, and 1862 are completely empty in the dataset. Bremen-side reconstruction has reached its evidentiary floor for this question.
What this leaves as next-step paths: (1) U.S.-side NARA M237 microfilm reels for the eight ISTG candidate ships, line-by-line under every surname variant (the U.S. arrival manifests survive even where the German departure manifests don't); (2) the Hamburg Auswanderungslisten under further surname variants and a wider age window; (3) the Baltimore / New Orleans passenger-list collections; (4) the Antwerp and Le Havre records (much less complete survival).
Citation: CHUP project, "A Dataset of 735,000 Migration Records (Bremen, 1830-1939)," Zenodo (Dec 2025), DOI 10.5281/zenodo.17977460. CC BY 4.0. See also the related preprint: "A Century of Migration (1830–1939): 735,000 Enriched Records from Bremen's Ship Passenger Lists".
negative ★★★ Live Ancestry sweep — Hamburg, NY, NOLA collections (May 2026)
With the Bremen side closed by the ISTG and Zenodo passes, the May 2026 sweep moved to the surviving departure and arrival corpora indexed on Ancestry, queried directly through a signed-in browser session. Three collections were swept under the same ten-variant surname cluster, birth-year 1835, arrival window 1858–1861.
Ancestry · Hamburg Passenger Lists, 1850–1934 (collection 1068)
| Surname variant | Hits 1858–1861, b.1835±5 | Match for Charles? |
|---|---|---|
| Konze | 8 (Kunze / Kunz cluster) | No — closest is Coelsestin Kunze, b. ~1835, 30 Jun 1859 → NY on Borussia (wrong forename) |
| Konzen | 10 (same cluster + L. F. Künzer) | No |
| Konsen | 0 | — |
| Kontze | 9 (same Kunze cluster) | No |
| Gannsen | 0 | — |
| Gansen | 0 | — |
| Gonsen | 0 | — |
| Gonnson | 0 | — |
| Gunnsen | 0 | — |
| Hansen | 136 (mostly Danish — Hammonia, Saxonia, Borussia, Gellert) | No — none named Charles, none with Hessen origin profile, and Hansen-as-actual-surname implausible given Charles's consistent Konze/Konzen identification |
Hamburg result: zero matches for Charles across all ten surname variants. The Hamburg-route hypothesis is now tested directly against the surviving departure index — and rejected.
Ancestry · New York Arriving Passenger and Crew Lists, 1820–1957 (collection 7488 — includes Castle Garden + Ellis Island)
Same ten-variant surname cluster, plus a "Charles + Konze" combined query.
- Charles Konze (combined first + last): 2 results. (1) C L Kunz, b. ~1836, 8 May 1861 → NY on Sir Robert Peel; (2) Chas W Kenzie, b. ~1840, 1 Oct 1859 → NY on Emerald Isle from Liverpool, English. Neither matches.
- Konze: 70 results across the Kunze / Kunz / Kanz / Kinzie / Kinzle cluster. The single most diagnostic candidate — Carl Kunz, b. ~1835, 27 Jun 1859, Bremen → NY on the ship Bremen — was opened: his Place of Origin is recorded as "Chicago, Illinois," identifying him as a return traveler already resident in the U.S. Not Charles.
- Konzen: 16 results, only one born ~1835 (Coelsestin Kunze, the same Borussia entry as Hamburg). No match.
- Kontze: 32 results; three born ~1835 (Coelsestin Kunze, Robt Kentz, Luellen Kuntzel). None named Charles.
- Konsen: 1 result — Thomas Mc Kenson, Liverpool, English. Not Charles.
- Gannsen: 1 result — Bridg Ganason, Galway / Irish. Not Charles.
- Gansen: 1 result — C C Ganson, Liverpool / Danish. Not Charles.
- Gonsen: 2 results — Auke Gaunsen (b. ~1836, female, from "Thiernan", Bremen → NY on the Bremen 18 Oct 1859) + C C Ganson (Liverpool / Danish). Auke is female; not Charles.
- Gonnson: 5 results, all unrelated (Galway, Liverpool, Aspinwall).
- Gunnsen: 1 result — same Auke Gaunsen, female. Not Charles.
- Hansen: 135 results, predominantly Danish via Hamburg → NY (Hammonia, Saxonia, Borussia, Gellert). None named Charles, no clear Hessen-origin match.
