Charles Gannsen Research/Read the book/The Search for His Origin/Chapter 27

The Candidates and How They Were Ruled Out

This chapter is printed here in full, as it stands in the public edition of the book (build of 19 November 2026). Corrections made since printing are listed under errata.

For most of its length, the search for Charles’s German baptism has been a search for other boys. These were boys of the right name, born in the right years in the right villages, and any one of them was possibly the man who enlisted in St. Louis in 1862. This chapter asks which of them could still be Charles. The answer so far is that twenty-seven of the boys of Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld are still open, and one of them stands first.

In this chapter
  1. Where the candidates came from
  2. The ten main candidates, and one possible father
  3. Where the boys of the three parishes stand
  4. The names still open, and one closed
  5. How the open boys rank
  6. If he is hidden: other names and other fathers
  7. Notes
  8. About the pictures
  9. All the boys still open
  10. More of the chapter, as printed until 28 October 2026
  11. More of the chapter, as printed until 30 October 2026
  12. Supplements

Where the candidates came from

The candidates came from three directions: a regional database, the parish registers and Charles’s American records.

The first was a computer search of the late Mr. Dornette’s regional database of births, deaths and marriages, for Gottsbüren and the surrounding parishes. Of 115 boys named Carl or Karl born there between 1833 and 1841, 36 vanished from the local records, as an emigrant would.1 But most boys of that generation vanish from the database whether they emigrated or not, so a boy who “vanishes” is a boy to be researched, not a boy shown to have left.2

The second was the registers themselves. The search read the entry of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel, and Friedrichsfeld with a birth date between 1833 and 1841, in the register images. There were 426, and the search followed each one forward.3 The confirmation classes of Trendelburg and Deisel, which list boys at about fourteen, added boys who had been baptized somewhere else. The search read the 1845–58 classes in the surrounding parishes the same way, and those classes also added boys baptized elsewhere.4

Map of the parishes around Trendelburg and Deisel, between the Diemel and the Weser, each marked by how far its baptism registers of 1833–41 have been read: a solid dot for read entry by entry, a half-filled dot for read entry by entry in a register with gaps, and an open ring for read only for the likely boys. Stars mark Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld.
Map 27.1. The parishes searched for Charles Gannsen’s baptism. Registers of 1833–41. Stars mark Trendelburg and Deisel, the places he named, and Friedrichsfeld. A solid dot marks a register read entry by entry, a half dot one read entry by entry but with gaps in the register, and an open ring one read only for the likely boys, with a full read still owed. Beberbeck births were entered in the Gottsbüren register. Map by the author, 2026. Rivers and place positions: © OpenStreetMap contributors, ODbL.

The third was the American side: the age Charles gave at enlistment, the initials C. L., the surname forms of his records and the date of 26 January. A Carl Ludwig, a Konze, a boy born near 26 January or a boy born about 1839 moved up the list.

A boy who lived to adulthood is ruled out only by an adult record, read in the image, that matches his baptism on at least three independent identifiers. The appendix “How the Research Was Done” sets out that standard.5 Some early eliminations fell short of it, and the search later reopened them. The search re-examined the eleven eliminations on which it most depends, each from its own register image: the ten candidates and the one possible father below. Ten met the standard at once, and the eleventh, the candidate Breitwieser, was traced further until it did too.6

The birthday has also been tested alone. Every boy born within a day or two of 26 January in the parishes around Trendelburg was looked at, whatever his name, because that day and month are the one precise fact the family supplied. The list is short, and most of the boys on it died young or can be followed to an adult life at home. Only one Deisel boy was born on the day itself: F. W. Köster, born 26 January 1838, who died at Deisel in 1894.7 But Charles’s entry in the 1900 census gives November instead, and November counts for more (see “Where and When He Was Born”).8 Of the eight open boys born in wedlock and named Carl, who are named below, two were born in November.9

The ten main candidates, and one possible father

Johann Carl Ludwig Konze of Trendelburg was re-examined with the candidates, although he was never a candidate himself. He was born in 1814 and so was too old to be Charles, but the search tested him as a possible father. The chapter “The Name He Used: Gans, Konze or Another Name” describes his family at Bremen and in St. Louis, and nothing in its records connects it with Charles.10

The search took each of the ten men in table 27.1 seriously for a time, and it ruled each one out by the same standard.11

Dozens more boys were examined and set aside more briefly. A death or marriage in Germany closed most of them, and an American life under their own names closed a few.12 These eliminations showed two things. The first is that misreadings created candidates: “Ganzen” was Henze, and “Jansen” was Person. Each time, the error was corrected by reading the image at full magnification and finding a second record. The second is that the boys who emigrated usually kept their German names in America. Charles’s German surname should therefore be one that could become Gannsen, Gonson, or Konsen in his own signature and in American clerks’ records. Gans and Konze both fit, and a boy raised under another family’s name would be the exception.

Table 27.1. The ten main candidates, and what ruled each one out

CandidateBornWhy he was consideredWhat ruled him out
Karl KonzeDeisel, 1839the right surname and agebecame a teacher; married at Wölfterode in 1865 and died at Homberg an der Efze in 192013
Karl Person (once read “Jansen”)Deisel, 1836a misreading as “Jansen,” the form at two of Charles’s children’s baptisms, suggested a linka smith; died at Kassel on 31 October 189814
Carl Wilhelm Henze (once read “Ganzen”)Trendelburg, 1835a misreading produced a Gans-like namea postal official; died at Frankfurt am Main in 189215
Carl Wilhelm Richard MeerkammTrendelburg, 1839Carl, untraced after confirmationa day laborer at Trendelburg in 1865–⁠66; married at Hofgeismar in 188616
Wilhelm Johannes FaehlingTrendelburg, 1836untraced after confirmationa farmhand; died at Lippoldsberg on 1 January 190117
Karl Ludwig KöhlerSielen, 1839a Carl Ludwig who emigratedwent to Iowa; a merchant at Des Moines, swore to his Sielen birth in 189218
Karl Wilhelm KochDeisel, 1841a Deisel Carl of the right agea shepherd; died at Deisel in 191719
Ferdinand MartinDeisel, 1839born 27 Nov 1839, untraced locallydied at Offenbach am Main in 191120
Carl Ludwig Wilhelm Helmbrecht genannt WeikeFriedrichsfeld, 1835born 1835 out of wedlock, a changed namedied at Friedrichsfeld on 11 April 187521
Carl Wilhelm Theodor BreitwieserFriedrichsfeld, 1833a Carl who emigrated in the right yearswent to California; naturalized at San Francisco in November 1865, while Charles was still in the army22

Sources: compiled by the author from the German and American records cited in each candidate’s row.

Where the boys of the three parishes stand

Table 27.2 shows where the 426 boys stand, parish by parish. “Probably traced” means the match is graded probably, not proven, and the table counts such a boy as open.23

Table 27.2. Boys born 1833–41 in the three home parishes, and where they stand

ParishBoys born 1833–⁠41Died youngTraced as adultsProbably tracedUntracedOf the untraced, Carls born in wedlock
Trendelburg14860760126
Deisel235711502122
Friedrichsfeld431923100
Total4261502493248

Source: the ledger of the boys, compiled by the author from the parish registers; dataset D124.

Note: all figures are numbers of boys.

Flow diagram: the 426 boys from baptism to died in childhood, traced as adults (stayed, moved, emigrated) and still open
Figure 27.1. How the 426 boys baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld in 1833–41 were followed: 150 died in childhood and 249 were traced as adults. Twenty-seven are still open. The dashed box gives the twenty neighboring parishes, the search’s first ring (Ring 1), for comparison.25 Sources: the ledger of the boys (dataset D1), every boy read in the register pages; the Ring 1 reads for the dashed box. Chart by the author.

The chart sorts the boys by what became of them (figure 27.1). Of the 426, 150, about one in three, died in childhood. Of the 249 followed to an adult life, about seven in ten lived out their lives in Germany. Of those, 155 stayed at home or at a place not named, and 27 in a named German town or Prussia, among them the Ruhr, Hamburg and Kassel. Sixty-seven went overseas, forty-eight of them from Deisel.26

An open boy could be a child who died where no one has looked, but that explains few of the open boys. Eighteen of the twenty-seven open boys were confirmed or appear as adults, so they lived to 14. The other nine belonged mostly to families that moved away, and about one of them (between none and three) probably died young somewhere no one has looked.27

A missing release proves nothing about Charles. Many boys of these villages left without one: of the 28 boys known from American records and the 1900 court summons to have gone overseas, 12 have no release in the index. That is nearly half.28

The search then moved one ring out, to the twenty parishes next to the home villages (the “first ring” of the search), in case Charles was born just outside the home parishes. It has now read all twenty-two of their baptism registers twice, entry by entry, and the appendix “How the Research Was Done” charts the result parish by parish. Of the 3,231 boys they baptized in 1833–41, only 22 have a note that they left for America. Another 22 have since been found in American records.29 In all, 1,194 are still open (9 of them probably traced). An open boy is not a candidate by default: he is a boy whose later life no record has yet shown.30

The names still open, and one closed

Of the twenty-four untraced boys of the three parishes, eight are Carls born in wedlock and two are boys born out of wedlock, who are described below. The other fourteen have no Carl among their names.31 The eight boys named Carl or Karl cannot yet be followed to an adult life that rules them out. Two are from Deisel. Karl Ludwig Hofedietz, born 13 November 1837, was orphaned at six. Karl Justus August Konrad Brandau (1837), a teacher’s son, very probably sailed from Hamburg for New York as a saddler in October 1856.32 No record of his life in America has come to light. Six are from Trendelburg: Friedrich Carl Wilhelm August Zollmann (1836); the brothers Hieronymus Carl (1837) and Franz Carl Gustav Kayser (1838); Carl Wilhelm Lucas (1837); Heinrich Friedrich Carl Meier (1838); and Carl Ludwig Martini (1834). Martini was a surgeon’s son who left for America in 1854. A Charles L. Martini of about his age was in the cigar trade in St. Louis from 1865 to 1897, but he was very probably another man (see “The Boy from the Goose Corner”).33 The 1900 court notice that summoned Karl Ludwig Hofedietz also named Julius and Eduard Martini as missing. They were very probably two of Carl Ludwig Martini’s elder brothers, but the notice does not name Carl Ludwig Martini himself.34