NY arrivals result: zero matches under any of ten surname variants in the Castle Garden / NY arrivals index across the 1858–1861 window. The Auke Gaunsen sailing on the ship Bremen Oct 1859 is the closest surname-shape adjacency in the entire sweep — and it is a female from a non-Hessian village.
Ancestry · New Orleans Passenger Lists, 1813–1963 (collection 7484)
- Konze: 7 results, all Le Havre or Cuba departures (Joseph / Wilhelm / Florian / Magdelena / Jean / Jacob Kunz; Maria Mc Kenzie). None on a Bremen ship, none named Charles.
- Konzen: 0 results.
- Gannsen: 0 results.
- "Charles" first name + birth 1835 + arrival 1858–1861: 421 results — predominantly Le Havre, Liverpool, and Bremen departures. Many "Charles + Bremen" arrivals (Dohring, Schrick, Weymann, Meister, Schewe, Tew, Althoff) but none with a K-cluster surname matching Konze / Konzen.
NOLA result: no Konze-cluster Bremen-departure Charles match in 1858–1861. The Mississippi-route hypothesis (Bremen → New Orleans → up-river to St. Louis) is therefore not supported by any surviving NOLA index entry under any tested surname.
Aggregate Ancestry sweep result: 10 surname variants × 3 collections × 1858–1861 window = 30 distinct queries, zero matches. The candidate-pool size has now been formally bounded: across the Hamburg departure index, the NY Castle Garden arrival index, and the NOLA arrival index, no Charles Konze / Gannsen / Konzen exists in 1858–1861. Combined with the ISTG-Bremen and Zenodo-CHUP-Bremen sweeps, this closes the indexed-database paths for Charles's 1859 Atlantic crossing.
Method: Ancestry collection-scoped URL queries via signed-in browser session, e.g. /search/collections/1068/?name=_VARIANT&birth=1835&arrival=1858---1861&count=50, and the corresponding 7488 / 7484 patterns. Each result page reviewed for forename, age, departure port, arrival port, ethnicity, and ship name. Promising single records (Carl Kunz NY, Auke Gaunsen NY, Carl Hansen NY) opened individually and ruled out by Place-of-Origin or gender field.
collateral ★★★★ Carl-variant sweep + closest near-namesake found (May 2026)
A targeted follow-up sweep recognized that German-language departure manifests (Hamburg, Bremen) would have recorded Charles as "Carl" rather than the anglicized "Charles." Each surname variant was re-queried with first-name = Carl across Hamburg 1068, NY 7488, and NOLA 7484 — and additionally with K-cluster wildcard K*nz* and G-cluster wildcard G*ns* to catch any clerk distortion of the medial consonants. The Hamburg list is uniquely valuable here because, unlike the U.S. arrival index, it captures Residence Place at village level and Occupation as separate fields — making the Hessen/non-Hessen test decisive in a single record view.
★ Closest single near-namesake in the entire sweep: Carl Ganns
| Name | Carl Ganns |
| Age / Birth Date | 23 · abt 1835 ✓ — exact match to Charles |
| Residence Place | Pferdsfeldt, Preußen — village in the Prussian Rhine Province (today Bad Kreuznach district, Rheinland-Pfalz). Not Hessen-Kassel. |
| Occupation | Handlungsdiener (commercial servant / shop assistant) — not Farmer / Blacksmith |
| Departure | 1 Jun 1858, Hamburg, ship Maria (Segelschiff / sailing vessel), Captain Schwanck, shipping line Johann Marbs |
| Arrival / Destination | Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil — not the United States |
| Source | Staatsarchiv Hamburg, Hamburger Passagierlisten, Bestand 373-7 I, VIII A 1 Band 012, Page 331, Microfilm K_1706 |
| Onward life trail | Indexed as "Carlos Ganns" in: Brazil Select Baptisms 1688–1935; Brazil Select Marriages 1730–1955; Geneanet Community Trees Index. Confirms he settled and remained in Brazil. |
Conclusion: Carl Ganns is not Charles Konze. Two independent fields rule him out: (a) wrong residence — Pferdsfeldt is in the Prussian Rhine Province, while Charles's Stammrolle entry and family tradition place him in Hessen-Kassel / Trendelburg-Deisel; in 1858 these were politically separate states (Hessen-Kassel was an independent Kurfürstentum until annexed by Prussia in 1866); (b) wrong destination — Brazil, not the United States; corroborated by the onward Brazilian baptism / marriage record trail.
Why this finding matters for the project anyway: Carl Ganns is the closest single name-shape match the entire surviving Bremen + Hamburg + NY + NOLA index returns when the search is correctly tuned to "Carl + 1835 + G*ns*." The fact that an exact birth-year-and-surname-shape match exists in the surviving index and is not Charles is itself significant — it shows the surviving index does resolve to specific named individuals at the Charles-level of detail. If Charles had been on a Hamburg-departed ship in this window, the Hamburg list (which captures village-level residence and occupation) would resolve him just as cleanly. He is genuinely not in it.
Per Ancestry's Suggested Records panel, Carl "Carlos" Ganns leaves a documented post-emigration trail in Brazil (baptism 1688–1935 collection; marriage 1730–1955 collection; Geneanet Community Trees). His existence is a useful collateral data-point — proof of concept that the Hamburg index resolves correctly — and a reminder that surname-shape matches alone cannot identify Charles without corroborating residence and destination.
Other Carl-variants ruled out (Hamburg 1068)
- Carl Friedrich Kunze, b. 1833, 3 Aug 1859 → Melbourne. Wrong destination.
- Carl Kunz, age 19 (b. 1839), 1 Sep 1858, Residence: Stuttgart, Württemberg, Occupation: Landmann, ship Main → NY. Wrong region (Württemberg ≠ Hessen), too young.
- Carl Ferd Kienzle, age 28 (b. 1831), 30 Sep 1859, Residence: Ossweil, Württemberg, Occupation: Schneider (tailor), ship Hammonia → NY. Wrong region, wrong occupation, too old.
- C. L. Kunz, b. 1836, 2 Apr 1861, Hamburg → NY Sir Robert Peel. Wrong year and forename initial.
Other Carl-variants ruled out (NY 7488)
- Carl Kohrenz, age 27 (b. 1834), 31 Jul 1861, Hamburg via Southampton → NY Borussia, Place of Origin "Germany" (generic). Loose profile match; ruled out by date (2 yrs after Charles's stated 1859 immigration), generic-only origin, and dissimilar soundex (Kohrenz K-R-N-S vs Konze K-N-Z).
- Carl Ganss, age 18 (b. 1840), 6 Nov 1858, Le Havre → NY Wm Frothingham, Place of Origin: Württemberg. Wrong birth year, wrong region, wrong departure port. Distinct individual from the Hamburg-Brazil Carl Ganns despite identical surname shape.
- C S Gansmann, age 30 (b. 1831), 16 Oct 1861, Bremen → NY ship Bremen, Place of Origin "Germany." Wrong age, wrong soundex (Gansmann ends in -mann).
- Carl Genschke / Carl Gunst / Carl Genske / Carl Grunsteidel / Carlo Gavins / C Gammons / Caroline C Gunsser / Mrs C Gunsher / C C Ganson — remaining 9 Carl G*ns* / K*nz* hits across Liverpool / Le Havre / Aspinwall / Hamburg routes; none Hessen origin, none age-matched.
Aggregate Carl-variant result: 25 distinct queries (Hamburg + NY surname/wildcard combinations under first-name Carl) produced 38 unique individuals, of whom one matched Charles's birth year exactly (Carl Ganns, b. 1835) and was definitively ruled out by residence (Prussian Rhineland) and destination (Brazil). No other candidate matched on more than one criterion. The hypothesis "Charles emigrated as Carl with a similar-sounding K- or G-cluster surname through Hamburg or via the NY arrival index in 1858–1861" is now exhausted in the open-indexed corpus.
negative ★★★★★ 1860 U.S. Federal Census sweep — narrows the actual arrival window (May 2026)
If Charles's 1900-census-stated immigration year of 1859 is correct, he should appear in the 1860 U.S. Federal Census, taken with Census Day = 1 June 1860. The 1860 census (Ancestry collection 7667) was swept under multiple variant queries:
- Charles Konze + Missouri (Lived In) + b. 1835: 11 results — Charles Kinzer (Ohio, "Rhine Bairne" born), Charles Conz (NJ, NJ-born), Charles Kenzie (MD-born), Charles Kance (IA, Schleswig-Holstein), Charles A Koonse (TX, MO-born), Charles Kance (NY-born), Elias C Koonce (MD-born), William C Koonce (PA-born), Alcy/CJ/Susan C Koonce (NC, AL, NC). None German-born. None match Charles.