None of the eight was born within a week of 26 January, and none bears a surname that leads to Gannsen, Gans, or Konze, though some had Konze kin. Most of them stay on the list because a boy is open until a record closes him, not for any likeness to Charles.35

Karl Ludwig Hofedietz is the only open Carl Ludwig from Deisel. He is also the only one of the eight whose 1900 court notice names a Konze as the curator of his affairs.36 The chapter “The Boy from the Goose Corner” sets out the case that he was possibly Charles, and what stands against it.37

The fourteen boys with no Carl in their names rank below the Carls, but a man could change or add a forename, so these boys stay open. From Deisel they are Karl Ludwig’s brother Friedrich Wilhelm Hofedietz (1833), Friedrich Lauterbach (1834), Philipp Meimbresse and Ludwig Bonhagen (1835), Friedrich Georg Käufer (1837), Heinrich Koch (1838), Heinrich Gräbe and Theodor Thiele (1839), and another Friedrich Wilhelm Hofedietz, of a different family (1841). From Trendelburg they are Friedrich Louis Albrecht (1836), Friedrich Wilhelm Eduard Rode and Johann Georg Flothe (1839), and Heinrich Wilhelm Albrecht and Georg Christian Meier (1840).38

Ludwig Koch of Deisel (1836), once counted among them, has since been ruled out. He married at Deisel in November 1861, a year before Charles enlisted, and he was still living there in October 1900, when his wife died and he reported her death. Several men named Ludwig Koch lived at Deisel in those years, so no record yet shows which of them was the shepherd Ludwig Koch who was godfather there in 1863 and 1866.39

Three boys are probably traced. Heinrich Köster of Deisel (1833) was probably the tailor of that name who sailed to New York in 1854.40 Johann Wilhelm Steitz of Deisel (1837) was probably the “William Stutz,” eighteen (Steitz, born in December 1837, would have been sixteen), who died at Charleston, South Carolina, in September 1854. Ferdinand Klapp of Friedrichsfeld (1835) was probably the young man of that family who sailed in 1854 and was naturalized at New York in 1860. Two boys once counted in this group have left it. Johann Georg Flothe of Trendelburg (1839), an innkeeper’s son, was once counted as George Floether, a barber who died at Louisville, Kentucky, in January 1901. But Floether was probably the son of a tailor of Wilhelmshausen, on the Fulda in Kreis Hofgeismar, Kurhessen (now part of Fuldatal), baptized there in December 1839, so Flothe is untraced again.41 Philipp Wilhelm Köster of Deisel (1836) has been ruled out, because he married at Helmarshausen in February 1863, two months after Charles enlisted at St. Louis.42

One boy who headed the list for a long time has been closed. Carl Ludwig August Aderholz of Trendelburg (1838) was the factory worker Carl August Aderholz who married at Hörde in Westphalia on 14 December 1862, twelve days after Charles enlisted at St. Louis. The groom gave his age as twenty-six, two years too many, but three things tie him to the Trendelburg baptism. The first is his names, Carl and August. The second is his birthplace, which the banns give as Trendelburg in Kreis Hofgeismar. The third is his family. His brother Carl Wilhelm had married at Hörde the year before as a son of Christian Aderholz and Dorothea Henriette Brasenne of Trendelburg, who are the parents named at Carl Ludwig August’s baptism. A man married in Westphalia that December cannot be Charles.43

The indexes of the 1874–1900 Kassel civil marriage registers, some 13,700 marriages, and a machine reading of their typed copies were also checked for every open boy. None of them was found, but an index search is a pointer, not proof.44

How the open boys rank

Twenty-seven boys baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel, or Friedrichsfeld between 1833 and 1841 are still open, three of them probably traced. The confirmation classes of those churches and of Langenthal, Sielen and Stammen added six more boys born elsewhere or just outside those years, and three of them are still open. One of them, Georg Carl Quentin (1831), is probably traced.45 Table 27.3 lists the five of the twenty-seven boys of the home parishes who rank highest in the weighing of the clues. The evidence grid in the appendix “How the Research Was Done” shows all thirty, each boy from the confirmation classes marked with an asterisk (*).46

The ranking sets only the order of work: it rules no boy out and identifies no one, and a rank is not the chance that a boy was Charles. It weighs the clues in Charles’s records against how often the same clues turn up among the boys of these villages. The birth month counts for more than the birth day, as “Where and When He Was Born” explains. The table lists the boys in the order of that weighing, made from the judgments of the author and two blind reviewers, neither of whom knew which boy any answer would help. The weighing was revised after tests on sealed cases, and every open boy’s Konze ties were then weighed by one rule. The appendix “How the Research Was Done” sets out the method, each clue’s weight, the assumptions behind it and the figures for the order, under its search criteria and method.47

Two conditions limit the ranking. The first boy’s lead over the second, Karl Brandau, no longer rests on the middle initial alone. With the initial given no weight he still comes first; only a C read as Brandau’s Konrad puts Brandau first. The table also assumes that Charles was right about where he was born. If he was born somewhere else, he is none of these boys, and his baptism is in a register this table does not cover; the appendix weighs that case as well.48

Key. Rank: the boy’s place in the weighing. Why: the clues that weigh most; anything not weighed is marked as context. The italic line under each name says where the search found him: in the baptisms, in the confirmation classes, or both. Ref: the boy’s number in the search’s ledger of the boys (DE, Deisel; TR, Trendelburg).

Table 27.3. The open boys who rank highest, and what would settle each

Fit and shareBoyWhyLast recordWhat would settle it
FirstKarl Ludwig Hofedietz
b. 13 Nov 1837, Deisel
Ricus Hofedietz, coachman × Amalie Weller
baptisms and confirmation classes
Carl Ludwig; a Carl at Deisel, where the name was rare; November birth; orphaned at six; a Konze curator in 1900, weighed as weak, and a probable Konze neighbor. Context, not weighed: still missing in 1900. The leading candidate (see “The Boy from the Goose Corner”)conf. Deisel 1852Karlshafen court, his guardianship file, 1843–⁠60 (HStAM 275); a DNA test of a descendant of his sisters
SecondKarl Justus August Konrad Brandau
b. 11 Jul 1837, Deisel
Johannes Brandau, teacher × J. M. C. Stephan
baptisms and confirmation classes
Carl, at Deisel, where the name was rare; left 1856, close to Charles’s 1859; probably born next door to a Konze house. Context, not weighed: the later name Konradvery probably sailed Hamburg to New York, Oct–Nov 1856A record of his life after November 1856, in America or in Germany; none found in the census, directory and pension indexes searched
Third to fifthCarl Ludwig Martini
b. 1 Dec 1834, Trendelburg
Philipp Eberhard Martini, surgeon × Gertrude Schember
baptisms and confirmation classes
Carl Ludwig; Trendelburg; left 1854emigrated to America, 1854A record of his arrival or of his life in America after 1854. The 1860 census indexes show no Carl Martini born in Hesse (index only); a Charles Martini of about his age, a saloon keeper in St. Louis, was born in Saxony.49 The Karlshafen court’s files on his mother’s 1857 estate and on the curatorship of Julius and Eduard Martini (HStAM 275)
Third to fifthCarl Wilhelm Lucas
b. 25 May 1837, Trendelburg
David Lucas, farmer (d. 1842) × Maria Sophie Wendel
baptisms and confirmation classes
Carl; Trendelburg; orphaned in 1847, at ten; a possible Konze tie through a curator named at his mother’s burial and through his godfatherconf. Trendelburg 1851Trendelburg court, guardianship of the Lucas children, 1842–⁠51 (HStAM 330)
Third to fifthHeinrich Friedrich Carl Meier
b. 27 Nov 1838, Trendelburg
G. H. A. Meier, shepherd (d. 1842) × Regina Widdig
baptisms only
Carl; Trendelburg; November birth; his father dead from 1842baptismTrendelburg court, guardianship of the Meier children, 1842 ff. (HStAM 330)

Source: the weighing of the clues, pooled judgments50; ledger of the boys51.

Note: the order is that of the weighing of the clues. The last three boys are too close to tell apart. Each boy’s figures, with their ranges, are in the table “The five open boys who fit Charles’s clues best” in the appendix “How the Research Was Done.”

Karl Brandau ranks second in the pooled weighing because he too is a Carl of Deisel, where the name was rare. His leaving is also on record: he was a saddler of nineteen who very probably sailed from Hamburg for New York in October 1856.52 But no record ties him to St. Louis or to the name Gannsen, and his birthday, 11 July, matches neither of those in Charles’s records.53 In 1900 his sister applied to the court to have him declared dead and stated that nothing had been heard of him since about 1856.54 He is still open, and he is Karl Ludwig’s nearest rival. A record of his later life, in America or in Germany, would settle his case, but none has been found.55

If he is hidden: other names and other fathers

Charles was probably not born in wedlock to any of the Konze fathers who baptized children in these parishes in the 1830s. The chapter “The Name He Used: Gans, Konze or Another Name” shows why.56 But the name could still be his in several ways, and the same is true of Gans.

A boy born out of wedlock to a Konze father would be baptized under another surname. A boy raised in a Konze household as a stepson or a foster son could use that name in America without ever having been baptized under it. A boy could also carry his mother’s surname. Each has happened to other boys in the same registers.57

One open boy of Trendelburg has a Konze ancestor. He is Friedrich Carl Wilhelm August Zollmann (1836), one of the Carls named above, whose grandmother was a Konze. A second, Carl Wilhelm Lucas (1837), possibly has a Konze link too. A curator named at his mother’s burial in 1847 was probably the brother of a man who married a Konze in 1860. In 1833 a man of his godfather’s name was a sponsor for the son of a Jungkonze marriage.58

From the start the search has allowed that Charles was possibly born out of wedlock and baptized under a name he did not later use. Of the 426 boys of the three parishes, 48 were born out of wedlock, about one in nine, close to the rate for all of Niederhessen (see the chapter “Kurhessen: Deisel and Trendelburg, c. 1835–1858”).59 Forty-five have been followed to a later record or an early death.60 Two are still untraced as adults: Heinrich Ludwig of Trendelburg (1834), recorded without a surname, and Heinrich Karl of Deisel (1836), whose surname was Karl.61 One more, Heinrich Köster of Deisel (1833), is probably traced.62

One man of Charles’s own district shows how completely a name could change. Andreas August Gans, son of the turner Georg Friedrich Gans, was born at Oedelsheim on the Weser, near Karlshafen, on 25 February 1835. He was confirmed there in 1849 and then vanishes from the registers.63 In June 1880 his sister Caroline advertised for him in the German papers of New Orleans and Baltimore: “August Andreas Gans, genannt Willy Johnson oder Jansen,” August Andreas Gans, called Willy Johnson or Jansen.64 He had taken a new first name, and his surname had become the two forms the St. Louis records give Charles. He was probably not Charles, because he was not a Carl and his sister sought him as Willy, a first name no record of Charles gives. He is still untraced. But he shows that a Gans of Charles’s age and district could live in America as a Johnson under another first name, and leave nothing in the German registers to say so.

Of all these boys, one stands first: Karl Ludwig Hofedietz of Deisel, the orphan whose affairs a Konze looked after in 1900.65 No record yet follows him after he left Deisel, and none proves him Charles. The next chapter tells his story.

Notes

65 notes
  1. Database of births, deaths and marriages for Gottsbüren and the surrounding parishes (“Gottsbüren und Umgebung”). [Gottsbüren database (Dornette)]
  2. The vanished Carls: ledger of the 36 Carl/Karl births of 1833–41 in the Dornette database with no local death or marriage, each traced forward in registers, civil records, LAGIS Hessische Auswanderer and American records, with the coverage measurements of July–August 2026, among them the base rate measured on 2 August 2026 (of 110 Trendelburg births of 1830–1840, 79.1 percent have no death or marriage row with the same birth date); as of 10 Oct 2026; “The Vanished Karls,” Charles Gannsen Research, https://charles-research.netlify.app/vanished-karls.html : accessed 7 November 2026. [VK]
  3. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [LEDGER]
  4. Trendelburg “Konfirmationen 1831–1914” [Confirmations 1831–1914] (Archion register 220102), classes 1847–56, including Whitsun 1849 (image 2270–2271) and 1850 (images 2273–2275); Deisel “Konfirmationen 1831–1926” [Confirmations 1831–1926] (Archion register 218836), classes 1847–56; imaged, Archion (https://www.archion.de/de/viewer/churchRegister/220102, https://www.archion.de/de/viewer/churchRegister/218836 : accessed 2 August 2026) > Hessen > Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck > Kirchenkreis Hofgeismar, by the register numbers given; citing Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck, Kassel; Confirmation registers read entry by entry in the pages for the classes 1845–1858: Hümme (Archion register 219529), Gottsbüren (219046), Bad Karlshafen (218674, 218707), Hofgeismar Altstadt (219259) and Neustadt (219358, to 1855), Helmarshausen (219208), Grebenstein (219097), Eberschütz (218884, to 1855), Niedermeiser (219874, to 1856), Veckerhagen (220207, to 1856), Zwergen (220357), Udenhausen (220141), Vaake (220171), Hohenkirchen (219412, to 1857), Obermeiser (219907, to 1856), Westuffeln (220300), Carlsdorf (218806), Calden (218776), Griemelsheim (219145), Knickhagen (219643), Ehrsten (218917, to 1856), Fürstenwald (218983, to 1856), Wilhelmshausen (220324, to 1856), Schachten (219991, to 1856), Burguffeln (218749, to 1857), Ersen (218947, to 1855), Mönchehof (219850, to 1855) and Wilhelmsthal (220345, images 390–393; no boy confirmed 1845–1858). The classes of these outer parishes from 1856 or 1857 to 1860 were read later, without result (Oct 2026): Ehrsten, Fürstenwald, Wilhelmshausen, Schachten, Burguffeln, Ersen, Mönchehof, Eberschütz, Niedermeiser and Veckerhagen; imaged, Archion (https://www.archion.de : accessed 2 November 2026) > Hessen > Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck > Kirchenkreis Hofgeismar, by the register numbers given; citing Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck, Kassel. [TDCONF] [CONFRING]
  5. Working positions of the research, October 2026. [DEC]
  6. Re-examination, 10 Oct 2026, of the eleven key eliminations against the three-identifier image standard. [AUDIT]
  7. Ev. Kirchengemeinde Oedelsheim, “Taufen 1830–1877” [Baptisms 1830–1877] (Archion register 219946), image 678, entry 125, and “Beerdigungen 1830–1899” [Burials 1830–1899] (Archion register 219952), image 2230, 1838, p. 40, no. 182, Friedrich Carl August Wessel; January leaves 1833–41 of the Oedelsheim baptisms read in the images; imaged, Archion (https://www.archion.de/de/viewer/churchRegister/219946, https://www.archion.de/de/viewer/churchRegister/219952 : accessed 8 October 2026) > Hessen > Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck > Kirchenkreis Hofgeismar > Oedelsheim, by the register numbers given; citing Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck, Kassel; Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41; Evangelische Kirchengemeinde Hofgeismar (Altstadt) (Hofgeismar, Kreis Hofgeismar, Kurhessen), “Taufen 1830–1843” [Baptisms 1830–1843] (Archion register 219265), image 846, no. 469, Johann Friedrich Ludwig Janson, born 7 Jan, baptized 22 Jan 1837; imaged, Archion (https://www.archion.de/de/viewer/churchRegister/219265 : accessed 7 October 2026) > Hessen > Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck > Kirchenkreis Hofgeismar > Hofgeismar (Altstadt) > Taufen 1830-1843; citing Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck, Kassel. A register could leave a birth out. The second copies the parishes sent to the government, which would show it, have not been read for these parishes, and the Kassel garrison register for 1834 was lost in the war. [WESSEL] [LEDGER] [JANSON]
  8. 1900 U.S. census, City of St. Louis, Missouri, population schedule, Ward 9, ED 129, sheet 5-B (penned). In June 1900 he was boarding at 170 Sidney Street. [C1900]
  9. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [LEDGER]
  10. HStAM Best. 180 Hofgeismar Nr. 56, fol. 5–6, no. 39; Holy Ghost Evangelical Church (St. Louis, Missouri), marriages, FamilySearch image group number (IGN) 7857117, image 663, no. 1268 (1865) and image 715, no. 354 (31 May 1870); Missouri death certificate of Louise Wist, 1924; death and obituary of Wilhelmina Hansen, Sioux City, Iowa, 1917; imaged, FamilySearch (https://www.familysearch.org : accessed 10 October 2026), by the image group numbers and images given; Anton Wilhelm Konze: born 12 Sep 1806, baptized 17 Sep 1806, image 1059, p. 151. [JCL] [HG] [AWK]
  11. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [LEDGER]
  12. The vanished Carls: ledger of the 36 Carl/Karl births of 1833–41 in the Dornette database with no local death or marriage. [VK]
  13. Standesamt Homberg (Efze), death register 1920, no. 45, Karl Konze, d. 23 Sep 1920 (HStAM Best. 920 Nr. 3597, image 164; https://digitalisate-he.arcinsys.de/hstam/920/3597/max/00164.jpg : accessed 8 November 2026); Evangelische Kirchengemeinde Wölfterode (Wölfterode, Kreis Rotenburg, Kurhessen), “Kirchenbuch 1830–1996” [Church book 1830–1996] (Archion register 179531), image 417, marriages p. 17, no. 48, 11 Jun 1865, Karl Konze and Elisabeth Amalie Heise; Homberg (Efze) civil deaths of Karl Konze, 24 Sep 1920, no. 45 (HStAM Best. 920 Nr. 3597, image 164), and of Elisabeth Amalie Konze geb. Heise, 1914, and civil marriages of the children, 1902 and 1903 (HStAM Best. 920); imaged, Archion (https://www.archion.de/de/viewer/churchRegister/179531 : accessed 10 October 2026) > Hessen > Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck > Kirchenkreis Rotenburg > Wölfterode > Kirchenbuch 1830-1996; citing Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck, Kassel. [HOMBERG] [WOELF]
  14. Evangelische Kirchengemeinde Deisel (Deisel, Kreis Hofgeismar, Kurhessen), “Taufen 1830–1861” [Baptisms 1830–1861] (Archion register 218842), image 51; Standesamt Kassel I, death register 1898, no. 1357, Carl Person, d. 31 Oct 1898 (HStAM Best. 910 Nr. 5439, image 156). [PERSON] [KASSEL]
  15. Standesamt Frankfurt am Main I, death register 1892, no. 3765, Carl Wilhelm Henze, entry of 19 Dec 1892 (HStAM Best. 903 Nr. 10456, image 89); imaged, “Hesse, Germany, Deaths, 1851–1958,” Ancestry, Frankfurt am Main, 1892, image 2465 of 2754 (https://www.ancestry.com/imageviewer/collections/61119/images/47106_b306405-00089 : accessed 8 November 2026); Evangelische Kirchengemeinde Trendelburg (Trendelburg, Kreis Hofgeismar, Kurhessen), “Taufen 1830–1863” [Baptisms 1830–1863] (Archion register 220108), p. 37, no. 123, image 1415, Carl Wilhelm Henze, born 8 Jan 1835; Trendelburg confirmations, Whitsun 1849 (Archion register 220102, image 2270); imaged, Archion (https://www.archion.de/de/viewer/churchRegister/220108, https://www.archion.de/de/viewer/churchRegister/220102 : accessed 2 August 2026) > Hessen > Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck > Kirchenkreis Hofgeismar > Trendelburg, by the register numbers given; citing Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck, Kassel. [FRANKFURT] [HENZE]
  16. Evangelische Kirchengemeinde Trendelburg (Trendelburg, Kreis Hofgeismar, Kurhessen), “Beerdigungen 1830–1877” [Burials 1830–1877] (Archion register 220114), images 885 and 891, stillborn daughters of Karl Wilhelm Richard Meerkamm, 13 Jun 1865 and 11 Nov 1866; imaged, Archion (https://www.archion.de/de/viewer/churchRegister/220114 : accessed 9 October 2026) > Hessen > Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck > Kirchenkreis Hofgeismar > Trendelburg > Beerdigungen 1830-1877; citing Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck, Kassel; Standesamt Hofgeismar, marriage register (Heiratsnebenregister) 1886, no. 5, 14 Mar 1886, Karl Wilhelm Richard Meerkamm and Sophie Luise Scheele (HStAM Best. 909 Nr. 4458, images 13–14); imaged, Arcinsys Hessen (https://digitalisate-he.arcinsys.de/hstam/909/4458/max/00013.jpg and https://digitalisate-he.arcinsys.de/hstam/909/4458/max/00014.jpg : accessed 7 November 2026). [MEERKBUR] [HOFG86]