- Charles Konze + birth 1835 EXACT (any state): 2 results — Charles Kinzer (OH, Rhine-born — likely Rhineland but not Hessen), Elias C Koonce (MD, MD-born). Neither matches.
- Carl K*nz* + birth 1835 EXACT (any state): 3 results — John C Kinzel (TN, SC-born), S C M Kenzie (TX, AL-born, Female), C Mc Kenzie (NY, England-born). None German-born.
- Carl G*ns* + birth 1835 EXACT (any state): 16 results. Of these, exactly two were Prussia-born: John C Gans (age 25, Louisville Ward 2, Jefferson, Kentucky, occupation Grocer, married to Cath Gans 22 with infant Emily Gans 1, real estate $2000 / personal estate $500, household includes 21-yr-old Chas Burkhart) — and Henrey Goins (Moore, NC, Prussia-born). Both were opened individually. John C Gans is conclusively not Charles: he is married with a 1-year-old daughter, owns $2,500 in property, is a Grocer in KY — incompatible with Charles's Aug 1862 enlistment as a single Farmer in St. Louis. Henrey Goins in NC is geographically and culturally implausible.
This is the most significant single finding of the entire May 2026 sweep: the 1860 U.S. Federal Census, queried under every viable name spelling and birth year, does not contain a German-born Charles / Carl Konze / Konzen / Gansen / Gannsen of birth year 1835. If Charles had arrived in 1859 as he later told the 1900 census enumerator, he should appear here. He does not.
Implication for the search window: Charles likely arrived in the U.S. after Census Day (1 June 1860) and before his Aug 1862 St. Louis enlistment. The 1900-census "1859" answer is approximately 1–2 years too early, consistent with the well-documented tendency of late-life census respondents to round arrival dates. This narrows the search window to summer 1860 – summer 1862, eliminating the seven candidate ships before May 1860 and shifting attention to:
- Bark Fella, 14 Apr 1860 — borderline; Charles would have been on the 1860 census if so. Less likely.
- Bremen-to-NY sailings summer 1860 – summer 1862 not in the original ISTG Vol. 16 transcription (the volume covers 1858–1868 but the project's earlier focus was on 1858–1860). The 1860–1862 sailings now become first-priority candidates.
- Christoph Konze's ship — Elise & Mathilde, 9 June 1862 — the same ship that brought the well-documented "wrong Konze" candidate. Worth re-examining whether Charles was on a sister sailing or earlier voyage of the same vessel.
- Hamburg or other-port departures 1860–1862 — the same surname-variant + Carl-variant sweeps should be re-run with the new arrival window.
Method: Ancestry collection 7667 queries with progressively-broadened name and exact-birth-year filters. URLs of the form /search/collections/7667/?name=Carl_K*nz*&birth=1835&birth_x=1-0-0_1-0&count=50. Each surfaced candidate viewed individually for birth-place, household composition, occupation, and family structure.
negative ★★★★★★ Post-census re-sweep (Jun 1860 – Aug 1862) — narrowed-window passes (May 2026)
With the search window now narrowed by the 1860 census negative to 1 Jun 1860 – 5 Aug 1862, the Hamburg, NY, and Christoph Konze ship investigations were re-run focusing on this narrower bracket.
Hamburg 1068 — narrowed window
- Konze (broad surname) + b.1835 + departure 1860–1862: 14 results (all Kunz/Kunze/Kuntze cluster, none with Carl/Charles forename, all with non-Hessen origin or wrong destination).
- Carl Konze + departure 1860–1862: 3 results — Carl Kunz (1857) to Brazil; C O Kunz (b. 1845, age 17, too young); C L Kunz (already eliminated).
- Carl K*nz* + b.1835 + departure 1860–1862: 1 result, C L Kunz (already eliminated).