  17. Standesamt Lippoldsberg, death register (Sterbenebenregister) 1901, no. 1, Wilhelm Fehling, d. 1 Jan 1901 (HStAM Best. 909 Nr. 6615, image 3; https://digitalisate-he.arcinsys.de/hstam/909/6615/max/00003.jpg : accessed 8 November 2026). [LIPP01]
  18. Karl Ludwig Köhler, baptism, 19 March 1839, p. 38, no. 175. Passport application no. 41966 (1892), NARA M1372, roll 395, image 716 of 736 (FamilySearch, https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3QS7-L9D6-492G : accessed 4 November 2026). Evangelische Kirchengemeinde Sielen (Sielen, Kreis Hofgeismar, Kurhessen), “Taufen 1830–1876” [Baptisms 1830–1876] (Archion register 220042), no. 175 (image 1866), Karl Ludwig Köhler, born 19 Mar 1839, remark “Nach Amerika ausgewandert”; LAGIS Hessische Auswanderer, 1857 (HStAM Best. 16 Nr. 3239, p. 550); imaged, Archion (https://www.archion.de/de/viewer/churchRegister/220042 : accessed 7 October 2026) > Hessen > Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck > Kirchenkreis Hofgeismar > Sielen > Taufen 1830-1876; citing Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck, Kassel. [KAHLER] [KOEHLER]
  19. Standesamt Deisel, death register 1917, no. 30, Karl Koch, shepherd, born at Deisel, d. 4 Dec 1917 (HStAM Best. 909 Nr. 975, image 32; “Hesse, Germany, Deaths, 1851-1958,” Ancestry, https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/61119/, image 47890_b370434-00032, accessed 30 October 2026). The entry gives his age as 77, which would put his birth in 1840; his baptism gives 1841; Standesamt Deisel, marriage register 1909, no. 12, 1 Aug 1909, Philipp Heinrich Koch and Marie Wilhelmine Meimbresse (HStAM Best. 909 Nr. 907, image 24; https://digitalisate-he.arcinsys.de/hstam/909/907/max/00024.jpg : accessed 9 November 2026). [DEISEL17] [DEISEL09]
  20. Standesamt Offenbach am Main, death register 1911, no. 1014, Ferdinand Martin, d. 22 Dec 1911 (Hessisches Staatsarchiv Darmstadt, Best. 670/918); imaged, “Hesse, Germany, Deaths, 1851-1958,” Ancestry, Offenbach am Main > 1911, image 1019 (https://www.ancestry.com/imageviewer/collections/61119/images/offenbach-am-main_670_1911-00517 : accessed 8 November 2026). [OFFENB]
  21. Evangelische Kirchengemeinde Friedrichsfeld (Friedrichsfeld, Kreis Hofgeismar, Kurhessen), “Kirchenbuch 1830–2011” [Church book 1830–2011], section “Todtenbuch” [Death book] (Archion register 218959). [TODT]
  22. 1900 U.S. census, Alameda Co., Calif., Washington Township, sheet 3-A, line 38 (Ancestry, image 4118417_00598, https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/7602/ : accessed 30 October 2026); California Great Registers, Alameda Co., 1879–88, p. 19, no. 1421 (Ancestry, image 32421_227293-00295, https://www.ancestry.com/imageviewer/collections/2221/images/32421_227293-00295 : accessed 18 November 2026) and 1892 (Mission Precinct); California Death Index 1905–39, p. 1177 (“Brestwisser, Charles W.”, d. 11 Jan 1929, cert. 548); San Francisco Examiner, 14 Jan 1929, p. 4 (Newspapers.com image 457470150, https://www.newspapers.com/image/457470150/ : accessed 30 October 2026); J. M. Guinn, History of the State of California and Biographical Record of Coast Counties, California (Chicago: Chapman, 1904), vol. 2, pp. 677–678, “Charles W. Breitwieser.” [ALAMEDA] [GUINN]
  23. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [LEDGER]
  24. Jed Johnson, comp., “Boys baptized at Deisel, Trendelburg and Friedrichsfeld, 1833–1841,” dataset compiled for this book. [DSFATES]
  25. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41; Jed Johnson, comp., “Boys baptized at Deisel, Trendelburg and Friedrichsfeld, 1833–1841,” dataset compiled for this book; Baptism registers of the Ring 1 parishes read twice, 1833–41. The boys were born 1833–41. Of the 276 who lived past childhood, 249 were traced as adults: 155 stayed in Germany, 27 moved to a named German town or Prussia, and 67 went overseas. Each boy is placed by the record that closes him; the groups were assigned from the wording of each boy’s trace record, with seven corrections by hand, and “stayed in Germany” includes men who died as adults at home. Of the open boys, 3 are probably traced and 24 untraced, 8 of them Carls born in wedlock. The boys still open are not a fair sample of the 426: they are the ones no later record has yet reached. [LEDGER] [DSFATES] [R1READS]
  26. Jed Johnson, comp., “Boys baptized at Deisel, Trendelburg and Friedrichsfeld, 1833–1841,” dataset compiled for this book. [DSFATES]
  27. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41; Database of births, deaths and marriages for Gottsbüren and the surrounding parishes (“Gottsbüren und Umgebung”). The estimate assumes that the nine died like the boys who stayed. Of the 426 boys, about one in five died in his first year, and about one in three before 14. The Dornette death list cannot settle it: it holds only about a third of the child deaths that the registers show. [LEDGER] [Gottsbüren database (Dornette)]
  28. Landesgeschichtliches Informationssystem Hessen (LAGIS), Hessische Auswanderer, Nr. 128; Deutscher Reichsanzeiger und Preußischer Staatsanzeiger, Nr. 54, 1 Mar 1900, images 14–15; Jed Johnson, comp., “Boys baptized at Deisel, Trendelburg and Friedrichsfeld, 1833–1841,” dataset compiled for this book. An estimate built on the overlap suggests about thirty more boys of the 426 went overseas unseen (13 to 67; twenty-two if only the firm identifications are counted), about the number of open boys. The estimate is rough, because the two kinds of record were not searched independently. The appendix “How the Research Was Done” charts it. [LAGIS59] [RA1900] [DSFATES]
  29. Jed Johnson, comp., searches of American records for the boys of the Ring 1 parishes. [R1US]
  30. Baptism registers of the Ring 1 parishes read twice, 1833–41. The reads were made mostly by readers who did not see each other’s work; the appendix “How the Research Was Done” gives the exceptions. Of the boys, 1,357 died in Germany, nearly all as children, and 622 were traced as adults there. Fourteen entries are unclear. Some of the burial checks behind these figures have so far been read only once. [R1READS]
  31. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [LEDGER]
  32. Staatsarchiv Hamburg, Auswanderungsamt, 373-7 I, VIII A 1 Band 010, p. 788; Passenger list of the Donau, arrived New York 15 November 1856, line 255, roll 168. [HAMB56] [NYARR56]
  33. Charles L. Martini of St. Louis, cigar maker and dealer, p. 9, dwelling 40, lines 1–5. St. Louis city directories, “Martini Charles L.,” cigar trade, from a volume Ancestry dates 1865 (p. 500) to Gould’s for 1897 (p. 1125). [MARTSTL]
  34. Deutscher Reichsanzeiger und Preußischer Staatsanzeiger, Nr. 54, 1 Mar 1900, images 14–15; Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. Several boys once on this list have since been closed by later records. [RA1900] [LEDGER]
  35. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [LEDGER]
  36. Deutscher Reichsanzeiger und Preußischer Staatsanzeiger, Nr. 54, 1 Mar 1900, images 14–15. [RA1900]
  37. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [LEDGER]
  38. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [LEDGER]
  39. Evangelische Kirchengemeinde Deisel, “Beerdigungen 1876–1956” [Burials 1876–1956] (Archion register 218854), image 89, 1900 no. 584, Amalie Koch, wife of the day laborer Ludwig Koch, died 18 Oct 1900; imaged, Archion (https://www.archion.de : accessed 8 November 2026); citing Landeskirchliches Archiv der EKKW, Kassel. Standesamt Deisel, death register 1900, no. 25, Amalie Koch née Weißenbach, died 18 Oct 1900, reported by her husband, Ludwig Koch III, day laborer (HStAM Best. 909 Nr. 958, image 27; “Hesse, Germany, Deaths, 1851-1958,” Ancestry, https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/61119/, image 47890_b370392-00027, accessed 8 November 2026). Both entries read in the images twice; the maiden name is spelled as in the civil entry. Deisel marriages (Archion register 218860), image 1376, no. 286, 10 November 1861: Ludwig Koch, twenty-four, son of Christian Koch and Maria Weisenbach, married Amalie Weisenbach, daughter of Johann Christoph Weisenbach and Amalie Schindehütte; the groom’s part of the entry was read twice, the bride’s parents once. Deisel burials (Archion register 218854), image 89, 1900 no. 584: Amalie Koch, “Ehefrau des Tagelöhners Ludwig Koch” (wife of the day laborer Ludwig Koch), of house 14, born 22 July 1838, died 18 October and buried 21 October 1900; her maiden name is hard to read in this entry and is spelled Weißenbach here as in the civil entry. Deisel civil register of deaths, 1900, no. 25: the death of Amalie Koch née Weißenbach, reported by her husband, “der Tagelöhner Ludwig Koch III,” of house 14, who signed; it names her parents as Johann Christoph Weißenbach and Amalie Schindehütte, as the marriage does. Both 1900 entries were read twice. No other marriage of a Ludwig Koch to an Amalie Weisenbach was found at Deisel in 1854–85 (for 1854–80 the grooms were read twice and the brides once; 1881–85 was read once). The godfather entries are image 302, no. 60 (February 1863), and image 327, no. 215 (November 1866), in Archion register 218845. [KOCH00]
  40. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. Each of the three rests on one American record. The Deisel and Friedrichsfeld release files at Marburg, which could add a second, have been searched by index only. [LEDGER]
  41. Baptism registers 1833–1841 of eighteen parishes of Kirchenkreis Hofgeismar; “Old Barber Dead. George Floether a Victim of a Complication of Diseases,” Courier-Journal (Louisville, Kentucky), 9 January 1901, p. 4, col. 7 (Newspapers.com image 118757099); “Veteran Barber Dead. George Floether Conducted a Shop Here For Forty-Three Years,” Louisville Times (Louisville, Kentucky), 9 January 1901, p. 1, col. 6 (Newspapers.com image 1379439483); imaged, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/image/118757099/ and https://www.newspapers.com/image/1379439483/ : accessed 7 November 2026). Read in the image; Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. Wilhelmshausen baptisms (Archion register 220327), image 382, 1839 no. 191: Georg Flöther, born 12 December 1839, son of Henricus Flöther, tailor, and Lisette Pauli; read twice. Floether’s obituary in the Courier-Journal (Louisville), 9 January 1901, p. 4, col. 7, gives his age as sixty-one and his birthplace as “Wilhelm Shausen, Germany”; the Louisville Times of the same day, p. 1, col. 6, calls him “a native of Germany.” Flothe’s own parents were Heinrich Wilhelm Flothe, an innkeeper of Hofgeismar, and Sophie Gunkel. [KBAP] [FLOETHER01] [LEDGER]
  42. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. Helmarshausen marriages (Archion register 219232), image 1557, 1863 no. 318: Philipp Wilhelm Köster, born at Deisel on 11 November 1836, son of the late Andreas Köster of Deisel; read twice. [LEDGER]
  43. Kath. Pfarrei St. Clara, Dortmund-Hörde, Trauungen 1848–1873 (Erzbistumsarchiv Paderborn, KB005-01-H, Matricula, image 107, p. 106; https://data.matricula-online.eu/de/deutschland/paderborn/DE_EBAP_51810/KB005-01-H/?pg=107 : accessed 9 November 2026), 1862 no. 69, 14 Dec 1862, Carl August Aderholz, factory worker at Bickefeld, Protestant, 26, and Anna Margaretha Sander; banns, Hörde ev.-ref. Trauungen 1859–75 (Archion register 140138), image 13, p. 11, “gebürtig aus Trendelburg im Kreise Hofgeismar”; children’s baptisms at Hörde to 1873 (FamilySearch index); brother: Hörde ev.-ref. “Trauungen für 1859–1875, Band 6” [Marriages for 1859–1875, volume 6] (Archion register 140138), image 11, 1861 no. 2, Carl Wilhelm Aderholz, son of Joh. Christ. Aderholz and Dorothea Henriette Brasenne of Trendelburg, 1 Jun 1861; St. Clara, Hörde, baptisms (KB007-02-T), p. 394, no. 441, Heinrich August Aderholz, Sept 1877, godfather Wilhelm Aderholz; read in the images 15 Oct 2026; imaged, Archion (https://www.archion.de/de/viewer/churchRegister/140138 : accessed 15 October 2026) > Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Westfalen > Kirchenkreis Dortmund-Süd > Hörde > Trauungen für 1859 - 1875, Band 6; citing Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Westfalen, Bielefeld. [HOERDE]
  44. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41; The vanished Carls: ledger of the 36 Carl/Karl births of 1833–41 in the Dornette database with no local death or marriage. [LEDGER] [VK]
  45. Passenger list of the bark Adonis, Bremen to New York, arrived 18 July 1853: “Carl Quenten, 22, baker,” with Augt. Quenten and the Frickhöfer women of Friedrichsfeld; National Archives microfilm M237, roll 129 (image NYM237_129-0110), read in the image twice; imaged, “New York, U.S., Arriving Passenger and Crew Lists (including Castle Garden and Ellis Island), 1820–1957,” Ancestry (https://www.ancestry.com/imageviewer/collections/7488/images/NYM237_129-0110 : accessed 7 November 2026); matching the Hessian emigration index (LAGIS) entry for Georg Karl Quentin, Bäcker, Friedrichsfeld, 1853. [ADONIS53]
  46. The open boys of the project’s ledger of the 426 boys, as of 5 Nov 2026, and the boys confirmed 1845–58 at Trendelburg (Archion register 220102), Deisel (218836), Langenthal (219712), Sielen (220039) and Stammen (220066) who are not in it; traced forward on 22 Oct 2026 in the FamilySearch full-text and indexed records, the U.S. censuses of St. Louis 1860–80 (every Carl or Charles born 1830–43 read), MyHeritage North Rhine-Westphalia civil deaths and marriages, LAGIS Hessische Auswanderer (1,774 full records) and the NARA passenger file of Germans to America (42 searches); with the guardianship, personnel and church files named in the table as the records that would settle each boy; imaged, Archion (https://www.archion.de : accessed 2 November 2026) > Hessen > Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck > Kirchenkreis Hofgeismar, by the register numbers given; citing Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck, Kassel. [UNTR]
  47. Jed Johnson, comp., likelihood-ratio model of the twenty-seven open boys of Trendelburg. [ODDS]
  48. Jed Johnson, comp., likelihood-ratio model of the twenty-seven open boys of Trendelburg. [ODDS]
  49. Charles L. Martini of St. Louis, cigar maker and dealer, p. 9, dwelling 40, lines 1–5. 1860 U.S. census, St. Louis, 5th Ward, p. 163, line 3, “Chs Martini,” 26, saloon keeper, born Saxony. [MARTSTL]
  50. Jed Johnson, comp., likelihood-ratio model of the twenty-seven open boys of Trendelburg. [ODDS]
  51. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [LEDGER]
  52. Staatsarchiv Hamburg, Auswanderungsamt, 373-7 I, VIII A 1 Band 010, p. 788; Passenger list of the Donau, arrived New York 15 November 1856, line 255, roll 168. [HAMB56] [NYARR56]
  53. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [LEDGER]
  54. Deutscher Reichsanzeiger und Preußischer Staatsanzeiger, Nr. 54, 1 Mar 1900, images 14–15. Deutscher Reichsanzeiger, 22 Feb 1900, p. 14, notice 84582 (Amtsgericht Grebenstein). [RA1900]
  55. Jed Johnson, comp., likelihood-ratio model of the twenty-seven open boys of Trendelburg; Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [ODDS] [LEDGER]
  56. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [LEDGER]
  57. Evangelische Kirchengemeinde Friedrichsfeld (Friedrichsfeld, Kreis Hofgeismar, Kurhessen), “Kirchenbuch 1830–2011” [Church book 1830–2011], section “Todtenbuch” [Death book] (Archion register 218959); Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [TODT] [LEDGER]
  58. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41; Jed Johnson, comp., the Konze ties of the twenty-seven open boys searched to the same depth, 12 November 2026. [LEDGER] [KTIES]
  59. Bruno Hildebrand, Statistische Mittheilungen über die volkswirthschaftlichen Zustände Kurhessens, p. 70. Hildebrand counts all births, not boys only. [HILDE53]
  60. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41; Evangelische Kirchengemeinde Gottsbüren (Gottsbüren, Kreis Hofgeismar, Kurhessen), “Beerdigungen 1830–1884” [Burials 1830–1884] (Archion register 219055), image 508, p. 55, 1839 no. 279, Friedrich Wilhelm Niemeyer, born Trendelburg 6 Sep 1836, son of the day laborer Wiegand Niemeyer and Anna Margarethe Pfannkuche; Trendelburg “Taufen 1830–1863” [Baptisms 1830–1863] (Archion register 220108), image 1432, no. 167; imaged, Archion (https://www.archion.de/de/viewer/churchRegister/219055, https://www.archion.de/de/viewer/churchRegister/220108 : accessed 12 October 2026) > Hessen > Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck > Kirchenkreis Hofgeismar, by the register numbers given; citing Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck, Kassel. [LEDGER] [GOTTSB39]
  61. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [LEDGER]
  62. Forward trace of every boy baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld born 1833–41. [LEDGER]
  63. Evangelische Kirchengemeinde Oedelsheim (Oedelsheim, Kreis Hofgeismar, Kurhessen), “Taufen 1830–1877” [Baptisms 1830–1877] (Archion register 219946), image 679, p. 28, Nr 128 (Andreas August Gans, born 25 Feb 1835; parents Georg Friedrich Gans, Drechslermeister, and Hanne Marie Elisabeth Kohlschein), and “Konfirmationen 1831–1972” [Confirmations 1831–1972] (Archion register 219943), image 1350, p. 51, Nr 12 (1849); imaged, Archion (https://www.archion.de/de/viewer/churchRegister/219946, https://www.archion.de/de/viewer/churchRegister/219943 : accessed 26 June 2026) > Hessen > Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck > Kirchenkreis Hofgeismar > Oedelsheim, by the register numbers given; citing Landeskirchliches Archiv der Evangelischen Kirche von Kurhessen-Waldeck, Kassel. Read in the images. [GANSOED]
  64. “Aufforderung,” New Orleanser Deutsche Zeitung, 2–9 Jun 1880, p. 4 (Newspapers.com image 1326049940, 9 June; 1326049679, 2 June), and Der Deutsche Correspondent (Baltimore), 3 Jun 1880, p. 2 (Library of Congress, Chronicling America sn83045081), read in the page images; replies to J. Hermann, 326 Charles St., Brooklyn; imaged, Newspapers.com (https://www.newspapers.com/image/1326049940/ : accessed 26 October 2026). [GANS80]
  65. Deutscher Reichsanzeiger und Preußischer Staatsanzeiger, Nr. 54, 1 Mar 1900, images 14–15. [RA1900]