- Carl G*ns* + b.1835 + departure 1860–1862: 1 result — Carl Gensch, age 27, residence Gartz an der Oder, Preußen (Pomerania, far northeastern Prussia near today's Polish border), occupation Seiler (rope-maker), departure 1 Jul 1862 Hamburg → Quebec on the ship Washington. Eliminated by region (Pomerania ≠ Hessen-Kassel), destination (Quebec; Quebec→St. Louis transit by 5 Aug enlistment is implausible for a sailing ship), and occupation (rope-maker ≠ Farmer).
NY 7488 — narrowed window
- Carl K* + b.1835 + arrival 1860–1862: 58 results — too many to fully transcribe but the top 30 were reviewed for K-N-Z soundex matches. Closest by ship-and-date timing: Carl Koch, age 28 (b. 1834), departure Bremen and Bremerhaven, arrival NY 25 Jun 1862 on the ship E F Gabain. Bremerhaven is the correct port for Hessen emigrants and 25 Jun 1862 → 5 Aug 1862 enlistment timeline is workable. Opened individually: Place of Origin "Wishben, Prussia" — Wischbeń is in West Prussia / today's Poland, far from Hessen-Kassel. Eliminated. Other K* arrivals in window (Klug, Klebsattel, Karig, König, Pretzer, Schade, Hiller, Heim) are post-census but none have K-N-Z soundex matching Konze, and Le Havre and Liverpool ones are filtered out as wrong departure ports.
- Christoph Konze's ship — Elise & Mathilde 9 Jun 1862, Bremen → NY: 6-page manifest image inspected directly. Christoph Konze appears on page 2. Page 2 also shows "Hermann Riemer, age 76, male, Farmer, Prussia → St. Charles" — St. Charles MO is on the Mississippi just north of St. Louis. Other K-cluster surnames not visible in the inspected pages, but full image-by-image transcription would require manual OCR re-read of all six pages.
- Christine Kunze (NY 30 Aug 1862, Bremen, ship Herzogin Von Brabant): arrives after Charles's 5 Aug 1862 enlistment date — cannot be his ship.
What this leaves
The narrowed-window sweep produced no new strong candidate. Charles is not findable in the surviving Hamburg departure index, the NY arrival index, or the NOLA arrival index under any tested name × birth year × window combination. The candidate-pool of potential ships in the narrowed Jun 1860 – Aug 1862 window has been systematically swept — every surfaced individual has been ruled out by region, destination, occupation, household structure, or timeline.
The remaining live hypotheses are now:
- Charles arrived as a passenger whose place-of-origin field was left blank on a Bremen-departed ship 1860–1862 (and is therefore not surfaceable by any place-of-origin filter).
- Charles's surname was distorted on the manifest beyond any tested wildcard or soundex bridge (e.g. "Konze" → "Hansen" → ?).
- Charles arrived under a completely different given name on the manifest (e.g. his actual baptismal name, then changed in the U.S.).
- Charles arrived via Antwerp, Le Havre, or another non-Hamburg/Bremen port whose 1860–1862 records are partially indexed.
- Charles's actual arrival was earlier than 1859, before our previously-tested window — possible but unlikely given the 1860 census negative.
The next-step paths for breaking the impasse remain: (1) FHL Salt Lake City alphabetical 15-year Hamburg index (definitive), (2) Marburg HStAM Hessian-side emigration registers under any village-level pre-emigration paper trail, (3) post-1862 records that might reference Charles's actual arrival ship (e.g. naturalization papers, witness statements, pension records).
negative Hamburg departure manifests
Hamburg State Archive's Auswanderungslisten — the most complete surviving German departure dataset, fully digitized 1850-1934 (the 1859 records sit in the third volume, covering February 1859 through November 1861). Unlike Bremen, the Hamburg lists were not destroyed — they survive in full at the Staatsarchiv Hamburg (Bestand 373-7 I, VIII Auswanderungsamt I, microfilm rolls K 1701 – K 2008). Searches conducted via:
- Ancestry · Hamburg Passenger Lists 1850-1934 — surname variants tried under birth year 1835 ± 5; no Charles match
- FamilySearch · Hamburg Passenger Lists 1850-1934 — same negative result
- Deutsche Auswanderer-Datenbank (DAD) at the Historisches Museum Bremerhaven, which aggregates Hamburg AND Bremerhaven manifest data 1820-1897 (~5 million records, covering Charles's window) — November 2025 query for "GANSEN, CARL" returned a doctor (not Charles); subsequent multi-spelling sweep also negative.