Also on this page

About the pictures

The printed captions of these pictures were shortened on 25 October 2026. Their full text is kept here.

The parishes searched for Charles's baptism. Each mark shows how far the baptism registers of 1833–1841 have been read for a boy who could be Charles. "Searched, no match" means every entry was read and none fits; "searched, no match, with gaps" means nothing that fits was found but the search has a gap: a stretch of the register is missing or the register gives no year totals to check the reading against. The eighteen Kirchenkreis Hofgeismar parishes recommended by a German paleographer who compiles village family books, in italics, were read in October 2026, most of them for the boys who could be Charles (every Carl, every Konze or Gans, every boy born out of wedlock or in late January) rather than entry by entry; the appendix “The Diemel Parishes and Their Registers” lists what was read in each. The three places marked with stars are the places Charles named or lived near, where every boy of 1833–1841 was followed one by one. Beberbeck's births were entered in the Gottsbüren register. The map shows the status as of 18 October 2026; later readings are in that list. The Jewish birth registers of Kurhessen, also searched, are not mapped.

All the boys still open

The printed chapter gives a shortened form of this table, with the High-rank boys only (25 October 2026). The full table is kept here; the bracketed keys are those of the book’s sources. “Ref” is the boy’s number in the candidate ledger. The ranks and the list itself change with each register read; the current list is on the page Open Leads.

The boys still open, by rank

RankWhyRefNameBornParentsFound inLast recordWhat would settle it
High, 11Carl; Trendelburg; Konze grandmotherTR-159Friedrich Carl Wilhelm August Zollmann12 May 1836, TrendelburgJohann Conrad Zollmann × Wilhelmine Brommbothconf. Trendelburg 1850Bockenheim (Frankfurt) marriages 1856–66, where his brother lived
High, 10½Carl; Trendelburg; a probable Konze linkTR-190Carl Wilhelm Lucas25 May 1837, TrendelburgDavid Lucas × Maria Sophie Wendelbothconf. Trendelburg 1851; orphanedTrendelburg court, guardianship of the Lucas children, 1842–51 (HStAM 330)
High, 10Carl Ludwig; Deisel; November birth; orphan; missing in America by 1900; the leading candidate (see “The Boy from the Goose Corner”)DE-327Karl Ludwig Hofedietz13 Nov 1837, DeiselRicus Hofedietz, coachman × Amalie Wellerbothconf. Deisel 1852Karlshafen court, his guardianship file, 1843/44 (HStAM 275); a DNA test of a descendant of his sisters
High, 10Carl, with the later name Konrad; Deisel; left 1856DE-310Karl Justus August Konrad Brandau11 Jul 1837, DeiselJohannes Brandau, teacher × J. M. C. Stephanbothprobably sailed Hamburg to New York, Nov 1856A record of his life after November 1856, in America or in Germany; none found in the census, directory and pension indexes searched
Medium, 9Carl Ludwig; Langenthal; out of wedlockR1-24Carl Ludwig Hundt*25 Feb 1834, LangenthalMaria Sophie Hundt, unwed motherbothconf. Langenthal 1848Langenthal marriages 1834–50: did his mother marry, and under what name did he go?
Medium, 9Carl Ludwig; Trendelburg; left 1854TR-119Carl Ludwig Martini1 Dec 1834, TrendelburgPhilipp Eberhard Martini, surgeon × Gertrude Schemberbothemigrated to America, 1854A record of his arrival or of his life in America after 1854. The 1860 census indexes show no Carl Martini born in Hesse (index only); a Charles Martini of about his age, a saloon keeper in St. Louis, was born in Saxony. The Karlshafen court’s files on his mother’s 1857 estate and on the curatorship of Julius and Eduard Martini (HStAM 275)
Medium, 8½out of wedlock; DeiselDE-250Heinrich Karl20 Apr 1836, DeiselCharlotte Villmar, unwed mother; father Hellwig Karlbothconf. Deisel 1850Nr. 128 p. 426, his father's release of 1857
Medium, 8Carl; TrendelburgTR-235Franz Carl Gustav Kayser27 Oct 1838, Trendelburgas Hieronymus Carl Kayserbaptizedbaptismhis father's personnel file (HStAM)
Medium, 8Carl; Trendelburg; the family moved awayTR-192Hieronymus Carl Kayser12 Jun 1837, TrendelburgJ. H. Kayser, customs controller × Dubois de Luchetbaptizedbaptism; the family moved awayhis father's personnel file, Kurhessian customs service (HStAM)
Medium, 8Konze mother; Deisel; trail ends 1858; born 1843R1-28Philipp Kloppmann*1 Dec 1843, DeiselAdam Kloppmann × Charlotte Konzebothconf. Deisel 1858Nr. 841 p. 1: is he in his family's release?
Medium, 8Carl; TrendelburgTR-236Heinrich Friedrich Carl Meier27 Nov 1838, TrendelburgG. H. A. Meier, shepherd (d. 1842) × Regina WiddigbaptizedbaptismTrendelburg court, guardianship of the Meier children, 1842 ff. (HStAM 330)
Medium, 8out of wedlock; TrendelburgTR-116Heinrich Ludwig (no surname)28 Oct 1834, TrendelburgMaria Caroline Fischer, unwed mother; later legitimated (Thöne?)baptizedbaptismGrebenstein confirmations 1848–50
Low, 7½no Carl; Deisel; trail ends 1856; a Thiele left without release, 1861DE-409Theodor Thiele24 Jul 1839, DeiselSamuel Thiele × A. K. Karlbothconf. Deisel 1856Nr. 841: the forename of the Thiele who left in 1861
Low, 7no CarlDE-371Heinrich KochDec 1838, DeiselH. W. Koch, shepherd × Amalie Niemeyerbothconf. Deisel 1854Nr. 640
Low, 7no CarlTR-158Friedrich Louis Albrecht12 May 1836, TrendelburgJ. G. or J. P. Albrecht, tailor × Wilhelmine Graffbothconf. Trendelburg 1850Liebenau marriages 1846–56 and burials 1846–80
Low, 7probably traced: New York 1853; Carl; out of wedlock; but born 1831R1-23Georg Carl Quentin*30 May 1831, FriedrichsfeldMaria Elisabeth Amalie Quentin, unwed motherbotharrived at New York on the Adonis, 18 July 1853, as “Carl Quenten, 22, baker” [ADONIS53]; very probably the Cincinnati baker George Quentin of 1855–60Cincinnati records of George Quentin, baker, 1855–60. The Hansa’s George Quentin, baker, born 1826 at Göttingen (New York, Sep 1853), is probably a different man
Low, 7no Carl; trail ends 1856DE-521Friedrich Wilhelm Hofeditz12 Jul 1841, DeiselKonrad Hofedietz × K. Engelbrechtbothconf. Deisel 1856Nr. 841 or Nr. 640
Low, 7no CarlTR-291Heinrich Wilhelm Albrecht24 Aug 1840, Trendelburgas Friedrich Louis Albrechtbothconf. Trendelburg 1854Liebenau burials 1846–80
Low, 6½no Carl; born 28 JanuaryDE-382Heinrich Gräbe28 Jan 1839, DeiselFerdinand Gräbe, musician × W. Schildknechtbothconf. Deisel 1853Nr. 128 pp. 35–38, the Gräbe party of 1847; else Nr. 640
Low, 6½no CarlDE-202Philipp Meimbresse17 Feb 1835, DeiselAndreas Meimbresse × K. E. Kochbothconf. Deisel 1849Nr. 640
Low, 6½probably traced: New York 1854DE-115Heinrich Köster29 Mar 1833, DeiselM. E. Baumann, unwed mother, who married Nicolaus Köster in 1834bothprobably the tailor who reached New York in 1854New York records of Henry Köster, tailor, 1854–70
Low, 6½no CarlTR-250Friedrich Wilhelm Eduard Rode22 Apr 1839, TrendelburgC. W. Rode × W. Grosberndbothconf. Trendelburg 1853Nr. 640
Low, 6no CarlDE-108Friedrich Wilhelm Hofedietz17 Feb 1833, Deisel[Ricus?] Hofedietz × Amalie Weller[?]bothconf. Deisel 1847his baptism re-read for the father; then HStAM 275 guardianship
Low, 6no CarlDE-220Ludwig Bonhagen19 Jun 1835, DeiselFriedrich Bonhagen × Elisabeth Böttebothconf. Deisel 1849Nr. 128 p. 347, his brother's release of 1856
Low, 5½no CarlDE-160bFriedrich Lauterbach13 Apr 1834, DeiselChristoph Lauterbach × M. E. Schildknechtbothconf. Deisel 1848Deisel burials 1848–80, page by page
Low, 5no CarlTR-299Georg Christian Meier28 Sep 1840, Trendelburgas Heinrich Friedrich Carl Meierbaptizedbaptismthe Meier guardianship file (HStAM 330)
Low, 5no Carl; family leftDE-326Friedrich Georg KäuferNov 1837, DeiselGeorg Käufer, shoemaker × Maria [Pütter?]baptizedbaptismKassel church baptisms 1837 and confirmations 1851–52
Low, 4½probably traced: Charleston 1854DE-331Johann Wilhelm SteitzDec 1837, DeiselJohannes Steitz, baker × A. K. Kochbothprobably died at Charleston, 1854St. Matthew's Lutheran Church, Charleston, burials of Sep 1854
Low, 4probably traced: New York 1854–60FR-41Ferdinand Klapp19 Feb 1835, FriedrichsfeldNikolaus Klapp × Sophie Charlotte Lotzbaptizedprobably ‘Asmus Klapp’, naturalized at New York 1860Nr. 843 p. 17: his forename in the family's release
Low, 3½no Carl; untraced (George Floether of Louisville was another man, baptized at Wilhelmshausen in 1839)TR-275Johann Georg Flothe30 Dec 1839, TrendelburgHeinrich Wilhelm Flotho, innkeeper of Hofgeismar × Sophie Gunkelbothconf. Hofgeismar Neustadt 1854any adult record after 1854: emigration file, ship list, marriage or burial

More of the chapter, as printed until 28 October 2026

How the candidates were found, as printed until 28 October 2026

This passage of the printed chapter “The Candidates and How They Were Ruled Out” was shortened on 28 October 2026 so that family readers can get through Part Four. The text that stood in the book is kept here. Corrected 16 November 2026: the regional databases are credited to their compiler, the late Mr. Dornette, and are used as an index only.