- Zenodo open-data check (May 2026): No Hamburg-equivalent of the Bremen CHUP dataset (DOI 10.5281/zenodo.17977460) has been released. The Hamburg Auswanderungslisten remain gated behind Ancestry, FamilySearch, the Hamburg State Archive's fee-paid search (ABC-Straße 19, Hamburg), and the FHL Salt Lake City microfilm collection — there is no openly-downloadable machine-readable Hamburg corpus for direct local sweep at this time.
Focused next-step path for Hamburg: the 15-year alphabetical index 1850–1871 exists on 46 microfilm reels at the Family History Library in Salt Lake City — sorted alphabetically by passenger surname rather than chronologically by departure date. A targeted FHL visit (or a Family History Center microfilm rental, where still available) under each of the ten surname variants would give a definitive yes/no across the entire 1850-1871 Hamburg corpus in a single sitting. The Hamburg State Archive's fee-paid surname search is a paid alternative (ABC-Straße 19, D-20354 Hamburg).
access update ★ 15-year Hamburg index is now DIGITIZED & online — plus two stronger finding aids surfaced (27 Jun 2026, signed-in FamilySearch catalog check)
Correcting the assumption in the pass above: the FHL Hamburg 15-year index no longer requires an in-person Salt Lake visit. The Hamburg Auswandererlisten, 1850–1934 ("The Hamburg passenger lists"; FS catalog koha:43289, 485 reels) is fully digitized, and the 15-year alphabetical card index (1856–1871, typewritten) opens in the online image viewer when signed in. Relevant reels for this case:
- G-surnames (Gans · Gansen · Gonnson · Gonsen · Ganssen) → Film 884670 / DGS 7945442 ("Fick, Maria – Hartzke, August", 5,497 images).
- K-surnames (Konze · Konzen · Kontze · Konsen) → Film 884672 / DGS 8107205 ("Katz, Samuel – Lewin, And.").
Caveat (per FamilySearch's own note): this 15-year card index is "incomplete" — the regular DIRECT and INDIRECT yearly indexes (also in koha:43289, alphabetical by first letter of the head-of-household surname) must be checked too if a passenger isn't in the card index. Status this session: the card-index images load in the viewer (Image 2701 of 5,497 rendered the viewer chrome), but the FamilySearch deep-zoom canvas could not be read via the automated screenshot tool — so the card-by-card read of the G and K leaves is the concrete now-unlocked next step for an interactive session, not a remaining archive visit.
Two stronger finding aids found in the catalog (neither previously consulted):
- The "Klüber Kartei" — Index zu Hamburger Schiffslistenkarteien, 1850–1871 — a separate DIRECT card index that FamilySearch explicitly calls "superior to the direct indexes" in koha:43289. On its own catalog record; should be browsed before the Hamburg direct lists are called negative.
- ★ Über Hamburg nach Amerika: Hessische Auswandernde in den Hamburger Schiffslisten 1855–1866 (Institut für Europäische Ethnologie und Kulturforschung der Universität Marburg; Assion et al., 1990; ISBN 3818500932; 370 pp.; FS catalog koha:737355). Its appendix is a Verzeichnis der hessischen Auswandernden with an alphabetisches Namensregister AND an Ortsregister (place index) of Hessian emigrants who left via Hamburg 1855–1866 — exactly Charles's region and window. This is the single most valuable untried aid: the Ortsregister lets you search by home village (Deisel / Trendelburg / Hofgeismar) rather than by surname, so it would surface Charles even under a garbled surname. Physical only at the FamilySearch Library, Salt Lake City (call no. 943 W3a, B2 floor) — not online (in copyright); other library copies via WorldCat. Covers Kurhessen ("Cassel — Emigration and immigration" is among its locality subjects).
negative U.S. arrival manifests
Major U.S. ports of entry searched for 1859 arrivals matching profile (German-born male, ~24 years old, surname variant):
- New York Castle Garden / NY Passenger Lists 1820-1957 — primary search target. Multiple surname variants. No match.
- New Orleans Passenger Lists 1820-1945 — secondary candidate (lower-cost passage for German emigrants who could not afford NYC route). No match.
- Baltimore Passenger Lists 1820-1872 — no match.
- Boston / New England port lists — no match.
negative Liverpool transit listings (research note, 27 Apr 2026)
Many German emigrants in 1859 transited via Liverpool to take advantage of cheaper trans-Atlantic packets. The note of 27 Apr 2026 investigated a specific candidate — Carl Kinzer / Carl Krieger on a 1859 Liverpool ship — but ruled it out as not Charles. No other Liverpool listing has surfaced a candidate match.
collateral Adjacent emigrants found
The same searches that returned negatives for Charles surfaced documented emigrants in his geographic and surname space — useful context but not Charles himself:
- Johannes Grandjot (Schöneberg → NYC, 25 Sep 1855) — Bremen → NYC arrival as "Joseph Grandjos" with co-traveler Lisette Grandjot. Demonstrates the Bremen-route record-survival pattern but is four years too early for Charles.
- Meier Meierhof (Deisel → NYC, 1854) — surfaced in the Marburg state archive emigrant register; demonstrates the Hessian-side record-survival pattern.
- 1853 Friedrichsfeld emigrant cohort (Quentin / Frickhöfer / Adolph Quentin) — surfaced in HStAM Best. 16 Nr. 3237 p. 110. Demonstrates that the Hessian emigration registers DO carry detailed records when an emigrant is registered.
The fact that contemporaneous Hessian emigrants surface cleanly while Charles does not suggests his emigration was either un-registered (illegal, see Stammrolle entry) or recorded under a surname so different from any tried variant that it remains unrecognized.
Sources / databases consulted
- Ancestry · Hamburg Passenger Lists 1850-1934
- Ancestry · NY Passenger and Immigration Lists 1820-1850
- Ancestry · NY Arriving Passenger and Crew Lists 1820-1957
- Ancestry · NY Passenger Lists Castle Garden 1820-1913
- Ancestry · New Orleans Passenger Lists 1820-1945
- Ancestry · Baltimore Passenger Lists 1820-1872
- Die Maus · Bremen genealogical society emigration database
- Deutsche Auswanderer-Datenbank (DAD) — Bremerhaven; queried Nov 2025 for "GANSEN, CARL" — returned a doctor, not Charles
- FamilySearch Full-Text Search (when available) — intermittent service issues during current sessions
Next paths to chase
- ★ Read the Marburg Hessian-emigrant index by PLACE (highest priority, new 27 Jun 2026). Über Hamburg nach Amerika: Hessische Auswandernde in den Hamburger Schiffslisten 1855–1866 (Univ. Marburg, 1990; FS catalog koha:737355; FS Library SLC call 943 W3a; copies via WorldCat). Use its Ortsregister to look up Deisel / Trendelburg / Hofgeismar directly — this bypasses the surname-spelling problem entirely and would surface Charles even if his name was garbled. Physical book only; obtain via the FS Library, a WorldCat-holding library, or interlibrary loan.
- ★ Browse the now-online Hamburg 15-year card index + the "Klüber Kartei" (new 27 Jun 2026). The 15-year index is digitized and viewable signed-in: read the G leaves (Film 884670 / DGS 7945442) and K leaves (Film 884672 / DGS 8107205) image-by-image. Then browse the separate, FS-designated "superior" direct index — the Klüber Kartei (Index zu Hamburger Schiffslistenkarteien, 1850–1871) — under each variant. These catch entries the Ancestry collection-1068 transcription may have mangled.
- Direct paid lookup at Bremen state archive — Staatsarchiv Bremen accepts genealogical queries for a fee. The Bremerhaven 1859 emigrant lists, where they survive, have not been fully searched manually.
- Hamburg state archive Auswanderungsamt I — original passenger contracts (Schiffslisten) sometimes survive separately from the indexed Hamburg passenger lists. Held under the Hamburg State Archive, accessible by mail or via on-site research.
- Antwerp / Le Havre 1859 emigrant lists — secondary departure ports for German emigrants; partially indexed. Not yet searched.
- Re-search after a German baptism record is found — once the actual surname spelling is locked in via a German-side record (parish or Stammrolle), the manifest search can be redone with the correct variant rather than the dozen guessed spellings.
Cross-references in the project
- Immigration session-notes index — full immigration-investigation arc
- The note of 27 Apr 2026 — manifest investigation (April 27)
- Sources & name-variant catalog
- Adjacent emigrations — Johannes Grandjot, Meier Meierhof, the 1853 Friedrichsfeld cohort