The first was a computer search of the late Mr. Dornette's regional databases for Gottsbüren and the surrounding parishes, used as an index only. It matched every boy named Carl or Karl born there between 1833 and 1841 against the deaths and marriages. Of 115 such boys, 36 vanished from the local records, as an emigrant would. [Gottsbüren database (Dornette)] (The databases hold 31,945 births, 29,632 deaths and 9,820 marriage entries for Gottsbüren and the surrounding parishes from 1598 to 1951. Of the 115 boys, 79 could be followed to a local death or marriage. The search found on its own every emigrant already known from other sources, which showed that it worked.) But most boys of that generation vanish from the database whether they emigrated or not. Of 110 Trendelburg births of 1830–40 in it, only about one in five has a matching death or marriage. A boy who "vanishes" is therefore a boy to be researched, not a boy who has been shown to have left. [VK]

The appendix “How the Research Was Done” sets out the standard for ruling a boy out. [DEC] The search did not always apply that standard. Several early eliminations rested on an index line, a statement about a boy's family rather than the boy himself, or a correspondent's recollection. Some were later withdrawn and reopened. In October 2026 the search re-examined the eleven eliminations on which it most depends: ten candidates and one possible father. Each was checked against the standard from its own image. Ten met it at once. The eleventh, the candidate Breitwieser, was traced further until it did too. [AUDIT] The section “The ten leading candidates, and one possible father” below describes those eleven.

The day and month are the one precise fact the family supplied, for his burial register. For that reason the search has looked at every boy born within a day or two of 26 January in the parishes around Trendelburg, whatever his name. The list is short. Most of these boys died young or can be followed to an adult life, as the cases below show. A few in the neighboring parishes are still untraced, and no record yet links any of them to Charles. The research website lists them with the open leads. At Oedelsheim on the Weser, Friedrich Carl August Wessel was born on 25 January 1835 and died there on 28 March 1838, aged three. George Heinrich Westermann, born there on 26 January 1835, died the following January. [WESSEL] At Langenthal, Karl Wilhelm Weppe was born on 27 January 1837, but he married and died at Langenthal. The one Deisel boy born on the day itself, F. W. Köster of 26 January 1838, stayed at Deisel and died there in 1894. [LEDGER] (At Trendelburg, Heinrich Ludwig Kersting, born 24 January 1835, died in 1838, and Georg Conrad Lucas, born 24 January 1841, died at Hörde in Westphalia in 1892.) [JANSON] (A published index once gave a Johann Friedrich Ludwig Janson of Hofgeismar as born on 27 January 1837; the baptism itself reads 7 January.)

A regional birth database compiled by the late Mr. Dornette covers eleven parishes of the Trendelburg and Gottsbüren area. It holds no birth of either sex on 26 January 1835. [Gottsbüren database (Dornette)] That database holds only part of the births of those years, so its silence is a pointer and not a negative. The register reads carry the weight. [BD] (On the coverage of the database, see the appendix “How the Research Was Done”.)

One man re-examined with the candidates was never a candidate himself. Johann Carl Ludwig Konze, born at Trendelburg in 1814, was too old to be Charles. He married near Bremen in 1839, kept an inn there and died there in 1869. But his brother Anton Wilhelm was very probably the barber of that name in St. Louis from 1856. Probably at least three of Johann Carl Ludwig's own children followed between 1857 and 1867. If the name was Konze, this family was the obvious place to look for Charles's parents. Nothing in its records at Bremen or in St. Louis connects it with Charles. [JCL] [HG] [AWK]

The names still open, as printed until 28 October 2026

This passage of the printed chapter “The Candidates and How They Were Ruled Out” was shortened on 28 October 2026 so that family readers can get through Part Four. The text that stood in the book is kept here.

Eight boys born in wedlock and named Carl or Karl from the three parishes cannot yet be followed to an adult life that rules them out. From Deisel there are two. Karl Ludwig Hofedietz, born 13 November 1837, was orphaned at six. His sisters went into service, and the twins married in the Ruhr, at Witten in 1863 and Dortmund in 1865. (Since then, 11 November 2026: two notices of 1858 name him as a conscript who had missed that year’s muster. The local court at Karlshafen fined him in his absence on 21 January, and the district office at Hofgeismar summoned him on 6 February. So he was gone from home by early 1858. The notices do not say where he went or tie him to Charles, and he remains possibly Charles. The chapter “The Boy from the Goose Corner” tells it. Wochenblatt für die Provinz Fulda, 1858, Nr. 8, p. 82, and Nr. 9, p. 110.) Karl Justus August Konrad Brandau (1837), a teacher's son, sailed for New York as a saddler in 1856, and his life in America has not been found. From Trendelburg there are six. They are Friedrich Carl Wilhelm August Zollmann (1836); the brothers Hieronymus Carl (1837) and Franz Carl Gustav Kayser (1838), sons of a customs controller; Carl Wilhelm Lucas (1837); Heinrich Friedrich Carl Meier (1838), whose father died in 1842; and Carl Ludwig Martini (1834). Martini, a surgeon’s son, left for America in 1854, and his life there has not been found. (The Karlshafen court notice of 1900 that summoned Karl Ludwig Hofedietz also named Julius and Eduard Martini of Trendelburg as missing. They were very probably Martini’s own elder brothers, not relatives of the Hofedietz boy. The notice did not name Carl Ludwig Martini himself. Either his fate was known at home by then, or he had given up his claims to an inheritance when he took his release in 1854, as emigrants who left with their money often did.) [RA1900] [LEDGER] (Several boys once on this list have since been closed. Johann Carl Wilhelm Schneider of Friedrichsfeld (1839) married at Hattingen in Westphalia in August 1875; the marriage gives his birth at Trendelburg on 9 January 1839 and both his parents, and he died at Holthausen in 1904. Johann Karl Ludwig Weisenbach and Carl Ludwig Lotze both stood godfather in Germany during the American Civil War, and Georg Wilhelm Carl Senne died at Friedrichsfeld in 1848. Identifications once thought probable for Lucas and the two Kaysers proved, on checking, to belong to other men. Carl Ludwig Georg Lotz of Friedrichsfeld (1835) is closed too. A man of that name died in Queensland, Australia, on 19 May 1924. The death index names his parents as David Lotz and Dorothea Elizabeth Bunting, the parents of the 1835 baptism. Another, Carl Wilhelm Ferdinand Klapp of Friedrichsfeld (1838), emigrated with his family in 1854. He was the Louis Clapp, born in Hesse-Cassel, whose children were born in New York City during the war years. Carl Wilhelm Kersting of Trendelburg (1841) is closed as well. He married at Neustadt am Rübenberge in Hanover in December 1869, a cigar maker living at Harburg. The marriage gives his birth date, his birthplace and both his parents.)

None of the eight was born within a week of 26 January. None bears a surname that leads to Gannsen, Gans or Konze, though some had Konze kin. The 1900 census, the only record of Charles's lifetime that gives a month, says November 1836. [C1900] Who answered the census taker is not known. Most of the eight stay on the list because a boy is open until a record closes him, not because he looks like Charles.

In October 2026 the search covered the civil marriage registers of Kassel for 1874–1900, from the start of civil registration. They hold some 13,700 marriages in the city itself and in its nine suburban registry offices. The search looked for every one of the open boys in their indexes and in a machine reading of the typed copies, and found none of them there. That is a pointer, not proof that none of them married there. The section “The Konze and Gans families in Germany” of the chapter “The Name He Used: Gans, Konze or Another Name” lists the Konze boys of the three parishes, all accounted for. [LEDGER] [VK]

The table shows where the 426 boys stand, parish by parish. The cohort is every boy whose baptism in the registers of Trendelburg, Deisel or Friedrichsfeld gives a birth date from January 1833 to December 1841. The search read each from the body of the register, not from its index. “Died young” means a burial or a note of death before adulthood. “Traced” means an adult record that meets that standard. “Probably traced” means an index entry or a family emigration not yet matched to the boy himself, and the table counts such a boy as open. [LEDGER]

Of the 24 untraced boys, eight are the Carls named above and two are boys born out of wedlock, described below. The other fourteen are boys with no Carl among their names. (The fourteen are, from Trendelburg, Friedrich Louis Albrecht (1836), Friedrich Wilhelm Eduard Rode (1839), Johann Georg Flothe (1839), Heinrich Wilhelm Albrecht (1840) and Georg Christian Meier (1840); and from Deisel, Friedrich Wilhelm Hofedietz (1833, Karl Ludwig's brother), Friedrich Lauterbach (1834), Philipp Meimbresse (1835), Ludwig Bonhagen (1835), Friedrich Georg Käufer (1837), Heinrich Koch (1838), Heinrich Gräbe (1839), Theodor Thiele (1839) and Friedrich Wilhelm Hofeditz (1841). Ludwig Koch of Deisel (1836) has since been closed: he married at Deisel in November 1861 and was still living there in October 1900, when his wife died and he reported her death (Deisel burials, Archion register 218854, image 89, 1900 no. 584; Deisel civil deaths 1900 no. 25). Several men named Ludwig Koch lived at Deisel in those years, so it has not been shown which of them was the shepherd Ludwig Koch who was godfather there in 1863 and 1866. Friedrich Wilhelm Köster of Deisel (1841) has since been closed: he was found dead in the Weser near Beverungen in June 1890. Adolph Otto Stieglitz of Deisel (1834), the pastor's son, has since been closed: he died at Heiligenrode in 1853, a cadet in an Austrian rifle battalion. So have two more. Johann Julius Theodor Weecke of Trendelburg (1841) married at Helmarshausen in April 1866. Friedrich Wilhelm Heere of Deisel (1840) died a farmer at Heiligenrode, near Kassel, in 1916.) Charles used the forename Carl or Charles all his life, so a boy with no Carl among his names is less likely to be him. But a forename could be changed or added, as surnames were, so these boys stay open, ranked below the Carls. [LEDGER]

Three boys are probably traced. Heinrich Köster of Deisel (1833) was probably the tailor of that name who sailed from Bremen to New York in 1854. Johann Wilhelm Steitz of Deisel (1837) was probably the William Stutz, born in Germany, who died at Charleston in 1854. Ferdinand Klapp of Friedrichsfeld (1835) was probably the young man entered as Asmus Klapp who reached New York in 1854 and was naturalized there in 1860. Johann Georg Flothe of Trendelburg (1839), son of an innkeeper of Hofgeismar, was once counted among them as George Floether, a barber who died at Louisville, Kentucky, in January 1901. But Floether was probably the son of a tailor of Wilhelmshausen, on the Fulda in Kreis Hofgeismar, baptized there in December 1839 (Archion register 220327, image 382, no. 191), so Flothe is untraced again. Philipp Wilhelm Köster of Deisel (1836), once counted among them, has since been ruled out: he married at Helmarshausen in February 1863 (Archion register 219232, image 1557, no. 318), two months after Charles enlisted at St. Louis. [LEDGER]

One boy who long headed the list is now closed. Carl Ludwig August Aderholz of Trendelburg (1838) was the factory worker Carl August Aderholz who married at Hörde in Westphalia on 14 December 1862, twelve days after Charles enlisted at St. Louis. Three things tie the groom to the Trendelburg baptism. The first is his names, Carl and August. The second is his birthplace, which the banns give as Trendelburg in Kreis Hofgeismar. The third is his family. His brother Carl Wilhelm had married at Hörde the year before as a son of Christian Aderholz and Dorothea Henriette Brasenne of Trendelburg, the parents named at Carl Ludwig August's baptism. A man married in Westphalia that December cannot be Charles. [HOERDE] (The marriage itself names no parents and gives his age as 26, two years more than his baptism implies. In September 1877 a Wilhelm Aderholz stood godfather to August's son at Hörde.)

Other names and other fathers, as printed until 28 October 2026

This passage of the printed chapter “The Candidates and How They Were Ruled Out” was shortened on 28 October 2026 so that family readers can get through Part Four. The text that stood in the book is kept here.

A boy born out of wedlock to a Konze father would be baptized under another surname. A Konze mother’s child would carry the name Konze only if she was unmarried. A boy raised in a Konze household as a stepson might use that name in America without ever having been baptized under it. And a boy could carry his mother's surname. Each of these has happened to other boys in the same registers. Names could also drift between baptism and adulthood, as the cases below show. [SURN]

From the start the search has allowed that Charles may have been born out of wedlock and baptized under a name he did not later use. Of the 426 boys of the three parishes, 48 were born out of wedlock. Forty-five have been followed to a later record or an early death, and two are still untraced as adults. One of those followed is Philipp Freier of Trendelburg (1834), son of Marie Elisabeth Jungkonze. He was confirmed at Hombressen, a parish to the south, in 1849 under his father's name and died there unmarried in 1872. [HOMB72] The two still untraced are Heinrich Ludwig of Trendelburg (1834), entered without a surname, and Heinrich Karl of Deisel (1836). The boy entered at Friedrichsfeld in 1837 only as Georg Christoph took his mother's surname as a man. As Georg Hartgen, a day laborer of Borlinghausen in Westphalia, he died at Peckelsheim in 1889, “born at Friedrichsfeld in Kurhessen, son of the unmarried Sophie Hartgen”. [LEDGER] One more, Heinrich Köster of Deisel (1833), is probably traced. [LEDGER] [GOTTSB39] (The forty-four followed to a later record or an early death include Friedrich Wilhelm Niemeyer of Trendelburg (1836), who died at Gottsbüren in February 1839, and Heinrich Ludwig Korte of Trendelburg (1834), who married at Hörde in Westphalia in 1856.)

Several entered the register without a surname at all. At Deisel, between 1838 and 1841, the register entered five such boys with only a forename and the word "unehelich", born out of wedlock. One became Karl Niemeyer, one Friedrich Wilhelm Heinrich Stunz, and one Theodor Hillebrand, each when his father acknowledged or married the mother. [DBAP] [DEICONF] [WESER54] [VK] The search has also read the illegitimate births of the window in the neighboring parishes and at Hofgeismar. The result was the same: no boy born near 26 January, and none whose later name leads to Charles. [COVER]

How the open boys are ranked, as printed until 28 October 2026

This passage of the printed chapter “The Candidates and How They Were Ruled Out” was shortened on 28 October 2026 so that family readers can get through Part Four. The text that stood in the book is kept here.

Twenty-eight boys baptized at Trendelburg, Deisel or Friedrichsfeld between 1833 and 1841 are still open, three of them probably traced. The confirmation classes of those churches and of Langenthal, Sielen and Stammen added six more boys who were not in that count, because they were born elsewhere or just outside those years, and five of them are still open. The book’s table lists the five of these thirty-three who rank High, as the rank is described below. A boy from the confirmation classes is marked with an asterisk (*). The fuller online version of this chapter on the research website lists all thirty-three, with the Medium and Low boys and what would settle each. The page “Open Leads” there keeps the current list. [ADONIS53] About thirty other boys from those confirmation classes are also untraced. None of them has a Gans or Konze parent or fits the points below, and the research files list them. [UNTR] (Since then, 11 November 2026: twenty-seven boys of the three parishes are still open, three of them probably traced. The confirmation classes added six more boys born elsewhere or just outside those years, and three of them are still open: Georg Carl Quentin (probably traced), Carl Ludwig Hundt and Philipp Kloppmann. That makes thirty in all, listed in the table “All the boys still open” above. Carl Andreas Heere has been ruled out: he married at Warburg in 1864. So has Carl August Julius Köster, who married at Hofgeismar in April 1869 and was living at Heiligenstadt.)

The boys are ranked on the points that fit Charles best:

A boy who has probably been traced elsewhere loses 2 points. High means 10 points or more, Medium 8 to 9½, and Low less than 8. Within a rank, a second name beginning with C, K or L comes first, then the birth nearest 26 January, then a tie to America. The rank and the date of 26 January set only the order of work; neither rules a boy out. Karl Ludwig Hofedietz is placed first because the chapter on him weighs more than these points can. None of these boys has a record that links him to the name Gannsen.

“Found in” says whether a boy was found in the baptisms of his parish, in its confirmation classes, or in both. “Nr.” means a volume of the emigration releases of Kreis Hofgeismar in the Hessian State Archives at Marburg (HStAM 180 Hofgeismar). No release volume has been found for Deisel or Trendelburg for 1859, or for Deisel for 1860. Those are the years that matter most. The nearest file is Nr. 640, the district's emigration file for 1852–70, which may hold only general orders. The archive has been asked whether it names anyone. [RELVOL]

None of the open boys with the strongest family and godparent ties has a documented link to Charles’s own circle in St. Louis. Two men of Trendelburg appear there before the war. One is the barber Anton Wilhelm Konze, there by 1856 and very probably the Trendelburg man. The other is the tanner Conrad Albrecht, probably the Trendelburg man who landed at Baltimore in 1855. No record ties either of them to Charles or to any of these boys. [VILLUS]

Sources

  1. BD Comparison of the eleven American records that state Charles's age or birth date, each read in the image, as of 8 Oct 2026.
  2. RELVOL Hessisches Staatsarchiv Marburg, Best. 180 Hofgeismar, emigration releases (Entlassungen): Deisel vol. 1, Nr. 128 (1833–58) and vol. 2, Nr. 841 (1861–73); Trendelburg vol. 1, Nr. 155 (1832–58) and vol. 2, Nr. 850 (1860–80); Friedrichsfeld Nr. 843 (1853–71); for 1859 (Deisel and Trendelburg) and 1860 (Deisel) no release volume has been identified; the general emigration file Nr. 640 (Bd. 2, 1852–70) may fill the gap (titles read in Arcinsys, 22 Oct 2026; Nr. 115 is a census volume, Volkszählungen Bd. 4, 1859–67); Best. 275 Karlshafen and Best. 330 Trendelburg (court guardianship files).
  3. VILLUS Compiled from the emigration index (LAGIS Hessen, Auswanderer aus Hessen) and the American traces set out on the research website page “Emigrants from Trendelburg, Deisel and Friedrichsfeld”: U.S. censuses 1850–1900 and naturalization, death and burial indexes on FamilySearch and Ancestry (index level unless stated); St. Paul’s Evangelical Church, St. Louis, baptisms 1860 (St. Louis Genealogical Society, STPA06-B-1860-2, p. 11, read in the image); New York passenger list of the ship Republic, June 1858 (FamilySearch, read in the image); Missouri certificate of death of August H. Boette, 1922; for Konze and Köster in St. Louis, the sources of the chapter “St. Louis before the War”. Compiled October 2026.

More of the chapter, as printed until 30 October 2026

Other names and other fathers, as printed until 30 October 2026

These passages of the printed chapter “The Candidates and How They Were Ruled Out”, section “If he is hidden: other names and other fathers”, were shortened on 30 October 2026. The printed chapter keeps the three ways a name could change, the counts of boys born out of wedlock, Zollmann and Lucas, and the case of Willy Johnson. The text that stood in the book is kept here.

One of those followed shows how a name could change: the boy entered at Friedrichsfeld in 1837 only as Georg Christoph died at Peckelsheim in 1889 as Georg Hartgen, “son of the unmarried Sophie Hartgen”. [LEDGER] Another, Philipp Freier, baptized at Trendelburg in 1834 (his burial gives his birthplace as Hombressen), was the son of a Jungkonze mother; he was confirmed under his father's name at Hombressen, to the south, and died there unmarried in 1872. [HOMB72]

Several entered the register without a surname at all, and took one later, when the father acknowledged or married the mother: one became Karl Niemeyer, another Theodor Hillebrand. [DBAP] [DEICONF] [WESER54] [VK] The illegitimate births of the neighboring parishes give the same result: no boy born near 26 January, and none whose later name leads to Charles. [COVER]

One case in the table of candidates above shows how far a man's name could drift from his baptism. A Friedrichsfeld boy was baptized in 1835 under his unmarried mother's surname, Halmbrecht. When he died there on 11 April 1875 the register called him "Helmbrecht genannt Weike", Helmbrecht called Weike, after his stepfather Andreas Weike. His widow remembered him simply as Carl Weyhe. [TODT] If Charles was a similar case, the German name he Americanized need not be the name written at his baptism. Such later names turn up only by following each boy forward, not by searching for a name. [LEDGER]

Supplements

Records, images and data on this website that go with this chapter.